Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the preservation of the social model and on the fight against fraud in social security, in Bordeaux on November 15, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

15 November 2011 · Bordeaux, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed an audience in Bordeaux on November 15, 2011, defending France's social model and combating social security fraud amid the European financial crisis.
Main themes
Preservation of French social model, fight against social security fraud, National Council of Resistance legacy, pension reform, social protection financing and debt, family policy, French republican values, economic and financial crisis, solidarity and social achievements
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,494
89th percentile
Sentences
245
93rd percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 39%38%
  • Economic 29%29%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

245 sentences in 99 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Madam and Gentlemen Ministers,

Dear Alain JUPPE,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

As I walked this morning along the banks of the Garonne to come to you, I fully appreciated the renaissance of Bordeaux and therefore the tremendous work undertaken for years by Alain Juppé, whom I want to salute and thank. I also remembered that from this same city, from these same quays, at a time when our country was sinking into defeat and some were expressing defeatism, a man, General de GAULLE, was leaving to join England to work on the renaissance of France.

It was in the fight against the occupier that all the resistance movements, Christian, Gaullist, Socialist, and Communist, defined the famous program of the National Council of Resistance. From this solidarity of fighting France was born a new ambition for France. A generous ambition inscribed in the marble of our fundamental laws because as early as 1946 the new constitution guaranteed all citizens of our country the protection of health and material security.

Conceived by the resistance, born with the Liberation, our social model is today part of the identity of our Nation. The French are attached to it, viscerally attached, because it is the fruit of our history and our values and in the context of the economic and financial crisis we are experiencing today, as head of state, I am the guarantor and my duty is to be the protector of our social model.

Should I remind you that in our country, we do not leave by the wayside those who are struck by illness, by age, by dependency, or by disability?

Should I remind you that in France, one does not lose their health coverage when one loses their job?

Should I remind you that in France, one does not lose their retirement due to the failings of international finance?

Should I remind you that in France, we guarantee the most disadvantaged access to healthcare, absolutely unparalleled in the world?

I remind you of this today in front of you, because it is necessary to tirelessly recall that the honor of France is to have built a democratic and social Republic on the ruins of the Second World War.

I want to emphasize this truth because I hear it said, here and there, that the pact of 1945 would be called into question, that the values and ideals of the CNR would be trampled upon, that we would be betraying the legacy left to us by the fathers of our social model.

I want to say that I do not accept these lies and that I do not accept these excesses.

I reject them and I have come here, to Bordeaux, to refute them, point by point.

I want to say that those who have betrayed the legacy of the CNR are those who, for decades, have refused any reform out of political cowardice or opportunism. That is the betrayal of our social model.

Those who have betrayed the legacy of the CNR are those who for decades have carefully concealed from the French that they were financing their social protection system through deficits and debt.

Thus, for decades, we have protected the French on credit without telling the French. We protected the French of the 1980s by mortgaging the future of their children and grandchildren. There lies the truth and there lies the betrayal of the spirit and the letter of our social model.

With the pension reform of 2010, and the efforts of all the French, we wanted to save the old-age branch of Social Security. A worker who has been paid the minimum wage throughout their professional life thus benefits from a replacement rate equal to 85% of the net minimum wage. The pension reform of 2010 preserved a major social achievement. Those who refuse the pension reform are ready to destroy a major social achievement. We implemented the pension reform to protect the social achievements of the French.

Let us look around us, my dear compatriots, and everyone can see that in the crisis, French retirees have been more preserved and protected than anywhere else in Europe.

The same goes for the family branch. It is one of the most generous and effective in the world. It combines universality in access to family allowances with targeted support for the most disadvantaged families. With the massive investment in early childhood policies that we are implementing, family policy is a central pillar of our country's dynamism and I will never accept any questioning of the fundamentals of our family policy because the results are there.

We manage to reconcile in France a high birth rate, of more than 2 children per woman, with a female employment rate of 85%. France has done everything to ensure that women can experience professional fulfillment without renouncing family fulfillment.

Year after year, our active population continues to grow. In 20 years, the population of France will have increased by 20%, while it will have decreased in 8 other European countries, notably Germany.

"There is no wealth but men," wrote the great French humanist Jean Bodin in the 16th century. France has managed to preserve this wealth because it has established a family policy unlike any other in Europe.

France is becoming what it was for centuries: the leading demographic power in Europe. In 30 years, France will have more inhabitants than Germany.

Finally, let us look at the health branch. It covers more than three-quarters of the health expenses incurred by the French. Whatever the critics say, even with advances in medicine and rising costs, this rate has remained stable for 15 years. Our healthcare system is one of the best in the world.

Ladies and Gentlemen, my dear compatriots, the proportion of national wealth thus allocated to social protection -- one third of our GDP -- makes France one of the most generous countries in terms of social policy. It is essential that each of us keeps this reality in mind. It is a chance and it is an asset.

It is an asset because I am convinced that economies perform better when there are effective social protection systems, and I contest the equation of growth and weakness of the social model. Effective social protection improves employee productivity and fosters balanced and sustainable growth. It is this same conviction that we supported at the G20, notably with Alain JUPPE and Xavier BERTRAND. For the first time, countries like the United States, India, China, and Brazil have recognized the necessity of building a social protection floor in each country. The road is long, but the path is open. And it is France that has paved the way.

This is the heart of my political commitment. That said, can we, my dear compatriots, look at our social protection system, our system of solidarity, as if nothing had happened between 1945 and 2011?

I am, more than anyone else, attached to the ideal set by General de GAULLE and the National Council of Resistance. But the best way to preserve this achievement is to reform it continuously to adapt it to the realities of our world.

In this area, as in all others, I would so much like to convince you, my dear compatriots, that it is not reform that is a danger, it is immobility that is a danger, it is conservatism that is a danger, it is the refusal to assume responsibilities, and it is the refusal to see that the world is changing and that it will not wait for us.

Thanks to advances in medicine and our healthcare system, our society is experiencing today a remarkable revolution, that of increased life expectancy, and consequently a colossal challenge, that of the growing elderly population.

At the time of the Liberation, I give you these figures to convince you that this is not a matter of ideology, of left or right, of opposition or majority, it is a matter of common sense, courage, duty, and taking responsibility. At the time of the Liberation, the life expectancy of a French person was 62 years. Today, it is 78 years for a man and 85 years for a woman. Who can say, who can dare to say that our pension system reform was not necessary when from 1945 to today, we have gone from a life expectancy of 62 years to 78 years for men and 85 years for women? Who will dare to say this to the French? Without lying, without turning red in the face? It would be shocking, and why not say it, scandalous, not to want to assume the responsibility that belongs to the men and women of state. In 1960, in our country, there were 4 contributors for one retiree. Today, there are 1.8 contributors for one retiree and by 2050, there will be 1 contributor for 1 retiree. Who will dare to say to the French: "retirees, sleep peacefully. Despite these figures, there is nothing to change, nothing to review, nothing to say"?

French society has profoundly evolved and its environment has transformed. We live in an open world, where the products we consume every day come from all horizons, where our industry is confronted with competition from new countries.

Our social model is not immutable. Our social model must remain alive. Reforming it, adapting it, is to save it and ensure its sustainability!

Let us first look at the values that inspire it and to which we are attached, as well as the objectives we want to achieve!

Do we still want to spend more without ever questioning the burdens that this represents?

Do we want a Social Security system that would only be a counter from which everyone could take as they please, or do we want the rights of social insured to also respond to the duties of social insured? The word duty is not a dirty word; it is the counterpart of rights.

The National Council of Resistance did not want a system of charity. It wanted to build a dignified system for a democratic and free France.

Solidarity is total on one condition, that responsibility is total and therefore shared.

What I wish is to defend the spirit of a founding social reform! I am not the defender of corporatist organizations or false achievements. And in any case, I will not accept lies, the concealment of the truth, on the pretext that there are upcoming electoral appointments. It is too serious. The French will choose, but they have the right to the truth, not to lies.

A few weeks ago, I spoke about the new challenges facing our country. And let things be clear, we cannot, we do not have the means, to embark on a strategy of ever more spending for ever more taxes. This strategy is a dead end. Because taxes rest on France that works, that is in competition with others. And we will then pay for it with relocations and job losses. The real answer, the only one, lies in a transformation of our social policies.

A few weeks ago, some actors, dear Xavier, in the healthcare system published a manifesto called "for equal health." It is not a matter of discussing here the sincere attachment that I believe these people have to our healthcare system but to tell them: "you too have a duty of responsibility." And to you too, irresponsibility is forbidden.

The main proposal of this manifesto was simple: to abandon any mechanism for controlling healthcare spending and to rely on automatic increases in contributions. I refuse this logic, I will always refuse it, because it is absurd and because it is dangerous.

I say this with even more force because I observed the debate in the Senate on the Social Security financing bill. The new Senate majority proposes to increase ONDAM spending by 3.6% and to pay for it with tax increases. How easy it is! Some promise spending, others suffer tax increases. I refuse this strategy.

With the reform of the hospital and liberal medicine, we have instead engaged in a profound reorganization of our healthcare system, Roselyne BACHELOT has greatly contributed to this. Health houses allow us to consolidate and bring healthcare offerings closer together. And this has allowed us to achieve results: the hospital has seen its deficit reduced by three between 2007 and 2011. By three! It is now reorganized and refocused on its missions in service of patients.

With our drug policy, we concentrate reimbursements on the most effective products and we adjust prices according to their life cycle, while continuing to support the research and innovation that we absolutely need. Xavier BERTRAND has perfectly learned all the lessons from the Mediator affair, because the trust of the French in our healthcare system must be preserved above all.

With the establishment of the Active Solidarity Income, we have increased the gap between social minima and earned income.

And we will go further in the logic of rights and duties. As proposed by Marc-Philippe DAUBRESSE, by the end of the year, we will experiment in about ten departments with a work obligation of seven hours for recipients of the RSA. Here too, let me be clear, this is not to punish; on the contrary, it is to respect, to restore dignity. One does not have dignity when one can only survive by begging.

With our policy in favor of the employment of seniors, we wanted to build new relationships in the workplace that allow seniors to remain employed. My dear compatriots, between 2007 and 2010, despite the crisis, the number of seniors in employment increased by 470,000, and the employment rate of those aged 55-59 now stands at 62% in our country. For the first time in our history, we have just surpassed the European average. But what was the logic of a policy that consisted of pushing all fifty-somethings out of a company when at the same time the government explains that we need to contribute longer to finance our pensions?

With the pension reform, we have therefore guaranteed the principles of solidarity of our pay-as-you-go system. In the face of a demographic shock that everyone saw coming, together with Prime Minister François FILLON, we refused to lower the pensions of 15 million retirees, because lowering their pensions would simply undermine our social pact. The effect of such a decision would have been disastrous, as the great achievement of the post-war period was the end of poverty among our elders, which had long been a typically French scourge.

And I was determined to honor my commitment to increase the minimum pension despite the crisis, with a 25% increase between 2007 and 2012.

Working longer because we live longer was the only sensible response. This is, by the way, my dear compatriots, the choice made by all the major developed countries, under both right and left-wing governments. I want to say to the French, there was no other solution. Those who tell you that we can work less and preserve our pension system are lying to you. To fill the funding gap of our pensions, it was necessary to work longer. That is why we raised the retirement age to 62.

This was not an easy decision to make, but it was the only one capable of preserving the pay-as-you-go pension system, which is one of the guarantees of our social cohesion.

You can see it clearly, it is by adapting our social protection system that we will ensure its sustainability. And it is in the same spirit that we have decided to take resolute action against social fraud.

Fraud: it is the most terrible and insidious betrayal of the spirit of 1945. It is fraud that undermines the very foundations of this Social Republic that the brothers-in-arms of the Resistance wanted to build for France and that they bequeathed to us.

To defraud, what do I say, to steal from Social Security, is to betray the trust of all the French people and to deal a terrible blow to the beautiful and necessary idea of national solidarity.

Defrauding Social Security is stealing. It is not simply "abusing the system"; it is not simply taking advantage of its generosity. It is stealing from each and every one of us.

Those who benefit from a fraudulent work stoppage, as well as those who prescribe it, I say simply, steal from the French, all the French.

Those who understate their income to obtain a benefit steal from the French.

Those who receive family allowances while not residing in the national territory, as well as those who invent a fictitious residence or rent an unsanitary dwelling to divert benefits, steal from the French.

Those who employ a worker without declaring them to Social Security cheat at the expense of the community.

I tell you, we must be uncompromising against fraudsters and cheaters. It is not in my mind to designate scapegoats, to turn one group against another; that would make no sense. It is about preserving a social achievement. If fraud thrives, we will not be able to maintain our social model. Those who refuse to fight against fraud are those who prepare the disintegration of our social model.

For too long, my dear compatriots, it was fashionable in certain circles to deny fraud. Denouncing fraud was even seen as inappropriate; those who denounced fraud were condemned by those fine minds who saw it as a form of militant redistribution.

That period is definitively behind us.

Since 2008, we have put our Social Security system in a position to identify and punish fraud and fraudsters. The interconnection of files between administrations, in compliance with applicable rules, is absolutely essential.

I also want to highlight and commend the role of the parliamentarians who have worked with the government to build this arsenal to combat Social Security fraud.

I also want, because it is my duty as head of state, to highlight the investment of all the agents of the state services and Social Security funds in this work, particularly the role of inspectors and controllers who do a very difficult job on the ground every day. And it is my duty to pay tribute to them. A family allowance fund like that of Gironde distributes 1.3 billion in family benefits. I want to pay tribute to these agents because they are on the front lines of discontent, of protests, and because controls are always good for the neighbor and always painful for oneself. You can be proud of your administration. Oh, of course, not everything goes as we would like it to go, but we are fortunate in our country to have a competent and honest administration. And I wanted to tell these agents, as well as the civil servants, that I understood their job was difficult, especially since -- and I claim this, I own it -- I wanted the choice of not replacing one civil servant out of two because France can no longer continue to multiply public jobs.

The first results of this policy of firmness are here. In 2010, 3.4 billion euros of tax, social, and customs fraud were detected, including half a billion euros from Social Security organizations. Simply because we wanted it. That is 20% more than in 2009.

It is clear that this policy of combating fraud is not the structural answer to our deficit problems. Those who say so are mistaken because in my mind, it is an absolute requirement of responsibility and good management of public money.

So this requirement is what finally leads us to continue on the path of restoring our public finances.

Our desire to control public spending is not an accounting obsession.

My dear compatriots, what is at stake is the control of our destiny. It is our national independence. It is our ability to assume our national sovereignty. Only a country that controls its finances can remain sovereign. And for that, we cannot continue to distribute more wealth than we produce.

Only a country that controls its finances can remain sovereign. And for that, we cannot continue to distribute more wealth than we produce. We cannot finance our social protection systems through debt that is automatically created when year after year our social spending exceeds the revenues that are supposed to finance them.

That is why we decided, with the Prime Minister, to increase by 1% a number of social benefits, in line with the latest growth forecasts. We will increase benefits in proportion to the wealth we are able to create.

We were able to meet the national objective for health insurance spending for 2010; it is the first time since 1997 that this has happened in our country. And we will meet it in 2011. And we will meet it in 2012 and for the following years with an ONDAM of 2.5%.

And that is why we decided to accelerate the timetable for pension reform. To restore the balance of pension schemes more quickly and protect retirees.

Do you know that before our reform, out of 15 million retirees in France, for one and a half million of them, Social Security was forced to borrow from the bank money it did not have? Could this system endure? No. It was impossible.

Ladies and gentlemen, pensions in Greece have been reduced by 20%. This is what happens to a country that lives beyond its means. In Portugal, pensions have also been reduced. This is what happens to a country that did not carry out the necessary reform in time. We do not want these developments for our country. Protecting retirees from a reduction in pensions that would once again rhyme old age with poverty is something we cannot accept.

The certainty that the status quo of our financing model is no longer possible will be my conclusion. We must rethink the financing system of our social system. It is a matter of our country's competitiveness.

In an open world, subject to competition, the very high cost of labor in our country penalizes our economy. And penalizing France in international competition increases the risk of relocations. The cost of labor has increased in France more rapidly than in Germany over the last 15 years. Do not look elsewhere for the good results of Germany and the difficulties of France.

Two decisions that were made have had catastrophic consequences on France's competitiveness. The first was at the beginning of the 1980s when we made the French believe that we could lower the retirement age from 65 to 60. We lied to the French. Everyone knew it, and this decision was made by denying the realities. And then there was the unbelievable affair of the 35-hour workweek at the beginning of the 2000s, of which we were the only country in the world to adopt.

We now need to open a calm debate on the financing of our social protection. On this subject, we are not on virgin territory. Many studies have already been undertaken to analyze the different hypotheses.

What measures can we take to reduce the burden of taxation on labor? This is an essential question.

Should the financing of social protection rely as much on wages, while our European and global partners are making a different choice and our employees are increasingly being put in competition?

To what extent should different types of taxes contribute to this broadening?

Should imports in our country contribute to the financing of our social model?

Beyond the issue of the cost of labor, there is also the question of the best integration of the coverage offered by complementary organizations to protect against various social risks.

This debate concerns us all. I propose to establish the High Council for the Financing of Social Protection, which will involve social partners. This High Council will engage in public debate on these questions that are at the heart of our social pact and its future. It will help us continue on the path of restoring the various branches of Social Security.

I hope that this High Council will begin its work before the end of the year, bringing serenity, seriousness, and objectivity to this debate. I will ask it to make proposals that are commensurate with the ambition I have for our social model. And in a few months, each of those considering the upcoming deadlines will have to express their views on an absolutely central question: that of financing our social model.

My dear compatriots, I hope you understand that this visit was very important to me. We will keep our social model; we have all seen images from across the Atlantic where when a man or woman loses their job, they find themselves in a mobile home, with nothing. We do not want that model. We do not judge others, but we do not want it. It does not correspond to who we are.

But at the same time, we also see the situation of countries that have lived without worrying about tomorrow. We do not want those models either.

Of course, we want to continue with a generous model, but we also do not want it to be abused. We do not want our social system and our country to be disrespected, considering that everything can be demanded of it while giving nothing in return. We will never accept that, because it is not in line with the idea we have of our country and our commitment.

And it is in this that we will be faithful to the legacy of General de GAULLE and those who created the National Council of the Resistance.

Ladies and gentlemen, the crisis is far from over. It is causing a lot of suffering in our country. And it requires that everyone rise to the occasion of this crisis by assuming their responsibilities, whatever risks the leaders may face. To assume one's responsibilities and to do one's duty.

But this crisis, which forces us to rethink our ideas, to reflect on who we are and where we want to go, is also an opportunity for France to react, to prepare for its future, and to remain among the leading nations that matter in today's world.

Rejecting the 21st century makes no sense, rejecting globalization makes no sense. To influence globalization, to reform the French model, and to matter for France so that your children can live in a country in which they will have confidence and of which they will be proud, just as we have all been proud of the manifestations of November 11. To make patriotism resonate towards the future and not just towards the past, to love France, to be proud of France, to restore France, to build France, that is what I wish for in this city of Bordeaux that has welcomed me today with such warmth and friendship.

Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you.