Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the priorities in defense and security policy, in Paris on August 23, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 August 2007 · Launch of the White Paper Commission on Defence and National Security · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the White Paper Commission on Defense and National Security in Paris on August 23, 2007, launching a comprehensive review of French defense and security policy.
Main themes
Defense and security policy, White Paper on Defense and National Security, nuclear deterrence, national independence, European defense, France's strategic priorities, civil-military relations, 21st century security challenges, parliamentary involvement, methodological reform, international alliances, human rights
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,818
52nd percentile
Sentences
87
56th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
12.9
55th percentile
Syntax
2.93
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 46%45%
  • Geopolitical 35%34%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

87 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. President of the White Paper Commission on Defense and National Security,

Ladies and gentlemen, members of the commission,

I wanted to give a certain solemnity to the launch of your work, both to mark the importance I personally attach to it, as head of state, head of the armed forces, guarantor of the country's independence and respect for international treaties, and to emphasize the new impulses I intend to give to our defense and security policy.

Why a white paper? A white paper is a reference text that defines, for a certain period, the objectives of a public policy, the framework in which it develops, the choices it calls for, particularly to adapt the state. White papers on defense and national security are of a particular nature: they concretely reflect the ambition of the state regarding the essential, that is to say, the survival of the nation. And in this area, I adopt the phrase of General de Gaulle: "Defense! It is the primary reason for the existence of the state. It cannot fail without destroying itself."

But today, in the field of defense and national security, we need a new framework.

The White Paper that you are preparing and that I will approve next March will be the third since the beginning of the Fifth Republic, following that of 1972 and that of 1994.

It will be different from the previous ones. Different because the world is changing rapidly. Different because our concepts, our doctrine, our organization must adapt, consequently, more quickly, unless we take the risk that the state fails in its primary duty: to protect the population, the country, the republican nature of its institutions, the major international choices that condition its security and well-being. Finally, it will be different because I have entrusted its realization to a commission with an unprecedented format and composition, I will return to this.

But you are not starting from scratch; not everything needs to be reinvented. The major functions of our defense—deterrence, prevention, protection, and projection—remain valid. In particular, deterrence remains an absolute imperative on which I have already clearly expressed my position. In this context, I want the reflection you will undertake to be faithful to the French conception of defense and security: that is to say, global in its vision of the world, demanding of its independence, ambitious for Europe but open and pragmatic in its alliances, bold in its approach to human rights, and particularly attentive to the regions of the world where France is historically and culturally present.

From the outset, I wanted several changes to mark your work.

The first relates to the necessary openness that must characterize the reflection. This is vital if we want to evolve our defense and national security towards a better consideration of the challenges of the 21st century. We must build the security and defense of tomorrow based on needs, not on habits or preconceived certainties.

Of course, since this concerns defense and security, this work, particularly in the decision-making preparation phase, will require a certain confidentiality; everyone understands that.

But I want a real break in methods. I have therefore asked the president of your commission, whom I know fully shares this vision, to pay particular attention to taking into account a wide diversity of opinions, expertise, and sensitivities—political, professional, and social.

This will involve broad consultations with the various actors in our defense and security, at all levels, with the support of the relevant ministers.

You will also need to conduct public hearings during your work. We must move beyond closed circles and reflections in private. I therefore wish for you to gather the opinions of foreign personalities, particularly Europeans, on the future evolution of the international environment and on their views of French policy. You may seek the opinions of scientists, philosophers, or sociologists who can shed light on the future and the relevance of our choices. Or even call upon the testimony and experience of field actors who are rarely heard.

For the same reasons, I also encourage you to meet those who, on a daily basis, serve national defense and security: we must move, listen, learn, so that this reflection takes into account the social, professional, and human realities faced by those who have chosen to serve the defense and security of the country.

Openness also means the presence among you of members of the national representation and local elected officials. I personally insisted that Parliament be involved in the commission from the outset of the work. We know that this will lead to several legislative translations. This is, in any case, an essential dimension for our national defense and security policy, essential for the link between the nation, its defense, and its choices in terms of security. I warmly salute and thank the members of both assemblies who have accepted this task, respecting the respective prerogatives and the diversity of each one's political choices.

Finally, I want to highlight the call for contributions that you will soon launch, particularly to relevant university centers, and the establishment of an online forum for this purpose. This is an essential avenue for expression and awareness today. I have said it; I want the French to hear about defense on other occasions than just July 14.

The other change relates to the broad conception of national defense and security that I ask you to define. Like you, I have been saying for years that France's external security and security on its territory are inseparable. But I do not always see this reflected concretely in our organization, our means, or even our reflection!

To be honest, we need to question the adequacy of our defense organization texts to the situation of tomorrow. We all agree that the end of the Cold War should have been more concretely reflected in our organization and our means. The time has come to review texts, certainly venerable like the ordinances of 1959, but which date back half a century. This reflection must also allow for the acceleration of the reform of the Ministry of Defense, which is one of the keys to this modernization. I leave this to your judgment: you sense mine.

I ask you to propose to me an updated global strategy for national defense and security that guarantees the interests of the nation if a strategic surprise were to threaten them. With major objectives, understandable to all our fellow citizens, the protection of the population and the defense of the fundamental interests of the nation, including its European and international interests.

On this broader basis, I wish to initiate a reform of the state, to adapt it to the future challenges of our security, to the transnational dimensions of threats and responses to threats. It is evident that we must break down silos among services and administrations, strengthen the inter-service dimension of our capabilities, better coordinate inter-ministerial action, and be able to act effectively in coordination with our European and international partners, who have established modernized structures.

The French expect the state to have anticipatory and very rapid reaction capabilities. This is the legitimate counterpart expected from the efforts, particularly financial, made in favor of national defense and security. We must meet this expectation. Anticipation and reactivity will therefore be the watchwords of this new strategy.

In this context, we will also need to address aspects of this public policy that could not be thoroughly addressed in 1994: of course, the consequences of the professionalization of the armed forces on the relationship between defense, security, and society; but also the organization of our means on the metropolitan territory and overseas, or the new dimensions of civil security in the face of risks of natural disasters, international health crises, or hyper-terrorism.

As I committed to the French, this reflection will be conducted without taboos. The skills gathered here and their diversity are a guarantee of credibility.

The security of the French indeed requires as clear an identification as possible of the dangers against which we must protect ourselves, but also of the cooperations and conditions of peace in the world that we must encourage.

Already, terrorism and proliferation appear as major issues. They were clearly identified in the 1994 White Paper, but they are on the verge of crossing a particularly worrying threshold. However, our security is not limited to this. Other issues, less obvious, other data, less known, will be decisive or will come to light in the coming years: I am thinking in particular of all the consequences of globalization.

Let us not yield to reductive, simplistic, or Manichean visions of the world: they are rarely a guarantee of peace, and they are not in the tradition of France. It is our responsibility to prepare for the future by taking into account the complexity of the issues, the causes of possible conflicts, and also the reasons for hope.

Moreover, and this is an essential dimension of your work, France defines its defense and national security within a European, transatlantic, and international framework. It must be able to weigh in the organizations that determine international peace and security, as well as to respond to the obligations arising from its participation and its place on the Security Council. You will need to make the proposals that you consider best in this regard. I wish to adapt our policy and our means to these challenges. I want France to actively contribute to defining a more effective, fairer international framework that meets the challenges of the next fifteen years. For, here too, lies one of the keys to the security of the French.

Finally, your work, broad and free, must be operational and conclusive. Your role is to help determine particularly important choices for the country: prioritized objectives of national defense and security, strategy, equipment, force formats, financing, human resources, coherence of intelligence efforts, industrial and research policy. Nothing should be foreign to you.

The task is tough, as the constraints are multiple, the necessities for change significant, and the legacy heavy.

I have set the general framework for the nation's effort at around 2% of national wealth. This is an important indication for your work. This objective must allow France to equip itself with the necessary capabilities and to remain among the leading nations in Europe, alongside the United Kingdom.

The arbitrations and decisions will fall to the head of state. Their legislative translation, which will undoubtedly be diverse given the scope assigned to you, will be submitted to Parliament by the government. It will be necessary, for this purpose, to have credible scenarios and clear choices. I will not shirk from the responsibilities entrusted to me by the French.

I would like to thank you, Mr. State Counselor, ladies and gentlemen, for agreeing to dedicate your time, energy, and experience to this essential undertaking of modernizing our defense and security.