Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reforms undertaken since 2007, particularly in favor of businesses, in Paris on October 5, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

5 October 2009 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French business leaders in Paris, reviewing reforms undertaken since 2007 and France's response to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Economic reforms since 2007, business competitiveness, financial crisis response, banking sector stabilization, labor market reform, vocational training, pension reform, university autonomy, G20 and global financial regulation, tax havens, bonus scandal, French leadership in Europe
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,568
93rd percentile
Sentences
319
96th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 73%72%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

319 sentences in 66 paragraphs

Gentlemen Ministers,

Gentlemen Presidents of the National Assembly and the Senate,

Mr. President of the CGPME,

Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

And if you will allow me, dear friends,

I remember very well our meeting on December 7, 2007, in Lyon. You invited me to the assembly of entrepreneurs.

On that occasion, I told you one thing: my determination to act, to act quickly and to act profoundly, and my determination to do so on all fronts at once so as not to overlook any conservatism, any immobility. I told you that we would work, that we would reform, and that we would do everything at the same time because French society is complex and we cannot modernize one aspect while neglecting the others. I know that this strategy posed problems. Today, it is clear that we were right to do so.

I was elected for five years, to work from the first minute to the last, not to comment on the problems of France. I was not elected to make one reform a year and be exhausted at the end of the year. I was not elected to, halfway through my term, say: "that's it, we are doing nothing more." I was elected for things to change, to solve the problems of the country, to strengthen the competitiveness of France.

I spoke to you about the reform of the labor market, the reform of vocational training, Sunday work, the abolition of the annual flat tax, supplier-distributor relations, the merger of ANPE and UNEDIC, the reform of special pension schemes, the establishment of minimum service, the autonomy of universities. All these themes that we had been discussing for years, today, I can come back before you and say: "it’s done." These are not commitments, this is not a promise, this is not even a report. These are decisions that have been made.

All my commitments have been kept. And yet, at the same time, we have gone through the worst crisis the world has known since the 1930s. In the face of this crisis, how easy and convenient it would have been to say: "oh, there is a crisis, we stop!" And then at the end of the crisis: "oh, there is an exit from the crisis, we still do nothing!" And then, there are elections: "oh, we do nothing!" And the day after the elections: "oh, we do even less!" I found in the crisis reasons to act and to accelerate reforms. Because whether there is a crisis or not, there are problems that our country has carried for too long and to which it was necessary to provide solutions.

When the crisis arrived, at France's initiative, Europe decided to save its financial system. Extraordinary! What controversy did I hear when we mobilized funds to prevent the bankruptcy of our banks, which would have led to the bankruptcy of your businesses, which would have led to the bankruptcy of savers! I said in Toulon: "not a single saver will have to queue at the bank to recover their money. Not a single saver will be robbed!" Today, have we kept our commitments or have we not? I said that the unprecedented plan to mobilize public money to prevent the collapse of the banks would not only cost the State a single cent but would also bring in money. BNP repaid 5 billion euros last week that we had lent to them. Another major bank will do the same this week. Do you know that the interest on the money that, on behalf of the State, we lent to the banks and which is being repaid to us these days has brought in 500 million euros, the equivalent of the funding for the youth plan, so that young people can find a job.

Here is the record. We wanted results, these results are here, they are undeniable. We see those who lied at the time and those who told the truth. There comes a time when facts must be demonstrated. That is what we have done. I take no glory from it; it was our duty. I add that, unlike what has happened in other countries, there has not been one plan, two plans, three banking plans; there has been only one. Because the first was the right one and because all the other countries in Europe adopted the French plan.

I know perfectly well that the attitude, dear Jean-Marc ROUBAUD, of a certain number of you has shocked. I know that. It shocked me too; I know perfectly well. On August 25, when we adopted the French plan to put an end to the scandal of bonuses, to bring the banks back to the work that is theirs, to transform short-term money into money lent for the medium and long term, to individuals, to businesses, this plan became, on September 17, the plan of Europe. And by the end of September, it became the plan of the world, because at the G20 in Pittsburgh, it was the French ideas and the European ideas that triumphed over a capitalism gone mad because it forgot production in the service of speculation. We will continue, including regarding the tax on speculative movements; there too, these are results.

And when I see that all French banks, last week, decided to close all their subsidiaries in tax havens, I tell myself that something has indeed happened, and what has happened is the determination of a government team that did not yield. The world has changed; today, worldwide, tax havens will be sanctioned, and French banks will no longer have subsidiaries in tax havens. That is the least we could expect, but in six months, who could have thought it would be so easy to get accepted at the G20, the 20 countries of the world that alone represent 85% of global GDP.

And of course, you have had problems. From the very beginning of the crisis, we mobilized to support SMEs; we massively increased the resources of OSEO, whose coverage was raised to 90%, inter-company credit, which is fundamental for your operation, was supported with public credit insurance supplement programs. We established credit mediation, and I want to pay tribute once again to René RICOL, who did remarkable work because he is a courageous man who did not hesitate to pound the table to defend you and to say before the court of public opinion that there were things that were scandalous.

The FSI was established, and when the financial crisis turned into an economic crisis, we launched stimulus plans to support activity. The French stimulus plan, 26 billion euros, was put in place as early as December 4. Extraordinary! When it was implemented, a number of very bad faith observers said, "It's too small; it will bring no results." The same people today say, "the deficit is too large"; one must know! Six months ago, I had not spent enough; six months later, I have spent too much! The same people who said, "this plan is not up to what the United States is doing; why doesn't it go further?" the same people in the same newspapers, the same interlocutors say, "why has he spent so much?" Did the stimulus plan serve no purpose? It saved the French automotive industry, and when I see that car sales have increased despite the crisis, I say it before the Minister of Industry, Christian ESTROSI, by 2.5% with 14% more last month. How did that happen? When the two major manufacturers came to see me, they were short 3 billion euros because no one wanted to lend to them. The State was there and lent the money. We will not allow the French automotive industry to be sacrificed.

When we decided to implement the scrappage bonus, everywhere in Europe, people started by saying it was nationalistic. Today, everywhere in the world, there is the same scrappage bonus that was decided by the French. But let things be clear, I was very happy to hear the President of Renault say that of the four factories that will manufacture electric cars, two will be in France, because French taxpayer money will be used to support jobs in France. This is not protectionism; it is common sense.

Here is what we have done to save the French automotive industry. And housing, I speak under the control of Parliament. The SCELLIER law, what is it, if not a tax advantage to revive housing? The State's purchase of all social and collective programs that had been halted. If today housing is picking up, it is because we have committed to an unprecedented plan. Public works, all the money we have mobilized, the FCTVA of local authorities, is also picking up.

It is no coincidence that of all the countries in Europe, France is the one with the best results. The best results for this year and according to forecasts from independent organizations, also for next year. And by the way, the IMF said: "be careful, continue to support growth." And to those who talk to me about deficits, I say: yes, yes, of course, we must take care of them, but if we were to return to depression, the deficits would be much larger. Our duty in a country that has lost 54 billion euros in tax revenue due to the crisis is to regain growth so that revenues return. And above all, we must turn our backs on this crisis.

So, of course, we will only truly emerge from the crisis when unemployment decreases. So for unemployment to decrease, growth must return. But we must also be more productive. We must allow those who work to be free to do so without hindrance. We must allow those who want to create wealth to create their businesses, and above all, to develop them. Jean-Marc ROUBAUD is right; unemployment is the primary problem. Of course, if unemployment is the primary problem, then employment is the primary solution. And for employment to be the primary solution, we must help businesses. I am told: "in the excellent budget of Eric WOERTH, you prioritized business." Of course, because who creates jobs if not businesses? What do you expect from me in a period of rising unemployment? To do less for businesses so that there are fewer jobs, less growth? Pitting businesses against households makes no sense because businesses create jobs for households. Doing for businesses is giving purchasing power to households, reducing unemployment, and strengthening the competitiveness of France. Pitting one against the other makes absolutely no sense.

So, rising unemployment, insufficient investment. These are the problems facing our country. Well, for that, we are going to take a number of measures.

First, I announce that we will extend the zero charge measure for small businesses because it has been a real success; 500,000 hires have already benefited from it. Specifically, all hires by companies with fewer than 10 employees made during the first half of 2010 will be exempt from all employer contributions for one year. It is simple, clear, massive, and immediate. It is not a gift for businesses; it is a gift for the hundreds of thousands of people who will have the chance to find a job thanks to this.

I also count on you to mobilize in favor of youth employment, a major issue, by resolutely engaging in work-study training. Let’s be concrete: if you hire an apprentice, I say this before Laurent WAUQUIEZ, who is doing a remarkable job to give young people a chance, if you hire an apprentice before June 30, 2010, you will pay no employer contributions. If you are a company with fewer than 50 employees and you hire additional apprentices, you will receive a grant of 1,800 euros per apprentice. For hires under professionalization contracts, the terms are also clear: you have a grant of 1,000 euros, increased to 2,000 euros if the young person concerned does not have a high school diploma. I want young people to enter businesses, not our administrations because we need them in our businesses more than in our administrations. Because we need private jobs, market jobs, and not administrative jobs.

Investment is a French ailment, the insufficiency of investment. The crisis has aggravated this weakness. Business investment will decrease by 7.6% in 2009. We should not be surprised by this: for 35 years, France has been the only country that taxes investment instead of promoting it, but that is outrageous! It is outrageous to say that we want to promote investment and then tax it. It makes no sense; it undermines the credibility of public speech.

With the reform of the business tax, we are initiating a revolution in our tax system, and I take responsibility for the carbon tax at the same time. Why do I take responsibility for both together, and I say it before you? Because we will stop taxing what is good for our country, investment, to tax what is bad for our country, pollution.

If we do not change the base of taxation and if we continue to tax investment and labor, we should not be surprised that the temptation to relocate is immense.

For 35 years, we have known that the business tax, which weighs on investments, is an economic aberration.

For 35 years, I say, our tax system has encouraged companies to relocate factories. In 1999, we thought we were doing the right thing by eliminating the payroll component of the business tax to help employment, but at the same time, we concentrated taxation even more on industry, precisely on the sectors most exposed to international competition. We created the conditions for there to be no industries or workers left in France. And indeed, we were on the verge of achieving that, with the help of the 35-hour workweek, and it is no coincidence that France has become the most deindustrialized of the major European economies. There are two reasons for this: a business tax that does not exist anywhere else in Europe and the 35-hour workweek that does not exist anywhere else in the world.

I will take an example to make myself clear. The business tax weighs 250 euros per vehicle produced in France. The automobile industry, including subcontractors, accounts for 10% of the French workforce, two million five hundred thousand employees. How do you expect our car manufacturers to choose to continue producing in France with that reality?

In 2004, we manufactured 3.2 million vehicles. By 2007, we were producing nearly 1 million fewer, or 2.4 million. A 25% reduction in French automobile production in three years. Bravo, if this is a policy, it is a triumph; it is not my policy, and I want us to keep industries in France. I am sorry to say that it is not to the glory of our country that the main French car manufacturer, in 2007, had two-thirds of its workforce outside France with the State as a shareholder at 17%. I want this reality to change. It is normal to build and produce abroad when you want to sell vehicles abroad, but it is not normal to build abroad vehicles that you want to sell in France. This is not the relocation that we accept and that we want. This is not the industrial process.

So, to save the automobile industry, as I said, we have the scrappage bonus, the bonus-malus system, financing for manufacturers, support for subcontractors. In September, new car sales reached record levels. The automobile market increased by 2.4% in one year thanks to the measures we have taken. This proves that we are not helpless; it proves that with a little will, a little energy, a little vision, we can change things. The market is not everything. The market is important, but it is the duty of a State to have an economic policy, to have an industrial policy. I hold on to my convictions, but resignation in the face of the market and fate is not acceptable.

I cannot accept the future of a France without factories. We will organize a national industry conference before the end of the year.

The reform of the business tax is at the heart of our new industrial policy. All my predecessors, without exception, have denounced this tax, I quote: foolish. Everyone agreed, it is curious, but no one abolished it.

As I committed myself, starting next year, in 2010, there will be no more business tax on company investments; it is over. You will be able to invest, and you will not pay a single cent of business tax on investments.

This is a competitiveness shock for our companies. This reform of the business tax will be done in one year. And I thank Eric Woerth because I know perfectly well that his services told him, "No, the business tax is a good reform, but come on, if you want to go very fast, we will do it in ten years. But it would be more reasonable to do it in twenty years, and we are ready to propose a scenario in thirty years." We decided with Eric that it would be done in one year. Because either the business tax is a good tax, and in that case, it should be kept. Or it is a bad tax, and in that case, it should be abolished. We must make decisions now and stick to them. This will translate in 2010 into a cash relief of 12 billion euros for French companies. This is not a gift. What we want is for you to be competitive, for you to gain market shares, for you to bring growth to the French economy, and for you to create jobs. In steady state, this reform will represent 6 billion euros in tax relief for companies.

The target of this reform, I say clearly, is the companies that are exposed to international competition, to strengthen the competitiveness of these companies. For almost all French companies, the impact of the reform will result in a very significant tax relief. I want you, the entrepreneurs, to play the game of our territory, of our country. That you invest primarily in France, since no tax burden will weigh on your investments.

All economic sectors will benefit from the reform. In some limited cases, certain companies will see an adjustment in their business tax contribution. I have asked Ms. Lagarde to provide for mechanisms for spreading over 5 years and for reductions, in order to limit some counter-effects of the abolition of the business tax.

I have asked that the capping of the business tax in relation to value added be reduced, Mr. President, from 3.5% today to 3% starting in 2010; this is a request you have made for a long time, and this request is satisfied. No company will pay more than 3% of the amount of its value added in business tax. We will also establish a second cap that takes into account the share of value added in turnover because we want to consider the situation of companies with high value added.

In the budgetary environment we are in, we must make choices; we must set priorities.

Our priority is our industrial policy. I know well that industry accounts for only 14% of value added and jobs, but it contributes to more than 30% of private investment, 90% of private research, and 80% of exports.

So, everyone will benefit from the reduction in the business tax, either directly or indirectly.

Our policy is coherent: it is a comprehensive competitiveness policy. In 2008, we tripled the research tax credit. To relieve the cash flow of companies, we decided to extend in 2010 the immediate reimbursement of research tax credit claims decided as part of the recovery plan.

Finally, in 2010, we will continue the abolition of the annual flat tax that I announced to you in Lyon. In 2010, almost all SMEs, those with a turnover of less than 15 million euros, will be definitively exempt. And by the end of 2010, the flat tax will no longer exist. That is a request you will no longer make in your congresses.

So, I know that we also need to rebuild working capital because we will need to make deferred investments during the crisis even as your cash flow is at its lowest. French companies need to invest, and to invest, they need equity. And they cannot remain indefinitely strangled by debt, and they will not be able to borrow without first strengthening their equity. The undercapitalization of French SMEs condemns them to choose between deadly stagnation and deadly over-indebtedness. It is an obstacle to growth. Yes, not enough equity, and when you do not have equity, you cannot develop, you cannot borrow, and when, to create equity, you go into debt, you are too indebted and you are strangled at the first economic downturn. And we see the result; the hallmark of French SMEs is precisely that they remain SMEs. France has only 460 independent mid-sized companies (ETIs), of which 150 are industrial companies. One and a half per department. It is true, France has great industrial champions. But far too many of them prefer to invest and produce abroad while SMEs and ETIs create jobs in France.

Unlike large groups, every euro invested in strengthening your equity is a euro invested in employment in France. That is why we are going to act now, for you.

Resources exist. It is now possible to allocate part of your wealth tax (ISF) to strengthening the equity of SMEs. What a scandal when I announced this measure, isn't it, dear Hervé Novelli? What a scandal. It is a tremendous success: 930 million euros have been raised under the 2008 campaign. Wealth tax money that has come to invest in your companies. Nearly one billion euros.

But we must go further.

I announce that we will put 2 billion euros at the disposal of SMEs and mid-sized companies to strengthen your equity. These amounts will fund a range of products that will be managed half by the strategic investment fund and half by OSEO.

The FSI will specifically direct 1 billion euros towards SMEs. We met with the Prime Minister and I asked the FSI now - the French sovereign fund - to take care of SMEs and to stop lending money or investing in companies that do not need it. This money will be invested in several ways. For companies weakened by the crisis, the consolidation fund created under the auspices of credit mediation will have 200 million euros. For SMEs with high growth potential, the FSI will reserve a direct investment line of 300 million euros for SMEs. And the FSI will inject 300 million euros into regional venture capital and private equity funds. We are going to put a lot into the equity of SMEs. We are easing the tax burden with the flat tax, the research tax credit, the abolition of the business tax on investment, and the exemptions from charges for your hiring. We are strengthening your competitiveness. And, with the FSI and OSEO, we are putting two billion euros to strengthen your equity. It is a coherent policy so that you are freed from constraints and can develop.

I know that these capital investments are not simple matters. I know that for many of you, opening your capital to external investors is a very heavy decision. You do not always want to account to directors you do not know. Opening up capital is a necessary step in the growth and maturity of a company. I do not know any large group that is 100% in the hands of a family. However, I know many wonderful companies whose family has retained control while mobilizing the savings of investors and individuals for their development.

But the choice must remain entirely free, and the contribution of equity is urgent. That is why we have decided, knowing your sensitivity to capital opening, to offer you quasi-equity. Quasi-equity has an advantage; it is long-term money, inexpensive, without you having to open your capital. But in relation to your creditors, quasi-equity has the same role as equity, but you retain total freedom in managing your company.

Well, I announce to you that the French Sovereign Fund will dedicate 300 million euros to these quasi-equity in the form of convertible bonds. They will be long-term, with an average or high-interest rate depending on whether they are converted into capital or not, and you will have the choice to refuse the conversion. They will have a major interest: you will have a quick response. I announce to you that we have requested that for files of less than 4 million euros, the FSI gives you a response in less than 4 weeks. This is a commitment I make to you because funds that are richly endowed where you have to wait four years for an acknowledgment of receipt is not exactly what I want.

OSEO will mobilize one billion euros in the form of participatory loans. These will be loans without guarantees, long-term, with deferred repayment. So, of course, they will have a higher interest rate than traditional bank loans because they will be riskier and there will be no guarantees.

We are not borrowing this money to burden future generations. These 2 billion euros will not be spent but invested in the French economy. They will produce a double benefit: that of the interest paid to the State and, above all, that of the growth and jobs of companies.

I have asked Christine Lagarde, the FSI, and OSEO that these products be immediately available. The FSI SME scheme, I announce to you, is immediately operational, and you can contact, as soon as you leave this meeting, directly the FSI or the regional directorate of the Caisse des Dépôts, dear Augustin. OSEO's participatory loans will be available directly at OSEO and throughout the banking networks starting November 1. Hervé Novelli, whom I thank for his dynamism, will lead a round table in a few moments to explain the details of these products. I did not come to give a lofty speech. I came as a man of the field to speak to women and men of the field. And again, you will judge by the results.

I would like to conclude by talking about deficits. Our deficits are widening due to the crisis and the collapse of revenues. I am told, "Is this really the time to help businesses?"

But if we had not abolished the professional tax on investments, it was gradually the very base of this tax that would have disappeared. We would have been faced with a virtual tax, as little by little all the industrial companies that bore the brunt of it were disappearing or relocating. The proof is, who is the largest taxpayer of the professional tax? The State. Since we found ourselves in an absolutely nonsensical system where elected officials were increasing the professional tax, companies were no longer paying it since they were capped, and the difference was paid by the State, thus by the taxpayer. Who can think that such a system could last?

It is not by burdening our businesses with charges and taxes that we will resolve the issue of deficits. I was not elected to raise taxes, and I will not do so. I confirm this because every time it has been done in the past in France, it has delayed the return of growth and limited growth. We are already the country with the highest mandatory levies in Europe; there is no question of falling into this ease. It is not the increase in taxes and the increase in charges that will bring back growth. It is competitiveness and investment that will bring back growth.

Of course, there is the question of controlling expenditures, where I see that I am being given a lot of advice. I am eager for it. But to those who may have forgotten, when we asked Rachida Dati to reform the judicial map, reducing the number of courts by a third, a judicial map that had not changed since 1958, where were those who are asking me for savings today? They were protesting against the reform of the judicial map. Since 1958, it had not been touched. Everyone knows that there were too many locations; we reformed the judicial map. To reduce deficits, we reformed our military installations. Fifty bases have been closed. When I became President of the Republic, there was nothing but 38 air bases, half of which had not had planes for 15 years. A country that can be crossed in 25 minutes with Mirage 2000-5. The army is meant to ensure the security of France and defend its interests, not to manage land use. Land use is very necessary, but if we have to keep all our courts, all our bases, what do we do? We have just passed the hospital law because hospitals account for 51% of health insurance expenditures, and we need to consolidate a number of structures to be more efficient, to provide better care, and to allocate money not to maintain structures that do not have the means to be competitive and effective, but to finance new machines, new treatments, and new doctors who will ensure your health.

Since I became President of the Republic, I have fully enforced the rule of not replacing one civil servant out of two who retires. We have eliminated 100,000 public jobs. This had never happened in France. When we know that salaries plus pensions account for more than 50% of the Nation's budget.

But the State cannot bear this effort of savings alone, while local government expenditures exceed 200 billion euros per year and, excluding transfers of competencies, their share of GDP has increased by 20% in 30 years. That is why I will carry out, starting this autumn, an ambitious reform of local authorities with the Prime Minister, which will lead to a reduction, halving the number of elected officials in our territories. And of course, it will be the same people who will animate our departments and regions. Can we continue with a region that ignores what the departments of that region are doing? Municipality, community of municipalities, department, region, State, Europe. Here too, everyone knows it well; everyone has denounced it. Who has done it? In the next regional elections, not this one, the next one, when you vote, you will vote for both your departmental elected official and your regional elected official, and they will do both at the same time. You will understand more and it will weigh less heavily. What I am naturally asking for local authorities will also apply to territorial administrations. The time has come to take into account a number of things.

But you know, ladies and gentlemen, this is the program until the end of the year. But there will be next year!

And I will not shy away. By the end of the year, I will announce the reform of high schools, because it is absolutely crucial that we have the best high schools in Europe just as we are going to have the best universities in Europe. We will reform the justice system.

And I will not shy away next year on the issue of pensions. We are facing the rising cost of aging. So yes, thanks to our demographics, we will be able to cope better than most other European countries. But this cost will weigh heavily on our public finances. If we want to preserve our social system, which has been functioning since 1945, we will need to adapt to demographic challenges. I will open this project in 2010 in close consultation with social partners. All solutions will be examined without taboos. You see, reading the press this morning, that some people who apparently do not know me well say, "Oh dear, he talks about it but he won't open it!" Well, see you in 2010. I was elected to solve the problems of the country, to solve them immediately with justice and equity. I do not feel imprisoned by any political family. I have a duty to every French citizen, whether they voted for me or not. I have a duty to each of them, to each of you. At the end of my term, to hand over to the French a more competitive, fairer France, with results. I am not a man to wait for the crisis and the sky to fall on our heads to act; I am not a man to say at the end of my term, "Oh dear, I didn't have time." We work from the first minute to the last minute; that is the meaning of the action of the government team. That is what I have asked, together with the Prime Minister, of all the ministers, and you know, ladies and gentlemen, I do it because I am convinced that it is in the general interest of the country, that it must be done, that time works against us, and that we have already waited far too long in our country, and that, in the end, if I was elected, it is to act, not to wait.

Thank you.