Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, particularly on religious tolerance, in New York on September 23, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 September 2008 · New York

Context
Sarkozy addressed a gathering in New York on September 23, 2008, speaking on religious tolerance, anti-Semitism, and Franco-American ties in the aftermath of 9/11.
Main themes
Religious tolerance, anti-Semitism, Franco-American solidarity, fight against terrorism, equality of religions in France, interfaith dialogue, democracy and human rights, war of civilizations, Middle East diversity, Lebanon and Israel, rule of law, French identity
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,289
38th percentile
Sentences
76
50th percentile
Readability
68
97th percentile
Grade
8.0
4th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
8th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 45%45%
  • Geopolitical 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

76 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

First of all, I want to say to the Mayor of New York that we are in the month of September. Seven years ago, when the two towers of New York collapsed, all the French, without exception, were deeply moved. You are a city that has inspired admiration around the world. When you had thousands of New Yorkers dead, all the French felt close to you, because what happened to you seven years ago could have happened to us under the same conditions. It was not New York that was targeted; it was democracy that was targeted, it was freedom that was targeted by barbarians who are common enemies.

New York has inspired admiration around the world because New York remained united, because you continued to live, and because you did not accept to give up your ideas. In this fight against terrorism, against barbarism, France will always stand by the United States.

When we needed you, you were there for us. I wanted to tell you today, in New York, that no one has forgotten your suffering, your dignity, and your courage.

I would like, Rabbi, to say a word about France. There has been much talk about anti-Semitism in France. I want you to know that when a Jew is insulted in France, when a Jew is mistreated because he is a Jew, it is not just the concern of the Jews of France; it is the concern of all of France, without exception. Because anti-Semitism is a stain on the French tricolor flag.

Rabbi, you know that I have waged an unrelenting fight against anti-Semites and against racists. Anti-Semitism cannot be explained; it must be fought and punished. When one tries to explain the inexplicable, it is because one is preparing to excuse the inexcusable. This is France's fight. I will lead this fight without weakness.

I want, Rabbi, to tell you something else. I have a great interest in religions. It is a personal domain, even if, at the end of each speech, I like to be told: "May God protect you." Honestly, I believe I need it.

But I want to be understood clearly. In France, there are my compatriots who are Jewish, others who are Christian, and others who are Muslim. In France, I want everyone to have the same rights. In France, there is no religion that is superior to another. Everyone has the right to pray and to believe or not to believe and not to pray. We all want them to be equal.

If you come to my beautiful country, not necessarily to spend money, to go to the theater, to listen to music, to see exhibitions, you will see that there are churches, that there are temples, that there are synagogues, and that there are also mosques. We are proud that everyone can live their faith in respect of all others.

I wanted, moreover, a different government with women and men from all backgrounds. I want to say here, in the United States, the land of freedom, that a humiliated identity is a radicalized identity. We must respect everyone.

In the land of freedom, France, the land of Human Rights, we do not fight terrorists with the methods of terrorists; we fight terrorists with our method: respect for the rule of law, respect for Human Rights, respect for due process.

I tell the Rabbi that when he invites the Pope to pray in his synagogue, he sets a magnificent example. It is like when the King of Saudi Arabia, the guardian of the holy places of Islam, goes to see the Holy Father to talk with him; he sets the right example.

Killing in the name of the religions of the Book is absurd; it is a scandal.

We do not want a war of religions. We do not want a war of civilizations. We respect Islam. It is not Islam that is the adversary; it is the fanatics, our adversaries. It is not the Muslims who are guilty; it is those who use them in the service of a cause that is one of war and hatred. We must not confuse individuals with others. But I want to tell them, with the same strength, that we accept that everyone, on our territory, lives their religion, but that we ask for reciprocity for Christians in the East. Diversity cannot be good for us and forbidden for them.

I want to conclude with this. Often, there have been attempts to lead a crusade in the service of democracy. It is a good intention. But sometimes, peoples who have a different tradition than ours say: "Democracy is your system that you want to impose on us." We must fight for diversity because diversity has always been known in the East. And the East is rich if the East remains diverse. That is why France fights for the independence of Lebanon, and that is why France fights for the security of Israel, because these are the two countries where diversity remains in the Middle East.

My Dear Friends, contrary to appearances, I must return to France, for I have more to do than just in New York. But I want to tell you one thing: I am trying to modernize my country with the Prime Minister and the ministers of the government who surround me. I am trying, in the crisis we all know, to draw inspiration from what has made the strength of the United States of America: work, freedom, social promotion. Everything is possible for you. And I want everything to become possible for us too.

Before I leave, I would like to tell you two last things. You are the inhabitants of the most powerful country on the planet. You have achieved something extraordinary here. But the world is watching you; you should also look at the world, and the world will help you more.

And then, a second thing I would like to tell you. When business is good, it is normal for many people to make a lot of money, but when business is bad, it is normal for those who have made such heavy mistakes to bear the consequences and responsibilities. This is perhaps a weakness, but I, Carla, have never been on the left. But I love justice, and it is not fair that those who have led us where we are do not assume the responsibilities that are theirs. Freedom is not the law of charity. Freedom only goes with responsibility, and believe me, I am aware of this every day. When things do not go well in my country, my country knows whom to blame. And it is normal; if I do not want responsibility, I should not seek the world to be president of my country. And when you are the president of a company, or the president of a bank, the president of an association, the representative of a faith, you cannot say: "Things are not going well; it is not my fault." It is necessarily the fault of the one who is the leader at the moment when failure occurs, because that same person who refuses failure would have been the first to demand the reward for success if success had been achieved.

My Dear Friends, there is a country called France, which has 64 million inhabitants and loves you very much, you Americans. When our children look at where they want to go, they often say first the United States, and especially New York. When you have such a power of attraction, you must absolutely contribute to being, through your reality, worthy of the dream we have projected onto the United States of America.

Thank you.