Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, particularly on the construction of a second EPR and on renewable energies, in Flamanville on February 6, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

6 February 2009 · Visit to the Flamanville nuclear construction site · Flamanville construction site, Flamanville, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed industry leaders and officials at Flamanville on February 6, 2009, to announce the construction of a second EPR nuclear reactor.
Main themes
EPR nuclear reactor construction, nuclear energy renaissance, French industrial excellence, energy security and electricity supply, CO2 emissions reduction, nuclear safety, investment continuity in nuclear sector, renewable energies, Flamanville construction site, EDF and Areva, long-term energy planning
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,606
70th percentile
Sentences
133
76th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 58%57%
  • Environmental 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 1%

133 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Madam Minister, Dear Christine,

Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents of EDF, Areva, Bouygues, Alstom,

Ladies and Gentlemen elected officials,

Mr. President,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Since I became President of the Republic, I have wanted to come here, to Flamanville, to see the largest construction site in Europe. That has now been accomplished, and I do not regret coming.

Flamanville is a construction site that the whole world is watching. It is the model site for the renaissance of nuclear energy worldwide. All countries that have chosen to return to nuclear energy or to develop nuclear energy will see in the success of Flamanville the confirmation of their choice. Flamanville is the showcase apartment of third-generation nuclear energy.

Flamanville is a facet of French excellence, technological excellence, industrial excellence - industry is not a dirty word - and environmental excellence. It is an image of France that our partners are rediscovering, that of a country that produces almost all of its electricity without CO2. A country, ours, that has managed for thirty years a homogeneous fleet of 58 nuclear power plants without a major incident. France is cited as an example, to show that one can reduce dependence on oil, reduce emissions, and ensure its population one of the lowest electricity prices in the world, based on thoughtful industrial choices. The two companies that are the foundation of this success are EDF and Areva, once again united in Flamanville on the site of the first French EPR. In Flamanville, these great companies hold the reputation and image of France, but also our economic future, our industrial future.

I have great confidence in the EPR and I have great confidence in the competence of our companies. In 2004, I was Minister of Economy and Finance and I decided to launch the first EPR and I chose Flamanville for its location. And it is because the Flamanville construction site is progressing under good conditions and provides all assurances of being completed on time that I was able to make the decision, with the Prime Minister and Christine LAGARDE, to launch the construction of a second EPR in France. You see, it is curious, before the presidential election, I was in favor of the EPR and after the presidential election, I have not changed my mind. I willingly admit that it is original. If we need to undertake a third EPR construction, we will decide that as well.

The EPR technology is the most advanced among third-generation reactors, it is the one that provides all guarantees of success. And Normandy will strengthen its place in the global nuclear sector since it is the Penly site that is preparing to host this new construction starting in 2012.

I thought a lot before making the decision to launch a second EPR. I consulted Christine LAGARDE, Jean-Louis BORLOO, and many experts. I decided on this second EPR for three main reasons.

First, because this second EPR will come into service in 2017 and that starting in 2019, several existing nuclear power plants will reach their fortieth anniversary. Based on the recommendations of the nuclear safety authority, it will be necessary to decide on their shutdown or extension and the associated investments. I want the nuclear safety authority to be able to make this decision in complete serenity, based solely on safety considerations. And it is because we will have a second EPR that the decision will be made based on safety elements and not under the pressure of the question of electricity supply for our country. The second EPR will provide a safety margin. It is because our nuclear fleet is not eternal that we must decide responsibly given the construction timelines of such equipment. Just think, I decided in 2004 on the first EPR, it will produce in 2012! I decided in 2009 on the second which will produce in 2017. You see that we must work for the future and not just day by day.

The second reason for my decision is the experience of countries returning to nuclear energy, which shows how difficult it is to recreate nuclear competence, industrial knowledge, in a country that is no longer investing. The succession of periods of massive investment and periods of complete halt is destructive for an industry like yours with such technological intensity. We cannot afford to stop; it is a continuum. It seems to me therefore sensible, to maintain the experience of projects of this size, to update skills, to keep them at the highest level, to prefer a spread of our investments over time rather than a complete halt to all nuclear investment at the end of the Flamanville project in 2012. Imagine if I had not made this decision; it would mean that the technological potential that has come together on this site would stop, dissolve into the sands. Whereas with the prospect of a second project, we are investing in a long-term industry.

The third reason, I do not hesitate to admit, is that France does not have such a flourishing foreign trade that it can disregard electricity exports. We are going to become an electricity exporter. An EPR produces about 12 billion kilowatt-hours per year, at European market prices, that is 600 million euros in exports; I am waiting for someone to tell me that we do not need it. And then, crisis or no crisis, it would be a strange conception of the economy to accept trade in all goods and services where our neighbors are more competitive than us, and to refuse it in a field where France is ranked first in the world.

These are the reasons why I deemed a second EPR necessary. I also add that it seemed useful to me for EDF to associate GDF Suez with its project. EDF will be the operator, but France has a second world-class energy company and must give it every chance. GDF Suez is a competent, recognized operator. I could not refuse GDF Suez the right, in international markets, to export French EPR technology and thus support Areva's export efforts, along with all the jobs that come with it. I do not see how I could have refused GDF Suez, of which the State and public companies own 40%, what was granted to the Italian electricity company, rightly so, ENEL, here in Flamanville? GDF Suez, as an associated partner in the future EPR of Penly, will be able to strengthen its competence on the EPR model, and given the nuclear need in the world, EDF and GDF Suez have every place to be major exporters.

Until 2007, it must be acknowledged, our energy policy relied solely on this pillar of nuclear energy. For the past eighteen months, I wanted our energy policy to take a fundamental turn, in addition to nuclear energy, towards renewable energies and energy savings. My ambition for France is that we be leaders in nuclear energy, but I see no reason why we would be leaders in nuclear energy and not seek to be leaders in renewable energy and energy savings. We must be leaders everywhere. The crisis we have experienced, the price of oil which has more than doubled to reach a peak of $145 last June, has only validated the relevance of the major orientations outlined during the Grenelle de l'Environnement. We will finish the 21st century without oil, perhaps without gas. Therefore, we must first reconnect with a great ambition in energy savings. I fully accept that saving energy, better using energy, improving energy efficiency are among the priorities of a sustainable energy policy.

That is why we are going to propose a zero-interest loan, up to 30,000 euros, with no income conditions for all those who want to better insulate public and private buildings. This is a considerable prospect for the construction industry: a zero-interest loan of up to 30,000 euros with no income conditions for energy-saving work.

And furthermore, we will develop renewable energies. I have committed on behalf of France to 23% renewable energy in our energy mix by 2020. This is a legal, binding objective, monitored by the European Court of Justice, and therefore we must get to work.

This objective that I have taken on behalf of France is considerable. It means that we will have to produce each year the energy of 4 EPRs in the form of wind turbines, one EPR in the form of solar energy, and 6 EPRs in the form of wood and biomass. The production of 11 EPRs supplied by renewable energies by 2020: this is an energy revolution for our country. When you think that we have the largest forest in Europe, that since 1950 the French forest has doubled, and that we find a way, as I speak to you, to be an importer of wood. Is that reasonable? Can we not invest in both the EPR, nuclear energy, and the wood sector to exploit our forests rather than let the wood that was knocked down by the storm rot? Is it reasonable for a country that has the largest forest in Europe? I therefore accept that we will do both.

This revolution in new energies is also an industrial revolution.

We must therefore build alongside nuclear energy a genuine French industrial strategy for the development of renewable energies. Not against nuclear energy, but alongside nuclear energy. We are starting from very far behind. I would like to remind you that the wind industry is Danish, that the photovoltaic industry is German and Californian. Wind in Denmark and sun in California, we understand that geography matters. But sun in Germany, it is not insulting our German friends to say that Normandy is still better. We have exceptional potential in renewable energies, abundant forest resources, and three complementary wind regimes that ultimately give us the second largest wind potential in Europe. Furthermore, overseas, France has the third largest maritime domain in the world and considerable solar potential. We have world-class research in energy, electronics, semiconductors, nanotechnologies, research that has only one flaw, that of not having embodied its work in a powerful industry. We will increase the share of renewable energies by 150%, which can only favor the emergence of an industry.

By 2020, 90 billion euros will need to be invested, almost entirely by private investors and individuals, to equip our country with solar power plants, wood heating systems, and all housing equipment based on renewable energies, which will allow us to meet our commitments.

I have asked Christine LAGARDE and Jean-Louis BORLOO to take on this fundamental issue. It is time to ask the Atomic Energy Commission to direct its action more massively towards new energies and to set up the technological platforms that will allow for the industrialization of production. We need to re-examine the effectiveness of our support for renewable energies. We need to be more proactive on certain energies. The public authorities are entitled to expect genuine industrial returns. I say this to Pierre GADONNEIX, our major energy companies have a particular responsibility in this area, especially EDF, which is making a considerable research and development effort. They must continue to invest in this area.

As for Areva, it is the very example, in nuclear energy, of success. All its competitors are now imitating its integrated model, which starts from the uranium mine, goes through the manufacture of fuel, the construction and maintenance of reactors, and ends with the treatment and recycling of waste, not far from here. It is a guarantee for all.

I support Areva's commitment to invest in these activities, particularly in the new Georges Besse 2 enrichment plant. Areva has just signed a contract in India for 2 of the 6 EPRs; I hope it will be six. This is another step in the revival of nuclear energy. Thanks to the two ongoing EPR projects, Areva has gained considerable ground that it must maintain.

I add that we will reflect on the industrial partnerships that would be most beneficial to Areva. Christine LAGARDE and Jean-Louis BORLOO are working on this. It is a reflection that cannot be improvised, that will take some time, but I want it to come to fruition soon because it is now necessary, and in any case, with the decision of the Germans, particularly Siemens, to leave Framatome, we have no choice: we must move forward. I reiterate, I was elected to make decisions, and I will make them. You understand the situation well. There is a considerable energy bet. Our strategy is the development of nuclear energy with EPR and the third generation. There are two to sign, and I am considering the possibility of a third in the coming years. We will invest massively in renewable energies. There is only complementarity, and I wish that we do not choose one energy source, that we do not cover the country with wind turbines, as some do, but that we pay attention to the wood sector, that we pay attention to solar energy, that we pay attention to all possible energy sources. Frankly, we have the means to do both. I add a third with the strategy on energy savings; we need to completely change our reasoning in this area. We have EDF, we have GDF/Suez, we have Total, we have Areva, we have Alstom, which will remain my pride for having refused to dismantle Alstom in 2004 when it was imposed on us, a remarkable company.

Now we need to work together. There is a world to conquer in terms of energy, and France, which has no oil, which has no gas, will become an energy exporter. That is the ambition I set for you. I would like to say to the employees who are here that I am fully aware that there are not only EDF people in the operation of a power plant; there are other employees, other companies, notably Bouygues, which is constructing, and that the issue of subcontractors is a concern for me. But when we build a nuclear power plant and operate it, all employees must be treated under the same conditions because they share the same skills and responsibilities. This is a subject that arises, not only for the nuclear industry but also for the automotive industry.

On construction sites, when I shake hands with workers, I shake hands in the same way regardless of the company. I say this on a construction site. The problem is less pressing. But I am talking about operation. I would also like to say to EDF employees, since I am on a site, you can be proud of the work you have done. And especially in a company that has succeeded in involving employees in the profits of the company. I spoke about it last night, but I did not mention it just to mention it. I spoke about it because I expect results, concrete results. I reiterate things as clearly as possible: that the employee organizations and employer organizations come to an agreement; if they come to an agreement, the State has nothing to say. If they do not come to an agreement, the State will take its responsibilities, and I will assume them. In any case, by the end of the year, we need to have made a decision on this issue and that the question of profit sharing has been resolved. You are proud to work in your companies; we are proud of your work and your skills; it is normal that you are thanked for it, and not just by a speech from the President of the Republic.

Thank you all for your attention.