Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, particularly on NATO, Euro-Russian relations, and European defense, in Munich on February 7, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

7 February 2009 · Munich Security Conference · Munich, Germany

Context
Sarkozy addressed the Munich Security Conference on February 7, 2009, speaking on NATO, European defense, and Euro-Russian relations amid post-Georgia crisis tensions.
Main themes
NATO membership criteria, Euro-Atlantic solidarity, multipolar world order, Euro-Russian relations, European defense, values-based alliances, Ukraine and Georgia, transatlantic friendship, terrorism and global risks, European integration, burden sharing, freedom and democracy
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,977
75th percentile
Sentences
184
87th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
8.7
9th percentile
Syntax
2.70
13th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Munich Security Conference Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 84%84%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

184 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Madam Chancellor, dear Angela,

Dear Donald,

Mr. President,

I am very happy to be here to discuss all these issues of defense, friendship with the United States, solidarity among us, to try to speak as frankly as possible, and with as little jargon as possible.

First of all, we are at the 20th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall.

Some believed that we had entered a "unipolar world." We are in a world of "relative powers." This is the first reasoning around which we must organize all our strategies. As Angela Merkel said, as Donald Tusk said, a single power cannot resolve the great conflicts of the world. The 21st century sees the emergence of great powers, which say: "we too want to have our say, we too matter, we too have interests to defend." Moreover, we need these new great powers to put pressure on the belligerents and achieve peace.

If we are willing to consider that we have entered the world of "relative powers," it means that the first consequence is the necessity of solidarity, Donald, and cooperation.

When there is only one great power, there is no need for cooperation; one decides and the others follow. When there are "relative powers," then solidarity and cooperation are required. The 21st century will be the century of cooperation and solidarity. That is why, by the way, I am so attached to the friendship with the United States of America. Friendship among independent allies who respect each other's values.

What has history taught us? That no Empire, however great, can win against the aspiration for freedom. All of us, in our history, have faced this painful reality. All of us, it is not just the 20th century, with the failures of the USSR, but in our history, when we look back at each other, we have all believed for a moment that we were an empire that could disregard the aspirations for freedom of others. The aspiration for freedom is not just in Europe; it is in all regions of the world. All of us have faced - and France like others in its history - great disillusionments when we forgot that freedom was meant for everyone.

Furthermore, we are all facing the same risks: terrorism, proliferation, attacks on the computer system, climate risks, competition for raw materials, competition for water, as we see in Darfur.

So, there is the family, let’s call it Western, Europe and America, we have common values, we must defend them together, but not to impose them on others, to convince them.

Europe has chosen European integration and the Atlantic Alliance; Europe has built its peace around these two pillars. France is deeply attached to these two pillars. But becoming a member of the European Union or becoming a member of NATO is not a right. Because if it is a right, it means there are no conditions, that it would be enough to knock on the door to enter. With that system, we would destroy Europe and we would destroy NATO. To enter the European Union and to enter NATO, one must share values. Donald, you did not talk much about values; that is the key, values. If one does not share the values, one is not a member of the family. One must have the capacity, to enter the European Union and NATO, the capacity to contribute to the common work, to take heavy commitments and to assume them. In the European Union, one must be ready to share sovereignty; in NATO, one must be ready to assist an ally under attack. That is the family. If we do not enforce this, there is no longer a family. Because if it is a right to enter, and if once one enters there are no duties, then there is no longer a family. Why did the European Union inspire dreams? Because it was founded on solidarity; I will come back to that.

Why was NATO seen as protection for a number of Eastern peoples who felt, let’s say the words, abandoned by Western Europe? Because there were rules, because there was Article 5, and because when one enters NATO, one assumes their share of responsibilities. I wanted to say this because I believe in Europe and I believe in NATO, but it is not an inn with the door open to every wind, where anyone who wants can enter because they saw the light. Only those who are ready to share our values, to defend them, and to submit themselves to internal obligations: democracy, resolving internal problems with minorities, and the vision they have for the future. I add: the sharing of the burden; everyone has their share. I share what has been said regarding Ukraine and Georgia. Angela and I shared the same conviction and said the same things at the Bucharest Summit. I do not feel any less a friend of Ukraine or Georgia for having said this. I simply say that NATO and Europe are so important for the stability of the world that we must remind ourselves of the rules that are those of the family. In a colloquium, we often tend to recall the rights pertaining to the family, and less the duties pertaining to the family.

A word on Russia. There was the gas crisis, there was the crisis with Georgia. Let’s say things as they are: there is a growing mistrust between the European Union and Russia. On one side, some of our members have a fear of Russia. On the other, Russia has a historical fear of encirclement. We must restore trust. I want to take my responsibilities; I take them. I do not believe that today’s Russia is a military threat to the European Union and NATO. I know that it is not customary, when one is head of state, to assert a conviction, and yet I choose to do so. I do not believe that the primary risk for NATO and the European Union is a military aggression from Russia. I do not believe it. I do not believe it for a number of reasons, and the first of them is that Russia has so many fantastic internal challenges to address that I do not see it as a direct threat to NATO and Europe. Moreover, a country that has so many problems with its demographics is not a country that spontaneously, and history shows us on all continents, is inclined to military aggression with its neighbors.

I add that it would still be inconceivable, with all the problems the world faces, to organize a confrontation between Russia and Europe, especially since we have the technology and capital, and Russia has the energy. To be clear, France is certainly the country in Europe that depends the least on Russian gas, since France, thanks to nuclear power, is energy independent. What I am saying cannot therefore be labeled as weakness, fear, or self-interest. But simply a reading of the situation.

I draw the conclusion that we must call on each other to remain calm. We have never seen a supplier who gets angry with its customers. We talk a lot about Europe’s dependence; I have never seen, in our system, that it is the customer who must thank the supplier. Therefore, it is urgent to restore trust between Russia and the European Union. Urgent. We must do this first by hoping that the United States and Russia conclude a "post-Start" agreement this year on the reduction of their nuclear arsenals.

Russia must continue its cooperation with the European Union, and I take my responsibilities once again: I think that a goal would be that one day, between the European Union and Russia, we build a common economic and human space. But how did we stop waging war - we, the French, the Germans - if not by building a common economic and human space? Why would what has been true between the Germans and the French, and what works, not be true between Russia and the European Union? A common economic and human space, a perspective, together. Naturally, we must reject the dialectic, the threat. In the gas crisis that Donald spoke of, there were only losers. Only losers! Russia lost part of its credibility. Excuse me, I am not sure that Ukraine emerged strengthened from all this. We Europeans, I do not think we emerged strengthened either. A strategy that only produces losers is a strategy that must be abandoned.

Then, we have another file: the Arctic. What does climate change lead to? The opening of the Northern route. We are not going to make the Arctic the new territory of a conflict between the United States, Russia, and the European Union; that would make absolutely no sense. I also think we should take President Medvedev at his word. Ask him what he means in his concept of pan-European security and discuss it together. Because, after all, Russia, like the European Union, like the United States, could one day be under the threat of missiles from a terrorist state. We have every interest in building together, after the economic space and the human space, a security space.

A word on France's defense policy. The world is changing. France is changing. From the moment I was elected, I launched a vast renovation of our defense and security policy. We are maintaining our effort. I want to tell you, by 2020, we will dedicate 377 billion euros to our armed forces. We will keep our nuclear deterrent capability alongside the British, with whom we want to work hand in hand. How can we imagine that the two only military nuclear powers in Europe do not work together? I was very happy with the courageous decision of the British government and Gordon Brown to reflect on and work on a defense policy. How can we imagine making Europe and that the two military nuclear powers do not talk to each other, do not work together? This will raise, in the future, the question of the complementarity between these independent nuclear powers and the security of Europe as a whole. France will therefore remain a nuclear military power.

And then there is European defense. Let’s be clear here too. European defense is a priority. We have, with Angela Merkel, written an article together. We want to work with the Germans to make it a military priority and a political priority. I say this to all Europeans; it is a test. It is a test for Europe. Does Europe want peace or does it want to be left in peace? I wish you to reflect on this. Do you want peace or do you want to be left in peace? It is not the same policy, it is not the same strategy, it is not the same consequences. If you want peace, you must give yourself the means to exist as an economic, financial, political, and military power. If you want to be left in peace, make yourself very small, stay in your corners, close your eyes, cover your ears, do not speak too loudly, and for a time, you will be left in peace. Until the moment when it is discovered that you do not have the means to ensure your own defense. But by then, it will be too late. Everyone has an interest in a European defense. Everyone, Donald. You Eastern Europeans, finally back in the family, who must contribute to ensure our security. Frankly, it was still good news for Europe that at the time of the conflict between Georgia, which needed help and needed to be saved, and Russia, it was Europe that stepped forward, in agreement, Mr. Vice President Biden, with the United States of America.

Europe has done its job better than during the time of Bosnia. Europe has existed and Europe has been able to act. It is reassuring for all the countries of Eastern Europe to say to themselves: Europe exists, Europe is giving itself the means to defend itself and to put its power at the service of a policy. But it is also in the interest of the United States of America. Who could say that the United States of America does not need a strong ally, a powerful ally? Do you believe that the United States of America does not need a strong Europe? Our interest is that the United States is strong. The interest of the United States is that Europe is strong. With Javier Solana, we decided, under the French Presidency, on a coherent defense policy. I thank Gordon Brown for the initiatives he has taken, but this is a test, we must not be mistaken. In my mind, Europe is not simply a market, it is not simply about the economy, Donald said it earlier, it is also about values. So do you know of any region in the world that can be rich without ensuring its defense? Do you know of any organization in the world that can uphold values and ask others to defend them? In my mind, things are clear: it is Europe of Defense and NATO, not Europe of Defense or NATO. Both together. It is because we will strengthen Europe of Defense that we will need to strengthen NATO. It was a great mistake to weaken one thinking of strengthening the other. I take responsibility for this political choice, which has not been an easy choice in France until now.

I must also say that this goes hand in hand for me with a deepening of the relationship with Germany, our ally, our friend. The "Franco-German brigade" was created by François Mitterrand and Helmut Kohl. Angela Merkel and I wish that there are no more taboos, we wish for evolution. France would therefore be happy to host a battalion of the German army on its territory. I think that in the 21st century, it is really time to turn the page. My dear friends, the friendship between France and Germany, I say it here, is not just that France places soldiers in Germany, it is that France is honored to have German soldiers on the territory of the French Republic. That is friendship between France and Germany. That is the new step, the construction of a new context. It is a historic act, dear Angela. I am very proud that we are organizing the NATO Summit together. What a beautiful symbol of the success of what those who preceded us have done!

NATO, to conclude. NATO has changed a lot. But what does not change is the fundamental pact that unites us since the Washington Treaty. Frankly, I never thought that Article 5 would be used by all Allies in the service of the United States of America. When the United States was attacked, all of NATO found itself alongside the United States. Frankly, who would have said before 2001 that the first time Article 5 would be invoked, it would be to defend the United States of America? We will continue in this direction. I want to tell you, to conclude, that France has often been suspected of wanting to weaken NATO. It is unfair, but that was the case. It was all the more ridiculous because at the same time that France was suspected of wanting to weaken NATO, France was taking more and more space within it. The more we said we were not in it, the more we were! In France, we made it seem that NATO was a threat to our independence. No one asked why we were the only ones asking the question. I will never do anything that undermines the independence of my country. Never! But the alliance with the United States and the alliance with Europe do not undermine the independence of my country; they strengthen the independence of my country. That is what I will explain to the French when the time comes. That moment is approaching. My conviction is that France can renew its relations with NATO by being an independent ally, a free partner of the United States. I would also like to say that we were all very happy, Mr. Vice President, to see the decisions that President Obama has made regarding Guantanamo. We share these values, and the America we love is the America that defends its values, that defends and practices human rights. I can tell you that all Europeans were relieved by the decision that President Obama made regarding the Guantanamo issue.

So I will have the opportunity, since I know what Vice President Biden is going to say, as he sent me his speech beforehand, and I had the opportunity to discuss it with President Obama, like them I believe that the renovation of relations between France and NATO will be beneficial for the Alliance, for Europe, and for France. Listen, when we want to organize well, it is better to know what we are going to say! Frankly, I cannot blame the United States of America for saying: "here is what we are going to say," and they knew roughly what I was going to say too. Organization is part of good management.

Before the Strasbourg/Kehl Summit, we will have a debate in France. This is a debate that I will lead, as always, with a spirit of frankness and integrity towards the French people. We have friends, we have allies, I know my family, I know where the values we must defend are, faithful to the ideal of the French Republic. It is probably time to review NATO's strategy and for France and Germany to draw a number of consequences from it. Believe me, by April, we will try to be at the rendezvous of a great ambition for the family that is ours.

Thank you.