Speech by Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz at the Baden-Baden Business Talks on September 10, 2022, in Baden-Baden:

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

13 September 2022 · Baden-Baden Business Talks · Baden-Baden, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Baden-Baden Business Talks on September 10, 2022, discussing the economic and security consequences of Russia's war against Ukraine.
Main themes
Russian war of aggression against Ukraine, energy security and supply diversification, economic challenges of the war, German defense spending and NATO, inflation and economic stability, support for Ukraine, fossil fuel alternatives, Putin's strategic miscalculations, turning point in European security order, German economic resilience
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,290
88th percentile
Sentences
203
89th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
3.04
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%54%
  • Geopolitical 27%27%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Environmental 4%3%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

203 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Thank you very much for the invitation, thank you for the opportunity to speak here once again. It was impressive for me to see how long this tradition has been going on. In 1958, when you participated in the tenth conversation, that was the year I was born. In that respect, I can only say: That is indeed a very long history that has taken place here. I learned today that one must work one’s way into the hall where the speaking takes place. I find that remarkable as well. I greet everyone in the upper halls.

One cannot speak about what lies ahead without addressing the great, threatening challenge that we are all currently facing – the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine and all the consequences that it entails.

I do not want to discuss the security policy consequences here in too much detail. I have done that on other occasions, to which you referred. But I do want to say: This is a turning point, because one of the very decisive understandings of the last decades regarding the security and peace order in Europe has been abrogated, namely that one does not change borders by force. But that is exactly what Putin intends: He wants to conquer his neighboring country, wholly or partially. Anyone who listens to his speeches and reads what he has written for a long time knows that he actually believes that Belarus and Ukraine should more or less completely belong to Russia. And his war shows that he means this very seriously.

In this respect, it is clear that we will do everything we can to support Ukraine in its fight for integrity and sovereignty. We have done this on a large scale, departing from many traditions of Germany's security policy in recent decades. We support Ukraine with weapons – not just financially and humanitarianly – and we do this on a very large scale.

We have ensured that we ourselves can make a greater contribution within NATO to guarantee our security. The special fund of 100 billion euros that we are putting in place is just the instrument, the vehicle, with which we will then embark on a path where we spend more money on security and defense. The goal is no longer to be capable of operating somewhere in the world in smaller or larger out-of-area missions under a United Nations mandate, but rather it is about national and alliance defense. This has entirely different consequences for what we must be able to do.

Today, however, I want to talk about the economic challenges associated with this and what we must and are doing as a result. I want to make this very clear, because the Russian president, whom I just spoke about, is also talking about this at so-called international economic conferences in St. Petersburg and Vladivostok, where not many international participants are present. But of course, we should all listen worldwide to what he is saying.

His scenario is well described. He envisions that this will turn out as follows: an exploding state debt crisis in our countries, in the global West, as he always refers to us, rising inflation, growing unemployment, many businesses having to cease operations, great dissatisfaction and unrest in our countries. I believe we are not mistaken in saying that he hopes for this as well. Even more: We must not delude ourselves. What he can contribute to making this happen, he has done, and he will continue to do. But he has miscalculated.

For me, as the newly elected Chancellor of this Republic, it was clear when looking at the danger that may be approaching us that we must prepare for all the things that are possible to happen. With the outbreak of the war, it has become even clearer that we must do this. That is why we made decisions at the beginning of the year from which we are now benefiting as a country in a very comprehensive way.

For example, we said we must be technically capable of actually getting all the fossil resources we still need in these years to Germany – and sometimes beyond, to our neighboring countries – even if there is no supply from Russia. That is why we clarified: How do we handle coal? That is not so difficult; it is being shipped. The coal is now coming from elsewhere. We clarified: How do we handle oil? That is also not so difficult; it is being shipped. We have a pipeline that reaches two refineries in eastern Germany. We are working hard to ensure that we can secure their operation, as well as the employment and prospects there. We asked the question: What if gas from Russia no longer flows? We had a discussion in recent years about whether there should be three or four pipelines. But even three are empty if they are not used.

That is why it is crucial that we catch up on what our country, in my view, has mistakenly not done in recent years – namely, to ensure that one can switch suppliers from one day to the next. Many of you as entrepreneurs will often discuss this question in your businesses: What happens if something goes wrong here or there, whether due to an accident or a dispute, whatever can happen? We as a country have not done this to an adequate extent.

But that is why it was very clear to me that we must now, with the greatest speed our nation is capable of, ensure that liquefied gas terminals are built on the northern German coasts; that our large trading companies transport gas to Germany; that we build pipelines. This will now happen at this pace. The first ones will open in January of next year, and more will follow – in Wilhelmshaven, in Stade, in Brunsbüttel, in Lubmin on the Baltic Sea – and then feed into the pipeline network that we have in Germany.

We have spoken with our friends in Western Europe, the Dutch, the Belgians, the French, that gas can come to Germany through their Western European ports. France is also now supplying gas to Germany for the first time. This is – it must be said – a break with traditions, but something that helps us greatly in this situation.

We have decided to store gas. In a strange lack of concern, no one did anything when it was noted that the storage facilities were becoming emptier and emptier, that gas was being delivered from German storage to Poland and not through the pipeline that leads to Poland. We made a law, and now we are at well over 85 percent and will achieve our ambitious goals. Others have done this as well. This is an early decision that is now effective. Because we had to buy gas in large quantities in the summer when no one was really concerned, to store it there, and we did that.

We said we would let the coal-fired power plants run again. None should be taken offline. All that are offline should be turned back on to produce electricity so that we can feed it into the grid.

We have now made laws that allow you to switch to other energy sources. Sometimes the old oil boiler or whatever you have been using is still in operation. It was about doing this quickly – keyword "fuel switch" – with eased regulations regarding speed and approval processes, without lowering the standards.

We have also decided that it should be possible for us, if necessary, to keep the nuclear power plants in southern Germany running in January, February, March, and April. These are all preparations for this situation.

I believe we can already say: The situation we are in is already quite difficult, but we have prepared so intensively in such a short time that we can say we will likely get through. No one could have said this at this point without all these measures.

It is clear that not all problems are solved by this. For example – you mentioned it – the major problems arising from prices, for citizens as well as for businesses. Many business processes are oriented towards entirely different prices. They are calculated, and it will not be possible to simply pass this on to customers and sell the same quantities. In this respect, we are in a difficult situation.

That is why the next thing we will do is to ensure that we answer the question: How do we achieve conditions that make the economy, production, and life possible in light of price developments?

First clear decision: We will try to combat the dysfunctions of the electricity market. We did this with the decisions from last weekend, which largely align with what the Commission in Europe has come up with. And we will ensure that no extraordinary profits can be made when the actual price of electricity production is determined by gas. We will tax these profits and use them to cushion electricity prices in general, the network fees, and their increase – but also to ensure that there is an electricity price brake for households. We are now working intensively on this. When I look at the European discussions: We will succeed in this as well.

Then, of course, the heating prices, especially the gas prices, come into play. One task is to ensure that we have a good supply by building the infrastructures so that this can even happen. But the other is to ensure that prices move back into ranges that can then also be paid. That is what we are doing now in Germany, in Europe, and discussing with many others.

But everyone who is knowledgeable about this matter knows: This is not as simple as is the case with the electricity market. Because we do not buy gas in large quantities somewhere in Germany, but we buy it in Norway, in the Netherlands – which are still close – in the USA, all over the world. You have followed this. You know it well. We cannot just write them a letter: "Your price is the following." That exceeds our legislative competencies and the extent of our jurisdiction, to put it that way.

In this regard, it is now about us succeeding in this. But it will require a great effort for us to do this. This also means that we will work with all the experts who understand a lot about these issues in the economy. We are doing this, it is being prepared, and will continue to be discussed. And that we are simultaneously ready to do everything necessary to ensure that we also get through economically and financially.

Therefore, I can assure you once again at this point, what I have been saying for some time now: We will manage this. One must not underestimate our country. If we stand together, if we are ready to meet this new, very concrete challenge, then we will succeed. We will tackle this task. No one, no company, but also no citizen will be left alone. We will do this together.

For me, this is now the next task, and – I want to say this explicitly – it is part of what is necessary for this winter and the next. But we must envision a world in which, for a very long time, energy supplies from Russia will no longer play a role in the supply on the world markets and in price formation on the world markets. One cannot speak about this in a populist manner; rather, one must simply tackle this concrete task. We will not shy away from it, but will do everything that is necessary.

I have deliberately placed the discussion of this crisis at the beginning because it is simply so fundamental right now. But it is an occasion to discuss various questions together that are of the utmost importance for the role of our country and for our future. They do not resolve all the other challenges that the progress coalition in Germany has set for itself.

One topic that I would like to address here – which is related to what we have just discussed – is, in my view, the crucial question: What is our stance on globalization and the further development of the world?

I want to begin with a clear commitment: I do not believe in deglobalization. I do not believe in giving up what has made prosperity and progress possible in the last decades all over the world and suddenly focusing again solely on ourselves.

Here is a good place to say this: It is the German Mittelstand that has benefited the most from globalization. Small companies with 500, 1,000, 2,000, 3,000, sometimes even a few more employees, which compete with two or three others in the global market with one or two products or services – these are the ones that make up the strength of our economy. If the framework conditions, if the scales, if the magnitudes in which this can be developed suddenly refer to Europe or Germany or to Europe and the USA, then that is definitely too small for the progress that has been possible. Therefore, I believe we must also say: Globalization has brought a lot of prosperity. It has brought billions of people around the world into a kind of middle class. Hunger has decreased, education has improved. Many supply issues have been resolved better than they had been for decades.

What many have completely overlooked is that in the last 30 to 40 years, things have gone exactly the opposite way compared to the 200 to 250 years of industrial history before that. Let us remember: British industrialism began with the violent destruction of Indian weaving machines. Now textiles are coming back from Asia – often with machines that are also built here in Germany. But I want to explicitly say: This is the changed process. Jobs have been created. Cities have been newly established. Infrastructures have been developed. There is prosperity.

That is why, for example, it has always been clear to me that this very special phase of globalization in which we have found ourselves in recent years is gradually coming to an end. The phenomenon that economists – I see one – are not all surprised by, but that they have discussed, can easily be resolved and explained. How could it be that we have economic growth, full employment, and low inflation? Because these parts of the world have produced something related to our markets, supplied raw materials in the supply chains, accompanied work processes, and as a result, things could become very cheap for us.

What perhaps one or the other has overlooked is: As this happens, new demand markets are also emerging there. Suddenly, during the Covid-19 pandemic, governments there are also implementing stimulus programs that influence the demand situation in the world.

Everyone wants to combat climate change – I will come to that – and many have decided: The intermediate technology for this is gas. I mean, this has consequences for global demand. Therefore, what is now coming through the current crisis may happen a bit faster than what would have likely occurred over the course of this decade anyway – namely that the peculiarities of this phase of globalization are coming to an end, which ultimately only thrived on the existence of a world market that encompassed only a part of the world’s population, while the others produced for it. Now it will be the case that the world market is much larger – it truly spans the globe, with its own demand and investment strategies from many countries around the world.

So far from the economic perspective. But something is also changing from the economic-political perspective. Therefore, I want to say: I am not only firmly against the idea of deglobalization and the demonization of globalization as a prosperity machine, but I am also firmly against the notion that we should think of the world in such a way that, looking back, it always leads to a new bipolar world. In the post-war order, the conflict was between the USA and the Soviet Union, and now it may be between the USA and China. And Russia is making its voice heard: “I am still here.” Therefore, what lies ahead of us will be more of a multipolar world.

In Asia, there are many rising and already strong nations. They will not accept being categorized into such a conflict. South Korea, Japan, Vietnam, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, India, to name just a few, will not accept being relegated to the sidelines. Therefore, the world will become much more multipolar. One cannot only look to Asia, which one must absolutely do when discussing China strategies, but this is also the case when we look to Africa or the southern part of America.

My firm conviction is: There will also be many influential nations in the world. All of this will take place around the middle of this century, in just a few decades. The question of what we want in this world and what goal perspective we pursue must be answered now. One of my answers is: no deglobalization. The other is: We are very pleased with this perspective of multipolarity.

But – this is the lesson that Putin is currently teaching us – it is not necessarily a good order if power and violence determine the relationships between states. Therefore, it must be clear to us: We want this world to be not only multipolar, with many influential countries, but we also want to ensure that it is a world that cooperates, what is called multilateralism. That should be our mission in Germany and in Europe.

That is why I also make this statement: The European Union is for us the hope that the world that is emerging, which will be very different from the one we have known for the last 200, 250 years, is one in which we have a say, in which we can secure our prosperity and ensure that, although we no longer have as large a share of the world’s social product as we have had for many decades and centuries, we can ensure that we secure the most modern technologies, the most advanced technologies, and the same prosperity as those who are at the forefront for Europe and for us.

With 80 million Germans, we are not able to influence the world events of then 10 billion inhabitants by 2050. Therefore, we can only succeed in this with the European Union. This European Union was created as a community to bring together the peoples that have waged wars against each other. But it must now take on a new role, after this has been very successfully achieved for decades and new members have joined: the Greeks, the Spaniards, the Portuguese, who have shaken off their dictatorships, the countries in Central and Eastern Europe that have shaken off communist dictatorships and have regained their freedom in the West, and all those in the Western Balkans who want to join and whom we have invited, Ukraine, Moldova, and Georgia in the longer term. They all must keep in mind the fact that we can only have an influence on the world collectively. This is then the perspective of a geopolitical union, as I have called it, in which we cooperate.

For us Germans, this has a consequence. Because actually, many have feared for centuries that this one country with the largest population and already quite a large economic power would come together and exert its entire power in a kind of state unity. When it happened in 1871, we showed that this concern was indeed justified – with two world wars that originated in Germany.

That we were allowed to come together again, that we now have our unity as a democratic country in the middle of Europe, we owe to this Europe, but also to the trust that many have in us and the way they rely on us.

But it remains the case: We are the large country in the middle of the European Union with the largest economic power and the largest population. Therefore, we must be the nation that is the most European, that firmly resolves that the future of Europe, the progress in Europe is our own national concern, and that we commit ourselves to it. I say: This is what I see as an essential mandate for myself as Chancellor. Therefore, we must ensure that the Union is reformed so that it plays a role as a sovereign player in the world.

Because everything is interconnected, let me add this sentence about globalization, the changed world, the role of Europe, and the war that Putin has started against Ukraine: It applies to all of us, and not only with regard to gas, oil, and coal, that we must diversify our supply relationships. It applies to all of us that we must diversify our export markets so that difficulties at one end of the world do not become our difficulties. Of course: If something that is going well suddenly does not go well, it will always cause problems. But if one is dependent on it because one cannot endure that it becomes difficult for ten or fifteen years, then that is a problem.

Therefore, I wish that we develop a much stronger focus on the other Asia, on Africa, and on the southern part of America for investments, for imports, and exports. This applies not only, but of course also, to raw material supplies.

For us, this has a consequence: that we shed the complacency, the convenience with which we have sometimes accompanied processes, for example, when it comes to lithium extraction somewhere in the world, to name just this example. One must also manage to want this and not leave it to regimes that do not have as many problems with their populations. Therefore, it is part of it that we also make a positive commitment to such investments in raw material production, in raw material generation, so that we can achieve diversification. A lot of German capital, both public and much, much more private, will be required to make this possible. But this should also be a lesson from the changed times.

The third topic I would like to address and develop for our discussion here is: Because the problems are as they are and because things have developed as they have, we do not stop doing what we urgently need to do for our future. For me, this includes continuing to pursue the goal of becoming a strong economic country that operates climate-neutral by 2045.

This is the great economic transformation of our country, the digitalization and ecological transformation, incidentally in a very progressive response: It is not the case, as one young man told us, that renunciation is the solution to the challenges we face now, but it is growth and progress, technological progress, and one in which we in Germany play a central role. We are the country that has the engineers, the entrepreneurs, and the financial power to develop such technologies so that they are globally competitive, so that others also want to use them.

We will not convince the citizens of Asia, Africa, and the southern part of America that they do not want as many cars as we do, that they do not want to live as beautifully as we do. They want all of that too and will get it sooner or later. We will not move them to renunciation.

What we can do is to say: We have technologies that are such that the world can sustain this prosperity without the climate and biodiversity suffering as a result. Exactly this is a very important task for all of us, because we in Germany can achieve exactly that. Therefore, these things belong together.

As we become independent, we are also finalizing many laws – some have even already been passed in this one year – that contribute to accelerating the transformation of our energy supply to renewable energies, to accelerating the expansion of the grid, to accelerating the transition to a hydrogen economy. Because it requires billions in private investments, which are necessary in the businesses and companies overall, which only work if someone who is now changing their production process for steel and moving away from the blast furnace route, if someone who is changing their chemical plant and moving away from the use of fossil resources and towards electrification and the use of hydrogen for many processes can also be sure: They will have all of this in rough quantities and at affordable prices.

This is the task we have set for ourselves. And this is what we absolutely want to achieve together with you, so that progress in Germany is possible, so that we can remain at the forefront in terms of our prosperity, and so that we can contribute to ensuring that the world operates climate-neutrally, but can also sustain the great prosperity that we wish for all citizens of this world.

In this sense, I look forward to the discussion, also to the discussion of the theses that the young people told us at the beginning. I actually found it very touching what we heard there. Because the most important message that came across was: One can have hope. We do not have to walk through the world grumpily. We even know how it will get better. Then we should do it.

Thank you very much.