Speech by Chancellor Scholz on the occasion of the 60th anniversary of the Council of Economic Experts on June 21, 2023, in Berlin.

Germany Olaf Scholz · Member of the Bundestag

21 June 2023 · 60th anniversary of the Council of Economic Experts · Berlin, Germany

Context
Scholz addressed the Council of Economic Experts in Berlin on June 21, 2023, marking the advisory body's 60th anniversary.
Main themes
Council of Economic Experts anniversary, economic policy advisory role, social market economy, energy price relief, Gas Price Commission, Concerted Action, gender diversity in economics, climate neutrality and industrial transformation, evidence-based public debate, renewable energy expansion, inflation management
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,902
55th percentile
Sentences
110
67th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 54%54%
  • Institutional 27%27%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

110 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Dear Ms. Puttrich,

dear Professor Schnitzer,

esteemed members of the Council of Economic Experts,

ladies and gentlemen,

60 years of the Council of Economic Experts means 59 annual reports with 16,781 pages, packed with economic expertise and always written with the assumption that all politicians read them. However, the weight of your analyses does not come from the approximately 350 pages per report. This weight comes from your independence and from the fact that the Council of Economic Experts does not see itself merely as a wise observer or a regulatory conscience that hovers above things and raises a finger once a year. As economic experts, you are the most important, most recognized, and most sought-after economic policy advisory body in the country. With your expertise, you ensure that the public understands what is going well and what is not, and that we as the federal government can weigh the pros and cons of our decisions in a well-founded manner.

For 60 years now, your reports have grown into something like the encyclopedia of the social market economy of Germany, intensively prepared over months, with the highest economic policy competence. Therefore, today I would like to extend my heartfelt congratulations not only to the current and former members of the Council of Economic Experts on this anniversary but also to all the staff members of the scientific team. It is wonderful that so many of you are here today!

This success of the Council of Economic Experts was not a given. It took seven years from the first proposal to the founding in 1963. For comparison: That is about the time it has taken so far to plan, approve, and build a wind energy facility in Germany. Fortunately, we have changed that, but more on that later. Historically speaking, it was indeed a stroke of luck that Ludwig Erhard was such a strong-willed person. Unlike Konrad Adenauer, who was also not bad in this regard, he was convinced that Germany needed this independent Council of Economic Experts. He was right. Not only are your reports valuable for our economic policy. Equally important is your contribution where your economic expertise directly translates into political action.

A current example is the Gas Price Commission under your chairmanship, dear Ms. Grimm. We have implemented the commission's proposals almost one-to-one, thereby cushioning the effects of high energy prices for companies and private households. That was a strong signal and has certainly contributed to the fact that energy prices have fallen significantly again. Today, they are as low as they have not been for two years.

Another example is your contribution to the Concerted Action, dear Ms. Schnitzer. You helped to bring about the tax-free one-time payments that are now widely used by employers and trade unions. This relieves many employees in light of rising prices. At the same time, such one-time payments help prevent inflation from becoming entrenched. Because it is precisely those with lower incomes who would suffer the most from that.

Dear Ms. Schnitzer, you are the first chairperson in the long history of the Council of Economic Experts. At the 50th anniversary, my predecessor in office, Angela Merkel, said that it would probably take another 50 years for the gender ratio in the council to balance out. Fortunately, it did not take that long. I am pleased that today three out of five members are women, especially considering that it took a full 40 years before Beatrice Weder di Mauro was appointed to the Council of Economic Experts. You have just described it, and you did not only talk about the cigars. Economic expertise has nothing to do with whether one is a man or a woman. Nevertheless, it is important to gather different perspectives on the world, on everyday life, and also on research questions in one room.

Precisely because you bring together these different perspectives, your advice is not only highly valued by politics but also by the public, especially since the topics you address directly affect the everyday lives of citizens. Unfortunately, your independent and factual, evidence-based economic advice does not always penetrate the depths of digital echo chambers. Therefore, it is all the more important how you bring your expertise to the public through social media, interviews, talk shows, or many other channels. Our societal debates benefit from this, and so do all those who do not have the time to work through 350-page reports.

We particularly need economic expertise for the greatest challenge our country faces in the coming years, namely to live and work in a climate-neutral manner while remaining an industrial nation. By 2045, in just over 20 years, the era of fossil resources in Germany will come to an end, at least regarding their use for propulsion and heating. The path there will not be easy, especially since we have made too little progress in recent years. Moreover, every change is exhausting, and we are talking about the greatest transformation since the industrial revolution in the 19th century.

Many citizens are asking themselves: Will this all turn out well for me, for my children, and for my grandchildren? We must provide convincing answers to this question. Otherwise, those who exploit the fears of citizens and create bad moods will gain even more followers. I do not need to tell you what risk this poses for Germany as an open, globally connected economy. The transition towards climate neutrality must become a convincing and palpable growth story for everyone. I am firmly convinced that this growth story will become a reality, and I see four reasons for this.

First: The era of mass unemployment in Germany is a thing of the past for the foreseeable future. Around 46 million women and men go to work every day. That is more than ever before. Of course, many baby boomers will retire in the coming years. But this gap will only become a problem if we do not fill it. That is why we are currently creating what is probably the most modern immigration law in the world. That is why we are promoting training and further education in companies. That is why we are ensuring better childcare options that help to better reconcile family and work. With all of this, we are increasing Germany's productivity. This creates growth.

The second driver of growth is innovation. Sometimes I hear that investments in renewable energies are growth-neutral because, in the end, you are only replacing a coal or gas power plant with a wind farm or an electrolyzer. However, we have already experienced leaps in innovation with this transformation, and we will continue to do so. By the way, Europe is leading the world in this transformation.

As a federal government, we are committed to research and development, to leaps in innovation made in Germany. We are repeatedly successful in climate-relevant technologies. The solar industry was a prime example of how misguided economic policy drove an entire sector out of the country. Now Germany is once again leading in the performance of certain high-performance cells. We are promoting industry-led hydrogen projects so that we can quickly move from manual labor to series production with electrolyzers, for example. We are also working to ensure that Germany can become one of the world's major production sites for semiconductors. This is what the agreement with Intel from Monday stands for. With more than 30 billion euros, it will be the largest foreign direct investment ever in Germany.

Precisely because Germany's economy is strong in innovation, and precisely because we are already further along than others in climate-neutral solutions in industry, we will be able to benefit from the global trend towards climate neutrality. This is the third major growth opportunity for Germany. The emerging countries of the global South have the same aspirations and the same right to prosperity as Europe and North America. Therefore, it is in our hands to produce the technologies that the whole world needs so that this can succeed in a climate-friendly manner and that growth can proceed in a climate-friendly way. The breadth and depth of the German industry, with its medium-sized world market leaders across the country, is our great strength in this regard.

The fourth driver of growth is — and this will not surprise anyone here — the forces of the market. It will not work without or even against these forces. CO2 certificates will become scarcer and thus more expensive in the future. Clearly stating this is part of the reliability that the economy depends on. It is obvious that we must temporarily cushion social hardships and protect our companies from unfair competition — keyword: border adjustment. Here, too, I ultimately advocate for a global system shaped by regulatory ideas, such as the international climate club, which aims to prevent new customs competitions. It is about common rules for the participating countries and equal competitive conditions for our companies.

Our national goals must also be predictable and reliable: 80 percent of electricity from renewable energies and 15 million electric vehicles on our roads by 2030, climate neutrality by 2045. A recent study by international auditors shows that Germany is now in second place among attractive locations for investments in renewable energies. According to this study, we have overtaken China. Now only the USA is ahead of us.

But none of this happens on its own. We calculate it year by year, increase the tenders for wind and solar parks, promote the ramp-up of hydrogen, and ensure transmission networks and storage so that even the chemical company or the steel corporation knows: by 2030, they will have enough electricity for their production. This is happening now. Companies can rely on this.

One thing is crucial: more courage at all levels. If every district office and every municipality first obtains half a dozen reports before approving a new electrolyzer or a new wind farm, then we will not be climate-neutral by 2080 because we simply do not have enough experts for all these reports. That is why we have significantly accelerated and simplified the approval processes in the past year and a half. However, simpler rules are only useful if they are also utilized. To make this happen, we want to agree with the federal states on a pact this year to further accelerate planning. A pact in which we all commit that the German speed is not only possible in the construction of LNG terminals. The German speed is also possible in the transformation that lies ahead of us and for which we need to program our country for growth again.

Ladies and gentlemen, I am grateful that you will help us with this as well. This is especially true for the economic experts. We continue to rely on your critical support, your expert advice, and your important insights. Because, of course, you are right, dear Ms. Schnitzer, when you say:

“No responsible economist believes that the future can be predicted exactly.”

But that does not prevent us from continuing to work towards ensuring that the future will be a good one, characterized by growth and progress. We have that in our hands. So much prediction can be ventured: The conditions for this are anything but bad. For all non-North Germans: That was North German for: Our chances are looking pretty good.

Congratulations on your anniversary and thank you very much for the invitation!