Control Session Senate - Responses from the President of the Government

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

15 February 2022 · Control Session of the Senate · Senate, Spain

Context
Sánchez addressed the Spanish Senate on February 15, 2022, responding to questions about government priorities and challenges for the remainder of the legislature.
Main themes
Government legislative agenda, economic recovery, pandemic response, rights and freedoms expansion, energy and digital transformation, social cohesion, territorial cohesion, feminist agenda, European funds, constitutional reform, employment protection, Catalonia coexistence
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,887
91st percentile
Sentences
211
90th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.22
75th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
71st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%36%
  • Economic 22%21%
  • Social 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

211 sentences in 97 paragraphs

President: Thank you, Your Honor, for your question. In short, your question was: What are the challenges for the Government in the remainder of the legislature? And you also told me to be brave. You also said that it is not enough to position oneself against something, but that we must be in favor of something. And I believe that, indeed, this government has demonstrated some bravery in advancing rights and freedoms in such a difficult context, from the perspective of the health, economic, and social emergency we are experiencing, unprecedented in the history of humanity over the last 100 years.

I presented myself for the investiture, Your Honor, in January 2020, outlining a roadmap of reforms, of transformations in the socioeconomic sphere, in the area of rights and freedoms, which placed Spain, for example, at the forefront of the ecological transition, of making a just energy transition, of aiming for progress in rights and freedoms, such as the one we have today in Spain, thanks to the support of the Cortes Generales for a euthanasia law, a law for dignified death, which is one of the few countries in the world that has precisely that.

Strengthening also, Your Honor, well, fundamental elements such as the one we have precisely advocated here with that minute of silence, such as a state pact against gender violence that we have renewed for the coming years, at least the majority of political parties, except for the far-right in the Cortes Generales.

Therefore, Your Honor, we have been advancing in rights and freedoms since the beginning of the legislature, with an agenda of progress from the socioeconomic perspective as well.

Then the pandemic came, and with the pandemic, Your Honors, we had to innovate instruments, tools that had never been used in the democratic history of our country, such as using, for example, a lockdown to protect and save lives.

More than 450,000 lives were saved as a result of that lockdown, Your Honors, or for example, by implementing temporary employment regulation files that during the worst moments of the pandemic helped almost 3 million 600 thousand workers to preserve their jobs.

95% of them are now back in their jobs.

We have 20 million employed. We have the lowest unemployment rate since 2008, that is, not at levels prior to the pandemic, but at levels prior to the financial crisis.

We protected half of the self-employed workers who are contributing to the RETA, the special regime for self-employed workers, with a direct self-employed benefit during the most difficult moments of the lockdown.

Today many of them, fortunately, are also back in their jobs.

In short, Your Honors, we have made an extraordinary, formidable effort, not only to protect, to resist, but also to reactivate the economy of our country, which is what we are doing now.

Therefore, in response to your question about what we are going to do during this legislature: Consolidate that economic growth and also distribute that economic growth, especially so that that economic recovery is fair.

And we want to do this, moreover, by managing European funds, addressing the four major transformations that I proposed in my investiture speech:

1. The energy transformation.

2. The digital transformation.

3. Social cohesion.

4. Territorial cohesion.

And lastly, of course, the feminist agenda with which this government is absolutely committed.

From the perspective of coexistence, Your Honor, you have told me on many occasions, and I have responded to you, to your group, and to other sovereignist groups, that we are the only party since 1978 still standing, with the same initials, that was the architect of the Spanish Constitution.

That constitutional pact, Your Honor, has names and surnames; that constitutional pact has the names and surnames of millions and millions of Spaniards from all the territories of our country, who advocated precisely for Spanish democracy.

And that is where the government of the Socialist Party stands. And that is where, logically, my presidency stands, in betting on the Constitution, in underpinning it. We believe, of course, that a reform of the Spanish Constitution would be necessary in some matters that have to do, for example, with the recognition of new rights or the deepening of freedoms in our Magna Carta.

But what do you want me to say, Your Honor, if the Popular Party is incapable even of reforming Article 49 to remove the word "diminished" from an article as all movements linked to disability are asking? Well, frankly, it is very complicated.

However, I tell you, the Socialist Party and, well, as long as I am president of the Government, we are going to bet on coexistence. We are going to bet on overcoming traumas like the one we experienced, for example, in Catalonia in 2017. And I believe I have taken quite significant steps in relation to that, and I believe I will also have the opportunity to respond to another senator during this control session.

And I sincerely believe that referendums only serve to divide.

I sincerely believe that referendums pose absolutely binary questions when we are talking about identity, and these are much more complex issues that logically affect matters related to coexistence.

However, of course, the Government of Spain is deploying an absolute agenda of dialogue and coordination with all territorial actors, with all governments. I believe that throughout the pandemic we have demonstrated this with the exercise of co-governance that we are practicing.

Next week we will hold a new conference of presidents, precisely on the island of La Palma, in the Canary Islands, in tribute to the people of La Palma for the natural disaster they have suffered during the long months of the volcanic eruption on the island of La Palma. And that is the path we must follow.

I will also make a reflection, Your Honor, when you talk about the 20th century, I believe, and I say this with all due respect, that independence is a political theory that represents the 20th or 19th century.

Today, after the pandemic, if anything has become clear, Your Honor, it is that we must integrate, integrate, integrate all nations within the European Union, precisely to be large enough, relevant enough, in an international order, with major actors, with giant actors like China, the United States, Brazil, India, or, why not say it, also Russia. And only together will we be stronger.

Disaggregating, centrifuging responsibilities and political power, as you are proposing, will make Europe a much smaller actor, therefore, an actor with less capacity to guarantee the development and prosperity of Europeans.

We, Your Honors, if we want to talk about a Constitution, it is about a European Constitution.

If we want to talk about the Spanish Constitution, we want to reform it, but guaranteeing the fundamental elements of its coexistence and cohesion, which are precisely those reflected in Title VIII of our Constitution and therefore, in the Statute, or rather, in the State of Autonomies.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Javier Maroto of the Popular Parliamentary Group.

President: Thank you, Mr. Maroto. I will answer your question and then, if you like, we can talk about Castilla y León for a bit.

Regarding the Sustainable Mobility Law, Your Honor, this government will indeed approve a Sustainable Mobility Law. We will do so on March 1. I can tell you that the draft law does not provide for or specify the adoption of any measures related to the entry into force of tolls. The future Mobility Law will indeed advance Spain towards a new model of transport, of mobility, linked to everything I mentioned earlier about sustainability, digitalization, social cohesion, and also territorial cohesion.

Your Honors, you are used to lowering taxes when you are in opposition and raising them when we are in government.

I want to remind you, Your Honors, that when you governed in 2012 and in 2018, you can talk to the former Minister de la Serna or also with the former Minister Pastor, there were reports from the Ministry of Development at that time, from the Government of the Popular Party, which indeed proposed a collection of 2.7 billion a year precisely from toll collection. This is what you defended when you were in government. Now, when you are in opposition, it seems that you do not defend tolls.

In any case, to make it clear, Your Honors, the Sustainable Mobility Law does not propose the adoption or entry into force of any of those tolls.

What is the problem? The problem, Your Honors, is that the Spanish political system suffers from an absolutely denialist opposition that even denies its own past. And thus you have no credibility to lead the opposition, Mr. Maroto.

You vote against a labor reform that is signed by employers, by the CEOE. You vote against the revaluation of pensions. You vote against a vocational training law agreed upon by social agents and the educational community. You vote against a euthanasia law. You vote against a new educational law. You vote no, no, and no; you make a denialist opposition. And the problem, Your Honors, the problem, Your Honors. The problem, Your Honors, is that if one speaks like Vox, does politics like Vox, acts like Vox, in the end, people end up abandoning the bad copy and sticking with the original.

Mr. Maroto, of course, it turns out that I am to blame for the result of the Popular Party in Castilla y León. I am to blame for the fact that, of course, I already know that. You started the campaign talking about Sánchez, you ended the campaign also talking about Vox. Now you are returning to the argument of Sánchez. But look, I, well, there are doubts about who calls the elections in Castilla y León, whether it is Casado or Mañueco, but what I can guarantee you is that I was not the one who called those elections.

And also what I can tell you is that I find it quite surprising because, well, seeing all the demographic right-wingers say that the Popular Party was going to sweep, was going to win by an absolute majority in Castilla y León, and then finding that you will have to negotiate with Vox precisely to guarantee a stable government in Castilla y León. Well, frankly, neither the Socialist Party nor I are to blame, Your Honors, for the early elections in Castilla y León. Neither the party nor I, Your Honors, are to blame or responsible for the agreements you have maintained and maintain with the far right in Madrid, in Murcia, in Andalusia, in many territories of our country. We are not responsible for that, Your Honors.

And therefore, if you want the abstention of the Socialist Party, ask the Socialist Party in Castilla y León and explain to the citizens in Castilla y León and throughout Spain why you refuse to have a coalition government with the far-right party. Often, Your Honors, in elections, we talk about who has won, but above all, we must talk about who has come out winning, Your Honor, with these elections that you called hastily. Who has come out winning? Have the women of Castilla y León, whom Vox has already pointed out, come out winning? Has the LGTBI community of Castilla y León, which Vox has also pointed out, come out winning? Has social and territorial cohesion in Castilla y León come out winning? Has coexistence in Castilla y León come out winning, Your Honor?

The problem is, Your Honor, that the one who has come out winning is Vox, and the one who has come out losing is Castilla y León. Precisely because you used Castilla y León for something very alien to what represents the interests of that land.

But as we said today in the Council of Ministers' Room, Your Honors, what we can guarantee to the citizens of Castilla y León, and I emphasize citizens of Castilla y León, is that any questioning made by the government you are going to form with Vox regarding women, the LGTBI community, or any issue related to a regression in rights and freedoms, will receive a strong and firm response, within the law, from the Government of Spain.

Reply from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Javier Maroto of the Popular Parliamentary Group.

President: Arguments can be twisted and stretched, Your Honor. They can be made, and you are a living example of that. But reality is stubborn, and the law of gravity is what it is, Your Honors. You called for elections because there were courtly advisors from the demographic right who told you that you were going to achieve 41% and therefore win by an absolute majority.

It has been proven that it was not true, that the change of cycle, that the strategy that was supposed to take Casado to Moncloa has not been such, Your Honor. Therefore. In short, if you want to request, I insist, the abstention of the Socialist Party in Castilla y León, explain to the citizens why you want the abstention of the Socialist Party in Castilla y León. Ask for it and explain why. Because if you explain that indeed the far right is a danger to democracy, maybe we can understand each other; if you explain that we need to put a sanitary cordon around those who are questioning the rights and freedoms of women or the LGTBI community, then maybe we can understand each other, but do one prior thing, Your Honor, do one prior thing: With all those who are negotiating with the far right in Madrid and outside of Madrid, tell them to also break the agreements with the far right.

And I insist, I believe, Mr. Maroto, that the great lesson, the great lesson from everything we experienced on February 13, is the following: who has come out losing is Castilla y León, and who has come out winning, because you have facilitated it, is the far right. And you are, Your Honors, the ones who have to respond to them.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Josep Lluís Cleries of the Nationalist Parliamentary Group Partit Demócrata (PDECAT-CDC)

President: Well, I imagine that the last question is a rhetorical one, right?, because after what you have said. I believe that, Your Honor, we can all agree that we have moved from a permanent conflict in 2017 to a constant dialogue on the part of the Govern of the Generalitat of Catalonia with the Government of Spain, in multiple forms.

This Friday we are going to have a bilateral commission between the two governments, precisely to materialize many transfers of which you have previously referred.

I believe it is an objective fact, it is an objective fact that today Catalonia is better than it was five years ago. Therefore, we are advancing on the path of coexistence and the consolidation of a dialogue space between the Government of Spain and the Govern of the Generalitat of Catalonia.

I have always missed, you talk a lot about the need for dialogue between the Govern of the Generalitat of Catalonia and the Government of Spain, I have always missed that dialogue table among Catalans. Because I want to remind you that there are not a few, but quite a few Catalans who do not share the independence agenda that you defend here.

In any case, I will simply give you a piece of data from the CEO. The CEO has placed at 16%, the main concern right now for Catalans, at 16%, the main concern regarding the relationship between the Government of Spain and the Govern of the Generalitat of Catalonia, when in 2018 it was 31%. And what does that have to do with? It has to do with the work being done, from a political point of view, by the parties that are betting on that dialogue.

And secondly, because logically there are now much more urgent priorities for Catalans, as for the whole of Spanish society, linked to the response to the pandemic and also to economic recovery and the management of European funds.

In short, you referred to The Economist, and I must lament, indeed, that this has occurred. But I also believe it is unfair to place such an issue on our shoulders, that is, the Government of Spain and also the parliamentary majority that supports the Government of Spain.

It will have to be the opposition, in this case the Popular Party, which constitutionally is the only way to renew the General Council of the Judiciary, which has been blocking the renewal of this important institution for more than three years. Not by the Government of Spain and the parliamentary groups that support it.

Well, in that agenda of reconnection, to which you referred earlier, it was discussed, for example, about reducing institutional conflict. Well, five final agreements have been reached on normative conflicts. There is another one pending to be signed regarding the acceleration of the deployment of renewable and distributive energies. Agreeing on the transfer of functions and services in the area of scholarships and study aids that will be addressed this Friday in the Bilateral Commission. Activating the working group to analyze other transfers. Developing and implementing the Catalonia rodalies plan, which maybe for you, who do not use the Cercanías, is not important. But, in short, it is an action that contemplates more than 6.3 billion euros of investment for the mobility needs of the citizens of Catalonia. And the renewal of Cercanías trains has been launched for 2.445 billion euros. I want to be precise.

We have eliminated tolls on 315 kilometers of highways in Catalonia since September 1, 2021. We have contributed 20 million euros to promote the cultural and scientific capital of Barcelona. We have transferred, extraordinarily, 3.262 billion euros in 2020, 3.154 billion euros in 2021, in the fight against the pandemic. For you, maybe this seems like a trifle or seems, let’s say, insufficient or unimportant. But I believe that for many healthcare professionals in Catalonia, who have seen their working conditions devalued as a result of cuts in primary care, which were perpetrated precisely by governments linked in the past to you and your political party, I think it is relevant.

We have complied for the first time, Your Honor, with the additional provision of the Statute, committing the necessary investments. In the General State Budgets, for example, which you voted against, allocate to Catalonia 2.230.7 million euros for investments, 236.8 million euros for capital transfers. And I could continue with many other issues that we have on the agenda and that we are carrying out.

For example, not to go any further, something that your group supports, and that I celebrate, as it also seems that Esquerra Republicana supports. And it is precisely that Olympic candidacy of the Pyrenees of Barcelona and Zaragoza, where the Government of Spain and also the Spanish Olympic Committee, well, we are supporting, precisely, to achieve that important candidacy that will generate opportunities, precisely, in the Aragonese and Catalan Pyrenees.

I understand that all this matters little to you. You are in another thing, you are in another world. You say that the labor reform, well, goes against the economic reality of Catalonia. Well, I have seen the Secretary General of the General Union of Workers and the Secretary General of Comisiones Obreras of Catalonia defend this labor reform in Catalonia. Maybe for you they are not good Catalans, but for me they are as Catalan as you are, Your Honor. They are as Catalan as you are.

Therefore, with all due respect, I will tell you that we are going to continue dialoguing at the Dialogue Table, in the Bilateral Commission, to guarantee coexistence, cohesion among Catalans and, in short, Your Honor, when one bets on dialogue, one bets with all the consequences.

And what cannot be is that you reproach the Government of Spain for that 'sit and talk', sit down and talk, and when we convene that dialogue table, who is missing is you.

Reply from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Josep Lluís Cleries of the Nationalist Parliamentary Group Partit Demócrata (PDECAT-CDC)

President: In short, I reaffirm, Your Honor, the path and the dialogue that we have opened between the Government of Spain and the Govern of the Generalitat of Catalonia. I reaffirm the two main instruments we have: the Bilateral Commission, which will meet this week, and the Dialogue Table, which will also take place.

And we are making progress, Your Honor. And the situation today, objectively, is not the situation of 2017. It seems that when I listen to you, you miss those times, that you can only live in a Catalonia that is at odds with itself. And, precisely, there are many of us, inside and outside of Catalonia, who want, precisely, the opposite. That Catalonia has coexistence and that Catalonia reduces its emotional distance between its own citizens. And among those citizens who feel very distant from Spain and their other compatriots who live in the rest of Spain.

That is the project that I defend, Your Honor, a project of integration and coexistence. Not a project of fracture and exclusion, which is what you express every time you have the opportunity to intervene in the Senate. That is not the Catalonia that many Catalans, fortunately, the majority, want, nor is it the Catalonia that many Spaniards want.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Carles Mulet García of the Mixed Parliamentary Group (Compromís)

President: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Your Honor, I would like to first thank your group, because in the General Courts, both in the Senate and particularly in the Congress, they have supported important reforms that have to do, for example, with labor reform, with the agreement reached between social agents and the Government of Spain.

Or also, for example, the revaluation of pensions, putting, in short, at 0.25% that, in short, condemned many retirees when the Popular Party was in power, and recovering that path of well-deserved rights for our retirees, such as the revaluation of pensions.

Also, the supports you have made in such important laws, such as the social shield, the approval of ERTEs, the euthanasia law, the vocational training law. In short, I have nothing but gratitude for the votes of your parliamentary group in the General Courts.

And I must tell you, Your Honor, that even with the mistakes we may have made, because, indeed, we have had to manage a pandemic. There was no roadmap for any government in what is the response to the emergency of the appearance of a new virus in our lives, such as COVID-19.

I believe that on the balance, we have protected our fellow citizens who are responding, for example, with the vaccination strategy in a formidable and exemplary manner compared to other countries not so far from ours.

And, therefore, it causes me great unease to hear you make such a negative, such a sad assessment. And that, in addition, you slide a series of concepts and arguments that, after all, only serve to bolster the right and make many of the things that have been achieved over these two years of legislature seem unjust.

To say that this is a Government that has done nothing but advance labor rights. For example, when we have recently approved an increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage to 1,000 euros per month. When, in short, in the financial crisis reaching 1,000 euros for many workers was an impossible dream. And today, on the other hand, it is a reality because it is the minimum wage for many workers in our country, particularly young people and women.

I think it is absolutely unfair, not only to the Government but also to the leftist ideologies that you or I, from different latitudes, may represent.

I must tell you that, without a doubt, if we had to make a balance on the management of this crisis in relation to the financial crisis, we are demonstrating that completely different responses can be proposed.

We have launched, Your Honor, ERTEs that have saved millions of jobs. That if we had not launched, very likely, the unemployment rate in our country could be unimaginably high, at 40 or 42%. Today we have an unemployment rate of 13%. We have 95% of workers back in their jobs.

That, Your Honor, also had a lot to do with something that this Government of Spain fought for in Brussels, with the creation of the European Unemployment Reinsurance Fund, which has allowed us to finance all those ERTEs.

And you say, Your Honor, that this is little more than what the PP did when it governed, which was to approve a labor reform that devalued wages and led to unemployment rates close to 30%?

Really, Your Honor, you do not believe that the approach we are making, for example, with the European funds, I mean from a political point of view of fighting, fighting in Brussels to get those European funds, to make the great transformations, to finance the welfare state, so that we come out of this crisis with a national health system much stronger than the one we entered precisely into this health emergency.

By the way, the reversal of the hospitals privatized by the governments of the Popular Party in the Valencian Community, Your Honor, is taking place precisely under a leftist government led by the Socialist Party and by Ximo Puig, as President. And that is in the hands and is the responsibility of the Govern, in this case, of the Generalitat of the Valencian Community. Therefore, in short, Your Honor, I also do not quite understand what you mean with some of these criticisms.

Our commitment, Your Honor, to regional financing is total. We have proposed, the Minister of Finance present here, and of Public Function, an initiative to talk with the autonomous communities and, evidently, to know what the regional financing system will be that we will establish for the coming years.

But, in the meantime, what have we done, Your Honor? Well, in 2019, or rather, since 2019, including that year, the funding for 2022 as well, has provided the autonomous communities with 36% more funding.

Keep this figure in mind, Your Honor, almost 500,000 million euros, which were not given during the last four years of the previous government. And the municipalities will receive in 2022 the largest transfers in history, which will grow by 13%.

And if we focus on the Comunitat Valenciana, between 2018 and 2020, the revenues of the Comunitat have grown by nearly 15%, a total of 2,575 million euros.

In 2021, that upward trend in the resources transferred to the autonomous community continued, and these increases are also reflected in the General Budgets for the year 2022.

Your Honor, we are also leading, along with other countries, the debate in Europe on new fiscal rules. And we are also leading, through a committee of experts, a tax reform that our country needs. Because if we want social justice, we also need fiscal justice, that is, those who have more should pay more.

But, Your Honor, we have been in government for two years, managing a pandemic.

And I believe we have done so with mistakes, but also with many successes, but above all we have done it by co-governing with the autonomous communities. Respecting Title VIII of the Constitution, appearing and being accountable before the Cortes Generales, in the Congress of Deputies and in the Senate. Managing European funds, precisely, with the autonomous communities.

I believe, Your Honor, that you are doing yourself a disservice by buying arguments from the right to qualify what I believe is a progressive policy, which is what we are doing from the Government of Spain.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Senator Carles Mulet García of the Mixed Parliamentary Group (Compromís).

President: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Your Honor, let's see, I believe that like any left-wing party that defends the Welfare State, we know how to add and we know how to subtract. That is to say, the sustainability of public finances is fundamental, it is paramount.

There are others who, precisely, justify the dismantling of the Welfare State, saying that it is unsustainable in the medium and long term. This has happened when the right has governed, and what they have done is cut the public pension system. But that is not our case, Your Honor, that is not our case.

If one qualifies what the social policies of this Government of Spain are, I can name them. They are called Minimum Vital Income, they are called ERTE, they are called scholarships for our youth, they are called a new housing law, they are called unprecedented social policies during these years, thanks, precisely, to the impetus and leadership of the progressive Government.