Pedro Sánchez: "Stability is guaranteed and the health of the coalition government is secured."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

9 February 2022 · Interview with elDiario.es · La Moncloa

Context
Sánchez spoke to elDiario.es at La Moncloa in February 2022, defending coalition stability and the recently passed labor reform amid PP and Vox opposition.
Main themes
Coalition government stability, labor reform, opposition criticism, social dialogue, PP and Vox delegitimization, parliamentary minority governance, European funds, constitutional obligations, investiture partners, social consensus
Duration
~45 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,394
93rd percentile
Sentences
237
92nd percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.07
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
60th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 52%51%
  • Economic 16%16%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

237 sentences in 99 paragraphs

"After what we have seen in the last two years, I expect little, if not nothing, from the opposition that Pablo Casado's Popular Party is making," says Pedro Sánchez, who adds that at this point, all he asks of the leader of the Popular Party is that he does not call into question democracy and fulfills his constitutional obligations. "PP and Vox are equally devaluing the political debate in our country."

The President of the Government receives elDiario.es at La Moncloa, where he emphasizes that the coalition is guaranteed and that the legislature will end in unity: "The good health of the Government contrasts with the conservative coalitions in Murcia, Madrid, and Castilla y León." He also conveys a message to his partners: "Governing means reconciling what is desirable with achieving the maximum of what is possible." And he asks for "a reflection" from PNV and ERC for their vote against the labor reform. "I am convinced that there are many voters of those formations who do not understand their 'no' to this social agreement between unions and employers."

What would have happened if the PP deputy Alberto Casero had not made a mistake when voting on the labor reform decree and had fallen?

Fortunately, that has not been the case. It was and is a good agreement for the country. Both workers and employers, as well as social dialogue, would have lost. The country would have lost.

Do you think the right somehow bought the UPN deputies who all day concealed that they intended to vote against the labor reform?

That will have to be clarified and answered by the PP. What is evident is that we had an agreement with UPN, and the president of this party himself expressed his displeasure at not having been informed by these two deputies until the last moment of their negative vote and, therefore, contravening the orders of the political leadership of UPN.

Do the appeals announced by PP and Vox against Thursday's vote have legal standing? Are you concerned that this labor reform could be overturned by the Constitutional Court?

I am not surprised by what PP and Vox are doing. For two years, they have been articulating a discourse of delegitimization of the Government of Spain, and now they are calling into question the legitimacy of a democratic vote that has been taking place in Congress.

PP and Vox are equally devaluing the political debate in our country. I find this serious. Throughout these two years, the Popular Party has made it clear to me that it is not going to lend a hand, that it is not going to shoulder the burden. It has done so in the most difficult moments of the pandemic, with the lockdown, by not approving the state of alarm...

I expect very little, if not nothing, from the PP regarding reaching agreements that are good for the country. But at least I ask the PP for two things. First, that it complies with the Constitution: that it unblocks the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary and does not question the democratic quality of our country, which is above any circumstantial consideration. And, secondly, that it does not speak ill of Spain by boycotting European funds that are the great opportunity to modernize our country. Boycotting and blocking European funds is boycotting and also blocking the future that Spain deserves.

Why has a labor reform with so much consensus in social dialogue been approved with so much dissent in Parliament?

The executive power had a fundamental task: to foster an agreement among social agents. In the years 2010, 2011, 2012, and 2013, counter-reforms were implemented that led to general strikes and large demonstrations by pensioners and also by workers. The task of the Government of Spain was to restore those broken consensuses. We reached an agreement with social agents for an important labor reform.

From there, the duty of the legislative power was to validate that good agreement and consolidate a path of social dialogue that is not a means, but an end in itself. Those reforms that have the support of unions and employers ultimately transcend mere ideological issues and enter the realm of common sense, which is that of the common good. I would like to thank the employers, the unions, and also the political forces that have supported this important labor reform for their agreement and support in the Cortes. And to reflect on those political forces, particularly the progressive ones, those that have systematically supported the Government throughout this legislature, because I am convinced that there are many voters of those formations who do not understand the 'no' of those formations to this social agreement between unions and employers.

How has the relationship with these investiture partners who voted against the labor reform decree been affected?

Stability is guaranteed. This Government, which has a parliamentary minority of 155 seats, has been able to pass 50 very important laws. Not only the labor reform: also the pension agreement, the Minimum Vital Income, the euthanasia law... We are also going to try to pass the first housing law in the history of our democracy soon. And two consecutive General State Budgets over the course of these first two years of the legislature, something that had not happened since 2014. Therefore, stability is guaranteed.

I believe that the health of the coalition government is safeguarded because it is made of the best material, which is a firm, strong will to dignify the lives of our fellow citizens. The Government of Spain is focused on demonstrating that it is possible to emerge from crises by consolidating those social advances and managing the economy better than the right did when it was in power during the years of the financial crisis, which used that financial crisis as an ideological excuse to cut and weaken the welfare state.

The labor reform that is being repealed with this reform is the one from 2012 by Mariano Rajoy. The coalition government committed to repealing it. Do you consider that they have fulfilled that promise with this decree, or have they left things pending?

I believe that having managed to recover the prevalence of collective agreements, having responded to ultra-activity, and providing responses to alternative flexibility mechanisms to dismissal, such as ERTE, are substantive elements of a new model of labor relations that addresses the two main concerns of workers and employers. First, structural unemployment, which is so high compared to the rest of Europe. And, secondly, the high precariousness and temporality of labor relations in our country.

The pending task of a government like ours in such a difficult moment is to guarantee stability, preserve social peace. And that implies consolidating spaces for dialogue and agreement among social agents. What the Government of Spain has done is promote and facilitate that agreement between employers and unions, and the duty we had as the two political formations that support the Government in Parliament was to defend and push forward this important labor reform. The objective has been achieved.

Pablo Casado has described the voting and approval of the decree as a "pucherazo" and has even accused the president of Congress of prevarication. Has your party spoken with the PP to try to redirect this enormous political polarization? Do you think it is possible to do so?

After what we have seen in the last two years, I expect little, if not nothing, from the opposition that Pablo Casado's Popular Party is making. Both the PP and Vox are equally devaluing the political debate in our country, and that in an anti-system party like Vox may be expected. But from a party that has governed Spain, I find it utterly inconceivable.

The only thing that can be asked of Casado's PP is at least not to call into question democracy and to fulfill its constitutional obligations.

Has the vote on the labor reform made it clear that an alternative majority to the investiture block is not possible, that it is difficult to find more than 175 deputies through Ciudadanos?

It depends on the debates. If one analyzes what the parliamentary votes on important laws have been - such as the Minimum Vital Income, the pension agreement, the labor reform, or the euthanasia law - we have seen parliamentary formations of all kinds voting in favor. It is true that we have always found two political parties in the 'no', in that denialist opposition that is the Popular Party and Vox. I believe they confuse opposition with denial.

In the first month of this labor reform, the number of permanent contracts increased by 92%, and that is precisely what the Popular Party wanted to overturn with its vote against, even using turncoats, as it attempted with these two UPN deputies.

With ERC, the coalition government has been on the brink of the abyss in many votes. This has happened with the labor reform, but also with the extension of the states of alarm or with the European funds. Do you consider ERC a reliable partner for the Government?

I appreciate the attitude that both ERC and PNV have had throughout this legislature. I believe they should reflect on their vote against the validation of an agreement among social agents. I am convinced that there are many voters of ERC and PNV who do not share the vote against a labor reform that improves and dignifies the working conditions of workers, both in Catalonia and also in the Basque Country. I do not say this alone; the unions also made it known, for example to ERC, which is who you are asking about, both UGT and CCOO.

You spoke earlier about strengthening the coalition. Will the coalition govern until the next elections, or will it break before then?

The coalition government enjoys good health because it is made of a material that is resilient: advancing in terms of social rights and also freedoms, which is what we have been doing over these two years of the legislature. It is true that we are two political organizations that have different cultures. It is true that social democracy represents that reformist left and that Unidas Podemos is a political party that is in the process of becoming a governing party, coming from activism and now in that transition, and governing means reconciling what is desirable with achieving the maximum of what is possible.

In that internal life of the coalition, is it understood better now with Yolanda Díaz than before with Pablo Iglesias?

I am respectful of my government partner, and I obviously have an extraordinary relationship with both Vice President Yolanda and I also had one at the time with Vice President Iglesias.

Are you concerned that your Minister of Labor and probable electoral rival is the most valued minister in the Government, or do you think that Yolanda Díaz's good image among many progressive voters is good news for the coalition government as a whole?

It is good news for everyone that the two political formations that currently make up the Government have clear, recognizable leaderships for the progressive electorate. That again demonstrates the good health of the coalition government, which contrasts, by the way, with the poor health of conservative coalition governments that we are seeing in different territories.

Elections in Castilla y León have been hastened precisely due to a rupture of a coalition government between the Popular Party and Ciudadanos; a similar situation occurred in Murcia and also in the Community of Madrid.

What is at stake for the PSOE and the Government in the elections this Sunday in Castilla y León?

We are clearly seeing a hasty call for elections by the Popular Party with a single interest: exclusively the interest of the Popular Party. In the meantime, a great window of opportunity for change has opened, which, by the way, the citizens of Castilla y León already expressed during the regional elections of 2019 that they wanted that change, that they wanted to put an end to 35 years of conservative government. That is why the PSOE won, and that is why alternative parliamentary majorities were possible then, which, unfortunately, did not occur as a result of a decision made by Ciudadanos at that time.

If the votes for change are concentrated in the party that can bring about that change, which is the PSOE, that change will take place. Our diagnosis is that Castilla y León needs a change and that what it does not need is precisely a new game of musical chairs, this time not between the PP and Ciudadanos, but between the PP and Vox.

What would the entry of Vox into a regional government mean for Spain?

First, we will try to ensure that this does not happen. It would be a clear deterioration and weakening, not only of the pillars of the welfare state, which are in the hands of the autonomous communities. We would be talking about an unprecedented step in European politics, the first in Spanish politics, of a bear hug from the Popular Party to Vox. I believe it would be bad news for Castilla y León and also very bad news, in the medium term, for the Popular Party.

Do you see it likely that Russia will invade Ukraine?

I hope that is not the case. The Minister of Foreign Affairs is traveling to Ukraine to meet with his counterpart. A few months ago, at the Eastern Partnership summit, I made it clear to President Zelensky the respect and defense that Spain makes of territorial integrity, in this case of Ukraine.

There may be Spanish citizens who consider that due to the geographical distance of Spain from Ukraine and Russia, this crisis does not directly concern us. I believe that is a mistake.

The Government of Spain has, from the very first minute, stated that Russia must respect, without a doubt, international legality, which is what is being called into question. The threat posed by the accumulation of battalions on the borders with Ukraine is calling into question the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Ukraine, that is, of a third country. In addition to that international legality, we are logically working through diplomatic channels and de-escalation to ensure that this military clash does not actually occur.

In the event that an open military conflict occurs, in the worst-case scenario, would Spain be willing to send more troops to the area?

It is not appropriate to enter into speculation at this moment. What is important now is to convey to Russia the unity of Europe and the Atlantic Alliance. Russia is calling into question the architecture of European security that we established after the Second World War. It is suggesting that NATO's borders should revert to the 1990s. That is to say, that the Baltic countries or Poland should not be part of that Atlantic Alliance. This is unacceptable for the European Union and for the allies within NATO.

However, Spain, together with Europe and the other countries of the Atlantic Alliance, is committed to de-escalation: through diplomatic means, through dialogue, and by trying to redirect a conflict that neither Ukraine nor Europe has sought.

Should NATO make it clear that Ukraine will not be part of the alliance, or do you believe that Russia's request is inadmissible?

When we talk about respect for national sovereignty, we are talking about a country being sovereign to decide what international policy and what international relations it chooses. That is why I believe it is important to convey to Russia that it is unacceptable for Russia to impose an international policy on a third country, in accordance with its legitimate interests, but which are not the legitimate interests of Ukraine.

What is the objective of the investigation you propose regarding ecclesiastical pedophilia through the Ombudsman? Will the guilty parties be named? Will there be compensation for the victims?

This is a government that is clearly and unequivocally committed to defending the rights of minors. We have approved an important law in the General Courts for the protection of children and youth against all forms of violence. One of the main milestones of this law is the elimination of the statute of limitations for these types of crimes as the years go by, but obviously, this does not have retroactive effect.

In this specific case, we are talking about opening an investigation, which has been requested by the victims, that clearly focuses on a problem that has been historically dragging on from victims who studied in schools linked to the Catholic Church.

Not only is there the interest of Spanish society, but it is also in the interest of the Catholic Church in Spain to clarify these responsibilities and to clarify what happened. I believe this will also be good for the Catholic Church.

Why is the Catholic Church so late compared to the Catholic churches in France, Poland, or the United States, which opened internal investigation processes much earlier?

It is true that this entire debate, both in Spain and in other parts of the world, is occurring late because we are talking about events that in most cases have probably already expired, but all the more reason not to delay further and to initiate these types of investigations. We want to do this, responding to your first question, with the aim, firstly, of listening to and understanding the victims, secondly, of repairing the harm caused to the victims, and thirdly, of putting in place measures to ensure that these situations do not happen again in the future. This is the objective: to attend to the victims because we are in debt to them. Spanish society is in debt to them, and we are a mature democracy, and we are sufficiently capable of addressing these types of debates with rigor and sensitivity.

We have proposed that the High Commissioner of the General Courts, who is the Ombudsman, lead the investigation, with the support of an independent advisory commission. And that he reports to the General Courts.

Why do you believe that this is the best method for this investigation?

The fundamental thing is to attend to the victims and therefore to create and build safe testimony spaces, sufficiently confidential so that they can express their pain and be heard and attended to, in this case by such an important institution as, I insist, the Ombudsman. From there, the Ombudsman will submit his resulting report to the General Courts and to the Government of Spain so that we can articulate the response measures: to restore the harm to the victims and to implement measures that prevent such regrettable events from occurring again.

Are you satisfied with the outcome of the negotiation with the Church regarding the properties registered under the reform made by Aznar at that time? The Episcopal Conference has acknowledged that there are a thousand properties that were incorrectly registered but cannot be returned because they are no longer in their possession.

That is the first step, but we are still working with the Episcopal Conference, precisely to continue clarifying the ownership situation of some of these properties. Therefore, I believe that this joint working group remains open, and we will continue to work rigorously, which is what we have been doing so far.

Should the Church pay property taxes?

Another of the working groups we have with the Episcopal Conference is precisely how we can review their responsibilities with the tax authorities in some of these areas. I hope that, in the coming months, we can provide a much more concrete response to this question you raise.

Will the price of electricity continue to rise? Until when?

What all forecasts tell us is that it will continue to rise over the coming months. From the perspective of the Government of Spain, measures have been taken to cushion that evolution of electricity prices. We are making a tremendous effort in the fiscal area to mitigate that evolution and to increase protection for vulnerable consumers. And, obviously, there is a different dimension, which is the European one, where the Government of Spain, for several months now, has been advocating the need to reform the energy market to somehow separate the evolution of gas prices from the evolution of electricity prices.

And are there any advances in Europe regarding that request? Because the crisis in Ukraine is causing even greater increases in gas prices.

Not only that, but what we are also seeing is that gas, which is currently indeed experiencing significant tension and a very important increase in price, is conditioning the price of all energy. In Spain, we have increased renewable electricity production by almost 10 points in the last year. We are around 46%. We are one of the countries that produces the most electricity from renewable energy sources.

This entire gas crisis shows us that we must continue to increase the penetration of renewable energies in our electrical system. And that is what the Government of Spain is doing, also betting on alternative energies, such as green hydrogen, which currently does not have all the necessary technology, but which in a few years could turn Spain into an exporting country of renewable energies and green hydrogen.

We are waiting for the reports and future communications that the European Commission will be able to present, but the Government of Spain is clear that we need to reform our energy system and decouple the evolution of gas prices from the evolution of electricity prices. And we need to send a clear, resounding message that what is not green cannot be classified as green. Investment in nuclear energy, investment in fossil fuels such as gas, cannot be considered in the taxonomy as green energy. Spain opposes this, and we will logically make our voice heard in the European Council and in the European Parliament.

Do you understand the PP's policy of discrediting Spain and its institutions by casting doubts on the management of European funds? Does this resonate in Europe or is it received with skepticism?

Fortunately, the Government of Spain is the first to do its homework regarding European funds. We have had a constant conversation from the very first minute in defining the plans to channel all these European funds, regarding the reforms we are implementing. But I insist, it is not good for Spain for the main opposition party to lose credibility with the community institutions, which is what is happening.

In any case, it is quite similar to what happened in the 1980s and 1990s, when the Popular Party, then also in opposition, criticized the socialist governments that obtained European funds, in this case, structural and cohesion funds, which improved the competitiveness and modernization of our economy. Today they are mistaken, just as they were mistaken then. These European funds are a great opportunity for our country, and we certainly will not waste it.

Are those European funds reaching the companies? There are criticisms that the process is slow, that the money is not arriving with the necessary fluidity.

We must put ourselves in the shoes of all institutions, not only the Government of Spain but also the autonomous communities, provincial councils, and municipalities. We must be aware that we started receiving the funds in the second half of last year and that the political will of the Government of Spain was to somehow lay the tracks for what will be the channels through which all these European funds will be channeled, especially in 2022 and 2023.

We are talking about 70 billion euros, but in any case, what I can convey is that many of those funds will precisely reach small and medium-sized enterprises in our country. Today, for example, we approved in the Council of Ministers a PERTE, a strategic project, linked to a very important industry in our country, such as agro-industry, which in our country is mainly made up of cooperatives, social economy, and small and medium-sized enterprises.

Will the minimum wage rise to 1,000 euros? Will that measure take effect retroactively from January 1?

That is the proposal, and that is the ambition of the Government of Spain. Our objective is clear: to reach 60% of the average salary by the end of 2023. I have always defined this government as a government of word and action. We say what we do and do what we say. We said we would raise the minimum wage to 60% by the end of the legislature, and we are on track to achieve that goal.

If anything has been demonstrated by the evolution of employment data and also, logically, the evolution of the minimum interprofessional wage, it is that there is no contradiction between the pace of job creation and the increase in the minimum interprofessional wage. On the contrary, what we have is a very powerful mechanism for the predistribution of that wealth, which is what the Government of Spain is doing.

We are acting on both fronts. We are acting on the predistribution front, but we are also acting on the front of just economic recovery. That is to say, distributing those opportunities and that growth around the most vulnerable layers of society and also of the territories. Today, in the Council of Ministers, we also presented a very important report, which we will take to the Conference of Presidents on the Island of La Palma, regarding the degree of evolution and evaluation of the 130 measures linked to the development of the Demographic Challenge Plan.

Is Juan Carlos I better off inside or outside of Spain?

This is a debate that we have indeed had over the past few months. I respect King Juan Carlos's decision to leave Spain, just as I also respect, logically, the investigation being led by the Attorney General's Office.

If he were to return, should the emeritus king apologize to the Spanish people?

I believe I have been clear on this. I think King Juan Carlos owes an explanation to Spanish society, and I also believe that this is not contradictory with the statement I made from the very first minute this crisis began. My commitment to the Spanish Constitution, to the constitutional architecture, and therefore to the institution of the Royal House is total, it is absolute, in the sense that, logically, here we are debating about the person and not about the institution.

You have committed to promoting a law to abolish prostitution. What measures are you considering? Is it risky to promise the disappearance of prostitution if you do not even have the consensus of forces like Unidas Podemos or ERC?

The abolition of prostitution is a commitment of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party. Throughout the congresses of the Socialist Party, many laws have emerged that at the time seemed like dreams, but which, fortunately, have become a reality and have materialized in the General Courts whenever we have governed as socialists. Just to remind you, from the congresses of the Socialist Party came the debate on the minimum vital income, which today is a reality; from the congresses of the Socialist Party came the commitment to approve a dignified death law on euthanasia, which today is a reality; from the congresses of the Socialist Party came the approval of a law to combat gender-based violence, which today is a reality; and the same will happen with the abolition of prostitution.

I previously asked the PP to comply with the Constitution and their obligation to renew the CGPJ, which has been in office for more than three years. Should the members of the CGPJ resign to force the PP to comply with the Constitution?

As President of the Government, I must carry out absolute and scrupulous respect for the separation of powers, out of duty and conviction. What the members of the General Council of the Judiciary do will have to be something they reflect on, think about, and do, in case they indeed make the decision you mentioned earlier. For my part, I have absolute respect for the current situation, which is already quite questionable due to the PP's blockade. In a moment of crisis like the one we are experiencing, all political parties should contribute to the legitimization and consolidation of the democratic institutions of our country.

The blockade by the Popular Party, the non-compliance and insubordination to the Spanish Constitution has no parallel in Europe. What it does is contribute to the questioning and weakening of democracy. This is not new; we are also seeing it with the unjustified criticisms they are making of the President of the Congress of Deputies, saying that it is a sham, that these things happen in Spain just as they happen in Latin American countries. The seriousness of these accusations, I believe, deserves reflection from the Popular Party.

The devaluation, the degradation of political debate to which the Popular Party and Vox are leading, equally, many of the debates that are being substantiated, whether in the blockade of the General Council of the Judiciary and its renewal, or in the result of a vote that validated the Royal Decree Law as a consequence of an error by a member of the Popular Party, seems to me to be something that has no parallel in Europe.

Have you, as a deputy, ever made a mistake when voting?

I have made mistakes.

Do you know any deputy who has never made a mistake?

I am convinced that more than 90% of the deputies who have ever had responsibilities in the Courts have made a mistake. Therefore, we are talking about that, about a material error. But that does not have to call into question either the legitimacy of a result, of a vote, in the Congress of Deputies, nor much less call into question the extraordinary work that the Presidency of the Congress is doing.

Do you think that the Popular Party, when they see that error from their deputy, is aware that UPN was going to vote as they did?

That has to be answered by the Popular Party, as well as the two deputies from UPN have to explain why during the morning they did not clearly state that they were going to vote no, and instead, repeatedly, the president of UPN was told that they were going to vote yes and to the media, publicly, they said they were going to vote yes.

Do you consider the pandemic over, or can we have new waves that could lead to restrictions in the medium term?

I cannot answer that question. Unfortunately, we do not yet have the answer, but we are starting to see that we have solid foundations to progressively move towards overcoming the pandemic. Not only because of vaccination rates and booster doses, but also because of the conditions of this new variant of Omicron, which have clearly not translated into greater hospitalization and a higher number of ICU admissions.

From there, I think the debate launched by the Government of Spain within the European Union and the World Health Organization is appropriate. We need to build that bridge towards managing this pandemic as an endemic disease. It is a necessary debate because, indeed, today we are much better than we were two years ago.

As president, what lesson have you learned from such a difficult management as that of these two years of pandemic?

Science, welfare state, and unity. I believe that these three elements are fundamental. The lesson that we need to strengthen science in our country. We will do this with a new science law. Secondly, the need to reinforce the welfare state and particularly our National Health System and especially primary care. That is one of the lessons that the autonomous communities must draw, which have diverted much of their investment towards hospital care to the detriment of primary care. And finally, unity. Unity, as we said before, for example, with social agents to reach thirteen very important agreements for the implementation of ERTEs, for self-employed benefits, for ICO credits, which we have been extending and which have saved hundreds of thousands of companies and millions of jobs. But also the unity of many political parties that, with many difficulties, have supported these measures.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of elDiario.es.