"I would like young people to feel this Constitution as their own."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

6 December 2018

Context
Sánchez gave an interview on Spain's Constitution Day, reflecting on 40 years of the 1978 Constitution and the need for reform and renewal.
Main themes
Spanish Constitution reform, territorial diversity and federalism, Catalan autonomy and broken consensus, youth participation in democracy, European Union integration, constitutional adaptation to modern society, autonomous state model, new rights and environmental rights, representative democracy, constitutional pact renewal
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,418
80th percentile
Sentences
153
81st percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%62%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

153 sentences in 40 paragraphs

- When was the Constitution approved and how old were you at that time?

- I was born in '72.

- Someone who was 6 years old when the Constitution was approved and is now the President of the Government, does he believe that its text still fits reality or that it needs an "evolutionary interpretation," as the Constitutional Court itself said at the time?

- I summarize it in one sentence, which may be a truism, but I think it illustrates the need for the Constitution to adapt to the society it serves, and that is that Spain in 2018 is not Spain in 1978. There are also other considerations. The first, in historical terms, is that I believe the Constitution of '78 assumes the legacy of the Second Republic, its failure, the Civil War, and subsequently the Franco dictatorship. It does so in that it posits that in our country there will never be democracy if territorial diversity is not recognized and vice versa; that is, there will never be territorial diversity if we are not within a democratic system. The second is that the Spanish Constitution allowed us to align ourselves with European democracies and consequently we were able to enter the EU. When we talk about the evolution of the Spanish Constitution, we have to look towards Europe: at some point, this generation of leaders that we currently represent from different parties in different areas (in the Government or in the opposition) must strengthen our ties with the European Union and promote that the process of evolution of our Constitution serves that purpose. It should serve to strengthen the very process of the European Union and to develop our contribution to that construction, to strengthen solidarity not only in terms of citizenship but also territorially and to improve the governance structure of Spain.

- One of the major issues that is always raised about the evolution of the Spanish Constitution is its reform to establish a federal structure of the State. How do you see it?

- I would say three things: the first, I really like a phrase from Jordi Solé Turá that said "it doesn't matter what it's called, the important thing is that it works." I think that pragmatic sense, coming from a person who was an exile, who returned and ultimately became Minister of Culture, is a good conception of political life: to have principles and to be pragmatic. Secondly, the problem is that federalism as such is a term that is not fully understood by Spaniards. The meaning it has in Spain has nothing to do with the meaning it has in other democracies. Federalism in Spain, I believe as a consequence also of the Second Republic, has more disaggregating connotations than aggregating ones, as may occur in the United States or Germany. That is why the great success of the constitutional fathers is, indeed, having found a terminology, which following Jordi Solé Turá's reflection, it doesn't matter what it's called, the point is that it works. And it has worked, it has worked for 40 years. What happens is that instruments wear out, materials suffer, like people, and we need to revitalize them. The renewal of the constitutional pact will not be an end in itself, when it begins to take place, but rather it will be a channel, a mechanism through which we can begin to recompose some of the broken consensuses. That is a bit the issue. But yes, I believe that the autonomous state is a federal state and that one of the great challenges we have now is to perfect our territorial model.

- When you talk about broken consensuses, what has fundamentally broken?

- It is evident that in Catalonia the constitutional consensus has broken, as a consequence of the non-acceptance by a majority minority of Catalan society of the Statute of Autonomy. That is one of the consensuses that must be recomposed. The second has to do with something that seems fundamental to me, and it is the way in which political life develops (in democratic politics both substance and form are fundamental) and, therefore, with the need for participation, especially from younger generations, in that process of renewing the constitutional pact. I do not speak of a constituent process because I do not believe we should fall into a kind of Adamism that does not recognize the virtues of the Constitution, but I do believe that the forms of political participation have changed. Logically, they must have the Congress of Deputies as their epicenter, and therefore representative democracy, but around it many energies, many constructive currents can be channeled, which can invigorate our democratic system.

- Like what?

- What has been the experience of the last constitutional reforms? They have practically been done with their backs to the citizens, quickly and haphazardly. When I talk about opening channels of participation, I mean opening channels of dialogue, for example, to see what new rights we can incorporate into the Constitution. Environmental rights, for example, were not as much of a priority in 1978 as they are today, when we face the challenge of climate change; gender equality is in our Constitution, but not as evidently as I believe feminism would like to see reflected after March 8. The fact that there are not only fathers but also mothers of the Constitution would already be an advance that would reflect the plural reality of our society. There are aspects that have to do with the labor world, with rights linked to the information society and the digital society that also need to be incorporated. There are many debates that could perfectly invigorate our democracy and enrich our text constitutionally.

- The Constitution states that Spain is a social state, however many analysts talk about the rupture of the social pact...

- Here again, Europe comes into play. Antón Costas and Joaquín Estefanía have written about the need to re-sign a social contract and it is true that the Constitution is part of that new contract. The great task we have as political parties is to understand that to a large extent the success of our political projects, at the national level, will depend a lot on the fate of Europe because, in the end, the renewal of that social contract must have as protagonists not only the State, the autonomous communities, and the municipalities, but also and very fundamentally the EU. When we talk about environmental rights, if we do not assume a series of political commitments at the supranational level, it will be difficult for us to do anything effective. If we talk about fair taxation, as established by the Spanish Constitution, it will be difficult for us to face and provide a real response to large digital corporations or tax havens if we do not speak in European terms. And what to say about labor mobility, which affects many young people, and the need for social and labor rights to be recognized across the continent. That new social contract, which obviously has a chapter that must be the renewal of our constitutional pact, with its gaze towards Europe, is also necessarily intertwined with the architecture of Europe in the future. That is why I think what was mentioned earlier is very important. In Spain, it is evident that the strengthening of our autonomous structure has a lot to do with the European project. A federal Europe with greater integration, with an embryo of a European budget, with the economic and monetary union completed or with a joint defense, must be present in the political debate about our Constitution. We are already precisely in that European vanguard that France and Germany propose.

- When you say "the important thing is that it works," does it also apply to Republic and Monarchy? What matters about the form of the State is that it works.

- Honestly, now that I have the opportunity to know firsthand the work that has been done over these 40 years and that the Royal House does today, and particularly King Felipe VI, I believe that the parliamentary monarchy is, right now, the keystone of a great constitutional consensus that was forged in 1978, and that I hope will endure. Felipe VI is a king of his time, a king who defends gender equality, Spain's commitment to the fight against climate change, workers' rights, and who has great sensitivity regarding the Catalan issue and the diversity of our country, despite the fact that Catalan independence supporters have criticized him. Earlier I evoked the Second Republic, it is worth remembering that when the independence supporters wanted to secede from Spain, they were actually doing so against the Republic. Now they are doing it against a parliamentary monarchy. That is to say, they do not care what type of structure and model of State we have, what they want is to go against the essence of Spain.

- Is there enough institutional loyalty at this moment to make a constitutional pact?

- Well. If you look at the PP, when they were in power they did it slowly, and now in opposition they are speeding up. I think it is also a bit of a product of the political time we live in, where news expires in two hours. The main means of communication that citizens have right now are digital media and television, and unfortunately the expiration of news, no matter how good and important they are, is measured in minutes. What I mean by this is that we are in an immediate democracy. Very conditioned by the media and very immediate. This eagerness to respond quickly, to set a position, makes politics more vulnerable to pressures. The times of politics, and this is one of the lessons I have learned in these months I have been President of the Government, are different from the positions of the media, and that does not mean that you do not have a political position, but simply that your moment to respond to some of the issues is later. All this vulnerability of politics makes agreements and consensuses more difficult.

- Are there constitutional reforms that can be carried out quickly, as happened with the famous article 135?

- In relation to 135, the position of the Government of Spain, of the PSOE, has always been the same, the one I have defended. It must be complemented with a commitment to a social minimum. Regarding reforms, I agree. If we conceive the need for our Constitution to evolve, that is, a mechanism to recompose the consensuses that may be weakened, broken, or that need a new impetus, I believe we should start with elements where there is consensus. For example, the Government of Spain has requested a report from the Council of State for the reform of the privileges that has received unanimous support from the members of that body. The idea is to see how we translate it into a proposal for constitutional reform that we will take to Congress. In theory, all parliamentary groups agree. When I say all, I mean all. Perhaps it is a good starting point. Or for example, I believe that article 84 defines people with disabilities in a way that has nothing to do with what they currently claim. That modification should also be a good starting point. I mean, great adventures ultimately begin with small steps and, therefore, it is not necessary to start talking about elements on which we surely have great differences, but rather about those where there is already agreement. If you ask me if I would like the Constitutional Commission to be open every legislature, I would say yes. Simply to be able to debate and see what elements of improvement of our Constitution we can incorporate, how it can evolve. It is not about setting deadlines but about an open process in the Constitutional Commission of the Congress of Deputies as a meeting point.

- If you had an entire legislature ahead of you, what concrete proposals would you make?

- We are already doing it. Some are surprised and say "you have 84 deputies," well, yes, 84 deputies, but I understand that for the reform of the Constitution regarding the limitation or suppression of privileges there will be 350 deputies, and the same in the Senate. So it is not so much the parliamentary number from which a certain constitutional reform is proposed but, first, the social backing it has, which I believe in this case is significant, and secondly, the eventual parliamentary support it can achieve.

- Start with smaller things, where an agreement can be quickly reached, and demonstrate that the Constitution is reformable.

- More than small, I would say in the things where there are already points of agreement. If we manage to make a reform of the Constitution, even if it is punctual, on a topic that has such significant consensus as, for example, that of privileges, I believe we will have provided a great service to the vigor of our Constitution.

- Do politicians use the Constitution too much in their electoral confrontations?

- Yes. Right now there is a current in that sense. It is always exacerbated when the right is in opposition. Before it was one voice. Now there are two and a half voices, with the one that is outside parliament, but to which perhaps they are not aware that both the PP and Ciudadanos are feeding with their rightward turn. That will be their responsibility. In any case, there is a proprietary sentiment regarding symbols, concepts like Spain or the Constitution, which I believe is dangerous. When Casado gathers certain political parties, he does not call the PSOE and tries to appropriate constitutionalism, he is doing a disservice precisely to the Constitution.

- Doesn't the left do that?

- We are less about symbols, but yes, we too, let’s say in the more progressive sphere of Spanish society, have also allowed that to happen. I believe that the Spanish flag belongs to everyone, including people on the left. Because precisely the coat of arms and the constitutional flag make visible a series of values, a series of principles for which many people even lost their lives during the Franco dictatorship and the Civil War. There is a part of the left that was a minority within the Communist Party, which somewhat called Santiago Carrillo a traitor for assuming parliamentary monarchy, in the name of what Azaña asked for: "Peace, mercy, forgiveness," and which, on the other hand, is now in the leadership of Unidos Podemos. It is curious how those who were then a minority, let’s say, today represent the majority or the leadership of such an important party for the political system as Unidos Podemos. That leadership somewhat reaffirms what was then the minority communist sector, the one for which the political transition did not actually mean a transition to anything, but simply a transfiguration of the Franco regime into a pseudodemocracy. And that, in that sector, legitimizes in their eyes and from their point of view, the right to self-determination of the peoples of Spain, because, according to them, what we really have is not a democracy. In some way, they make it so that suddenly, in the realm of the right and also in the realm of the left, ticks that we thought were forgotten resurface.

- Could the Socialist Party have done something about it?

- Well, I believe that Unidos Podemos has also evolved in its political thought and political action. For example, in the budget agreement, it has adopted the rules of the stability and growth pact, and therefore aligns itself with the main axes that define European construction. That is good for the country. But yes, indeed, we, as a major social democratic party in Europe and Spain, also have the task of empathizing with the causes of regeneration that at one point were in the 15-M movement. I have always said that the new Constitution must be a Constitution with which the people of 15-M identify. But not in terms of a constituent process, but simply in seeing what positive elements that spectacular social movement had, which gave such a positive image of our country, both inside and outside of Spain, because we now forget, but while in other societies they were seeing reactionary movements, here, in Spain, people began to talk about how to redistribute wealth, how to address the issue of evictions, the best of our society emerged. We must support the causes that are worthwhile, and bring them to public action. And that is something we can do as a political organization, but also with other political organizations.

- And is it possible to have a Constitution in which both the 15-M and the PP feel represented?

- Why not. I am convinced that in the 15-M there were sons and daughters of people who vote for the PP. I believe that the 15-M was precisely an absolutely transversal movement, a movement where there was no political party that represented it. I myself had friends from one party and another who were there for days. I insist. It was a regenerating movement and as a regenerating movement it did not belong to any political party but to all.

- What would those transformations be?

- I believe that Spain has lost a decade and now what it is about is winning a decade. In reality, it is a sort of life cycle, with five essential transformations.

The first is education. It is true that we need to adapt our education to the society of the 21st century, to the technological changes that are advancing, and when I talk about education I am not only talking about basic education, I am talking about university, vocational training, or even active employment policies that clearly need to be renewed.

Two. The labor market and the business fabric. We talk about the Constitution but we must also talk about the Workers' Statute, which has indeed been modified over the last few decades, and it is time that in the next legislature we open a great debate with social agents about that new Statute.

Three. We need to talk about taxation. About what kind of welfare state we want. And from there, see how we finance it. That is a debate we need to open seriously. There will obviously be ideological contrasts, but I believe it is reasonable to guarantee the principle of universality in education, in healthcare, to guarantee decent pensions, that is, that they are indexed to the evolution of prices, the cost of living, and logically also to clean up our public accounts, because we still unfortunately have a high public deficit in relative terms with the EU and also a high public debt.

Four. The ecological transition. It is evident that we need to transform our energy system, our mobility system, and all of that will need at least a decade to accomplish.

Fifth. The constitutional reform.

- It seems that the constitutional reform is primarily about territorial reform. Because for the other modifications, it is not just changing the fundamental text...

- The debate on fundamental rights is part of the constitutional reform. And when I put it as the fifth point, it does not mean that it is the fifth, but I believe that these are five compact objectives that nourish one another. And yes, I think it is a communication error of the Socialist Party that when we talk about constitutional reform it is always associated with the territorial issue. But in reality, we have always talked about constitutional reform in a much broader sense. As the left, we are more interested in the debate about rights, freedoms. I also understand that there are people who have reservations about discussing all these things, but it is probably time for a mature society like ours, 40 years later, to have at the forefront a generation capable of reforming the Constitution, that is, not to approve a new one, because it is not necessary, but to reform the current one. There is a very beautiful idea behind the constitutional pact: it is a sort of social contract, an alliance between generations. I would like young people to feel this Constitution as their own. And that requires its reform.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of El País.