Intervention by the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, at the closing of the presentation of the study "The Cost of Child Poverty in Spain."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

6 March 2023 · Closing of the presentation of the study "The Cost of Child Poverty in Spain"

Context
Sánchez addressed the closing presentation of a study on the cost of child poverty in Spain, held on March 6, 2023, emphasizing government commitment to tackling inequality.
Main themes
Child poverty, economic cost of child poverty, social inequality, gender inequality, public policy intervention, labor market outcomes, health deterioration, lost talent and opportunity, government commitment to eradicating poverty, OECD research findings
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,025
76th percentile
Sentences
106
66th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
14.3
69th percentile
Syntax
3.40
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 56%56%
  • Economic 25%25%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

106 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Good morning everyone, First Vice President of the Government, Minister of Consumer Affairs, High Commissioner, Deputy Secretary-General of the OECD, friends.

It is often rightly said that inequality is the cradle of all inequalities. And this evidence is not only the expression of a terrible injustice, that the fate of a human being is predetermined by the place where they are born. But also because it challenges us when we think about the price to pay for not combating child poverty, which was something we were discussing just before entering the room. A reality present in too many homes, unfortunately, also in Spain. And therefore, this is the main objective of the study being presented today, to measure the cost of child poverty.

Allow me to first acknowledge, as it could not be otherwise, all the entities that have made this important academic work possible. To the High Commissioner, as the coordinating entity, to the La Caixa Foundation for supporting this research, and of course, also to the researchers from the universities of Alcalá and Pompeu Fabra, for measuring something that I believe we can all agree is difficult to measure, to quantify, what we lose as a society due to child poverty.

The conclusion is devastating, as you know. Child poverty costs more than 63 billion euros a year, that is, 5.1% of the annual Gross Domestic Product based on 2019 figures.

That is the cost of not eradicating child poverty. 63 billion euros a year. And it is calculated based on two magnitudes that I would like to share with all of you, just to emphasize it, because it caught my attention yesterday when I was reading the advance of the study.

The first is the labor performance of a person who has suffered from child poverty. Being poor in childhood or adolescence guarantees poorer professional performance and there is evidently more precariousness. This means, on average, that in adulthood one earns a lower salary of 5,100 euros gross per year.

And the difference is even greater, especially this week as we are celebrating real and effective equality between men and women as a cause that unites us all as a society, as I mentioned earlier, the difference is even greater in the case of girls, who are victims of this double discrimination for being women and for childhood marked by poverty.

Alongside this, the second magnitude is the deterioration of health, because there is an exponential increase in the risk of having poor health, suffering from overweight, or experiencing some type of mental illness, with the costs derived, of course, for our healthcare system in our country.

Therefore, no decent society can resign itself to this injustice. We must make it visible, that of child poverty, in every possible way. I believe this study puts black on white, also with figures, a reality that is absolutely a priority for our government and for society as a whole, such as child poverty, because no society should become accustomed to deprivation in childhood and that this should be a sort of condemnation to have fewer job opportunities in the future, to undermine health in adulthood.

Certainly, from the Government of Spain, I personally, as president, do not resign ourselves to something like this.

We do not accept that the only alternative is to wait for the market to repair this, if we can call it, infamy, because it will never happen. If there are no efficient public policies that address a morally unacceptable, socially unsustainable, and economically suicidal gap. Especially now, immersed in such a revolutionary transformation process in our economy as is, for example, digital transformation. And also, logically, the ecological transition that forces us not to waste a single gram of talent present in our society.

A few years ago, one of the world's leading newspapers, the New York Times, published a report titled "The Lost Einsteins," and what it did was cross-reference data on family income, academic performance, patent registration, and the study referred to in that article, scientifically and academically accredited, that a teenager from a poor family could not rely solely on academic excellence, that creativity, the authors of this report said, is distributed, but that opportunities, on the other hand, are not. Only the best students, who also came from high-income families, had a real opportunity to become inventors.

Therefore, combating inequality should be an absolute priority for any public institution, for any government, regardless of what their competencies may be, a municipal government, a provincial government, regional, state, or even European. I insist, not only for social justice but also for the interest of the country or for European interest.

And these reflections are more pertinent this week, on the eve of March 8, because from the question we can ask ourselves, with a disturbing answer, we can see what the challenge we have ahead is. The question is: What levels of human progress and innovation could we have achieved if half of the population had not been discriminated against for centuries? Some respond to this question by shrugging their shoulders, saying literally, as we have seen in the past, everything comes, let’s not get into that, they say, while they evidently trust in the virtues of that invisible hand of the market to correct those gaps, a correction that never arrives.

And fortunately, in these decades, Spain has had governments that have indeed tackled this. If in four decades we have multiplied by 14 the presence of women in the Council of Ministers, and by seven the number of female deputies in the General Courts, it is because there were governments, which if you allow me to also sweep for the space represented by the progressive coalition government, progressive governments that dared to break the inertia with courage. And we will continue to do so. Tomorrow, precisely in the Council of Ministers, we will take the first step towards the approval of a pioneering regulation in Europe, a law aimed at extending parity to all areas. And in this, we have already paved the way in political power, making Spain one of the main global references, and we will consolidate this with this law. But we want to take a step further and extend it to the private sector as well, promoting the presence of women in leadership positions in large companies, professional associations, or also in award committees that publicly recognize the excellence of the awardees.

In other words, if women are half of society, they must be half of political power and also of economic power. Some, evidently, will see this as excessive, but those of us who believe in feminism, I believe in feminism, see it simply as just. It is a matter of justice.

In short, in politics, as in life, what is not named, as I said before, does not exist. The gender gap exists, child poverty exists. We must name it. That is our obligation. Today we are doing it again to make it visible. But above all, we want to make it visible to correct it, because we come from a lost decade, with neoliberal recipes that raised this scourge to absolutely intolerable levels, above 30%. Often, when you talk to people outside of Spain and tell them that we have reached that 30% or that we have more than 2 million children suffering from some type of poverty, they are very surprised. But this is the reality of our country, which we must make visible, which we must correct so that misery does not become chronic in thousands of homes.

In these years, I believe we have acted with determination and there is still much to be done. We have done it in the midst of a very adverse situation, which you all know. First with the pandemic, later with the consequences of the war in Ukraine. And today empirical evidence shows that thanks to these measures, we have at least halted the increase in child poverty by 11 points, and that thanks to the social shield deployed, we have prevented nearly 1 million children and adolescents from falling into poverty.

And in this, I want to specify four major lines of action that we have been deploying in the midst of the pandemic and now in the midst of the war, because I believe they are public policies, not only committed, that act from a structural point of view on what represents child poverty, but also represent an innovation in public policies that I always like to emphasize whenever I refer to them.

First, I refer, as it could not be otherwise, to the minimum vital income. I remember that when we were, Vice President Nadia, negotiating the European funds, I found it particularly interesting that some conservative parties, in some parts of Europe, said that structural reforms had to be made linking structural reforms with the neoliberal reforms that were made during the financial crisis. And at a lunch I had with then Chancellor Merkel, where we were doing a tour with the countries that were a bit more reluctant to have the European funds, Chancellor Merkel herself told me that she had defended, before the German national parliament, the virtues of this structural reform that we had launched from the Government of Spain, which was the minimum vital income. Because one of the main recommendations that the European Commission had made to us for many years was how we could resolve this tangle of incomes, of social insertion, at the level of autonomous communities with different asymmetries also in the autonomous communities. And how we could address this structural reform that would truly provide a common response to a common problem we have in Spain. Well, I say this because that is how the minimum vital income emerged, which already protects more than 1.5 million people, half a million households, in these few years it has been in force. In two-thirds of which, there is always at least one minor, and more than 42% of these beneficiaries, which I would also like to share with all of you, are minors. Six out of ten recipients are women and therefore poverty in Spain has primarily a female face. And that is why we have also wanted to address, from the perspective of gender, the minimum vital income.

On many occasions, when we were designing this public policy, I told the ministers of the affected departments, of the most involved departments, that we had to focus the minimum vital income, if you allow me, more on child poverty, because that is really where we had to break that cycle that on many occasions, from the High Commissioner, and also from the reports that have been published, has been denounced as one of the main challenges, to break that cycle of poverty.

Along with the minimum vital income, undoubtedly, I believe that another of the elements that on many occasions, I see some of the interlocutors with whom I have had the opportunity to talk about child poverty, is the increase in child benefits. They had been frozen, it is said quickly, for many years, for 17 years, until 2019. Well, since that year, we have doubled their amount for minors in households with severe poverty. We have launched the childhood aid supplement, with 1,000 euros for children up to three years old, which already reaches 300,000 households.

And thirdly, with brave measures in the socio-labor field, such as, for example, the increase of the minimum interprofessional wage by 47% in five years. Let us remember that 60% of the recipients, of the beneficiaries, of the minimum interprofessional wage increase, are fundamentally women, and that it places us as the third country in the OECD that has increased the minimum interprofessional wage the most in recent years.

But alongside this, many other transversal policies explain this gender perspective that poverty has and that we also have to respond to from public policies, such as, not to go any further, the equalization of paternity and maternity leave to improve what is called co-responsibility, which is not the reconciliation of work, personal, and family life.

More than 1,700,000 women benefit from this last increase, as I mentioned earlier, of the minimum interprofessional wage, and many of them are single mothers. When we often talk about wage inequality, it fundamentally occurs among women who are mothers or who have some dependent family member in their immediate environment, which forces them, or ultimately leads them to reduce their working hours, or to effectively leave their jobs. Therefore, what we have to do is dignify, as you have heard me say many times, wages to combat labor poverty, to tackle the wage gap, but also to combat child poverty in households.

And finally, and I think it is also important to say this, it is fiscal justice, because there is no social justice without fiscal justice. And there is a lot of work to be done in this area, because in all the demographic studies, what is said is that the majority of citizens believe that those who have more do not contribute more effort to the public coffers, to the financing of the Welfare State.

Well, I believe that with a reduction in personal income tax that we have approved in this General State Budget that is now being implemented, it will benefit half of the workers.

The reductions we are also making in the VAT on gas, electricity, the thermal and electric social bonus, which are mentioned infrequently, but which are having a very important impact on vulnerable families and households. It is, ultimately, about having those who can pay more do so in order to protect those who need it most in this very, very difficult situation.

I believe that, with these measures, what we are doing is tackling material deprivation, the lack of resources. But we must obviously go much further to break this cycle of child poverty. And this is, and this is the final reflection I would like to make in the field of education. I believe this is the key. And it is a commitment that we must make sustained over time so that we can definitively reverse the origin of that child poverty.

This year, as you know, we reached an absolutely historic allocation in the scholarship policy. It is more than 2,500,000,000 euros to ensure that no young person has to sacrifice their education. We are talking about 1 million young students who will benefit from one of these scholarships, fundamentally, again, they are women students who make up the majority of those currently studying at universities, to cite one case. And obviously, I believe this leads me to an additional reflection, which I would like to share with all of you to conclude my speech.

We are losing if we accept that women, for example, are underrepresented in studies and in STEAM options, and therefore it is not tolerable that women represent barely 25% in university studies linked to STEAM disciplines, or when we are talking about vocational training, they represent only 10%. And I say this because I believe we should not resign ourselves. Of course, from the Government of Spain, we do not resign ourselves. We act decisively, but I believe this is a task that transcends public authorities and also calls on the private sector.

Because in the midst of digital transformation, doing nothing in this area is equivalent to sowing the seed of a new wage gap and a new gap in opportunities between men and women.

Many of these measures, ultimately, and with this I conclude, are framed within that action plan to implement the European Child Guarantee, which our High Commissioner for Child Poverty often refers to. A plan funded by Spain with 1,633,000,000 euros, that is, 66% more than planned and which doubles the minimum required by the community executive, by the European Commission. And if it represents anything, it is the commitment of our country to the European pillar of social rights and which is framed and to which we will give special relevance during the presidency of the European Council that we will assume in just a few months. Because after all, this represents the best Europe, which is the Europe that protects citizens, and above all, our youngest.

In short, we will continue to work with that aim, to protect people with more public policies, with the necessary resources to sustain them over time and make structural transformations, which is what our society deserves and needs, with more initiatives to eradicate an injustice, such as child poverty, which stigmatizes for life, which robs a child of the most beautiful right they have, which is childhood, the right to dream.

But we will also do it thanks, and this is the important part, to the studies that are being published with technical soundness, with academic soundness, because I believe that is ultimately what also allows us in public authorities to act effectively, not only with equity but with effectiveness. With the empirical evidence that Spain loses every time it closes its eyes, or pretends that child poverty or inequality are challenges that have been overcome, or that they obey an ideological confrontation. No, it is a real problem, it is a social problem, that we must make visible and that we must, consequently, act to correct.

Therefore, we not only do not resign ourselves, but we also fight against inequality and against child poverty as one of the most powerful engines that drive and explain the action of the progressive coalition government. Thus, the only thing the High Commissioner can do, and all those who have participated in this report, is to thank you, because you have given us more instruments, more tools so that we can continue this battle, which I believe is a battle that undoubtedly explains the political commitment of this government. And it is to end the most painful inequality, the one that hurts us the most, which is the inequality suffered by our children and our adolescents.

Thank you.