Intervention by the President of the Government at the presentation of the National Office for Scientific Advice (ONAC)

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

20 June 2024 · Presentation of the National Office for Scientific Advice (ONAC)

Context
Sánchez addressed the launch ceremony of Spain's National Office for Scientific Advice (ONAC) on June 20, 2024, celebrating the new institution's role in evidence-based governance.
Main themes
Science-policy relationship, National Office for Scientific Advice (ONAC) launch, scientific evidence in policymaking, Montreal Protocol and ozone layer recovery, role of science in human progress, environmental governance, industry resistance to regulation, international cooperation, progressive politics and science, Spain's scientific investment
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,134
77th percentile
Sentences
124
73rd percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
13.2
58th percentile
Syntax
3.18
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%58%
  • Environmental 9%8%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Technological 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Economic 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Not in focus 10%

124 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Minister, president, other university authorities and public research organizations.

I must acknowledge that for me this is probably one of the most exciting events as President of the Government. It is evident that it will not make the front pages of the media, but I believe we all feel that what we are starting today has a transformative power that, if consistent over time, will change our country for the better.

Therefore, I want to first thank the minister, Diana, and the president, Eloísa, for inviting me, for allowing me to share this exciting project with all of you, and for enjoying such an intelligent event, where we have shared the perspective of science, even mixing it with a bit of magic, and now it is time for the politician to also give their view on that necessary and complex relationship, as previously pointed out, between politics and science.

I will begin my speech with a brief reminder of an experience that I believe was very successful in scientific advice to politics. In the 1970s, back in the 20th century, scientists from all over the world began to publish reports warning of a drastic reduction in the amount of ozone in the atmosphere, and the empirical evidence was quite clear. It was compelling. It stated that there would be a reduction of more than 50% in a few decades, and it also pointed to CFCs as the main culprits of that drastic drop in the amount of ozone in the atmosphere. The situation was, as you may recall, particularly concerning in the South Pole, where researchers found a huge hole in the ozone layer that protects the Earth from solar radiation. The models predicted that if urgent measures were not taken then, hundreds of thousands of people would suffer from skin cancer, autoimmune diseases by the year 2000, and that by 2040, sectors as important as agriculture and the ecology of the oceans would collapse; without the ozone layer, ultraviolet rays would wipe out plankton, which is, as you know, the basis of marine life.

At that time, CFC gases, you will remember, were used practically for everything. They were an essential component for refrigerators, air conditioning machines, insecticides, aerosols, or even for inhalers themselves. And that is why, when scientists called for their prohibition, many in the industry opposed it. The large chemical companies, you will recall, argued that banning CFCs would cause an unprecedented economic collapse, that the loss of this industry would lead to the loss of millions of jobs, and they launched an aggressive campaign to pressure all governments, all politicians, and to discredit the scientists who demanded their prohibition.

But there were also some politicians who fortunately listened to science. And those policymakers responded to the scientific consensus and mobilized: they funded new studies, pushed for increasingly restrictive regulations, and in 1987, no less than 20 nations signed what was then called the Montreal Protocol, in which they committed to gradually banning the production of these CFCs.

Over time, what happened was that Spain and the rest of the countries in the world joined in, and the Montreal Protocol became the first international treaty signed by all member states of the United Nations. The industry did not collapse; it found more efficient, and by the way, less harmful alternatives; people did not lose their jobs, nor their health, and fortunately, their quality of life was not diminished. On the contrary. The concentration of CFCs in the atmosphere was reduced, and ozone levels began to recover. And today, nearly 40 years later, the hole in the ozone layer is practically closed, and humanity has been able to overcome a challenge that threatened nothing less than our very existence.

Well, I wanted to recall this story for two reasons. First, because it demonstrates that when we want to, I believe that human beings are capable of halting environmental degradation, no matter how systemic it may be. It is a matter of work, it is a matter of resources, it is also a matter of will. And, secondly, because I think it is a magnificent example of the key role that scientific advice can have in our society.

Look, I consider myself a progressive politician, and I consider myself a progressive politician because I believe in progress. It is because I am convinced that humanity can be better and move towards much more effective, much more equitable, much more sustainable forms of organization. It has done so in the past, and I know it will continue to do so in the future, thanks to two tools that I would like to share with you. First, the moral improvement of human beings, and second, science.

Science, that sum of errors that brings us closer to the truth. We owe almost everything to it. And I, in fact, also feel this event and this announcement of what we are going to launch starting today as a debt that Spanish society has owed to science, to scientists for a long time. Science has revealed our own nature, has shown us where we come from, has helped us along the way. Science has allowed us to double our life expectancy, also modify our environment, explore the cosmos, overcome pain, disease, achieve levels of abundance, security, and well-being paradoxically, in this time when there is so much unease, from the citizen's point of view, from the development point of view, isn't that so?

With what evidently all development our ancestors would not have dared to even dream. And science, without a doubt, has transformed the way we move, eat, heal, interact, and now it is time for it to also transform the way we govern, because we really need your help from politics.

Today, in these very fluid times in which political parties or 'influencers' who deny the usefulness of vaccines, the effectiveness of redistributive policies, the very existence of climate change proliferate, I believe that the contribution of science is more necessary than ever. To also look from politics at scientists. Opinions and intuitions are evidently important in politics. That is so. And also, believe me, it is so, but only when these opinions and intuitions are informed and based on empirical evidence. Because we face social, technological, environmental challenges, to name just a few, that are very complex, in which politics needs the contribution and advice of science. And we do so with brains, as has been said before by the neuroscientist, with brains full of biases, distortions. And to overcome them, we must take advantage of the vast scientific knowledge generated by our universities, our research centers; in a broad sense, including pure sciences, but also, and I think it is very important, as has been done here by other speakers, social sciences and human sciences.

The problem is that doing so is not easy, not even from politics. In recent years, it is evident that many governments, international organizations have created mechanisms for scientific advice to reinforce their decision-making processes. And yet, few countries have managed to establish stable, interdisciplinary, and truly effective formulas to bridge the gap that exists between science and the silos that, unfortunately, we also have in public administration, in ministerial departments, and that generate truly useful knowledge.

Consequently, for the Executive Power that I, temporarily, may represent. That is the objective we pursue. That is the objective that brings us together here today and for which, I repeat, I am very excited.

From the beginning, we were clear that our country, Spain, should be at the forefront of this movement. And so, what did we do? We established technical profiles in the Council of Ministers. Some of them have accompanied me here, have been with me: Joan Subirats, for example; or Pedro Duque; now Diana Morant.

That is why we have also created in the cabinet of the Presidency of the Government in La Moncloa a large team of doctors in economics, political science, environmental engineering, law, sociology… who play a key role in the decision-making we make, redundancy intended, from the Presidency of the Government every day. And that is why we also approved a transfer and innovation plan to strengthen exchanges between researchers and public institutions.

Today we are here to take another step in that good direction. I believe that this is a milestone; well, it makes me a bit shy to say it is historic, because so many things are happening… But it will indeed be a transformative milestone, or at least that is how we experience and feel it from the Executive Power.

Today we are launching our national scientific advisory ecosystem, an ecosystem that we have been designing for almost two years. We have thought a lot about this announcement that we are presenting today at this headquarters of the CSIC. We have been talking to many experts. We have also been comparing the experiences of other countries. It is never easy because the political system and the culture of a country are not the same as in others: we always look to the Anglo-Saxon world, although sometimes the Anglo-Saxon world does not give us great lessons either, also creating, or at least trying to create, innovative solutions that adapt to our social and institutional reality.

An ecosystem that we believe will be one of the most ambitious, and we aspire for it to be one of the most sophisticated in the world, and with which we hope, ultimately, to recover the lost time, which has been much, and to position ourselves as soon as possible among the group of countries that best link scientific knowledge with political decision-making.

There is no time to give all the details here at this event, but I would like to share with all of you its two guiding principles and its three basic commitments with some immediate announcement. The principles are simple, the principles are rigor and effectiveness. We do not want to create something just to say we have it, which, by the way, is quite typical in politics. We want that something to work and to work for real; to provide useful and solid knowledge to the General Administration of the State and also to the rest of the administrations and to give Spanish science a clear communication channel that it has not had until now, stable and also institutionalized with the Executive Power.

The chain that this mechanism needs creates a culture that will take years to consolidate. I think it is very important to say this as well: we must be consistent in what we are starting today, and that is why we must start as soon as possible. With three basic components, which is what I would like to share with you and with public opinion. The first and perhaps the most important, the people. If we want there to be more science in the Government, we need to have more scientists in public administration. It is that simple.

That is why I announce that in the coming months we will incorporate more than fifty scientific advisors into the General Administration of the State through various mechanisms.

On the one hand, what we are going to do is create the figure of the scientific advisor in the cabinet of each Ministry of the Government of Spain. An advisor who will be dedicated exclusively to connecting the questions that will arise from their ministry and the answers with universities and public research centers. Therefore, a scientific advisor in the cabinet of each ministry.

On the other hand, what we are going to do is launch a research stay program so that scientists can spend between six and eight months in the different ministries. And with this, what we will achieve, what I am convinced we will achieve, is to familiarize them with the functioning and needs of the administration, to help those scientists deal with specific challenges that belong to their field of expertise. I think this is something that has also been mentioned by some of the speakers and I find it very important.

It is as important for politics to know science as it is for science to know the functioning of public administrations, in this case, the executive power.

And we are also going to create a support unit for the scientific advice of the Government, which will be, dear president, here at the CSIC. It will be responsible for connecting the needs of the Executive with the talent and knowledge generated in our universities and also in our research centers.

And finally, what we are going to do is strengthen the National Office for Scientific Advice, which is in the Presidency of the Government of Spain. It will be responsible for coordinating, instructing, and supporting all these profiles, managing the entire ecosystem, and ensuring that the voice of Science is heard in an integral way, even at the highest level of government, obviously, in the Presidency of the Executive.

If we compare ourselves to others, the design we are presenting today to Spanish society, I believe that very few countries in the world have a scientific advisory network like the one we are about to deploy.

The calls for applications to access the positions of ministerial advisor and the Support Unit of the CSIC will be published today. And I would therefore like to encourage all those who are interested in generating a positive impact from their talent to apply for these calls. Because what we want is to have the best scientists, because we want the best policy for our country, for Spain.

The second component of our advisory ecosystem will be something that I have often discussed with the president of the CSIC, which is applied research, also with Minister Morán. Because we need to incentivize those studies that help us address the economic, social, and environmental challenges facing our country.

And that is why the announcement I would like to share with you is that today a call for proposals worth two million euros will also be published in the Official State Gazette to finance randomized experiments in public innovation and to initiate the exploitation of ministerial databases, with the aim of turning that rich raw information held by many public bodies of the General State Administration into academic knowledge, which in turn will serve to improve the design and implementation of our public policies.

And likewise, I also inform you that next month, in July, we will publish the draft Royal Decree that modifies the regime of quinquennials and sexennials for teaching and research staff. For what purpose? With the purpose of promoting and rewarding the work of transfer and also of applied research.

I believe that science - and you will agree with me on this - must help to solve people's problems as a priority. And we want to support that direction from the Executive.

The third and final component of our scientific advisory ecosystem will be the institutional mechanisms. If there is one thing I believe became evident, and Miguel also experienced it both during the lockdown and in the de-escalation that we designed thanks to his advice and scientific knowledge. If one thing became clear during the pandemic in Spain, and I would say also in the rest of the world, especially in the Western world, it is that we still did not have well-defined procedures to mobilize the opinions of experts, especially in crisis contexts. Organizations, governments, had to create a lot on the fly. And what we are going to do now is design clear institutional protocols that establish how scientific advice is gathered; what methodological principles, but also ethical ones, must be followed; how that exercise is financed and what is done with the recommendations generated. The goal is that the next time there is an emergency, and hopefully it will be many years from now, public administrations will have well-defined mechanisms to quickly and rigorously identify and consult experts.

These are the main components, ladies and gentlemen, that the scientific advisory ecosystem we are launching today will have. First-rate scientists, more applied research, and more institutional channels.

We live in a moment when our societies have to decide what kind of leadership we want for the future of our societies. Some are betting, as we are seeing in some other continents and not so far from our country, to return to those so-called strong men and women, leaders who mobilize the masses with simplistic diagnoses of reality and impossible promises that are often completely alien to and contrary to scientific evidence. And I do not want that for my country, I do not want it. I want Spain to illuminate its steps with the flame of knowledge, to turn the scientific principles of rigor and experimentation into the pillars of its government. I want our future to be in the hands of people who understand that there is nothing, no problem, no public debate that is simple, because they are all filled with great complexity.

It is evident - and Miguel pointed this out in his speech - that science should not decide, cannot decide because it does not have a single voice and because the sovereignty of the people does not reside in it, but in the institutions and in the representatives elected democratically by the vote of the citizens. But that does not mean that those same institutions do not have the moral obligation, the practical need to listen to science and to rely on science as much as possible. Because a democracy that rests on science is a more effective democracy, therefore, more robust, and I would say that this is what matters most to me, more equitable.

The advisory ecosystem that we are launching today is born to facilitate that work, to equip our country with that scientific culture and the necessary institutional mechanisms to face the challenges of this century.

I ask all Spanish scientists not to settle for being mere spectators. I am convinced that this is not the case, but I feel obliged to say it. We need them to lend a hand, to contribute their knowledge and passion to help us make Spain a better country.

As I said at the beginning of my speech, this event will not make the evening news, nor will it, of course, make any newspaper tomorrow, but believe me when I say that as we feel it from the Executive Power and from the Presidency of the Government of Spain, today we are taking one of the most transformative steps for our society in the short, medium, and long term. I feel it that way. I ask you to feel it that way too.

Nothing more. And thank you very much.