Press conference of the President of the Government after the extraordinary European Council.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

21 February 2020 · Extraordinary European Council (press conference after)

Context
Sánchez held a press conference on February 21, 2020, following an extraordinary European Council meeting focused on the EU's multiannual financial framework negotiations.
Main themes
EU multiannual financial framework, Spain's national interests in Europe, cohesion policy, common agricultural policy, Brexit impact on EU budget, European Council negotiations, decarbonization and environmental policy, EU budget volume disputes, member state contributions
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,382
88th percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
13.0
56th percentile
Syntax
3.19
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

166 sentences in 45 paragraphs

If you agree, I will make a brief statement regarding this day and a half we have had at the European Council, and then you can ask me any questions you deem appropriate.

Spain has come to this Council with the awareness that the debate that has been initiated regarding the multiannual financial framework, that is, the budgets for the next five years of the European Union, is a complex debate and negotiation. It is complex, firstly, because reconciling the interests of 27 member countries and also trying to promote the European project in community policies is, in itself, a complex matter. But if, in addition to that, we have to factor in that there is a net contributor leaving the European Union, in this case the United Kingdom, then logically the difficulty and complexity of the negotiation multiplies exponentially.

Therefore, over the past weeks, what we have done is negotiate at a technical level, at the COREPER level, at the level of the various ministries involved, to whom I want to express my gratitude for the work you have been doing during these intense weeks, with a constructive attitude, being aware of what the principles and objectives were that we, as Spain, wanted to present to our European partners and also to the main community institutions.

What we want is to defend Spain's interests in a strong Europe. This would be a bit of a summary, the synthesis of what the primary objective of the Government of Spain is. To defend Spain's interests in a strong Europe.

Well, being aware of that complexity of the negotiation, what we have found, as I mentioned in the brief statement before the European Council, is that the proposal that had been put on the table, the third proposal that had been put on the table, because we must remember that there is a first proposal from the European Commission, then there is a second proposal, a third proposal, which is from the current President of the European Council, and throughout today, we have also had a sort of draft from the two main institutions based on different exercises that have been carried out regarding the various alternatives that have been given to the different member states.

Well, what have we seen? Well, what I told you in that brief statement, that the proposal for Spain was disappointing. And it was disappointing, firstly, in terms of volume, of the budget as a whole. Note that the European Parliament proposes 1.3% of the European gross national income. The European Commission proposed 1.114% of the European Gross National Income. The proposal put forward by the President of the Council represented around 1.074%, if my memory serves me correctly. And therefore, what we have seen has been a gradual reduction by the different leaders of each of the proposals, in relation to the total amount of the multiannual financial framework. Of course, it is true that we have to do things much better; we have always defended that things can be done much better. They are done well, but they can be done better. Without a doubt, what we cannot do is many things and also with fewer economic resources.

Therefore, we have always defended that we had to listen to the European Parliament, that we also had to look at the figures from the European Commission because, after all, the European Commission knows well what the programs are, what the needs of each of those policies are, and consequently, we understood that the proposal to negotiate should start from the basis of those two, let’s say, proposals for the volume of resources that had been put forward by both the European Parliament and the European Commission.

Therefore, one, we were not satisfied and considered it disappointing as a consequence of that dimension of the total volume of the multiannual financial framework, but secondly, we also considered it disappointing because we understood that a rather misleading and deceptive distinction was being made about what good policies and bad policies represent in the European Union, almost as if the good is the new and the old is the bad. And we believed and believe that policies such as cohesion policy, the common agricultural policy, are policies close to citizens, policies that strengthen the European single market, which is one of the main assets that the European Union currently has, and that consequently, any reduction that could be made to these two fundamental policies would be detrimental to the functioning of our European common market.

Not only that, but also if we want to achieve complete decarbonization by the year 2050 of our economy, the European economy, it is evident that we need to incorporate those environmental criteria into such important policies as the Common Agricultural Policy.

Therefore, from the point of view of the traditional policies that have been cut and even somewhat stigmatized, it seemed to us a profound error.

And alongside that, logically, that reduction of the pie, of the size of the pie, meant that very important policies also for the Government of Spain, but also for other governments, such as youth guarantee, child guarantee, which has disappeared, or issues like Erasmus and many other programs so important for building Europe from the citizen's perspective, were logically affected.

Finally, there was another issue that made us classify the proposal as disappointing. And that is that the system of rebates was maintained, a regressive rebate system that benefits mainly the wealthiest countries and that made sense when the United Kingdom was a member of the European Union. But once the United Kingdom is no longer among the members of the European Union, we logically considered, and that has been the proposal that the Government of Spain has always put forward, that we had to review if not eliminate those rebates.

And alongside that, logically, the debate on own resources, that eternal debate that the European Union always has, but which today is more necessary than ever, because there is evidently a need to increase resources and that those resources are also own. And there are also many proposals on the table. For example, we have proposed the creation of a carbon border tax, which among other things would greatly benefit industry on our continent against other large economic blocs that are proposing protectionist policies to the detriment of European industry. All these debates, practically in this day and a half, which is the first council we have had on the multiannual financial framework in earnest, in detail, have not seen any progress, and therefore, logically, we cannot be satisfied with the results of the negotiations and the dialogues that have been opened between the different member states and also with the different community institutions. So this is the result, a result that I would say is insufficient, disappointing, and we hope that in the coming weeks we can meet again with a much more ambitious proposal, which is what Spain needs and what Europe demands. Certainly, our position has always been constructive and with the objective I mentioned earlier. What we want is to defend Spain's interests in a strong Europe, because we also understand that both things go hand in hand. If we have a strong Europe, then Spain will be strong and vice versa. So I am now at your disposal to answer your questions.

Q: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Throughout this debate, four countries, the so-called frugal countries, have played a major role and have somehow set the agenda for the discussions, which has given them, in my view at least, an influence far beyond what their weight in the European Union would correspond to. Do you not think that from the cohesion countries that you lead, there should have been a more forceful reaction in leading this agenda and not leaving it in the hands of those who are precisely against your interests?

President: Well, actually, Jaume, what does it matter if there are 4, 1, 2, 3, 17? I mean, in the end, the multiannual financial framework has to be approved by all 27 member states. If there is one that is against it, it will not be approved, so it is not so much about talking about blocks of countries, whether they are 3, 4, or 17, it is simply being aware that first, what budgetary approach do we take? During these last months, after the appointment of the main heads of the institutions, we agreed in Parliament, we also agreed in the Council, we also agreed with the European Commission on a strategic agenda for the five years of action of the main community institutions. There, we talked about climate change, the digitalization of small and medium-sized enterprises, education, the common agricultural policy, the cohesion fund, foreign policy, defense policy, immigration policy, and so on. Of course, we then have to translate that into numbers, and those numbers are not logically aligning with those ambitious overarching goals that the three main institutions have agreed upon. Moreover, the four main groups of the European Parliament have sent a letter to the Council reminding that strategic agenda and, secondly, urging that we be more ambitious in the budgetary proposal that has been put on the table. Therefore, it is not that there is a group of countries or another; it is that right now in this type of debate, the multiannual financial framework at the council level, any country, no matter how small or large, if there is one, it blocks the entire debate and all approval. Therefore, I think it is important that we are aware of the magnitude of the debate we have, the complexity, that we are generous, and that together in the coming weeks we find a path that balances the national interests of all countries with the interests of the European Union.

Q: Given that all these proposals you have mentioned from the Commission and the Parliament have gone down and that the only proposal that has been put on the table with figures by the institutions today is also in that line that you have considered unacceptable from the beginning. Should we think that the result in the future will have a ceiling that will not go much beyond and a diversion of funds that may make Spain more comfortable with the CAP and cohesion, or do you really have hopes among this group of cohesion friends of ambition that the ceiling can be increased? And related to President Michel, he has said that there is no specific date and that he has to make informal consultations for the next time you are going to meet. Are you concerned that this delay, these clashes that are already being seen, could cause negotiations like those of Brexit to become stuck and contaminated?

President: I would not mix both things. They are two completely different debates. Here we are talking about policies and what budgetary support those policies have. They can perfectly go in parallel; they must go in parallel. In fact, they are already happening in parallel because we are negotiating with the United Kingdom at the community level, and therefore I believe that one thing does not preclude the other. I insist, they are two different negotiations. And it does not matter, because there is also the migration policy, which we will have to talk about. We also have to talk about the enlargement policy towards the countries of the Balkans. What I want to say with this is that it does not matter, because any debate we have right now at the European level is of sufficient magnitude not to be opposed to the necessary debate on community budgets. From there, I insist, I think it is important that we demonstrate ambition, that we demonstrate ambition. It cannot be that we propose a roadmap that then does not have a numerical and budgetary translation. The European Commission proposed 1.114%. The European Parliament proposed 1.3%. You cannot propose 1% as a proposal to launch all those necessary policies if we want to be, first, a relevant and reference global actor. And secondly, to respond to the urgencies we have as a Union, from a social point of view, from a sectoral point of view, such as agriculture, or from the point of view of cohesion.

Here is a rather interesting graph because it is a graph from the European Commission itself, data from the European Commission itself about who the winners are, those who benefit the most from the proper functioning of the single market. And in this graph, what we see is that precisely those countries that contribute the most benefit the most from the functioning of the single market. Cohesion policies, policies like the Common Agricultural Policy, what they do is precisely strengthen the single market and therefore the debate about who contributes more or who receives more from the community budgets is an incomplete debate. It is an incomplete debate. It is not a debate that truly reflects the depth of the consequences of having a better or worse budget, for example, in such a fundamental, such a transcendental aspect for our Union as the single market. This is something we have conveyed to those countries that are net contributors who are currently not very receptive to increasing their participation in the community budgets, but I insist that we not only have to talk about those, we have to talk about the own resources at the community level. We also have to talk about the, let’s say, necessity or not of having checks afterwards and once the United Kingdom has left the European Union. Does it make sense to maintain such regressive systems for the European Union? We have a position, there are other countries that have another, and now I believe that politics needs to find a landing strip so that we can achieve the fundamental objective, which is to have a budget as soon as possible.

Q: Good, Mr. President, then how do you think, I wanted to ask you two questions, one more technical, how do you think it is possible to combine the two things, maintaining the volumes of cohesion policy and agricultural policy, knowing that the budget is going to be smaller and that the European Union cannot go into debt? That is to say, if you pull the blanket from one side, the other side is uncovered.

And the other question is a bit more personal. I would like to know if you have any kind of intellectual or moral discomfort listening to all these accusations that are constantly made about whether you tell the truth or whether you lied when you wrote your thesis or not.

President: No, I have no discomfort. I am already used to this type of debate. And regarding the first point, Enrique, I truly believe that what I said at the beginning seems key to me. What we cannot do is convey from a political point of view at the institutional level that the Common Agricultural Policy or cohesion policy are policies that do not work, they are old policies that no longer have a foundation. I believe that there are traditional policies that precisely underpin the success of the European Union, which are very close to citizens, not only to sectors like, for example, the agricultural sector in our country that is manifesting as a consequence of falling prices, as a consequence of unilateral actions taken by the United States regarding tariffs or also as a consequence of the depopulation that is being suffered in those territories. Or even also the need to modernize their agricultural productions to be able to meet the environmental criteria that are being imposed or demanded, or rather, by the community institutions, to address climate change. All of that, logically, needs economic resources. Therefore, is there room for maneuver to improve the total volume of the budgets of the financial framework? Without a doubt, there is.

Are there also capacities for the European Union to increase its own resources? Without a doubt, there are. And of course, there are also margins for the Common Agricultural Policy and cohesion policy to have unfair funding. Here we are talking about justice, we are talking about cohesion. There is nothing fairer than cohesion, and cohesion is equality, guaranteeing the opportunity to live wherever one lives. And that seems to me that in countries as important as, for example, Spain in the European context, it must be taken into account. But not only Spain, there is Poland and there is Italy. There are small countries like Slovenia or large countries like Spain and Italy. Therefore, I believe that, well, we must be patient, this is a complex negotiation but we will certainly go with the best of spirits. What I do tell you is that the Government of Spain wants to defend Spain's interests, and defending Spain's interests means building a stronger Europe. And in that, we will logically devote all our efforts.

Q: With what budget volume would Spain feel comfortable in the next proposal and, within this volume, could you give us an approximate figure for the cuts in agriculture and cohesion? Remember well that any country can block the agreement, as unanimity is required.

To what extent would Spain be willing to block this agreement? And I would like to know if you have any clues about when they might meet again to agree on the budgets.

President: I don’t know when we will meet again. I imagine we will start informal contacts with the presidency of the Council, with, well, but here is the ambassador, the Secretary of State for the EU, the finance technicians, we will see in the coming days.

And regarding the first point: the larger the volume, the better. Much better. And if we even get close to the proposal of the European Parliament, all the better. And if we get close to the proposal of the European Commission, then also.

One of the things we did say is that proposals that simply reduce and reduce and reduce the size of the pie, in colloquial terms, so to speak, will hinder an equitable and fair distribution of important policies for Spain such as cohesion or the CAP.

What is important is, as I said before, to go with a constructive spirit.

Q: Thank you, Mr. President. I wanted to ask you about that coronavirus case we learned about today in northern Italy. I wanted to know if you are concerned that the increase in infections could affect nearby countries like Spain and if you have been able to discuss it with the Italian Prime Minister. Thank you.

President: Yes, I have spoken with the Italian Prime Minister, but, well, I think that fortunately we have an extraordinary public health system in Spain that is doing a basic job, which is to control, from a scientific point of view, this disease, and also from a communication point of view, conveying guarantees, certainties, and tranquility to the Spanish public opinion.

Q: Yes, Mr. President, after all these hours we have been talking mainly about cuts, I wanted to ask you in general if you believe that the EU, after Brexit, is clearly going backwards.

I also wanted to ask you about the agricultural sector, you have said it is on fire. Today there have been new incidents. Do you think the agricultural sector could withstand a strong cut in the CAP? Do you think it would be a definitive blow to the tension that is being experienced?

And finally, a key week begins, the dialogue table meeting, the spending ceiling is voted on Thursday... do you think this week your majority will come out strengthened or weakened and will we be closer or further from having budgets?

President: Well, regarding Brexit, I have always seen that Brexit, well, I never bet on Brexit. In fact, I have made many statements saying that this is indeed a collective misfortune because the European Union will not be the same without the United Kingdom. The United Kingdom and the contribution it has always made to the history of our common project is, I would say, essential. And therefore now we are in a different phase, which is how we relate once divorced. That will also have its implications.

But well, given that things are as they are, I believe that Brexit can also be a new impetus for the European Union. That is to say, there have been many issues that we have had to set aside as a consequence of having to dedicate many European Councils to talk about Brexit, now about the withdrawal agreement, etc.

So, I think it can be precisely something that spurs integration and the strength of the European Union. But for that, we need, evidently, not only to make good roadmaps, exciting and hopeful roadmaps, but that then do not find a budgetary support that gives credibility to those things that we approve in the three institutions.

Regarding the Common Agricultural Policy, we have said it many times, Carlos. The agricultural sector in Spain does not have a single problem. When one talks, and through the media, you have also been able to report it, farmers do not only talk about the Common Agricultural Policy. They talk above all about price policy and, consequently, about transparency, about the profit margins that large distributors have, about depopulation, about the lack of young people taking charge of those agricultural holdings, about the levels of competitiveness that certain structures in the agricultural sector may have...

In short, we are talking about a problem that has many perspectives. Or a challenge more than a problem. A challenge because the agricultural sector is never a problem, it is a very, very positive reality for our country that we must care for from all public institutions.

This government, the Minister of Agriculture said it in the press conference of the Council of Ministers, this is the minister who is dedicated, he said, Luis Planas, he is the minister of agriculture and livestock in our country. And he has demonstrated it. He has demonstrated it in the dialogue with all sectors and we are going to demonstrate it starting already after having spoken with all sectors next Tuesday by approving a royal decree law that will begin to incorporate solutions from the point of view of transparency and price control in the food chain through a royal decree law.

But it will be the first of many things that we are going to implement once we have spoken with the sector during this last month. But, evidently, the Common Agricultural Policy, of course, is an important issue, it is for the sector but it is also for Spain. And, of course, we are defending the interests of the sector because the interests of the sector are the interests of Spain.

And regarding the issues we have ahead next week, I believe that what is important is that dialogue paves the way. And that dialogue paves the way despite those who do not believe in dialogue or who obstruct dialogue. Moreover, I am convinced that as that dialogue takes place, and agreements are reached, those same agreements will open the door to new agreements. That is why I said a few days ago when we talked about the bilateral commission that what was important was to start dialoguing and trying to find agreements on those issues where we can feel closer, not further apart. Because I am convinced that that dynamic of reaching agreements will open the doors to new agreements.

It is true that we have very distant positions, that it will be a complex dialogue that will not yield immediate results. But I think it is good news that all the citizens of our country want us to resolve conflicts through dialogue that have been built over the last ten years precisely due to the lack of dialogue, and that have brought us to a balance of absolute, regrettable failure, with a territorial crisis that has not been experienced in our country during the last 40 years and with consequences from all points of view that you see reflected in the media, as could not be otherwise.

What do we believe? Well, that we need to set in motion an agenda for reconnection. That this agenda for reconnection represents an opportunity for dialogue and for reconnection. We put on the table 44 measures, 44 proposals, by the way, 44 proposals that stemmed from many of the issues that the independence movement itself has raised to the Government of Spain over the last ten years without finding a response.

There are evidently some very difficult issues to resolve, but there are others where I am convinced we can start moving forward. That is what the Government of Spain is going to do and besides that, I said it in the control session. There are four years ahead, four years ahead. In those four years ahead, the Government of Spain wants to normalize both institutional life and budgetary life in our country and have budgets. Having an institutional life as rational and normalized as possible, I think is necessary after all these seven years of disorder that the previous administration has left us, and to that we are going to dedicate our efforts. In that sense, I have always extended my hand to the opposition. I have understood that the opposition logically has to do two things: one, oppose the Government in its political action, but there is also another issue that has to do with the renewal of institutional positions, of governing bodies that are stipulated in the Constitution, which need a parliamentary majority of two-thirds, and therefore the participation of the opposition is unavoidable.

And in that sense, what I have asked the main opposition party is to oppose as much as they want, but not to block the proper functioning of democratic institutions that are so important for our country. If they remain in blocking and opposition, then it will be a bit long for them to spend four years opposing and blocking.