Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

12 February 2020 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Sánchez responded to parliamentary questions from PP leader Casado and Vox leader Abascal during a Spanish Congress control session on February 12, 2020.
Main themes
Catalan independence crisis, rule of law and constitutionalism, dialogue vs. confrontation, opposition strategy, Venezuela diplomatic incident, territorial dialogue, Popular Party criticism, democratic institutions, political coexistence
Duration
~18 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,208
62nd percentile
Sentences
106
66th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%32%
  • Geopolitical 26%24%
  • Social 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 19%18%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

106 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Mr. Sánchez, we have already seen that for you the severity of a coup against the state depends on what you need from the coup plotters, but you are already overstepping the limits, even the lax ones you usually have. It cannot be said in Spain that the law is not enough, because where the law is not enough, democracy bends its... Because when the law says that you are not enough, what happens is that you are in a political system, in which as a democracy you may agree or disagree with that law, but you can never disobey it.

Remember what Kennedy said in another situation of insurrection: "If it were to reach the point where anyone by force or threat could challenge the commandments of Justice and the Constitution, no law would be free of doubt, no judge would be secure in his mandate, and no citizen would be safe even from their deviations." You, no matter how much you look in the mirror, are not Kennedy. But at the same time, you are not following in Maduro's footsteps, returning to respect for institutions and the rule of law.

Mr. Sánchez, comply with the law, and enforce it, which is not too much to ask in a democracy. Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President.

Mr. Casado, I understood that after two general elections last year, and having lost five elections in a year, you would change, at least, the opposition strategy, but I see that you continue stubbornly with the strategy of opposition based on tension and confrontation. Look back, Mr. Casado.

You talk about the territorial issue. Look back. See what has happened during these last seven years of the Popular Party's administration: two illegal referendums, Mr. Casado; a Unilateral Declaration of Independence, imprisoned politicians, and many others in exile; the balance is lamentable. No one has won, Mr. Casado. No one has won. Democracy has lost, and politics has lost. We are facing a collective failure, unfortunately, led by a Popular Party administration over these last seven years. Therefore, Mr. Casado, we only have two options, two alternatives to resolve this issue, as well as many others we have ahead: The first is to continue with confrontation, with tension, and with conflict, which has led us to the greatest social and coexistence fracture in Catalonia and throughout the country. Or two: give an opportunity to reconnection, dialogue, and agreement, Mr. Casado. I invite you to join the dialogue and agreement, Mr. Casado. Because territorial dialogue is as important as dialogue between the Government and the opposition. We have many things we can work on together. We can talk about Catalonia. We can dialogue about the Toledo Pact. We can dialogue and agree on a new renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary. We can talk about regional financing. Mr. Casado, make a state opposition. Do not be the echo of the far-right. Be the echo and the voice of those millions of Spaniards who voted for a moderate option of the Popular Party. Mr. Casado, make a useful opposition, loyal to Spain and to the Spaniards. The question you will have to answer during these four years of legislature is where you and the Popular Party will position yourselves, in confrontation, in dialogue, in tension, or in agreement. If you are willing to be brave, not to be dragged by those who want to lead you to an extremist drift, and what you want is to dialogue and meet to resolve many of the problems we have ahead as a society, I extend my hand to you in this legislature.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Deputy Mr. Santiago Abascal Conde, from the Vox parliamentary group.

Mr. Abascal.- Good morning. Mr. Sánchez, did the Minister of Transport, Mr. Ábalos, meet at Barajas airport with the vice president of the narco-government of Venezuela allowing her entry into Spain, while at the same time preventing her arrest by express instructions from the President of the Government?

President.- Mr. Abascal, Honorable Members, Mr. Ábalos did his duty, which was to prevent a diplomatic crisis with his intervention.

Mr. Abascal.- Mr. Sánchez, you have shown such a lack of scruples and such a lack of remorse when lying that, when I was coming here thinking I had to ask you a question, I didn’t know if I was committing an act of political innocence. Because you have lied to socialist voters committing a gigantic fraud regarding the pacts you were going to have after the elections, why wouldn’t you lie now to the fascists of Vox and, in passing, to all Spaniards? This is very easy, Mr. Sánchez, a Spanish minister who has already given a thousand versions and will probably give some more, goes to Barajas Airport at dawn to receive the minister of a narco-dictatorship and prevents her from being arrested, on Spanish soil, in the VIP room, by the way, of an illegal government, that of Venezuela, which has led to Juan Guaidó and his wife being beaten upon their arrival in Caracas yesterday.

What has happened in Madrid is very simple, Mr. Sánchez, if you gave the order, resign. If the order was given by your vice president, who is Maduro's delegate, both should resign. And if Mr. Ábalos acted on his own, it’s better that he leaves. If the order was given to all of you by Maduro, you can all leave together.

But, in any case, it is also an act of innocence, if not of political virginity, to think that you are going to assume any kind of responsibility.

You have arrived at that blue bench walking and riding on the fraud and the lies to the Spaniards: illegitimately, because it is still not illegal to lie to the Spaniards. And, therefore, everything is in order: from an illegitimate government to an illegal government of Venezuela. From an illegitimate government to meeting with the illegal and disqualified president of an Autonomous Community. And that is why you will leave here today - you have already hinted at it in the response you gave to Mr. Casado - willing to delegitimize four million Spaniards whom you want to turn into hate criminals to hide that you are in bed with communists, separatists, and pro-terrorists.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President.

Well, I know that the word of the President of the Government means nothing to you. I will remind you what Mr. Guaidó said, Mr. Abascal, I will remind you what Mr. Guaidó said to see if we can all agree. Mr. Guaidó said, precisely: "We have the best relations with Spain. Spain is an ally of democracy, of freedom, and I hope and I am sure that it will remain that way. And we will continue to insist on working with everyone." That is to say, Mr. Abascal, it is quite clear what the position is, in this case, of the opposition leader in Venezuela.

So, why do you bring this issue here? Well, you care about Venezuela as much as you care about Spain; that is, nothing. What you do is use Spain and Venezuela to do the only thing you know how to do, which is make noise. Noise, Mr. Abascal.

Look, Honorable Members, the truth is that the far-right even moves us. Because, of course, they pretend to be friends of Venezuela, I understand then that you also pretend to be friends of Venezuelans, but here you stigmatize immigrants and say they are the main cause of all the ills of the Spanish population. You claim to be patriots and what you do is run after and practice parallel diplomacy, like, for example, with some groups in Bolivia that only stigmatize the action and democracy of the country you aspire to represent.

You say, Mr. Abascal, that you are a political party defending Spain, of course, but financed with Iranian money. You will have to give many explanations, Mr. Abascal. Mr. Abascal, the interest of the Government of Spain is authentic, it is for reconnection and for democracy and reconciliation in Venezuela. The interest that your group has in Venezuela or the supposedly love you profess for Spain is as false as the visas of Ms. Monasterio.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Deputy Mr. Gabriel Rufián Romero, from the Republican Parliamentary Group.

Mr. Rufián.- Thank you very much, Madam President. Good morning, Mr. President, what actions does your Government plan to take to curb the rise of fascism? Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Madam President.

Mr. Rufián, we have placed Democratic Memory, Honorable Members, at the level of state policy. Yesterday the vice president said it in her first appearance in the Senate. I believe that Democratic Memory must be a state policy, it has to be a transversal policy. It is a policy, moreover, in which we must claim not only the contribution of those who were murdered during the Franco dictatorship to the democracy that today, let’s say, shelters us. And, undoubtedly, also the recognition of this Government, and I am also convinced of the majority of this Chamber, to the families of those who are still searching for the remains of their loved ones in many ditches in our country. Certainly, the Government of Spain will address economic resources to achieve the exhumation of the remains of those loved ones. Over these last months we have done many things in favor of Democratic Memory. We will do others throughout the legislature. For example, we will modify and update the Historical Memory Law, precisely because we have found during these last years of application that there are some gaps that we need to correct.

Evidently, it has been raised in the Congress of Deputies, and, in particular, in the Table Clarifications about a file, in particular, in this case, of the famous 'Billy the Kid'. Certainly, the Government of Spain wants the greatest transparency. The greatest reparations of memory and justice for the victims of Francoism. And, in that sense, Mr. Rufián, we will also make modifications to the Democratic Memory Law to end the recognitions that, unjustly, have also been given to people linked to Francoism who tortured human beings in our country.

And finally, in relation also to one of the issues that is important for Esquerra Republicana, which is the trial of Lluis Companys, I must remind you, also, that at the Council of Ministers we held in Barcelona last year, one of the issues we also raised was precisely the declaration and recognition of the figure of Lluis Companys and to denounce the trial to which he was subjected.

I understand that you also have some issues to raise in the Democratic Memory Law, let’s talk about it, and let’s talk about it, I am convinced that the joint work we can do will be to the benefit of that democratic memory that represents both of our political families, many others that are present here, but above all, in strengthening Spanish democracy.

Mr. Rufián.- Thank you very much, Madam President.

There are things that, evidently, sound very good from what you say. We expect the best from this Government. We will continue the legacy of the immense Joan Tarda. You will have us as guardians of that Law, future Democratic Law or Historical Memory Law.

I believe there are many types of fascism, we could basically identify three. One terribly dangerous for obvious reasons, the one that murdered Enrique Ruano, Sonia Rescalvo, Guillem Agulló, Aitor Zabaleta, Carlos Palomino, that one, for obvious reasons, is terribly dangerous. Another is the ridiculous one, the one we have present, the one that is very close, even physically, that denies rights, that records itself with its rifles in shooting ranges. And, another, which is the worst of all, which is the one in a tie, the one in a gown, and the one in uniform, which shelters the other two.

I urge you, as I did more than a year ago, to let the left be left, once and for all. Because it is the best antidote to these people. And, above all, to bring to this Chamber a Historical Memory Law that basically dignifies the memory of 120,000 people still in ditches, 80 years later, to the shame of many. Two: annul sentences from murderous fascist and Francoist courts. And, three, eliminate, once and for all, a fascist Mausoleum in the capital of the Kingdom called Valle de los Caídos.

But I do ask you to start with two things, which I believe you have half-announced, but I ask you to specify. One, to withdraw once and for all the medals from a recognized fascist torturer, Francoist like Antonio González Pacheco, 'alias' 'Billy the Kid' for its symbolic weight. Then many others will come. And, two, it is evidently very important for all Catalan republicanism, that once and for all the memory of the only democratically elected president, murdered with impunity by fascism in Europe, like our president, President Lluis Companys, is dignified. These are ideas...