Press conference of the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, alongside the Prime Minister of Slovenia, Robert Golob.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

17 February 2023 · Joint press conference with the Prime Minister of Slovenia

Context
Sánchez held a joint press conference with Slovenian Prime Minister Robert Golob in Ljubljana on February 17, 2023, following bilateral talks ahead of Spain's EU Council Presidency.
Main themes
Spain-Slovenia bilateral relations, Spanish EU Council Presidency, European energy market reform, open strategic autonomy, EU external partnerships, Mediterranean cooperation, Ukraine war and energy vulnerability, Erasmus student exchanges, NATO, semiconductor and microchip industry, Barcelona process
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,339
88th percentile
Sentences
196
89th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

196 sentences in 79 paragraphs

Thank you very much, Mr. Prime Minister. And thank you, dear Robert, for your hospitality.

The truth is that the Prime Minister has said it before. I believe that Spain and Slovenia still have a huge amount of room for improvement in cooperation, both economically and in terms of commercial investments. And as always, it is the young people who are ahead, because there are many Slovenian students who go to Spain to study and to spend their university Erasmus. And Spain is the largest nationality of students in Slovenia, studying and participating in university courses in this wonderful country, which I believe allows us to elevate our bilateral relations to a new level.

And that is why we applaud and support the idea proposed by the Prime Minister to systematically hold bilateral summits between our two countries, and we will implement it as soon as possible.

I believe that within the European context, being able to weave and forge those bilateral relations between different countries, perhaps geographically distant, but united by the Mediterranean, is undoubtedly fundamental.

It is true that both Slovenia and Spain are part of very important organizations. NATO is undoubtedly one of them, especially since the beginning of Putin's war in Ukraine almost a year ago. The European Union is one, and so is the Med-9, that is, the club of Mediterranean countries that are part of the European Union. I have always believed that a Mediterranean approach to European construction and European solutions always benefits Europe.

And this is something that is very much in line with the solutions to the problems and challenges that Europe faces, as presented by the Slovenian Prime Minister and myself, in many of the forums and European councils we have held over these months. I want to acknowledge the leadership that both Slovenia and Spain have had in everything related to the energy crisis. I believe we have been two countries that have positioned ourselves at the forefront in finding European solutions to a problem that is affecting the Slovenian population, the Spanish population, but also the entire European citizenry.

In that sense, I believe that one of the main proposals or agreements, we could say, between the government of Slovenia and the government of Spain in this meeting we have just held, is to continue promoting the necessary reform of the electricity market in Europe, a structural reform that goes much further than the one-off aid we can provide to families, businesses, and industry to cope with this explosion in energy prices, and that we truly enter into a structural reform that protects our families structurally, also our economy, and makes us more competitive. And that will be the fundamental objective of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union.

That is why I wanted to be in Slovenia with your government, to listen to what your priorities are, what your solutions are to the challenges we have ahead for the second half of the year, and to see how we can incorporate them into the priorities of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union. I can already tell you that they are very much in line because we have been working together on those solutions for a long time.

But to summarize them and do so in a way very similar to what Robert has said, I would say, first of all, the open strategic autonomy. If we have learned anything from the pandemic and now from the war, it is that Europe is very vulnerable, it is excessively dependent on some countries. Let us remember, for example, what happened with masks or ventilators during the pandemic.

But if we now turn to the war in Ukraine, how vulnerable we are to the import of energy by many European countries from Russia, which is currently violating international law, so we must promote that strategic autonomy, and in that sense, the work that Spain is doing to propose to the other member states during our Presidency is to focus on four aspects of that strategic autonomy.

One, energy. Two, health. Three, the primary sector, the agricultural, livestock, and fishing sector, and four, everything related to new technologies linked to the new semiconductor and microchip industry. That is, how we can turn this theoretical concept into pragmatic policies that we can promote at the European level.

Secondly, along with open strategic autonomy, Europe needs friends, new alliances, to strengthen ties with other parts of the world. And there we have a whole territory to gain. The Prime Minister Robert has mentioned it before with the South and the Southern neighborhood, all the Mediterranean countries, and North Africa. We want to promote the Barcelona process. We want there to be a summit between the European Union and the Southern neighborhood by the end of this year.

But before that, in July, what we want is to promote that summit that has not been held since 2015 between the European Union and a very important part of the American continent, which is CELAC, that is, Latin America and the Caribbean. And in that context, to see if we can take definitive steps to close the free trade agreement between Mercosur and the European Union. We are talking about a free trade area that would be the largest in the world if we reach that agreement with Brazil, with Argentina, that is, with the main South American economies.

Secondly, also how we update the Free Trade Agreement with Chile and Mexico, which would also guarantee us, in a way, the provision of critical raw materials to make possible that energy transition, that digital transformation, that reindustrialization of the entire European continent linking it again with that idea I mentioned earlier of open strategic autonomy. Therefore, this will be one of the second objectives that we will propose to the other member states during the Presidency.

Thirdly, I believe we need to conclude a necessary debate in this complex economic context, which is the fiscal rules, the new economic governance. That is, what do we do with the Stability and Growth Pact, how do we develop the proposal from the European Commission, and above all, how do we ensure a fiscal policy in line with our main objective, which is to continue maintaining economic growth and the transformation and modernization of the European economy.

And finally, there is a matter that you have already heard me mention, especially the Spanish media accompanying us, and that is precisely the migratory debate where there are two dimensions, the internal dimension, but also the external dimension.

We know that Spain is defending, promoting, and strengthening that external dimension because we understand that the best way to combat the mafias that traffic in human beings and therefore reduce regular migration to Europe has a lot to do with cooperation with transit countries and countries of origin.

These are the topics we have discussed. Of course, as the Prime Minister mentioned earlier, for Spain it is fundamental, in that approach to the idea of enlargement that we inevitably have in the East, on the eastern flank of Europe, as a consequence of Ukraine, Georgia, and Moldova and their situation, to never forget the Western Balkans.

When Robert, in one of his first councils, pushed for Europe to recognize Bosnia-Herzegovina's candidate status, we supported it from the very first moment because we believe that indeed, that entire European area must take decisive steps towards its future integration into the European Union, which we will also discuss during lunch.

And I conclude, once again thanking, of course, all the collaboration, friendship, and alignment on many of the solutions and proposals for the challenges we have ahead, to the Prime Minister and his government.

Q.- [Juan de Dios Colmenero, Onda Cero]

Thank you very much.

Good morning, Prime Minister. Good morning, President.

In the European context precisely of what the President of the Spanish Government referred to, also regarding the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, the immigration and asylum pact pending for a long time, with those two sides that exist within European countries, more security, more physical borders versus, well, another line.

I would like to know what the Slovenian Prime Minister's specific position is on that issue and for Pedro Sánchez, how he will achieve a middle position between both countries. And for the President of the Spanish Government specifically, if I may ask a national question, with the upcoming elections in the last year of the legislature in Spain and in light of the evident internal division explicitly within his government, a division also in feminism. How do you assess in general the management that the Minister of Equality, Irene Montero, has carried out, given that the intention is to reform one of her main laws, with or without Podemos and with the support of the Popular Party? I don't know if this last point also concerns you.

Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Juan, for your questions.

Regarding the first of the issues. Well, I believe that security is guaranteed at the origin, that is, by reducing irregular migration flows at the origin, and that means generating positive narratives, positive collaborations that, for example, we are doing with some of these countries of origin and transit. With Morocco, you know, with Mauritania as well, but undoubtedly with Senegal and other parts of the Sahel that clearly concern us much more directly.

I believe that strengthening regular migration policies to the detriment of irregular migration and generating spaces for cooperation with countries of origin and transit is the best way to guarantee the security of Europe.

We have seen it in the Mediterranean. We see it, unfortunately, in the Mediterranean. How a physical border like the Mediterranean, probably one of the most important, is not enough to stop the suffering and desires for prosperity of human beings fleeing their countries of origin, forced by multiple causes, both from the political point of view of persecution, also the effects of climate change, or in search of the opportunities that their country of origin denies them.

Therefore, I believe that from the point of view of what the migration and asylum pact is, the external dimension is, for me, not a priority, it is fundamental if we really want to stop the flows of migration to Europe.

And in that sense, Spain's position and the one we will present to the other European colleagues is an agreement that is inclusive, that is, that does not divide Europe between first-entry countries and countries that advocate for greater control of what they call secondary movements.

Two. An agreement that is balanced between what is responsibility and solidarity. There must be responsibility, but there must also be solidarity among countries in managing those irregular migration flows.

And thirdly, as I said before, the entire external dimension, which is really about talking about a realistic migration policy.

We in Spain know this well because we have a distance of 14 kilometers with a country like Morocco. We know that we have to make a realistic policy, and that realistic policy means not denying the evidence.

And the evidence is that migration flows are inherent to human history, and we must order those migration flows based on, as I said before, positive cooperations and not punitive or merely security-based ones, which is probably the least important part of the entire migratory phenomenon, which requires greater cooperation.

Regarding the second of the questions. Look, I believe that, despite the discrepancies that indeed exist on this issue, what is important is to reclaim all that has been done, which has been a lot and very important by the progressive coalition government.

Yesterday we saw, for example, a case in the national Parliament with the approval of the LGTBI law and also with the reform of the abortion law, which places Spain once again at the forefront in the recognition of rights and freedoms for the entire population and, specifically, for the women of our country.

Therefore, to reclaim and recognize that roadmap and the achievements we have made, which have been many and very important, and also what we still have to do, which is still a lot.

Therefore, I believe that what is relevant is that, to reclaim what has been done and what we have left to do for the progressive coalition government.

Secondly, on the issue of the "yes is yes" law, I would say the following. To say that maintaining consent at the heart of the law is perfectly compatible with addressing a social alarm that has been provoked.

Therefore, both objectives are not incompatible, but rather complementary. And in this, the government is evidently involved, and in particular - now, if you ask me as the Secretary General of the Socialist Party - the Socialist Parliamentary Group. But, in any case, I will tell you, as I have always done, Juan - you know this because I have been asked many times - I am proud of the work that each and every one of the ministers of the Government of Spain does. When they took office as ministers of the Government of Spain, I told them: "You are no longer ministers of one political party or another; you are ministers of the Government of Spain, and as such, we will work." We are doing so, and as such, we clearly have much left to do, as I mentioned at the beginning of my speech.

Q.- [Špela Novak, Radio Slovenia]

Good morning. Today marks fifteen years since Kosovo's independence was declared, so I have a question for the Spanish president. Regarding the existing tensions in Kosovo, how do you envision resolving the Kosovo conflict? And what is Spain's likelihood of recognizing Kosovo?

President.- Thank you very much for your question.

First of all, Prime Minister Golob mentioned it earlier.

I had the fortune and honor of being able to work for the United Nations during the Kosovo war in Sarajevo, in what was then called and still is the Office of the High Representative, which was responsible for ensuring compliance with the Dayton agreements that achieved peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina.

So I say this as a preamble to convey a confidence and a political decision that the Government of Spain has, which is that the stability of the Western Balkans is paramount. It is critical to ensure the stability of the entire European Union.

And secondly, the future of these Western Balkan countries is in Europe, and Spain will always advocate for the integration of the Western Balkans into the European Union as member states of this common project that we are building together.

From there, you know, because the position of the Government of Spain regarding Kosovo is well known, but I also believe that what is important now is to support that dialogue between Belgrade and Pristina and not to anticipate scenarios. I think what is relevant now, what is important, is to recognize that willingness to dialogue between both parties and to support that dialogue so that it bears fruit.

And that is where the Government of Spain stands, in supporting this dialogue process between Belgrade and Pristina and hoping that an agreement can be reached between both parties.

Q.- [Antonio Ruiz Valdivia, Infolibre]

Good morning. I wanted to ask both leaders about the situation in Ukraine. A year of war is approaching. How do you see the situation? Do you think the end of this war could come? And could that end come during the Spanish Presidency of the European Union? And to the President of the Spanish Government, if I may, the Prosecutor's Office has requested seven years in prison for the environment of Oriol Junqueras. You made a very risky bet on politics in Catalonia. How do you think this could affect the streets and Catalan society and the relationship with Esquerra? And if I may ask one last question. Are you internationally concerned about Spain's image in light of the scandal regarding Barcelona's payment to the vice president of referees? Thank you.

President.- Well, Antonio, thank you for your questions.

Regarding the first one. Indeed, next week, if it can be celebrated, allow me to use this verb, the anniversary of Putin's invasion of Ukraine will take place. There will be an important debate at the United Nations General Assembly in New York.

You know the position of the Government of Spain is one of total support and unity from allies and, in particular, from the European Union to Ukraine at all levels, both from the perspective of humanitarian aid and from the perspective of hosting refugees - we also have more than 160,000 Ukrainian refugees in Spain - in the supply of arms for their legitimate defense, for their freedom, for their territorial integrity, which is currently being violated by Putin and the Russian army.

And also in parallel, we conveyed to President Zelensky at the last European Council the need for all of us to extend support to the entire international community for his peace proposal.

I think it is very important that together we find many more allies outside of Europe for the peace proposal that President Zelensky presented a few months ago.

Secondly, regarding the approach you make about the Prosecutor's Office and, well, the judicial decisions we have known in recent days, I take this opportunity to convey, of course, what cannot be otherwise as President of the Government of Spain, total respect for judicial decisions. But also, on the other hand, the advocacy of a policy that I believe is doing a lot of good for Catalonia and, therefore, for Spain.

I believe that the dynamic of blocks in Catalan politics has been broken, and I think this is good for Catalan society. A society that has decided to turn the page on a dramatic and regrettable situation we experienced in 2017 and to bet on coexistence and dialogue between the different parties. And the Government of Spain will always be in that. Believe me, we are making a commitment, we have been doing so since the beginning of my presidency, for dialogue, for agreement, and for coexistence in Catalonia. And I believe that today no one doubts, except for the most belligerent, that the situation in Catalonia in 2023 is nothing like what, unfortunately, we suffered in 2017.

And finally, regarding the last question. Well, let's see… I just learned about it, right? I believe that the Spanish Football Federation is going to open an investigation into this matter. I think we will also wait for the bodies responsible for the good governance of the League, in this case Spanish, to clarify the situation that, unfortunately, we are learning about through the media.

Q. [Jure Kosec, Delo]

A question for both presidents. One of the ambitions of the Spanish presidency is also the reform of the energy market. Can you tell us what solutions Spain sees in this area? What solutions does Slovenia see in this area? And where do both countries see the possibility of cooperating in this area?

And a question about Ukraine. You have talked about the first anniversary of the war; do you expect Europe to continue maintaining a high degree of unanimity, considering the armament in Ukraine?

President.- Thank you very much for your questions. Regarding Ukraine, I think it is very important, now that we are approaching the first anniversary of the war, to not forget the origin of it. And to reaffirm some issues that seem obvious but are very necessary to remember.

One. No one wanted a war here except one person. No one wanted a war. I did not see Ukraine with any desire to conquer any territory of Russia.

Two. I think it is important not to be equidistant. In no aspect of life can one be equidistant between the aggressor and the aggrieved. And here there is an aggressor and there is an aggrieved. And we are with the aggrieved, among other things, because behind this lies something very important for Europe, which we first saw in South Ossetia, also in Crimea, now in Ukraine. And we are playing with or redefining the terms of European security and, therefore, global security. And a system of values that lies behind what we call global security, which is respect for human rights, respect for an international order based on rules, respect for the freedom of peoples to decide about their future, their territorial integrity. Some elements that we take for granted and certain, but that, unfortunately, are being violated in Ukraine.

Three. If we have never wanted war, how can we not advocate for peace? We want peace, but I believe that the basis of that peace must be defined around the proposals made by the one who is being aggrieved, which is President Zelensky and his country. And that is why I say it is so necessary that together we involve the entire international community, all regions of the world, about the need to move towards peace, the end of the war, around the proposal put forth by the government that is currently being aggrieved, the country that is currently suffering the invasion, which is Ukraine.

And, as Prime Minister Robert mentioned earlier, the need to remain united around this idea and never forget the origin of this war. And the origin of this war is pure imperialism, pure imperialism. And imperialism, unfortunately, we have experienced at other moments in our history, and it is something that we cannot accept as democratic societies. But, of course, we advocate for peace because no one, except one person, I insist, wanted war a year ago.

And regarding the second question, that is, the reform of the electricity market, let’s see… In very colloquial terms, I will explain it. Does it make any sense for Europe to be paying caviar prices for something we could pay at a much more appropriate price for the household and medium economies of our societies? It does not.

Right now we have renewable energies at very competitive, very low prices, and yet we are paying for energy and electricity at gold prices. It makes no sense. We can do this well with subsidies to compensate or with a structural reform of the electricity market, which both the government of Slovenia and the government of Spain have been advocating for. And I believe that now that we are talking about how to guarantee and improve the competitiveness of Europe, we need to put the reform of the electricity market back on the table. We cannot forget one of the main determinants for companies to establish themselves in Slovenia, in Spain, throughout Europe, and not to move to other parts of the world.

And in that sense, I greatly appreciate the alliance we have with the Government of Slovenia because, in the end, we are talking about competitiveness, but we are also talking about strategic autonomy, about being stronger against the blackmail that third countries may pose to us, as Putin has done.

And finally, we must meet our climate goals. There is a climate emergency that is not so present in public conversation. Just yesterday we learned - it was the front page, by the way, of some media in Spain - about the significant ice sheet break in the Arctic. The effects of climate change are there. This is a climate emergency of the first magnitude for humanity that transcends mere ideological confrontation and that we cannot, without a doubt, forget.

Moreover, the response we must give to the energy crisis caused by Putin's invasion of Ukraine must be consistent with the response we give to the climate emergency. And we can only do that if we promote renewable energies, if we strengthen the culture of energy saving, and therefore gain energy autonomy and promote all clean energies.

And that has a lot to do with the regulation of the market itself. Certainly, I believe that the status quo defined 20 or 30 years ago, which had its economic rationale 20 or 30 years ago, because at that time renewable energies were not as developed or competitive as they are now, certainly today makes no sense. I insist, we cannot be paying caviar prices for energy that we can buy at a much cheaper price. It is neither fair for our households, nor for companies, nor for industries. And certainly, governments, if we have to position ourselves with someone, it is precisely with households, with companies, and with industries, and not with those who benefit from these profits and from this absolutely outdated status quo, which does not obey any economic, political, or social logic.

And I tell you that in that sense, both the government of Slovenia and the government of Spain have been fighting together for a long time. And in fact, look, even the measures we have taken are working. Earlier, Prime Minister Golob referred to the Iberian solution. But if we look at the European level, at the beginning of the year we implemented the establishment of a gas purchase price from third countries by the European Union. Also the joint platform for gas purchasing. And finally, the push for renewables, as Robert has often defended, because I have witnessed his advocacy in the Council.

What has been the reaction of the markets? The price drop. That is to say, the intervention is working because we are sending decisive signals to the markets about what price we are willing to pay as Europeans to defend our economy and our industry and the households of our continent.

In short, I believe it is a debate, without a doubt, very necessary. And there is a consensus between both governments that this must be a central element for this year. We must definitively resolve the structural reform of the electricity market in the European continent.

Thank you very much.