"The PSOE-UP pact is not in question, and Cs is moving."

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

28 June 2020

Context
Sánchez gave a wide-ranging interview in late June 2020 reflecting on Spain's COVID-19 response, government coalition stability, and opposition tactics during the pandemic.
Main themes
COVID-19 pandemic management, state of alarm decisions, coalition government stability, opposition party criticism, parliamentary support, social discipline and resilience, science-based governance, co-governance with autonomous regions, political polarization, economic and social crisis, recovery fund, transparency and accountability
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,928
74th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.72
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
50th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%44%
  • Economic 27%27%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

180 sentences in 55 paragraphs

- The Covid-19 epidemic has forced you to make decisions that affect and continue to affect millions of people. How have you experienced it?

- The procession goes on inside, but I have always been very aware that the Spanish citizens, in an unprecedented moment in our history, with the most serious health, economic, and social crisis in the last hundred years, expected from the President of the Government serenity, clarity, and a willingness to guide the country with a clear direction to face the seriousness of the epidemic.

- What has been your worst moment? When did you feel most overwhelmed?

- We have lived through very tough circumstances. My worst moment was on March 14, when I had to convene the Council of Ministers to approve the state of alarm. This involved a series of unprecedented demands in the history of Spanish democracy, such as confining the entire population to their homes. We were facing an unknown virus. Science still does not know everything about the propagation capacity of this pathogen and how to stop it. The second most complicated moment, without a doubt, was March 26, when we suffered the peak of the epidemic, in terms of infections and also in the number of deaths.

- What is your opinion on the response of Spanish society?

- Very positive. In a majority way, it has demonstrated three very important things. First: an unprecedented social discipline that is difficult to find in other parts of the world. The degree of compliance with such severe restrictive measures as those we have implemented during these long and intense weeks of the state of alarm has been extraordinary. Second: a team spirit, because that discipline was not only exercised to protect ourselves but also to protect our loved ones. And third: a morale of victory.

- During these months, the expression "retrospective bias" has become fashionable. Suppose you could go back. What decisions would you not make?

- Well, I think the great lesson of this pandemic, both in Spain and in Europe and other parts of the world, is that the West arrived late. Should the state of alarm have been approved earlier? I do not deny that right now, but it is also true that Spanish society and many political forces would not have understood it with a number of deaths lower than what we had in the second week of March...

- Was it entirely necessary to subject the country to the political stress of an extension of the state of alarm every fifteen days?

- I wanted to appear before Parliament every fifteen days. I wanted to do it that way. I can say that I have lived a debate on the state of the nation every fifteen days. Our entire management has been based on five principles. Science: all decisions have been based on scientific criteria. Co-governance, in coordination with the autonomous governments, without recentralization of competences, there has been no recentralization. Respect for the Constitution, which has allowed us to apply the state of alarm. Transparency, since we have been accountable every fifteen days. And dialogue, not only with institutional actors but also with social agents.

- The Popular Party claims that you have not made many efforts to communicate with them.

We have maintained contacts with all the autonomous governments, with all of them, including those of the PP. A culture of cooperation has been greased, which I claim. For the first time, the president has met more than fourteen times with all the autonomous presidents.

- We were asking you about Pablo Casado.

- It is evident that the strategy of harassment and demolition of the right against the coalition government has failed. They have used the epidemic to try to overthrow the Government.

- Overthrow?

- Yes, overthrow. Since the motion of censure in 2018, the right has not assimilated the loss of power. They did not accept it at that time and did not accept the double electoral defeat of 2019, in April and November. The leader of the opposition speaks these days of unity. They must choose. They must decide whether they want to continue in provocation, playing into the hands of the far right, or if they want the path of consensus. So far, they have been in the strategy of trying to bring down the Government. They have used the dead in the political struggle and with that have attacked their own autonomous governments. They are damaging the image of the country when they send reports to the European Commission questioning the quality of our democracy. It seems to me something unworthy of a party with a sense of state. They have aligned themselves with the most maximalist European positions on the recovery fund against the interests of the Spaniards. This strategy of harassment and demolition has failed. It has failed, and the coalition government is today more consolidated.

- Do you think the Government can withstand what lies ahead, with unstable parliamentary support and significant differences in criteria, such as those that, for example, separate Pablo Iglesias from Nadia Calviño?

- We are in a new experience, unprecedented in the governance of Spain. I perceive at this critical moment an absolute loyalty among each and every one of the members of the Government. And also an alignment regarding the objectives.

- The Government was formed in January under very different circumstances than the current ones. Are you considering a reshuffle for after the summer?

- No. I am proud of the work of each and every one of the members of my Government.

- Is the current PSOE-UP coalition compatible with the pact with Ciudadanos?

- The most important thing is the validity of the government agreement between the PSOE and Unidas Podemos, an agreement that is not in question. Moreover, some of the central elements of that agreement, such as digital transition, ecological transition, and inclusive social responses, with the minimum vital income as a paradigm, are now more relevant than ever. From here, there has been a change in attitude on the part of some political actors, particularly Ciudadanos. I understand that this party has seen that the strategy of total alignment with the Popular Party and Vox was leading them to be left without space. Time will tell if it is a strategic attitude or purely tactical.

"The grace measures are well defined in our jurisdiction"

- Today marks ten years since the Constitutional Court's ruling on the Statute of Catalonia, and soon it will be a decade since the monumental protest demonstration that took place in Barcelona after that ruling. Ten years later, the situation is what it is. Your Government makes gestures, but specifics, few. What message do you want to send to Catalan society?

- Politics is dynamic, and it is evident that the priority right now for the entire Spanish society, and also for Catalan society, is the economic crisis. If we have learned any lesson from the situation experienced in these months, it is that if we do not unite and share, we will hardly be resilient enough to face the changes that have accelerated with Covid-19. I do not think we should overlook the effort made by the Government to strengthen the autonomous communities. A fund of 16 billion has been approved, 70% of which is allocated to health and education, a fund from which all communities benefit, including Catalonia, logically.

- The issue of Catalonia goes beyond the economic levers to address the current urgencies...

- It is a crisis that we are not going to resolve in a month, nor in two months, nor in a year, nor in two. But we must start to resolve it. We want to convene the dialogue commission between both governments. We want it to be this coming July, but I see a difficult context in Catalonia, as a clearly pre-electoral situation is being generated.

- And what solution do you see to the conflict?

- First of all, a change of attitude. There needs to be more dialogue. What Catalonia needs, what Spain needs, is precisely more dialogue, more unity, more cohesion. We must have the lucidity to be aware that we are entering an unprecedented crisis, from which we can emerge much stronger if we are able to understand the changes. And with this mentality, we must address problems that have unfortunately become structural due to a lack of political will, such as the political crisis in Catalonia, which has a coexistence derivative. It is that clear. That said, the first thing to do is to set the framework, and that is none other than legality. The path is dialogue, and the goal is reconnection. And that reconnection must bear fruit. It must materialize in a political agreement that will logically have to be ratified by Catalan society in a vote.

- The pardon for the Catalan politicians convicted could favor the reconnection. Is the Government considering the pardon?

- This is a topic that has been the subject of debate for many months, even before the Supreme Court issued its ruling. I have perceived in some actors and sectors more of a thirst for revenge than a desire for justice. And that goes against the spirit of the Constitution and also against the spirit of Spanish legislation itself. What I can tell you is that in penitentiary policy, grace measures are clearly defined in our jurisdiction and also in jurisdictional acts.

- During the state of alarm, relevant news has emerged associating the figure of the emeritus king with economic movements not in accordance with legality. To what extent have these news items affected and affect the stability of the State?

- First of all, I think it must be made clear that in our country there is no impunity. It is very negative that actors external to the judicial sphere want to position themselves as prosecutors and judges. What is important is that we let justice work and respect its independence. What I can say is that the relationship I maintain with King Felipe VI is extremely cordial. The head of state has perfectly understood what role the Royal House must play in Spanish society in the 21st century, a role based on transparency, exemplarity, and public service.

- Some sectors accuse the Government of not defending the monarchy strongly enough.

- There are sectors that indeed question the commitment of the left to Spain. They interpret that the monarchy is a symbol of the unity of Spain and try to appropriate and privatize the Head of State, as they have tried to privatize the flag of Spain. The commitment of the left to Spain is beyond doubt. The commitment of the PSOE is beyond doubt. We can link to a leftist tradition, that of the Communist Party with Santiago Carrillo, who defended the establishment of democracy in our country. And who accepted parliamentary monarchy. Unidas Podemos largely comes from there. Vox comes from Blas Piñar. It is not the same. There is a substantial difference, and the drama is that we have a right willing to pact with Vox to oust the Socialist Party from the institutions, something that does not happen in Germany, does not happen in the Netherlands, does not happen in France. Politics is made with the dead, votes are cast against the state of alarm, and they go to Brussels to say that there is no democracy in Spain, with an absolute lack of a sense of state. These are the consequences of the underlying strategy that the Popular Party is following.

- How do you fit the repeated interventions of Felipe González? What do you think when González says that the current Government is like the Marx Brothers' cabin?

- The other day I was asked in Congress about Felipe González's legacy, and I said it was a legacy of modernization. He was the president who modernized Spain and brought us into the European Union. I listen to all former presidents with the utmost attention, but the political and social conditions of our country today are very different from those of forty years ago.

"The tax system will improve towards fiscal justice"

- There is great concern in Spain about how the resources coming from Europe will be invested. What will your priorities be?

- First, those resources from the European Union must come. We should not take for granted what has not yet been definitively agreed upon. I believe that Europe must save Europe. What is at risk right now is the single market. We cannot have an internal market with very pronounced, very aggravated levels of inequality. I believe that Europe has learned the lessons from past crises, such as those from ten years ago, and today we are making aligned monetary and fiscal policy. That did not happen ten years ago.

- Everything has changed abruptly in three months.

- I remember that in February I was working with the economic team on a horizon of budgetary stability, with public debt below 95% by the end of the legislature, and a public deficit of less than 1%. That framework has exploded. Fortunately, there is beginning to be a common response at the European level. There is beginning to be one, for example, with the unemployment insurance fund, which will serve to finance ERTE in our country. There is a common response with the lines of the EIB (European Investment Bank) and also with that precautionary line, without conditionality, for health spending through the ESM. Obviously, the most important thing is the recovery fund that we are currently negotiating with Brussels and the other countries. I judge the proposal of the European Commission very positively.

- Can you specify the priorities of that fund in Spain?

-First, digitization. Second, the training of human capital. Third, the ecological transition. And I want to add something very important, because sometimes it feels like there are countries that give and others that only receive. This recovery fund will be financed 20% by Germany; 9% by Spain; and 6% by the Netherlands. I say this to dispel that distorted, misrepresented, and unfounded image that Spain will not contribute anything to this fund. That is not true. We will contribute more than some countries that are having, let’s say, political difficulties in accepting and agreeing to it.

-Is the agreement close?

-We have difficult, complex weeks ahead, but I am convinced that we are taking unprecedented steps in the right direction. Neither the markets nor the citizens would understand if there were no agreement. Work is being done to preserve the unity of Europe.

-We could say that there are two parallel negotiations.

-Yes, one refers to the recovery fund, and the other to the multiannual financial framework, where we are working to ensure that the agri-food sector comes out stronger. What has been done in these months of alarm from the agri-food and commercial distribution sector has been very important. I won’t give you numbers, but I hope and wish that during the month of July we will have an agreement around these two fundamental areas. I truly believe that we can try to make a significant leap in competitiveness in a short time, and this, without a doubt, can also represent a before and after in the prosperity of our country.

-Will the labor reform be repealed under the terms agreed with Bildu, that noisy night of May 20?

-Social dialogue must be prioritized. One of the main structural reforms that we are currently implementing is the ERTE. It is a figure typical of much more industrialized economies than ours, such as, for example, Germany. We are applying ERTE in a productive fabric that is basically made up of micro-enterprises in the service sector. In these months, during the peak of the epidemic, we have managed to protect 35% of the employed population in this country. I believe we are facing a significant structural reform that we must ensure remains, as it will be an alternative to dismissal, the traditional solution in recent crises. If we want to come out stronger, we must come out more united. Things can no longer be imposed as happened with the last labor reform. With it, a gap was opened, a wound that is still not closed as it disrupted the framework of social negotiation. One of the tasks ahead for social agents, with the Government's support, is to restore a new balance in the new economy we will have after the pandemic.

-Will there be a tax increase?

-The State is making an enormous effort and is backing as never before in the last 40 years of democracy in this country. One hundred billion euros in credit lines, guarantees for small and medium-sized enterprises. All of this financed with public debt and with public spending from the State. This is not sustainable in the medium or long term. If we already had a structural shortfall in terms of how to finance it with our own resources, that is, through taxes, we will logically have to propose an improvement of our tax system.

-And how do you plan to do that?

-That improvement of our tax system must be structural and there must be much greater tax justice. We will have to do it because the State, right now, is responding and is saving many companies and many jobs that were at severe risk.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of La Vanguardia.