The Prime Minister's speech in the Folketing on September 6, 2000, during the third reading of L288.

Denmark Poul Nyrup Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

6 September 2000 · Third reading of bill L288 in the Folketing · Folketing, Denmark

Context
Rasmussen addressed the Folketing during the third reading of the bill enabling Denmark's September 28, 2000 referendum on joining the euro.
Main themes
Euro referendum, Danish sovereignty, European Monetary Union, federal state concerns, social welfare harmonization, public deficit rules, Danish welfare model, EU integration, economic policy, no side arguments, fiscal rules
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,350
65th percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
56
80th percentile
Grade
10.6
28th percentile
Syntax
2.98
44th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 32%31%
  • Economic 22%22%
  • Social 21%20%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

108 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Before long, we will vote on the third reading of this bill, which is the basis for the population to hold a referendum on September 28. We have had nearly six months of debate. We have gone through many things. We have four weeks ahead of us. In the six months of debate we have gone through, we can both recognize traits from previous referendums, and there are, of course, also new issues that the population must take into account when each individual must make a decision.

Among the traits from previous referendum debates that I can recognize, we have touched on many today. The question of a slippery slope towards a federal state formation in Europe, a so-called superstate, is not a new viewpoint that has been put forward by the no side. We have experienced that since 1972. Today, we have clearly and unequivocally refuted it. No one wants a federal state in Europe. There is much misunderstanding surrounding the issue. Even Germany does not want a European federal state. No people want that. It has been claimed that a yes to the third phase of the Economic and Monetary Union, to the euro, will be synonymous with subsequent political integration. I take that as a non-polemical remark from one of those who has put it forward most strongly, namely Mr. Holger K. Nielsen, who has called it logic for guinea fowl. I must say that I cannot see the logic, nor the guinea fowl. The truth is that what is being created in these years is something quite special, which cannot be recognized in the USA or in any other federal state formation. The common currency is equipped with some rules that each individual country within the common currency must adhere to. That is precisely the alternative to the superstate. If there were no rules, then one would have to have a state formation. That is precisely why we have those rules. Why do we have those rules? Well, we have them also to protect each other from the dominance of large states in relation to small ones.

There are no provisions in the current treaties or in the proposal for the intergovernmental conference in Nice that even give a minimum hint of or basis for the standard of living and welfare in Denmark being pressured downwards or harmonized. That viewpoint has been put forward: Well, indirectly it will probably happen anyway. I will say to everyone in the Folketing now and to the entire Danish population that that is not true either. There is no logic, not even for guinea fowl.

If I were to engage with the no side's argumentation for how it would lead to harmonization and political integration in the social area, I have heard the arguments. One is: If there is a future economic downturn within the EU area, then Denmark will have to do something to avoid the deficit becoming too large, and since we have a predominantly tax-financed system, we must harmonize our social welfare. That is not correct. The Danish sovereign state, like all other member states in the EU, including those within the euro area, has complete freedom to compose its revenues for its welfare society. We have complete freedom to handle future economic downturns under one condition, that we comply with the rule of having a maximum deficit of 3 percent in public finances.

The second point that must be completely clear today is that the rule regarding the maximum deficit of 3 percent of public finances says nothing about and does not impose any limitations on how large the public sector should be. The 3 percent applies to a large public sector, and the 3 percent applies to a small public sector. The crucial thing is to conduct a sound economic policy. It does not lead to social harmonization that we have this excellent, very reasonable rule that the money must be there before we can use it. It will also be the case in the future that we can improve the old-age pension here in the country if we decide to do so and procure the money for it. The money must be there before we can use it. That is not something the EU has come up with. It is something that is very reasonable. It is something we have adhered to for many, many years - at least under the current government, but also under most previous ones.

The third argument I have heard is: Well, in other countries, there are predominantly employer-financed and employee-financed contributions, and here we have predominantly tax-financed contributions to our welfare. To that, I must say that it is too simplified a picture. We are not facing a clear, common European model on one side and the Danish welfare society on the other side. There are very large differences between the countries. Also in other countries, there are solidarity-based tax revenues, and there is, of course, an overlay on labor market contributions. But even that argument does not hold up, for the fact is that Denmark at any time has the sovereign right to determine how tax revenues should be composed. So: If we are in an economic downturn, the Danish government, together with a majority here in the Folketing, can decide whether our revenues to cover a deficit in public finances should predominantly be income tax, tax increases, or contribution increases for the labor market parties. Every serious working member of the Folketing here in the chamber knows that this is the case. It will also be so in the future. It will be a sovereign right for us in Denmark to decide whether it is more revenues or fewer expenses, or whether it is combinations thereof.

There is no logic, not even for guinea fowl, in the claim that social harmonization will be sneaked in through the back door. It does not exist in anyone's world other than in the theoretical reality of the no-sayers. I say this because the worst thing we can almost encounter in a Folketing debate like this one and also in a debate about a referendum is to scare people into a panic.

In addition, there is another very simple consideration, and here I speak from seven and a half years of personal experience at the negotiating table in the European Council. I speak from experience from many conversations with my colleagues around Europe. In all modesty, I am the one who now has the highest seniority of them all. I speak of hard, long night negotiations, I speak of many meetings and travels around the capitals of Europe. There is no one, and I repeat, there is no one who has ever expressed that it was an independent goal to harmonize Danish welfare - no one. And why would they ever wish to do so? What on earth would they wish that for? They have a completely different desire: that their welfare societies can also improve, that their people can also have better social conditions and better security, that their workers and employees can also have more jobs. That is the desire they have. No one wishes to push us down. Everyone wishes to lift their own societies up. That is my private, personal experience, which is now also written down in clear conclusions from the penultimate summit in Lisbon. In Lisbon, for the first time in history - and I think that is a fantastic handshake to the Danish people - we have a handshake to the populations that now not only Denmark has set the continued welfare state as a goal for the future, but now each individual member state within the EU has set the continued development of the welfare state as their own goals. We have even said at that summit, and it is all written down, that we have committed each other to say: That is our goal. Full employment is our goal, employment for women in the labor market is our goal, for that is the crucial path to equality in our society.

Stopping social exclusion is our goal. Lifelong education, so our people do not get caught in the future's internationalization, is our goal. How we will achieve those goals, we have also said in Lisbon, is up to us. It is in each of our societies up to us to use the resources we have tradition for, cultural background for, and ambitions about. We set ourselves some good, common goals, and we go home and implement those goals with the traditional methods or with new methods and with the resources we use in each of our countries. I think that is a fantastic breakthrough and a clarity for the Danish people. Now the Danish population can know for themselves that it is no longer up for discussion whether we should have a superstate or something else - by the way, no one wants a superstate - now it is mapped out and documented that our method of cooperation in the future in some of these areas is about us learning a little from each other, setting ourselves some common goals, and ensuring through the common currency to have a stable basis for achieving those goals. The other is the suspicion from the no side or a hint that there is something we are hiding from the population. I would like to say to the population and to the members of the Folketing here in the chamber: There is nothing we are hiding.

The Minister of Foreign Affairs has already said it: The Nice Treaty is completely like an open book to read, and everyone is welcome. The purpose of the Nice Treaty in December is to resolve the outstanding issues so that the enlargement can get underway. There is nothing in the Nice Treaty that can be used to harmonize our or other countries' social conditions.

I would therefore summarize what I think is the most important aspect of this referendum: We have spent 100 years building our welfare society in Denmark. Our idea behind building our welfare society has been that we must create some human frameworks around the market economy so that people can have a decent life, so that people do not fall by the wayside, so that there is cohesion and community and social care.

That is, in fact, what we are now setting out to ensure is taken care of to a greater extent at the European level. And why? Because we can no longer be sure that what we do in Denmark is sufficient to secure us a welfare society in the future.

I have the following reasons for recommending a yes on September 28: My first reason and my first emphasis to the population is: Denmark must not be isolated, we must not stand outside and be exposed to the pressures of international market forces. We must be inside a community that once and for all protects us against the pressures of international forces on us.

Secondly: Denmark's workplaces are best off, and Danish companies are best off when they can sell in a large market, where the majority of our exports take place. And I believe that everyone who is employed in the public sector, when they think it through, knows that what is good for Danish companies is also good for public workplaces, as it provides money to further develop our welfare.

Thirdly: Democracy is presence. It can never be more democratic to keep out of an international scene and battleground where decisions are made that affect us. Democracy is being present where decisions are made, so we can safeguard Denmark's interests.

And then I will say what has already been hinted at: I would also like to express respect for both Mr. Jørn Jespersen's and Ms. Margrete Auken's viewpoints and arguments. I believe we as individuals, members of the Folketing, as a country always have a duty to make a difference if we can make a difference.

I believe this country's tradition and this Folketing's political work for the most part has always dealt with: What is our role in the world? Can we, through our efforts, ease the conditions for those who are oppressed, or those who live under poor conditions?

And may I therefore also say to the Folketing: In Eastern Europe, the peoples have experienced top-down communism. In Southern Europe, the peoples have experienced the abominable fascism. In Western Europe, over in the United Kingdom, people have experienced Thatcherism. The peoples of Europe now see that what lies ahead of them and us is the idea of a welfare society, which is an alternative to the American idea, which is not a tail end to the USA or to the dollar area, but an offer to our own people and to the peoples of the world.

I was pleased with what was said by Mr. Jørn Jespersen and Ms. Margrete Auken earlier, that Europe has a unique historical chance to take on global leadership, which we have never had before. A leadership that has nothing to do with a superstate, but is unique.

A number of countries in Europe have an idea, have an economic power, have an opportunity to influence the WTO negotiations, an opportunity to influence the G7, G8 negotiations on the future of financial markets, an opportunity to realize the Kyoto environmental goals.

Now that all the peoples in Europe agree that the welfare idea is the right one, should we then doubt? Now that all the peoples in Europe think that Denmark is welcome in the company, we should not doubt. A yes is best for Denmark, a yes is best for all the people in Denmark who need a welfare society, a yes is best for our own self-esteem, for our own value, which also means that we can make an effort for others. On that basis, for a more peaceful Europe, for a fairer Europe, for the sake of global solidarity and for Denmark's own sake, I recommend a yes on September 28.