Speech at the Danish Industry and COIndustry conference on "Denmark's Future European Policy Agenda - On the Way to the Presidency 2002"

Denmark Poul Nyrup Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

22 March 2001 · Danish Industry and Commerce conference on Denmark's future European policy agenda · Copenhagen, Denmark

Context
Rasmussen addressed a Danish Industry and COIndustry conference in March 2001, outlining Denmark's preparations and key priorities for its upcoming 2002 EU Council Presidency.
Main themes
Danish EU presidency 2002, presidency preparation and organization, European Parliament engagement, ministerial coordination, EU policy agenda, public engagement and European debate, Denmark's role in EU, euro referendum aftermath, EU cooperation visibility, resource planning for presidency
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,638
93rd percentile
Sentences
293
95th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 29%28%
  • Economic 27%26%
  • Institutional 27%26%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 5%

293 sentences in 65 paragraphs

'The Circle Closes in Copenhagen'

The government has, as its very first task, organized a quite extensive preparation process for our EU presidency. The worst thing that could happen at this stage would be to say: 'Oh well, that only takes a couple of months.' But the truth is that if we remember our presidency in the spring of 1993 and look at the Swedish preparations, we must say that it is a very large task we have ahead of us. It is a very resource-intensive task. It is a task that places very high demands on the government - the parliament - also here in the country.

The truth is that since the spring of 1993, quite significant changes have occurred in the way we work in the EU. May I mention one example, which I believe many do not consider or underestimate. It is the increasing role of the European Parliament.

I believe we must prepare for the fact that almost all of the government’s ministers, with a few exceptions, will be busy participating in the dialogue in the European Parliament. I even think it will require so much work that we will have to talk to the Folketing about whether it is feasible. That we should not be in two places at the same time. I hope the Folketing will understand this.

This is a presidency that effectively starts around September 1 and ends at the turn of the year. I would like to already suggest today that we plan, in terms of the Folketing's work and the EU presidency, so that we do not expose ourselves to unnecessary criticism from the European Parliament for not being present.

There has been – and in a way rightly so – a stronger awareness and self-awareness in the European Parliament. This means that it is expected that for the crucial debates, and even the less crucial ones, a minister is present. Even the Swedish presidency, which has been among the most diligent in attending the European Parliament, has faced an expectation that being present at the level of deputy ministers or at non-elected levels is no longer sufficient. So we must face the fact that we need to be there. We must face the fact that we need to plan – which is also absolutely necessary.

I have therefore agreed with the foreign minister that all of the government’s ministers are now starting – each in their own department – to prepare very carefully what they will deliver for the presidency. I have told them that if the permanent secretary says to you as a minister that first we need the money. I have then said that it is not forbidden to think, before you can get the money – perhaps you even need to qualify for it. For it is clear that a presidency will also cost resources and money. But we must start by looking at what tasks we need to solve. What administrative and political tasks each individual minister must take on? How should the tasks be organized, and how should we involve industry, trade unions, interest organizations, and all parties in our society?

I also believe that the presidency can become a new basis for revitalizing our European debate. I can see from our experiences in Sweden that there is much to suggest that there is a certain correlation between having a presidency and having a certain increasing awareness that even a smaller country can assert its influence if it does it well. Therefore, I see the presidency in several different dimensions. Firstly, that Denmark must show that we can do this. Secondly, that people should be able to see that Denmark can make a difference, and thirdly, that we politically must set ourselves some key issues. We must, of course, also be aware that when we have a presidency, we are the servants of European cooperation. One does not expect a presidency to place its own interests at the top. I certainly do not mean that one should be critical of a country looking after its own interests, but my point is that we, as the presiding country, must also naturally think of the whole.

We must make cooperation visible. We must contribute to demystifying cooperation, and we must contribute to nuance cooperation. We may also have a chance to show the population in Denmark how many threads – how many direct and indirect influences there actually are between Denmark and the surrounding European community. Examples upon examples can arise. And who knows? Even though the Danes sometimes say no when they could say yes and say yes when they could say no! I believe that many Danes in the referendum on September 28 actually sent us the main signal: 'It is just a bit too early.' I must also confess to myself today that it was a very difficult exercise. I still remember it: Standing there and saying that the euro is strong – it is rock solid. And ten seconds later on the TV screen, it says that the euro's exchange rate against the dollar has fallen. It was not an easy pedagogical task. I can understand that the Danes said: 'That won't do. Shouldn't we just wait and see…'

Everyone who knows me knows that it was not due to a lack of personal, political, and physical effort. Many of you here have similarly worked hard on the matter. That is not what I am talking about. I am talking about how important it is that we rediscover a dialogue between those who said yes and those who said no.

It is incredibly important, and I believe that we have good opportunities to do this if we organize our presidency wisely.

I would also like to compliment Dansk Industri and COIndustri for this event and for your persistence in the debate. I am pleased with the survey that you are also publishing today. It is gratifying to confirm that the Danes on September 28 indeed voted no by a majority. But the Danes did not turn their backs on Europe. The Danes do not want an isolated Denmark. The Danes want to see a country and a government and a Folketing that are active in European cooperation.

Let me take the ball on the debate theme today and talk about three major challenges that I believe we can contribute a little to.

First, to continue the work to establish and secure peace and stability in Europe. Second, to seize the opportunities of globalization, and third, to ensure and expand the popular anchoring that European cooperation must necessarily be based on.

First, peace, stability, and security in Europe. There is one major headline for the Danish presidency that is more important than the others: It is the EU's expansion to the East. I feel a special obligation to this because it was during the Danish presidency – in the spring of 1993 – that the so-called Copenhagen criteria were defined for the EU's expansion. Our vision, in the Danish government, is that during the second half of 2002 of the Danish presidency, we can close the circle. We can complete the crucial negotiations with a large number – hopefully most and hopefully all, but let us be realistic and say – with a large number of applicant countries. Thus, we can operate with a historical circle that finds its end in Copenhagen. From Copenhagen to Copenhagen. An almost 10-year period that will be a decisive breakthrough for the peace that must follow – and follows – the Cold War and the fall of the Berlin Wall.

We have seen new nations being born. We have seen new democracies emerging. We see economic and social development making its way, but we also see very significant human and personal costs following in its wake. We see disappointed expectations among broad segments of the population in the new democracies. Why is my real income, income, and employment not improving faster? Why are there not more jobs coming more quickly? The whole process from the old top-down communist dictatorship to the free market economy combined with democracy and a budding welfare state thinking takes time.

We have a deep obligation to help ensure that the disappointment that exists does not turn into a negative attitude towards Europe. I do not believe it needs to do so if we are persistent.

I believe we have a multidimensional task to lift. First, we must make it completely clear to ourselves – also in relation to the Danish population – that the EU's expansion is a win-win situation. Even from a small Danish perspective, it is advantageous to strongly support the EU's expansion. For Dansk Industri, for Danish jobs, for Danish exports, for Danish welfare, it is absolutely a winning situation. Then it is always a bit easier to be particularly idealistic. I believe that then we can advocate for the EU's expansion with even greater voice - also in the practical work. Ensure that our bilateral assistance, technically, politically, and economically, is top-notch in relation to the three Baltic countries, in relation to the other applicant countries. Ensure that the EU's budgets contain the necessary resources allocated for this and ensure that we continue our ongoing work for the renewal of the agricultural policy in the EU and create room to further support the expansion and the applicant countries.

I see a direct connection between the EU's future agricultural policy on one side and the expansion process on the other. Both in terms of the future of food prices. In terms of competition in the global markets, but also in terms of the possibilities for the EU's budget to lift the support tasks as strongly as possible in relation to the applicant countries.

It is clear that the new applicant countries will be the ones who will have to take on the largest part of the adjustment tasks. We place very high demands on them. They know it, and we know it, and they are doing what they can to meet them. I am pleased to see how many times the pessimists have been disappointed in their predictions about how long it would take for the applicant countries to meet the criteria and the demands we place on them.

Take Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, or Poland: Just 5-6 years ago, most well-educated and smart economists believed that Polish society would be an agricultural economy for many years. Today we must say that everyone is deeply impressed by the Polish economic development. The same goes for the three Baltic countries. I think this is a strong emphasis that when we unleash democracy and economy, and when we develop a close cooperation between the European Union and the applicant countries, we see results. Estonia and Slovenia are now on par with each other and are the two societies that, measured against the Copenhagen criteria, measured against the economic opportunities, measured against the adjustments, have progressed the furthest.

I therefore believe that the first round of expansion can take place quite shortly after the end of the Danish presidency. I also believe we have a few things from previous expansions that we can learn from. If we take Spain, Portugal, and Greece, many of you may remember that there were indeed different transition periods, but for some of the countries, there were also common accession periods and common accession dates. Therefore, it is quite conceivable that the new group of countries, which will be the first group to become members of the EU, may have differences in their transition periods while joining at the same time and participating at the same time.

I consider it absolutely crucial that such a large group of countries joins in the first round. It will be the clear political line of the Danish government that the three Baltic countries join in the first round along with as many as possible – including Poland. I believe there are good opportunities for that. I believe the EU can lift the task. We have prepared ourselves with the Nice Treaty. One can have many opinions about the formulation of the Nice Treaty, but one cannot take away from it that it has established the foundation for the EU's expansion to now become a reality. This applies to the voting rules. This applies to the adaptation of the institutions – it is all set up.

The Danish presidency and the Commission have a long-standing good acquaintance with each other. I feel that the commissioner – Verheugen – who has the main responsibility for the negotiations has already demonstrated his professional expertise, his political commitment, and his strong ambition in the EU's expansion. Our good cooperation with the Commission from the government's side bodes well for us to achieve good results in the Danish summit round.

Stockholm on March 22-23, 2001, will be the first stop on that journey. I had a meeting with my colleague, Prime Minister Göran Persson, the other day. The Swedish presidency confirms to us that the pace is being maintained in the applicant countries, that we will have the opportunity in Stockholm to take a brief status check. We will not receive a new report from the Commission, but we have a new report that documents that the ambition I have outlined here will hold.

We will also have another dimension in Stockholm. We will be visited by Russia's new president, Putin, and will have the opportunity to add an extra dimension to the EU's expansion. We must not forget that the expansion should and must also lead to greater cooperation and freer cooperation with Russia and Ukraine. Two very large societies that are of absolutely crucial interest to us in terms of security policy, economic, trade, and peace policy. Here too, the Danish government, together with colleagues in Europe, will be frontrunners when it comes to renewal, opening up markets, and expanding cooperation with, among others, Russia. Such cooperation naturally also includes speaking frankly about each other's foreign policy. Both in terms of the critical situation regarding Chechnya, and in terms of the economic and employment aspects concerning the development of our societies.

The second major challenge facing the Danish EU presidency is globalization. A complex process. I would warn against - as I will do in relation to enlargement - falling into the trap of thinking that it is either something one supports or something one opposes. When it comes to globalization, one can at least state one thing, and that is that regardless of whether one supports globalization or opposes it – it is there. You cannot actually pull down the curtains on it, it is there. In all or most of what we do, the effects of globalization are visible. Therefore, we must relate to it.

Globalization affects our societies and populations in many ways. On the one hand, globalization is driven by a new IT technology and a new knowledge economy that we have never known before. On the other hand, globalization is also characterized by a number of old, familiar phenomena; tourism, trade with countries. The intensity has increased, and new technology has amplified the effects.

Globalization is propelled by a significant development that allows us today to speak of a new global marketplace. Globalization is also a consequence of political decisions regarding market openings, exchanges on the internet. Decisions that have been made because we were in no doubt that the free exchange of goods and markets is a crucial contribution to welfare – also for a society like the Danish.

On a more abstract level, globalization offers new opportunities that, if we understand how to exploit them, can be of great benefit to Danish society. The exchange of knowledge, the exchange of culture, the exchange of art is crucial for our own self-awareness and for our own dynamism.

But there are also problems.

Let me try to list them. First, there are the hard problems that are becoming much more visible now than they were before – and much more extensive: Human trafficking, money laundering, drug trade, and crime. All these phenomena – some of them have been with us for better or worse for a longer period, others have become clearer and more extensive – all these phenomena are also elements in the wake of the new globalization, which places increasing demands on us for effective European and international cooperation. We have taken strong action on this in Europe. We have followed up strongly in the Baltic Sea cooperation, and it must continue to be followed up effectively.

There is no doubt that the free exchange of goods, services, and capital is crucial for the conditions of our economic growth, but there is also no doubt that other risks are emerging. The technological development globally also means that the contrasts in our societies can become greater if we do not address it directly. The division in our society between those who have and those who do not have access to the new knowledge economy is something we should avoid. It requires an offensively formulated policy – both in Denmark and at the European level, and it is something we are extraordinarily active in. I believe those present are aware of this.

Another aspect of the issue is the environmental side. There is no doubt that if we do not provide a national and European response here, competition based on poor environmental standards or unregulated conditions will mean that our own environmental ambitions cannot be realized. Also, competition based on the lowest taxation can undermine our revenue sources for the modern welfare state in an unfortunate and unacceptable way. So there is much that needs to be initiated as a result of globalization if we are to reap its benefits and ensure that the negative effects are kept down and away.

I naturally wish for us to fully benefit from the welfare gains of globalization, but I also say that there is a need for more policy in relation to the unregulated behavior of market forces across the globe.

Market forces can create economic growth, but economic growth is not enough. We want it to go further. We want more policy in Europe and globally so that people can reap the full benefits.

I would also like to conclude this aspect by pointing to a new phenomenon that I believe we will need to analyze and relate to more clearly and increasingly. It is the digital economy, which one could call the knowledge economy.

I believe we will have to live with the fact that fluctuations in our new economy will occur more frequently and more extensively than we have been used to in the past. The 0-1 economy, one might call it. We know that in the American economy, the new IT-based industry accounts for up to 15-20% – depending on how one measures it – of the total American growth contribution. And I think we have seen signs that the discussion about sudden swings in the U.S. economy is now reflected not only in the financial markets but also in the growth rates of the American economy. One can choose to regard it as a purely short-term cyclical phenomenon. I believe it is wise not to settle for that, but also to regard it as a new structural phenomenon.

Denmark and Sweden are among the most developed IT nations in the world. We expect that in Denmark, the use of IT and IT-based industries will contribute a larger share of growth than what we see in the U.S. today. And in a few years, we will be at a turning point with Sweden, where up to a third – as the Swedes themselves say – of their total economic growth can be related to the new knowledge economy. It is clear that this is a development that will be reinforced in the coming years: Therefore, I also believe that we need to get used to thinking strategically about how we will relate to fluctuations that will come more frequently and perhaps also with shorter notice than we were used to before.

This requires persistence in economic policy in each of our countries. It requires a strong pull. A rejection of short-term temptations to deviate from the economic-political line in Denmark, just as it does in the rest of Europe.

Another aspect that is part of the globalization work is international trade. It is important that Denmark and Europe take the lead in the next WTO round. It is important that the arrangement is well-prepared. It is important that, unlike Seattle, it is based on a new mutual, respectful dialogue between the developing world, Europe, and the U.S. It is important that Europe does not only deal with the WTO as an extension of free trade but also adds new dimensions to trade. It is important that it is a broad agenda. That we do not only talk about the liberalization of world trade, but that we also link demands for the protection of workers' rights, the right to organize to these discussions. That we similarly move demands for environmental standards to these discussions, and that we likewise link demands for the protection of children and other forms of human rights abuses to our discussions.

And speaking of another major area, the environment, which will characterize the Danish presidency. Under the Danish EU presidency, a major UN environmental conference is likely to be held – a major summit – to mark the 10th anniversary of the Rio Summit on environment and development. The environmental summit will take place in South Africa, but it will be the Danish presidency that will take on the task in relation to the developing world and our African hosts. A huge task that I feel we are equipped for both through Danish experiences and the Danish commitment we have.

This EU presidency will thus have a very strong environmental dimension.

Another strong dimension is ASEM 4, which will also take place during the Danish presidency. This is cooperation between the European Union and the Southeast Asian countries, including China and Japan. The last summit took place – as many will remember – in Seoul, South Korea. Things are now arranged so that expectations for a tighter agenda, a more binding agenda at ASEM 4 in Copenhagen, are very high.

Many of my colleagues in Europe – I know that we are also working at the official level to organize the work – have high expectations for this summit. It will take place in September 2002 here in Denmark – in Copenhagen. It is an incredibly important summit. It will be a summit that must address the negative sides of globalization, as I mentioned. A summit that will have great significance also in relation to the WTO. A summit that will have great significance in relation to environmental issues. Therefore, I hope that you will receive it well. We will do everything we can to create the right and effective framework.

Then there is the internal market, which is of course the real European dimension in the discussion of globalization in economics and trade. We will never be finished with the internal market.

The internal market is an ongoing process, as Dansk Industri and CO-Industri correctly describe it. I believe that we should also invest considerable effort in it, because new dimensions are also emerging in the internal market. Trade via the Internet, to mention one example. We must ensure that companies do not face unfair competition when they sell their goods. Therefore, we must have common binding EU rules in the internal market – for example, on consumer protection for online trade. We see new circumvention opportunities that we can neither accept nor should accept. For example, the tendency towards unfair competition in taxation, as I mentioned earlier – in labor conditions and the environment. I believe that we should continue the work to establish minimum requirements in a number of taxation areas. Not least in the area of corporate taxation, I believe we have an important theme to address. There should certainly be no lack of Danish efforts in this area.

In the area of labor conditions and the environment, we must constantly – through our practical presentation of proposals – also illustrate to the Danish population that it is in their interest to create common minimum rules. Not to harmonize the level but to ensure protection against dumping.

Then there are other areas where we do not need binding common EU rules. These are areas that the Lisbon Summit identified as new, important additional dimensions to EU work. I believe it is very important to make it clear that what is happening in Europe right now is something that actually fits well with the Danish mentality. In Europe, we should not only talk about economic policy, about market forces. It is clear that economic development is a very important foundation. But we should also think about incorporating a labor market and social dimension as a balance in relation to the economy alone. This is precisely what we have taken on under the Lisbon Summit in March last year, where the heads of state and government decided, as a new strategic goal for the next 10 years, to say. I quote: 'To become the most competitive and dynamic knowledge-based economy in the world. An economy that must create sustainable economic growth with more and better jobs and greater social cohesion.' And a little further down in the same text, the term 'welfare state' is used as the foundation for the new European dimension.

I think it is important that we are frontrunners here. I would like to say that I consider it a main task also for the summit in Stockholm to contribute offensively and actively to this line. It is also important to convey to the Danish population that it is a special type of new cooperation, the new dimension that is now being added. The so-called open coordination method, the so-called best practice method, which does not aim to harmonize but aims to set common goals. Where it is then up to each country – through its own methods and tools – to achieve the common goal. First, that we reach an employment rate, an employment level for women as close to men as possible within a few years. For us, it is a natural goal and a reality. But for many other European societies, it is a very ambitious goal to realize. Second, to effectively combat social exclusion in our societies. This is not something the EU should dictate, but something we can all define as common goals. Once we have defined them as common goals, we will all benefit from it as we move towards them.

Third, in Stockholm, as a lead-up to the Danish presidency, two additional dimensions have been pointed out in the continuation of the Lisbon process. One is education. One might ask, why should the EU now get involved in that? The EU should not, in principle, but on the other hand, one must say that just as naturally as it is for the Danish government, for the Danish Parliament, for all of us, to be fully aware of how crucial education is as a foundation for economic growth, I can assure you that just as surely, we will be affected if other countries in Europe do not also define an advanced educational effort as a dynamic part of their economic growth. One could say that our interest is also that other societies prioritize education and thus competitiveness at the top of their agendas.

Another key element we will discuss in Stockholm and beyond, also under the Danish presidency, will be the issue of pensions and demographics. One might ask, why on earth?! Well, because if other countries do not, in line with us, address these problems, they will face economic setbacks, and we will be affected.

Let me illustrate this: The discussion we are having in Danish political life right now about the future development of an increasing number of elderly people in our society and a decreasing number of people in the labor market. This discussion is taking place in every EU country. It is incredibly important that each country also develops responses to this. The answers are different. We are in a special situation together with Sweden, Norway, and Finland, because we have such a high employment rate for men and women and therefore must find the answers in a slightly different way – an even more demanding way. In the central southern European societies, one can find the answers through a higher employment rate, as you are all aware. But the issue must be resolved, and it must be resolved in each individual society. A common goal and national tools.

Then there are other elements of free economic cooperation that also relate to both the national strategy and the EU strategy. Let me again mention the IT economy and let me mention how important it is that the free telecommunications market in Europe becomes a reality. Here, Denmark is among the countries that are actively working to finalize the directives that presuppose the liberalization of telecommunications regulation in the EU. I believe that this is in our interest, and I believe that it is a very dynamic part of our IT strategy.

Consumer protection, biotechnology, employment. The list is long in the areas where we have a number of common interests.

Let me conclude with my third area: To ensure – as best we can – a stronger interaction between ordinary people in their daily lives and in the EU. After Nice, what we do will be absolutely crucial for this stronger popular change.

We must try to see if we can reach a new fundamental treaty in the EU. I am in favor of having a simpler treaty. But I can also promise and assure that it is easier said than done. Many of those present who have worked with the EU over the years know this, and I know it especially well myself. I believe that the goal is worth pursuing. I hope a fundamental treaty can be part of the answer to bridge the Danish population up in Europe for that matter.

By a fundamental treaty, I mean a simpler treaty. And by a fundamental treaty, I also mean a treaty that, in a way, draws the line more clearly, as Max Bæhring pointed out. I would also caution against simply jumping on board the so-called competence catalog.

This is an issue that especially the German government has been working on since 1992. On the one hand, I can understand the attraction of a competence catalog, where one has very precisely described what is included and what is excluded. I must say: Be careful! There may be tasks that we do not foresee today, and that we will blame ourselves for not being able to handle because we drew a very precise catalog of what should be included and what should not.

Conversely, I believe it is absolutely necessary that we draw a line that is clearer in relation to the population. Knowledgeable EU people here in the room will say that we already have a line – and that is essentially true. The problem is that it is not clear enough. The problem is that there is concern in large parts of the Danish population, but there is also concern in other parts of the populations in Europe, I can assure you. There is a concern for: What about my identity, what about my country, what about my nation: Therefore, I believe that this is a task we must invest an incredible amount of thought into. The principle of proximity will be one of the methods, but other lines and methods must certainly be considered thoroughly. I am in favor of the line, and that it becomes clearer. I believe that it will benefit the public's sense of security regarding European cooperation. I just say at the same time that we must do it wisely, and we must do it with historical reach, then we can also find the solution.

The Charter of Fundamental Rights must also be clarified in terms of how it will be positioned in relation to the new treaty. I find that this charter is so promising and has so many positive elements in it that it will be natural for us to work on how the content of the charter can be placed in the new European treaty.

As you can hear, I believe the keys to rediscovering a broad public understanding of European cooperation lie in transparency, clarity, and simplification. It also lies in a European vision of a broad, peacefully anchored Europe from the Atlantic Ocean to the Ural Mountains. It lies in a demystification of what the EU is and what the EU is not. And it lies in a clarification of how much and how significant the EU is for Denmark and Denmark's future.

If we can do this, then we have done what we should do: Contribute to a peaceful, visionary European development perspective for the Danish population, for the Danish government, even though it may be the least important of all – but for Danish society as a whole.

That will be the ambition! Three important summits: An environmental summit, a summit with ASEM countries, a summit in December that will follow up on the overall enlargement. If we can achieve that, then we can also show that we can in Europe. It will create respect for us. Let us unite our efforts to achieve the results.

Thank you for the word.