President Piñera declares Chile's position on the Marrakech Migration Pact.

Chile Sebastián Piñera · President of Chile

14 December 2018 · Declaration of Chile's position on the Marrakech Migration Pact

Context
Piñera addressed the Chilean public in December 2018 to explain his government's decision not to adopt the UN Global Compact for Migration agreed upon in Marrakech.
Main themes
Marrakech Migration Pact rejection, safe and orderly migration policy, national sovereignty over borders, irregular migration control, migrant regularization process, human rights of migrants, migration law reform, criminal exclusion from entry, distinction between regular and irregular migrants, state obligations under international pacts
Duration
~12 min
42nd percentile
Words
1,439
42nd percentile
Sentences
43
27th percentile
Readability
28
13th percentile
Grade
17.7
92nd percentile
Syntax
3.60
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 46%44%
  • Social 27%26%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

43 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Good afternoon:

Our Government promotes and is committed to safe, orderly, and regular migration.

What does this mean? That Chile has a policy of open doors and open arms to receive and welcome those migrants who come to Chile to start a new and better life, but with the firm intention of respecting our laws, starting with the Migration Law, to integrate into our society and contribute to the development of our country.

But it also means that Chile has a policy of closed doors to prevent those people or groups who come to harm us, such as criminal gangs, organized crime, drug traffickers, or human trafficking groups, from entering our country.

We also believe that every person has the right to leave their own country, but with equal strength, we believe that every country has the right to decide how and under what rules those who wish to come as migrants may enter our country.

This principle sometimes coincides and sometimes contradicts, and a President must always prioritize the interests of Chile and Chileans.

But, of course, human rights are universal and, therefore, must be respected and protected for all, including all types of migrants, regular or irregular, at all times, in all places, and under all circumstances.

I also want to affirm that when we took office, the migration situation in Chile reflected, in our opinion, an alarming disorder. During the Government of the New Majority, nearly 700,000 people entered Chile as tourists, hundreds of thousands of them with the clear intention of staying irregularly or deceived by true human trafficking mafias, who promised them things that were never fulfilled. As of March 11 of this year, there were more than 250,000 irregular migrants in Chile.

And for that reason, one of the first emergencies and challenges that our Government took on was to bring order to our house.

In this way, we managed to move towards safe, orderly, and regular migration. And that is why we initiated an extraordinary process of regularization of migrants, excluding those with criminal records, to which more than 155,000 migrants have already joined in these months, who are in the process of regularizing their situation.

We also repealed the Temporary Visa for labor reasons, which had generated more than 45,000 false documents, deceiving our system.

We also believe it is important to improve our Migration Law, which dates back to 1975. That is why, during our first Government, we sent a bill to modernize it, to improve it, and today we are strengthening that process through a set of indications that establish clear entry requirements for migrants and effective administrative procedures, to achieve that safe, orderly, and regular migration.

Regarding the Marrakech Migration Pact, our Government - as announced by the Chancellor - decided not to adopt the Marrakech Migration Pact. And for very profound reasons, because it contradicts some of the principles of our own migration policy and because it does not adequately safeguard the legitimate interests of Chile and Chileans.

Our decision was based on three fundamental reasons:

First, the Marrakech Pact undoubtedly encourages irregular migration, by promoting informal work, by fostering the entry of so-called "vulnerable migrants," by making it difficult to detain irregular migrants, and by granting access to pensions to these migrants without meeting the requirements of our country. And by blurring the distinction between migrants and refugees, and the distinction between regular migrants and irregular migrants, which undoubtedly harms the situation of refugees suffering persecution in their countries and the situation of regular migrants who entered our country respecting our laws.

Second, the Marrakech Pact introduces new duties for States, including the signatory States, such as having to review our legislation, our public policies, our administrative acts, and having to promote the signing of new bilateral or regional agreements.

Additionally, it establishes as a duty of the State the creation of conditions for the economic and social development of those migrants who are expelled from a certain country, so that once they have returned to their country of origin, the State that received them and expelled them has the obligation to care for their social protection, psychological assistance, and employment opportunities in the country of origin.

Third, the Marrakech Pact limits the sovereign right of every State to decide how to safeguard its borders, who and under what conditions may enter its territory, and to whom benefits may be granted.

Although the Marrakech Pact states in its text that it is not binding, it is evident that if a country - and especially a serious and responsible country like Chile - adopts that Pact, it commits to its spirit and content.

In fact, the Marrakech Pact uses the word "commitment" 86 times and the word "duty" 15 times, and additionally, experience has shown us that this type of pact can and has had political and legal effects, because these instruments known as "Soft Laws" are often used by international bodies, including international courts, to demand compliance or to attempt to derive legal obligations from the States that adhere to those pacts.

I have heard some criticisms regarding our Government's position and I would like to respond to them very directly and frankly.

Some have argued that the Government's decision not to adhere to this Pact would be contrary to a State policy in foreign relations. Undoubtedly, in Chile, we have had a long and beautiful tradition of State policies in the major matters of international relations. Chile has undoubtedly had this tradition, and our Government values, respects, and applies this tradition, as we have done in the cases of the trials before the International Court of The Hague, where we have consulted and sought agreements with all the different sectors of our country; as we have done in matters related to the maintenance of peace, international security, and respect for democracies and human rights; and as we have done regarding the major issues of international law, such as our commitment to climate change and global warming, and in many other instances.

However, in our opinion, the way Chile regulates its migration policy is an issue of an essentially internal nature, without prejudice to international collaboration, and does not therefore form part of a State policy. The best proof of this is that when we were in opposition, we were never consulted, and we also always disagreed and very deeply with the migration policy applied by the previous Government, which resulted in the entry of hundreds of thousands of irregular immigrants into Chile, and that undoubtedly this situation was known, promoted, or tolerated by the previous Government and that deeply affected the interests of all Chileans.

Others have argued that our Government's decision regarding the Marrakech Pact would deviate from the multilateralism that our country has practiced. Our Government firmly believes in the benefits of multilateralism, which is why we actively participate in practically all international forums. However, and as is evident, multilateralism can never mean the obligation to subscribe to every single agreement, pact, or declaration that arises from multilateral bodies, because it is the essence of multilateralism that each country has the right to freely exercise its decisions to adhere to those agreements or simply decide not to do so.

Chile believes in and is committed to dialogue and international collaboration because we want and are moving towards safer, more orderly, and more regular migration. We want this to happen in the world and also in our country.

However, as President of Chile and in safeguarding the interests of our country and all our compatriots, I cannot support a text that, for the reasons mentioned above and after a thorough and exhaustive analysis, I consider harms and does not safeguard the interests of Chile and Chileans, that encourages and focuses on irregular migration, that facilitates the promotion of unrecognized rights, that establishes new duties for the State of Chile, and that makes it difficult to safeguard our borders, limits our sovereign capacity to make decisions regarding migration, always thinking of the interests of Chile and all Chileans.

That is why today we are promoting and enriching with new indications the Migration Law project that we presented during our first Government, which is so important for the quality of life of all Chileans.

And we are convinced that these issues must be discussed primarily in Chile and in Valparaíso, and not only in Marrakech or New York.

For all these reasons, as President of Chile, fulfilling my duty to conduct international relations and thinking only of the interests of Chile and Chileans, I have decided not to adopt the Marrakech Pact.

Thank you very much.