- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on May 24, 1937, paying tribute to the late Lord Snowden and answering the Leader of the Opposition's criticism of the Civil List proposals.
- Main themes
- Civil List provision for the Crown, tribute to the late Lord Snowden, reply to the Leader of the Opposition, Labour opposition to a Division, ceremonial and pageantry of the Monarchy, calls for simplicity in royal arrangements, upkeep of royal residences, Sovereign and political appointments to the Household, state coaches versus motor cars, public support for royal splendour, Select Committee on the Civil List
- Duration
- ~9 min
- Words
- 1,080
- Sentences
- 43
- Readability
- 54
- Grade
- 11.9
- Syntax
- 3.02
- Vocabulary
- 2.17
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other43 sentences in 8 paragraphs
I should like to associate myself with what has been said by the Chancellor of the Exchequer and the Leader of the Opposition about the late Lord Snowden. For nearly seven years he and I were engaged in constant controversy in this House, sometimes of a very acrimonious character, and I should like to pay my tribute to the Roman qualities, the classical qualities, of his nature and of his political record, his fearless adherence to the principles of politics as he conceived them, his fierce confrontation of opposition in every quarter and the record of service to the State which he built up in his long life, doing equal honour to the class and the county from which he sprang and to the House of Commons, which enabled him to play so large a part in our affairs.
I do not think the speech of the Leader of the Opposition ought to go without some answer from these benches. The right hon. Gentleman couched it in terms of great mildness and studied moderation. He endeavoured to soften the effects of every proposition that he put forward, and to clothe it all with an air of sweet reasonableness and absolutely up-to-date modernity. Nevertheless, it would be a very serious thing if he led the party that he represents into the Lobby to vote solidly against the proposals now put forward for the upkeep of the maintenance of the honour and dignity of the Crown. It would be an unfortunate event in our modern Parliamentary history, and I earnestly hope that, whatever passes in Debate, the right hon. Gentleman will reconsider very carefully the attitude that he should take in actually pushing these matters to a Division. When one listened to his speech one really might wonder where he had been these last few weeks. What evidence is there, for instance, that the masses of the people are feeling uncomfortable about the ceremonial, the splendour and the pageantry that are associated with the Crown? I have been about, and I have not seen any of that evidence. I have seen the Leader of the Opposition now here, now there. I wonder indeed on what he bases his contention that there is this deep feeling among the advanced thinkers, the modern
46
highbrows, that all this sort of thing requires profound simplification. We had a speech by a former colleague of the right hon. Gentleman, the hon. and learned Gentleman the Member for Bristol (Sir S. Cripps), who described what had taken place as bunting and bunkum. The bunting was everywhere. The bunkum can be located with very much more precise particularity.
But I should like to know what is meant by more simplicity. A Motion moved by the right hon. Gentleman in the Select Committee gave some detailed reasons. Is it proposed, for instance, that the Royal residences should be cut down—Windsor Castle, Balmoral, and so forth? I think that statements of that general character, if they are to be done justice to by Parliament, ought to be supported by more precise recommendations. If the residences are not to be reduced, obviously they must be maintained by what is considered to be an adequate staff. Then, I understand that great objection is taken by the Leader of the Opposition to the association of the Sovereign with persons of one political outlook. Really that is not the fault of the Sovereign. That is the fault of the Opposition. If they were to obtain a majority, under our free constitution they would be surrounding the Sovereign on every side. Not only would they have the great offices of State, but all the personal offices of the Royal Household are in their nomination. When you consider that twice within the last To years the official Opposition have formed an administration and filled these functions and these offices with credit and dignity, I am surprised that they should cut themselves off from their past and from their co-operation in this part of our constitutional work. Of course, one great step towards simplicity would be the abolition of the coaches of State and the substitution of the far more modern motor car, but I ask myself whether that is really what the public would like—whether really it is what is likely to meet the wishes of the great masses of the people.
It is true that the right hon. Gentleman made a reservation that he would allow ceremonial to take place on certain limited occasions. I am sure we must be very grateful that he has given this hope that some saving clause will be added to cover that. Of course, the difficulties of any other procedure would be very great. If
47
you are not to have the glitter and the splendour of ceremonial pageant, I do not really know how the great mass of the people would be associated with the main facts of the State. Of course, the Sovereign might come in a motor car to the House of Commons, the House of Lords being abolished, and might take the Oath in our presence, and then return in a motor car to his habitation, but I am not at all sure that the public would view such a change with, satisfaction. They would require some sort of a procession. If the worst came to the worst, we ought not to shrink from our duty. The House of Commons itself might march in the procession, but one is not quite certain what reception they would get, or who would get the best reception. It might well be that some raven-haired representative of the Clydeside would get much louder cheers than the Leader of the official Opposition. At any rate, it seems to me that we have had in these last few weeks an absolutely clear manifestation that it is the wish of the overwhelming majority of all parties in the country that the pomp and circumstance—I use the words without fear or apology—which have been hitherto associated with the English Monarchy should not be pared away from it in these modern days. Only a year ago, as the Chancellor of the Exchequer has reminded us, we passed very similar provisions to these through the Select Committee on the Civil List, and there was, apparently, general agreement that the provision was adequate, but not more than adequate. What has happened in the interval to change this point of view on the part of the Opposition?
