Mr. Duff Cooprr'S Speech.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill

29 June 1936 · House of Commons debate · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on 29 June 1936, defending the Secretary of State for War's speech on Anglo-French friendship as consistent with government policy and appropriately timed.
Main themes
Secretary of State for War's speech to a Franco-British gathering, propriety between ministerial colleagues, consultation of the speech with the Foreign Secretary, contrast between the speech and government policy, Anglo-French staff conversations, defence of the Franco-Belgian frontier, French labour troubles and strikes, untimeliness of the speech, comfort to the French people, Leader of the Opposition's visit to France, separate diplomacy with a foreign government
Duration
~5 min
16th percentile
Words
603
16th percentile
Sentences
23
13th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
12.4
49th percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
1.83
1st percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 44%35%
  • Institutional 39%30%
  • Economic 11%9%
  • Ceremonial 6%4%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 22%

23 sentences in 7 paragraphs

I certainly understood that he did. Then I state, according to my

125

information, which no doubt can be verified or disproved by the Government, that that is what took place, and it seems to me that there is very little in it to say that, though the speech was consulted upon by the two Ministers concerned, the final draft did not come under the eye of the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs. Is it suggested that, after these Ministers had reached an agreement upon what should be said, the Secretary for War went away and made a final draft which did not correspond to the agreement which they had made? It cannot be that there was such a suggestion in any way. Therefore, it seems to me that in making a speech of this kind, the Secretary of State for War acted fully in accordance with what were the necessary proprieties of one colleague to another in the course of public business.

The question to which you, Sir, most rightly and strictly, limit our Debate, is whether there is a contrast between the speech of the Secretary of State and the policy of the Government. It seems to me that the speech of the Secretary of State lies well within the policy of the Government. The right hon. Gentleman, I think it was—or was it the Leader of the Opposition?—referred to the staff conversations that had been taking place. Well, can you compare a speech of this kind in general terms, of a courteous and ceremonious character, on a festive occasion of good will, on the celebration of fraternal good will between Great Britain and France—can you compare a speech of that kind with the grave, sombre meeting together of technical experts from the different countries, from the two countries concerned, with Belgium added, not all the countries, but the two particular countries who have a common frontier, preparing to defend the common frontier, who were not merely making speeches about it, but military experts making plans and preparing to defend that common frontier in case that common frontier should be the object of unprovoked aggression? With that fact staring us in the face, surely, is it not boggling at very much smaller matters to make all this tremendous attack upon a speech which the Secretary of State made, and which fell far short of the facts as they have been approved by this House?

There is another question which may arise. It may be said that although the

126

speech of the Secretary of State did not go beyond the actual facts and policy of the Government, it indirectly went beyond them by its untimeliness. There, again, I cannot feel that there is any ground for saying that. There have been great labour troubles in France, and we, too, have had in our past labour troubles, but very often foreign countries exaggerate the effect of troubles which are going on in another country and form wrong conclusions thereby. They do not realise that a country may be having a lot of internal disputes and even strikes and so forth, and yet, if danger confronts the whole country, it would be united as one. It was timely to speak a word of comfort to the French people. The Leader of the Opposition paid a visit to France himself a little while ago. I am not going to dwell upon that, except as an illustration in procedure. It seems to me that for the Leader of the Opposition to open up, as it were, separate diplomacy with the head of another Government—