Government Of India Act, 1935 And Government Of Burma Act, 1935.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

12 June 1936 · House of Commons debate · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on June 12, 1936, in the debate on the Government of India and Burma Acts, criticising the Niemeyer Report's finances while accepting provincial government as an experiment.
Main themes
Niemeyer Report on provincial finances, financial embarrassments of the Indian Provinces, Sind deficit and the Lloyd Barrage, Orissa Famine Fund, inauguration of provincial government in India, separation of provincial and federal schemes, cost of the new Constitution, Government of India's response to the report, criticism of the Government's metaphors
Duration
~7 min
22nd percentile
Words
785
22nd percentile
Sentences
37
23rd percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
3.01
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 49%46%
  • Geopolitical 17%16%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Institutional 9%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

37 sentences in 12 paragraphs

Oh, I see. It is curious that on both sides this same sub-conscious oppression should have manifested itself in the imagery employed. The platform is prepared, all is ready, and now we pull the lever. I think that great supporters of this policy must be a little more careful that their metaphors do not so readily reveal

587

the inward thoughts which their minds harbour. The first lever appears to be the Niemeyer Report. I have studied that report. I know Sir Otto Niemeyer. I knew him very well at the Treasury, and you could not have a more able financier; a more commanding mind applied to the details of finance could hardly be found, and he has written his report. It is a document rich in dark and cryptic phrases. The balancing, the guarding, of every statement, the total lack of the slightest spark of enthusiasm or hearty confidence at any point, the almost extorted admission that on the whole there is no reason to pull up—these are characteristics of the Niemeyer Report. Indeed, it is a very bleak outlook which he presents to the Government of India, and an even bleaker response which is made by that Government to his report. We see the Provinces passed under review and their great financial embarrassments described. In some cases a note almost of pathos is struck.

Take paragraph 13, "Sind." The deficit for the future, say Sir Otto, may be estimated at 105 lakhs—a considerably higher figure than the estimate of the Sind Conference in 1932 (approximately 80 lakhs).

Then he says:

The future of Sind and of the subvention as part of Sind finances is inseparably bound up with the financial future of the Lloyd Barrage.

So Lord Lloyd seems to have done some good in his work in Bombay, but Sir Otto says that in order that this result shall be obtained by the Government, it will be necessary that the Barrage scheme will be administered on lines comparable with similar schemes elsewhere and that adequate rates will be charged for the facilities it will provide.

Of course, the beneficial effect of the barrage, as of the reservoirs supplied from it, is in inverse ratio to the charges which are exacted. If, however, a subvention of 105 lakhs is found from the Central Government, the question of Sind does not seem to be insoluble. I see one ray of hope in this paragraph, where it says that if a single non-recurrent grant of five lakhs can be obtained from the Central Government, there will be every possibility of celebrating the

588

inauguration of the new Constitution by erecting a very large new jail at Shikarpur. With regard to Orissa, the Government appear to me to be taking a prudent course in following Sir Otto Niemeyer's advice to make a further advance towards the Famine Fund and to raise the total to the figure of 10 lakhs prescribed in the Orissa Order in Council.

If you look through these Provinces one by one with a jocular or a serious comment—and what is jocular is serious very often—one can point to the very great problems which lie ahead of the inauguration of provincial governments in India. We have in the many disputes of the past ranged ourselves against the principle of provincial government in India. It is true that we considered always that this attempt to make India prosperous by spending a great deal of money and by constitutional theories would not give the best results to the Indian people, and that we would have been glad if this process could have been postponed until the long-past Montagu reforms had actually proved to yield satisfactory results. But still, in the course of these debates, we always offered to the Government our support, if they had need of it, for the provincial scheme, provided that it was separated from the federal scheme. Therefore, we do not at all oppose what is being done to-day. If an experiment is to be made, the sooner it is made the better, and the sooner the results come in the better the House will be able to judge the possibility of going forward into the federal scheme. My right hon. Friend has approved himself—not immodestly in any way, for he gave credit to others—for the accuracy of the forecast of the cost of the Constitution. He said that the figure of £3,500,000 was the same figure he indicated to the House more than a year ago. The Government of India do not say that. They say in their report, paragraph 3:

The figures of the initial cost are in excess of anything that the Government of India have hitherto contemplated.