Government Of India Act, 1935 And Government Of Burma Act, 1935.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

12 June 1936 · House of Commons debate · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on June 12, 1936, in the debate on the Government of India and Burma Acts, warning of financial limits on the new provincial governments and urging caution before federation.
Main themes
Niemeyer Report on Indian finances, provincial governments in India, Government of India Act 1935, financial limits on provincial social services, railway solvency and customs revenue, wider franchise and election promises, caution before a Federal Constitution, Lord Linlithgow as new Viceroy, improving Indian agriculture, Government of India Act and Burma Act
Duration
~11 min
40th percentile
Words
1,364
40th percentile
Sentences
56
37th percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 39%29%
  • Institutional 34%25%
  • Ceremonial 12%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%5%
  • Social 7%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 27%

56 sentences in 28 paragraphs

To be extremely cautious is not necessary in order to achieve that laudible aim of embarking upon mis-statements. It is not always considered the best thing to do, because they say that the figures are in excess of anything they have ever contemplated. Then they proceed to a series of slammings and bangings of the cupboard door which, taken in series, amount to a veritable bombardment. In paragraph 3 are the words:

no question of increasing in any appreciable degree the total of the initial assistance recommended.

In paragraph 4, they say:

Inevitably these estimates are invested with great uncertainty.

A little lower down:

There still falls to be considered the position of the railways and the possibility of the law of diminishing returns setting in in connection with Customs revenue.

As regards the railways, they say in paragraph 5:

The Government of India have no hesitation in saying that, unless their solvency on the basis of a full commercial accounting system can be restored, and that before very long, the latter stages of the programme envisaged by Sir Otto Niemeyer will be quite impossible of execution.

I think that it is a great thing not to be carried away by enthusiasm. The Government are quite right in keeping a strong hold on the enthusiasm which may be welling in their bosom and not allowing themselves to be put in a position in which they can be afterwards reproached for being too sanguine about the success of the scheme. As regards Customs, paragraph 6 says:

The general level of the tariff is now so high that the maintenance of the aggregate yield, which is by far the most important single factor in the whole revenue position, has become a somewhat precarious task.

However, after seting forth these cautionary statements, they say:

They hope, and have fair reason to believe, that Sir Otto's programme is feasible.

They go on to say in paragraph 8:

Sir Otto has rendered it difficult in the next 10 years for the Government of India

590

either to increase its exiguous provision for sinking fund to a reasonable figure or to reduce those indirect taxes which are an undue burden. … Indeed, unless prosperity returns at a quicker pace than now seems likely, both the present Government of India and its Federal successors will find their freedom of action in the financial sphere uncomfortably limited.''

They conclude with the statement:

We wish to make it clear beyond a peradventure"—

President Wilson's historic phrase—

that we see no prospect whatever of being able to undertake additional burdens of this magnitude, or indeed, as we have previously tried to show, of any appreciable size at all.

I do not think that anyone can feel that there is very much cause for us to be exhilarated when we read a Report of this character. It is a very serious Report, and I agree with the tenour of what was said by the hon. Gentleman who represents the Opposition. Here are these Provincial Governments now to be called into being. The elections are to be held on a franchise much wider than has been attempted before in the East. Candidates will be competing against each other in order to be elected, and it will be easy for them to promise that if they are elected they will confer all kinds of benefits in the way of improved social services upon their constituents. Even in the most highly developed political States such things have been known to occur, and it may well be that there will be an orgy of promises in all the elections which take place for the Provincial Governments. When, however, these members arrive at the local legislatures full of hope, full of desire to confer great benefits on those who return them, they will be confronted with this very unpleasant and forbidding situation which the Government of India has been at such pains to outline before them.

I foresee that there may be a most disillusioning moment when they arrive with hopes of hospitals and universities and improvements of every kind in the social services, and they find that the revenues of the Provinces show no expansion and that the succour which may be administered to them from the Centre has already been given in the fullest measure, and that beyond a peradventure it is no use coming back like Oliver Twist to ask for more. I think it will be a shock to all those fine hopes which had been excited of the great advantages of establishing a

591

western democratic system in this large part of Asia. After all, apart from political rights, most people when they throw themselves very heartily into a political programme expect to get something out of it in the way of material well-being. That is the way the Constitution works in this country. But no such hope presents itself to the would be legislators of the Indian Provincial Assemblies. For them a course of severe economy is prescribed, a course of stern restraint and frugal moderation, and no one is more capable of inculcating that policy in the correct terminology than Sir Otto Niemeyer, whom I knew well in the old days as being animated by the most admirable forms of Treasury unsentimentality.

There you are. However, I do not propose to detain the House longer because, as my right hon. Friend the First Lord has said, there is no opposition to this step, no opposition to the establishment of Provincial Governments at the earliest opportunity. I think I speak not only for myself but for some friends with whom I worked last year when I say that we are very glad not to be responsible in any way for this course, upon which, for good or ill—I pray it may be for good—the march of Anglo-Indian affairs has been directed. So the responsibility must rest with those who have had their way, who have had the power, who have taken the action, who have framed great and far-reaching schemes. They have every means at their disposal to carry them into effect and are now in a position to sit back and await the consequences. We shall do nothing to obstruct, to hamper the carrying out of a policy which Parliament has approved and which has recieved the Royal Assent; but I would say that all that has transpired since the Niemeyer Report makes it extremely necessary that we should see very clearly where we are in the Provinces before we hurry on to the further step of a Federal Constitution.

I could not sit down without making one further remark. We have a new Viceroy in India. I think everyone feels that if anything could give them encouragement and confidence in the inauguration of this great departure in India it would be the character and personality of the eminent man who has been chosen to bear the chief responsibility. To him we

592

do extend a measure of the utmost confidence and of encouragement from here. Great as will be the difficulties, we are certain they will have no such good chance of solution in any other hands but his. I have noticed in the public Press the note which Lord Linlithgow struck when he first arrived in India, as to the great importance of improving the yield and fertility of Indian agriculture—a note which has earned him the honourable title of "The Peasants' Viceroy," as the talk is said to go in the Indian bazaars. If the British Government with its raj will once again endeavour to manifest itself through the healing, fertilising, revivifying processes of stimulating agriculture and improving the conditions of the horribly poor toiling masses of India, if it can make two blades of grass grow where one grew before and can serve two drops of water where before there was only one—if that is the policy associated with the British raj and all his officers and lieutenants, believe me it has a far greater chance of rallying India and Indian interests to the British Crown than the most elaborate constitutional experiments which the ingenuity of constitution-mongers can devise.