Foreign Office.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

11 July 1935 · House of Commons debate on foreign affairs · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on July 11, 1935, in a foreign affairs debate, criticising the Government's naval agreement with Germany as a departure from collective security and the Stresa understanding.
Main themes
Anglo-German naval agreement, German treaty breaking on armaments, collective security through the League of Nations, Stresa declaration, confidence between Britain and France, inferiority of British air defence, Italian threat to Abyssinia, criticism of Labour Opposition speech, tribute to the late Foreign Secretary, new Foreign Secretary's survey of world affairs
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,689
49th percentile
Sentences
56
37th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 80%80%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

56 sentences in 15 paragraphs

I have some comments to make upon the recent conduct of foreign affairs which, I cannot disguise at the outset, may be deemed to be of a critical character, but I must say that I do not find myself in any closer agreement with the speech which has just been delivered by the right hon. Gentleman who speaks for the Labour Opposition. It was a speech which certainly was entirely devoid of any kind of constructive suggestion. I do not say that private Members, or even Members who speak with great authority for organised parties, are called upon in every speech to make constructive suggestions, and it is a very easy thing for Governments to say, "Let us have your alternative plan." My experience leads me to believe that it is a very great risk for private persons to attempt to offer constructive plans. But still, the right hon. Gentleman, representing as he does a scheme of thought and putting his case so very high, ought, I think, to have given us a little more to build on than the statement that all pacts are useless, that Europe is cumbered with the litter of pacts, and, at the same time, that we ought to join with the small nations as

541

far as possible in endeavouring to secure that reign of law and that inauguration of permanent peace which his adherents desire and which is the common property of us all.

I do not quite agree with the right hon. Gentleman, I must say, in his references to the late Foreign Secretary. I have criticised him, and I shall no doubt criticise his successor, but I certainly think it is very unfair to try to pile upon a single man the blame for all the awful transformation and degeneration which has occurred in European affairs and in world affairs during the last four or five years. Certainly I feel that the late Foreign Secretary devoted to his task talents which are not easily to be rivalled by any one in this House, and a sincere, profound desire for peace and for working for peace, in pursuance of which he has made sacrifices which have never been surpassed by any Member now sitting on the Front Opposition Bench, except perhaps the Leader of the Opposition himself. No; I hope that we shall not go about imagining that we are going to make our discussion of these matters any easier by simply trying to throw upon a single man the blame for events which all men have so far found themselves unable to contain or to control.

I listened to the speech of my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs. I have seen a great deal of him this Session. I hope he will not mind my saying that, in spite of my differences with him on India, I rather wish he had remained to see that important matter through, but at any rate he may be quite sure that no friction engendered in those Debates will or should in the slightest degree prejudice any of those who may differ from him on the India matter. We all hope his tenure of the Foreign Office—indeed, we have no alternative but to hope, for what choice have we, considering that all our interests are in the matter and all our lives and fortunes are in the matter?—we all hope and pray that he will have good success. It was, therefore, with those sentiments that I listened to his speech, and I do not think anyone could find positive fault with that speech. It certainly was a survey of the world designed to deal with these different matters in such a way as to leave calmer and quieter feelings behind. If it did

542

not, as I agree, face the grave issues which exist, it certainly was designed to have a pacifying and soothing effect, and for the right hon. Gentleman who spoke for the Opposition to pretend that it was a sort of speech of a Mr. Hyde reverting to old, pre-war, jingo, Imperialistic policy, and as it were to class the right hon. Gentleman and the entirely well meaning, blameless, and peace-minded Government whom he represents with the kind of Imperialist dictatorships of Europe, is an absurdity which has only to be presented to win the universal condemnation which it deserves.

My right hon. Friend began his speech by saying that he would leap into the deep end of the pool and not go to the shallow part where the platitudes and generalities exist. I do not blame him that, after a few vigorous strokes in the deeper end, he found himself swimming in the part which is more usually frequented, the safer part of the bathing pool. As I say, we must wish him well in his task, and to say that we welcome him arriving in his position is not, in my opinion, to cast an invidious reflection upon the man whom he has succeeded. I do not think that when Ministers leave great Departments it should be supposed that it means that they have failed or that they are thereby humiliated. It may well be that circumstances, which are constantly changing, do require that new agents should come and take a new view at particular moments, and I am sure that the House will not support ungenerous attempts to blame on an individual what after all is beyond the compass of any human being.

I now must say that when we last discussed foreign affairs I thought there was very general agreement. We were agreed, or we seemed to be agreed, to what had been done at Stresa, the declaration of comradeship between the three great Powers that met at Stresa. We were agreed, I think, in supporting the action of the Government in joining in the resolution of the League of Nations condemning treaty breaking by Germany in the matter of armaments. We were agreed to work in combination through the League of Nations for those principles of collective security—real collective security—which mean that the contributions to that security shall be

543

adequate to give a sense of relief and assurance to all. I thought we were all agreed on that. I found myself in closer relation to His Majesty's Government on foreign affairs than I had been in the whole of this Parliament. Curiously enough it seemed to me that the last act of the late Prime Minister—who is now Lord President—in foreign affairs, in making his comments on the Stresa negotiations, made him more truly the mouthpiece of British feeling and British interest than ever before. We have now heard a speech from the Foreign Secretary which, I say, in no way conflicts with those general principles which were established when we last discussed foreign affairs.

Meanwhile, however, a number of things have happened which do conflict most markedly with those general principles, which the right hon. Gentleman has recited to us to-day. The scene is gravely changed. We have condoned, and even praised, the German treaty breaking in fleet building. I see that Lord Beatty, speaking somewhere else, said that we ought to be grateful to Germany for not having demanded 50 per cent. On that basis we ought to be more grateful that they did not demand 100 per cent. We have condoned this unilateral violation of the Treaty, and we have become a party to it without agreement with any of the other contries concerned. We have, however unintentionally, nullified and stultified the League of Nations' condemnation of treaty breaking in respect of armaments, in which we were ourselves concerned, in which, indeed, we took a leading part. We have, it seems to me, revealed, again quite unintentionally, a very considerable measure of indifference to the interests of other Powers, particularly Powers in the Baltic, who were encouraged by our example to join with us in the League of Nations in condemning treaty breaking. Our defence has been made by the right hon. Gentleman, and it is, I gather, that we have taken this step and made this naval agreement, as he said, for our own advantage and security. Of course, he contends, and rightly contends, that it is in many respects not necessarily contrary to the advantage and security of others. But, at any rate, it is an entirely separate action. I must say a word later about

544

this naval agreement and the alleged advantages which we are supposed to have derived from it. For the moment, I only refer to them to bring to the notice of the Committee that we have in this matter, in the name of what is called practical realism, seemed to depart from the principle of collective security in a very notable fashion.

We have seemed to depart from—although I hope we may return again to—the comradeship agreed upon at Stresa and from the League of Nations resolution against Treaty-breaking, and we have done it in order to make a side deal with Germany which we thought to be in our interests, and not contrary to other interests in Europe. We cannot have done this without affecting prejudicially—although, again, I hope only for the time being—the confidence which exists between us and France, which is so vitally necessary for us at all times, but never more vitally necessary for us than during these years upon which we are now entering, when our air defence will be so woefully inferior to that of Germany. It is not a very good tale which I have had to tell of what has happened since we last had a full dress debate on foreign affairs. But it is only one part of the story. At the same time that we have been diverging from the League of Nations in one direction for our particular and legitimate national interest, real or supposed, Italy has made it plain that she means to invade and conquer Abyssinia. I hope that the optimism of the right hon. Gentleman the Leader of the Liberal party may be borne out.