- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on April 21, 1936, criticising the Colonial Secretary's equivocal assurances on possible colonial transfers, especially Tanganyika, and urging the Government to rule them out firmly.
- Main themes
- Possible transfer of Tanganyika, Colonial Secretary's assurances, closed versus open question of colonial transfers, need for a clear government negation, parliamentary opportunities for backbenchers, Supply days and Opposition control of debate time, British investment in Tanganyika, expectations raised among powerful foreign states, Chancellor of the Exchequer's answer, tribute to the Member for Smethwick for raising the debate
- Duration
- ~9 min
- Words
- 1,121
- Sentences
- 47
- Readability
- 67
- Grade
- 8.8
- Syntax
- 3.06
- Vocabulary
- 1.97
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other47 sentences in 9 paragraphs
When my right hon. Friend the Colonial Secretary had got about three-quarters through his speech, I was feeling very exhilarated by his breezy style. It was a great satisfaction to hear him expose the many very patent errors which bulked largely in the impromptu extempore speech, as he called it, of the hon. Member for Gower (Mr. Grenfell). Indeed, so successful was my right hon. Friend in flinging the arguments back across the Table, and so robust were the sentiments he expressed on many topics, one really felt that in these days when they talk about the retirement of a Prime Minister, if the Conservative party had to look for a champion he was, at that stage in his speech, at any rate, not disqualifying himself from that position. As my right hon. Friend approached the latter part of his speech—the last lap, I might say—he flagged terribly. It was quite evident that while he was dealing with the attacks of his old friends across the way he was very much master of the situation, but when he came to give the assurances which have been asked for by Members on this side of the House, we saw the spectacle of a good man wrestling with adversity. My right hon. Friend floundered about from one side to the other and he did what one is often forced to do in these circumstances—he tried to have the best of both worlds.
What was the impression which my right hon. Friend gave? It was certainly that this was not a closed question. I very much regret that that was the impression left upon my mind. That is exactly why this Debate has been raised, and I think we owe a debt to my hon. Friend the Member for Smethwick (Mr. Wise) for having taken advantage of this opportunity. I do not at all agree with the hon. Gentleman opposite that this is not a fitting occasion to raise this matter. Parliamentary time is much congested, and here we had an opportunity which might not easily recur. The Leader of the Opposition and the Leader of the Liberal party have the disposition of 20 Supply days, and very often, I am glad to say, they consider the general wishes of the House in exercising that power. They also have the opportunity of Votes of Censure and opportunities of practically guiding the discussions on going into Committee of Supply, and on
102
other questions. Many Members who sit on this side, however, have no means whatever of bringing forward questions. Sometimes they may number as many as the Labour party, and yet they have no means of bringing them forward. Therefore, they are not only justified but bound to take advantage of what otherwise would have been a wasted evening from six o'clock onwards to inaugurate a discussion which has been of considerable interest and of real importance, and which has been attended by a large number of earnest Members of the House. Therefore, I am very grateful to my hon. Friend for having done it.
What is the anxiety that is in our minds? It is the very anxiety which the last five minutes of the Colonial Secretary's speech emphasised: the question is not a closed question. It ought to be. If there were any question about which the Government should have a clear, definite, resolute conviction, it is this particular question. A door should be either open or shut. It should not be flapping to and fro to see whether there is anyone pushing or whether he is pushing hard enough. We could have no greater danger at this time than the excitement of all kinds of hopes and expectations in the breasts of powerful people abroad, and then, when they come and propose their plans, as they may do very soon, and quote all you have said, you will perhaps be forced by Parliamentary pressure to give the plain answer which ought to be given now. Then the matter will have got into a much more serious condition, and you will have reached a stage when something in the nature of an affront may take the place of what at the present time can be a very reasonable, simple and easy diplomatic negation. Therefore, I very much regret the last part of my right hon. Friend's speech. Not only does it justify this Debate, but it makes it clear that the matter cannot stop here. Some of my hon. and right hon. Friends who take a great interest in this matter will do their utmost to clarify this issue.
I am sure that my right hon. Friend has his heart in the right place on this subject, and I trust that he will do his utmost to represent to his colleagues what has passed in this Debate. What is the use of telling us, with regard to
103
some person who is to invest money in Tanganyika, that the right hon. Gentleman was able to say, "On the whole, you may go ahead; you need not be worried"? Nobody supposes that if this colony were transferred the actual investments of British subjects would be at once expropriated. The mere fact that this matter has been discussed in these terms shows how extremely uncertain the position is. I was disappointed in the answer of the Chancellor of the Exchequer the other night. I do not read into it more than it meant. With a great deal of that answer I agree. I thought that my right hon. Friend marshalled in a very calm and effective manner a large number of defensive positions and set up a great number of conditions which would have to be satisfied before it was possible that any transfer could take place. But, believe me, you will do far better to say that you are not going to have any transfers. That is the path of safety. If you go dangling these things about you will have many a strong hand reaching out to clutch them from you.
We have succeeded to some extent this evening, but let it be merely a preliminary debate which the fortunes of the afternoon have given us. This subject must be pressed forward on every occasion and by all the opportunities that the procedure of the House permits. I thank the right hon. Gentleman for some of the statements he has made, and I earnestly hope that we may have his continued aid and assistance in this matter, but I must not leave him under the impression that the words he used in the latter part of his speech leave anything but a feeling of grave anxiety on the part of many Members.
