- Context
- Churchill, a backbench Member, addressed the House of Commons in London on April 23, 1936, criticising government delay on defence preparation and presenting estimates of German rearmament spending of about £800,000,000 in 1935.
- Main themes
- Delay in appointing a Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, absence of a Ministry of Supply, trade union co-operation on dilution and apprenticeship, profiteering in rearmament, German expenditure on warlike preparations, estimates of £800,000,000 spent in 1935, German capital expenditure and national income figures, Chancellor's Budget warning of flames, Supplementary Estimates debate, Europe approaching a climax, a strongly armed Britain and peace
- Duration
- ~12 min
- Words
- 1,429
- Sentences
- 64
- Readability
- 54
- Grade
- 11.4
- Syntax
- 2.99
- Vocabulary
- 2.13
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other64 sentences in 13 paragraphs
I gladly welcome the right hon. Gentleman's accession to the appeal that I have made to him. I have no reason to cavil at anything that he has said about what has happened in the past. I also hope that, when the Supplementary Estimates come on, they will not be interpreted in a narrow sense but will be so used by the House as to throw open a broad discussion on these matters so vital to our safety. When these opportunities come, we shall have to examine the programmes; we shall have to examine how they are being executed and how far they are falling short either of what was planned or of what we need. If there have been neglects in the past, we must endeavour to establish accountability, and we have to look back upon a record of many squandered weeks and months. If the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence had been appointed list year, when Parliament asked for it, he would have had a great advantage to-day in the work that he has to do. If a separate Ministry of Supply or Ministry of Munitions had been set up a year ago, it would have been working actively now. Nothing has been done. Even now no steps are being taken. I read in a paper to-day that no meeting had yet taken place between the Government and trade unions in regard to questions of apprenticeship and dilution and transference, without settling which you cannot possibly expand your munitions production. You cannot do anything without a working arrangement with the trade unions and here we are on this day of April, 1936, and it is said that no meeting has yet taken place upon that matter. Nothing effective has been done about profiteering. I regard it as impossible to carry out this process of putting our affairs in good order and our defences in a state of security without the co-operation of the trade unions. You will not get the effective co-operation of the working people unless you can make
337
sure that there are not a lot of greedy fingers having a rake-off. We are still drifting and dawdling as the precious months flow out.
Meanwhile what is happening abroad? The Chancellor of the Exchequer used a most grievous expression when he said we could already feel the heat of the flames upon our faces. That is a formidable expression to be used by a Minister who is characteristically restrained in his language on the important occasion of the opening of the Budget. I have for a long time past made what I consider grave and startling statements about Germany's expenditure on warlike preparations. I obtained my information originally from a source which I cannot divulge. I have, however, attempted to check it with a great many other points of view from every possible quarter, and I will give the Committee the result of my labours, in which I have been assisted by very able people, in good faith. A private Member has not the resources that are open to the Government, but I give the results for what they are worth.
From the end of March, 1933, to the end of June, 1935, the official publications of the German Government show an increase in the public debt to a minimum figure of over seven milliards of reichsmarks, to which must be added the yield from increased taxation in that period, which has been used for Government expenditure, and which amount to five milliards. Therefore, the minimum expenditure for 2½ years above the preceding Budget expenditure is 12 milliards, or £1,000,000,000 at the official rate of exchange. That is all that is acknowledged, but there are two other lines of approach which suggest that that figure is far below the actual fact. A veto prevails in Germany on all expansion of private plant for purely economic purposes. The capital expenditure of Germany other than for residential buildings may, therefore, be regarded as almost exclusively devoted to warlike preparations, in which, of course, I include the preparation of those great military roads where four columns of troops can march abreast, which may play a greater part in a future war than the fortifications that are being built.
Again, taking the figures from German official sources, the expenditure on capital account, deducting the expendi-
338
ture on residential buildings, has been as follows In 1933, nearly five milliards of marks; in 1934, nearly eight milliards of marks; and in 1935, nearly 11 milliards, a total of 24 milliards, or roughly £2,000,000,000. I am taking the rate of exchange at 12 marks to the pound, and I am thus making allowance for the fact that armament production is much cheaper in Germany than it is here. Wages are much lower. Look at those figures—five, eight and eleven for the three years. They give you exactly the kind of progession which a properly developing munitions industry would take.
There is a second line of approach to these figures. There is a marked increase in the German national income. Again I take this from official German figures. The increase in the national income has not gone into consumption. Wages have remained unchanged and the cost of living, if anything, has risen. Therefore, the increase in the national income has gone into constructional work, the bulk of which is represented directly or indirectly, I am led to believe, by armaments. Look at these figures of the increase in the figures of the German national income—in 1933, 1,200,000,000 reichsmarks; in 1934, 7,000,000,000 reichsmarks; and in 1935, 11,500,000,000 reichsmarks—exactly the same progression as I showed in the previous calculation. That is exactly what you would expect from an industry getting on its feet, opening out and finally coming into full blast. These figures make a total, since Herr Hitler came into power, of nearly 20,000,000,000 reichsmarks. The year 1935 shows, on this calculation as well as on the previous one, the same figure of over 11,000,000,000, which is considerably over the £800,000,000 which I have for some months past been bruiting about the country.
There are other means by which this progress can be checked. There is the number of persons employed in the armament and cognate industries and in the military forces. There has also been an elaborate investigation into the number of stamps which have been affixed to the three months' bills which are used for effecting this extraordinary process of internal inflation, but that is too complicated to trouble the Committee with now. They will see from what I have
339
said that there is very considerable justification for the startling statement that I have advanced, and to which I most strictly adhere, that £800,000,000 was spent on warlike preparations in 1935 alone. Even if you take off £200,000,000, it does not alter the fact for any purpose with which we are concerned. There remains a disconcerting and alarming figure. Do the Government contradict these figures? Unless my right hon. Friend is able to contradict them specifically and can show reasons why they are wrong, I think my statement might be allowed to stand, and might be taken into the general currency of thought on this topic.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer used an argument about how expenditure would rise to a peak, then fall a little and then remain level but at a much greater height than at the present time. That is not the future as I foresee it. I cannot believe that, after armaments in all countries have reached a towering height, they will settle down and continue at a hideous level far above the present level, which is already crushing and that that will be for many years a normal feature of the world's routine. Whatever happens, I do not believe that will. Europe is approaching a climax. I believe that that climax will be reached in the lifetime of the present Parliament. Either there will be a melting of hearts and a joining of hands between great nations which will set out upon realising the glorious age of prosperity and freedom which is now within the grasp of the millions of toiling people, or there will be an explosion and a catastrophe the course of which no imagination can measure, and beyond which no human eye can see. I believe also that a strongly armed Britain, resolutely and valiantly led, seeking to make for peace but ready to run risks for peace, may conceivably turn the scale between the blessing and the cursing of mankind.
