- Context
- Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on May 4, 1936, during the Navy Supplementary Estimate debate, urging transfer of the Fleet Air Arm to the Admiralty and creation of a Ministry of Supply.
- Main themes
- Transfer of the Fleet Air Arm to the Royal Navy, 1933 decision on naval air control, independence of the Air Force, overburdened Air Ministry and Air Staff, expansion of the Air Force, air-mindedness of naval officers, proposed Ministry of Supply, coordination of aircraft orders, Ministry of Munitions precedent
- Duration
- ~7 min
- Words
- 813
- Sentences
- 28
- Readability
- 58
- Grade
- 12.1
- Syntax
- 3.16
- Vocabulary
- 1.98
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other28 sentences in 8 paragraphs
It does not seem to be so from the figures I have just quoted of the enormous force in the possession of the Admiralty at the end of the War. However, in those days there was a feeling in the Navy rather antagonistic to the development of the Air Force, and that is why I took the matter into my own personal hands and forced it through with my hon. and gallant Friend's assistance. But I think those days are done, and from all that I hear there is no body of His Majesty's subjects more air-minded and more keen upon the air than the admirals and officers of the Fleet at the present time. They are burning to get their hands upon this. They are sure they can make much more of it than is being made in the present circumstances.
I do not condemn the decision which was taken in 1933. I was not in office at the time, but I can see it was a very reasonable decision to take in the circumstances at that moment. Then the Air Force was small, working under conditions of economy, and the important thing was that it should be strong enough to stand upon its own footing. If the Naval Air arm had been cut away from it, it might well have been that the rest of it would have been given to the Army, and the idea of an independent Air Force
1418
and Air Ministry would have vanished altogether, which would have been a great disaster, because one can see now that the Air Force, so far from being a mere appendage of other services is perhaps going to swallow up many forms of war upon land and upon water. Therefore, I do not reproach those who were responsible for the decision which was taken in 1920 and 1923. But the whole condition has absolutely changed. In the first place, so far from being underworked, the Air Ministry is the most over-burdened Ministry in the country, and the Air Staff is the most over-burdened staff. They are doubling, tripling, quadrupling the Air Force as fast as it can be done. Heaven forbid that I should make any invidious distinction in this, but I must say I do not think there is any one of the three fighting Departments whose Staff and Ministry is more overweighted by the pressure of work upon them at the present moment than the Air Ministry and the Air Staff. Surely they should be relieved of this. Surely, you should hand over this complicated Service, with so many variations which differentiate from the Army or the Air Service, to the great, powerful, well-established Department which is longing to assume full responsibility, I am sure you will get a very effective, rich and rapid reward if you will take this step. After all these are matters in which the Navy have an immense interest. One of the reasons why I urge this course is that I believe it would add to the air power, would increase the general output and development of your power, and bring new resources of energy and organisation to the development of this new modern weapon.
I could not leave the topic without mentioning the question of supply, for otherwise my right hon. and learned Friend would say, "Look at the confusion which will arise in the aircraft factories when the two Departments are bidding against one another and overlapping in their orders and so on." That would be true, if the matter were left there, but I have advised my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister for the last six months—and I should have thought it was pretty plain six months before—that we ought to create a proper Ministry of Supply, not necessarily on the great scale of the Ministry of Munitions, but on the same lines. There ought to be a Ministry of
1419
Supply which would make a great many of the articles for the different Services.
Certainly when we come to a Debate on the more general Votes, I propose to address the Committee, with their indulgence, upon the details of a Ministry of Munitions and Supply, and show how essential it is to the proper development of our programmes at the present time. Therefore, in suggesting that the Fleet Air Arm should be transferred to the Royal Navy, I am also considering that as an essential part of it there should be established a Ministry of Supply to which both Services would give their orders, for which both Services would lay their requirements—both the Air Ministry and the Admiralty—and whose work would be co-ordinated under the Ministry, or another Minister, or a Deputy of his, in the way that it was done during the war. I am grateful to the Committee for having listened to me for so long.
