- Context
- Churchill, then a backbench Conservative MP, spoke in the House of Commons Budget debate in London on April 23, 1936, comparing finances since 1929 and criticising the slow pace of rearmament.
- Main themes
- 1936 Budget debate, comparison of British finance in 1929 and 1936, abandonment of Gladstonian finance, Free Trade and adoption of Protection, Income Tax and Surtax yields, Sinking Fund and unemployment insurance, growth of civil expenditure and social services, inadequacy of rearmament spending, air parity and defence loan, peace conditions and the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, allocation of Supply Days for defence debates
- Duration
- ~32 min
- Words
- 3,820
- Sentences
- 153
- Readability
- 60
- Grade
- 10.7
- Syntax
- 3.13
- Vocabulary
- 2.15
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other153 sentences in 35 paragraphs
I think that the hon. Member who has just addressed us with such a mass of information and wealth of imagery must make the hon. Member for West Fife (Mr. Gallacher) rather anxious for his laurels. I know that there is a great gulf between the hon. Member for Shettleston (Mr. McGovern) and the hon. Member for West Fife. There is another great gulf between him and those who sit above the Gangway on the Labour benches. But I am bound to say that it seems to me that the hon. Member has all the qualifications, the aptitude, the modes of speech, the inexhaustible vivacity and rhetoric which would qualify him to deprive the hon. Member for West Fife, at any moment he chose, of the leadership of the Communist party. I know that he will forgive me if I do not attempt to deal with all the points in his statement, but I have no doubt they will be very carefully considered in all quarters of the Committee.
327
I have listened to a deal of this Debate on the Budget. It seems to me that it has followed the usual course of Budget Debates. As I remember Budget debates the Chancellor of the Exchequer always makes a very good speech, which is very well received. The House hangs with bated breath on his words until he reaches the concluding stages of his oration. Then always, for the next two or three days, there is one long dreary drip of disparaging declamation, if I may paraphrase an expression of Mr. Glad-stone's. All those who have been benefited by the Budget naturally remain silent, lest worse things should occur; all those who have been injured by the Budget are clamant and vociferous; and all those who are not affected one way or the other are disaffected.
To-day I am not going to join in the chorus of captious criticism. I am not even going to criticise my right hon. friend's treatment of the Raid Fund—I mean the Road Fund. That is the sort of thing that slips off one's tongue in an unguarded moment, but I agree with the Chancellor that it is a monstrous assertion that any important body of taxpayers should claim proprietary rights over the particular quota of taxation which they contribute, and that all should not be brought into an area freely justiciable by the House of Commons. The pioneers who blaze the trial are those who suffer. I was lacerated by the thorns and bruised by the falling branches, but I opened the path along which the right hon. Gentleman has advanced with great dignity and general acceptance. To some the dust, to others the palm. But I do not begrudge him, because I think that in this matter he has taken a course which will commend itself to the good sense of the Committee and which is also in the public interest.
Not having for a good many years taken part in these Budget Debates I was naturally interested to see what changes had occurred since the time when I used to be responsible for the finances of the country. We usually look back to the previous year, but sometimes there is an advantage in looking back over longer periods, because one can see the whole scene. I will not say that distance lends enchantment to it, but if you step back a little way you can see the whole scene. By going back a few years you get a
328
broader base for triangulation. You can judge more clearly where you have gone and where you are going by taking a glance back into the past. Therefore, I will venture to offer to the Committee a few comparisons between the state of affairs in 1929 and those which prevail to-day.
Since 1929, not only the entire structure but the whole character of British finance has been transformed. Controversies disputed for generations have been settled. Practices hitherto condemned have been adopted by general consent. Vast new sources of revenue have been opened and expedients have been adopted for regulating the exchanges by secret processes —and have been successfully adopted. We have shaken ourselves entirely free from the whole Gladstonian structure and tradition of finance, for good or for ill, but no one would deny that we have done it. Principles universally accepted and generally observed in this country down to 1929, all of them so far as I can make out, have been abandoned. What was the old plan? The old plan was Free Trade; no taxation except for revenue; lowering the cost of living by every means that the Minister of Agriculture could conceive; the Gold Standard, of blessed memory; an enormous Sinking Fund, and strict and punctual discharge of international obligations. All these were features of that vanished scene. All are gone, "unwept, unhonoured and unsung." All those rules by which all the Chancellors of every party, except in wartime, were rigidly bound, have now been swept away. How Mr. Gladstone, Sir Stafford Northcote and Sir Michael Hicks-Beach, gifted, all of them, with very forceful modes of expression, would have received the information which these Budget Papers convey! How they would stare if this could all be explained to them!
I am going to reveal a mystery to the Committee. I was the last orthodox Chancellor of the Victorian epoch. I cannot admit the claims of Lord Snowden. That episode I regard as a deplorable interlude. I feel that I am entitled to ask the Committee to recognise in me the last of the Mohicans. You did not think so at the time, but judge these matters in the calm light of the future and in retrospect and you will see that the claim, perhaps a melancholy one,
329
which I put in, ought in justice to be conceded. Look at the changes since 1929. Now we are a Protectionist country. We have a substantial Tariff, which no doubt we shall raise higher as the years pass by. The Gold Standard is not only dead, but it has been relegated for a long period to purgatory. We have no Sinking Fund, except the somewhat fortuitous balance of the last year's surplus. We have greatly increased our taxation, and we have dealt with the American Debt liability in a manner which, I am bound to say, no one would have tolerated in the years for which I was responsible. Those are very remarkable occurrences. Merely to recount them makes one rub one's eyes.
But let us look at the causes which have forced, and which have facilitated, these astounding changes. Since 1929, in common with many other countries, we have sustained prodigious misfortunes in the financial and economic sphere. In a catalogue they produce a staggering effect: unemployment is doubled; our foreign trade is halved; our carrying trade, shipping and shipbuilding, is woefully reduced; Lancashire is broken; the cotton trade to India, once the glory of our exports as a whole, has fallen to a quarter of what it was in 1929—only yesterday. A dark cloud of economic privation envelops the once brilliant North. The income from foreign investments, that steady flow which yielded such a nourishment to our revenue and was a noticeable feature in supporting our incomparable social services, has shrunk by more than 25 per cent. If the Treasury of 1929 could have foreseen the tremendous financial and economic misfortunes which were coming upon us, which were about to fall upon us in common with other countries, I believe they would have felt that the difficulties, looked at in their advent, were insurmountable.
To-day, we meet in circumstances when we can say that they have been surmounted. Our Budget is balanced; the Chancellor presents a surplus realised and prospective; credit was never higher; the rent of money has fallen to levels rivaling the palmy days of Queen Victoria; the cost of living, in spite of some well-meant efforts to the contrary, remains low relatively to wages; banks are gorged full with unprecedented accumulations;
330
London is again, after the scandalous crisis of 1931, and in spite of the treatment to which I have been forced to refer about the American Debt, still regarded as the safest asylum for international credit and for cosmopolitan gold. Our feeling to-day should be one of broad thankfulness. I certainly feel that. I do not think that, in that thankfulness, we should fail to include the Chancellor of the Exchequer, who has not only presided over that recovery but has contributed to it in notable ways, both negative and constructive. My right hon. Friend has had several rough years to go through, and several rough years to make us all go through, but we have little doubt, and latterly it has become quite clear and is admitted and felt in all parts of the House, that his stewardship of the National Finances has been a high and memorable success. We rejoice that in his fifth Budget he is able to present a position of exceptional financial strength to meet an exceptional public danger. If anything like the same forethought and circumspection, the same indifference to changing gusts of superficial opinion, the same search for truth and the same contact with reality had been shown in the maintenance of our defences and in the conduct of our foreign affairs, I believe it is no exaggeration to say that not only our own condition but the condition of all Europe would be far better to-day.
I do not suggest that our financial and economic structure has not suffered injury. We have recovered, but we bear the scars. I will try to make a few comparisons in detail between the actual receipts of 1928–29, the last year for the full results of which I was responsible, and those of 1935–36. It is rather remarkable that the total Inland Revenue for those two years is almost identical. It was £406,000,000 then and it is £404,000,000 now. It is very remarkable, after all that has happened, that that same figure should be maintained. But there is a certain qualification to which I must draw the attention of the Committee. My right hon. Friend got £238,000,000 last year out of Income Tax, against my £237,500,000, but he has to charge 4s. 6d. in the £ to get it, whereas it was yielded by 4s. in those bygone days. My right hon. Friend got, in Super-tax and Surtax. £51,000,000 against £56,000,000 which was obtained by a
331
lower rate of Surtax, and without the additional and usually—I would say invariably—forgotten, except by those who pay it, additional Surtax of 10 per cent. Therefore, you have a higher rate but a substantially smaller revenue.
It seems to me that there are various explanations, but one of them stands out very plainly, and that is that the enormously high rates at which Income and Super-tax now stands do not yield the same proportional result as they did upon the lower rate. The higher you have to go, the greater the burden imposed upon the taxpayer; yet you get a less yield to the Exchequer. If, for instance, the times were happier and we were able substantially to reduce the Income Tax and the Super-tax, it is my personal belief—I have thought about it a good deal and had some experience—that the loss to the Revenue would be far less than the gain to national well-being and employment. It would be a help to the Committee if my right hon. Friend when he winds up the Debate this evening could tell us what are the comparable yields per ld. on the Income Tax, between the last year of the late Conservative Government before the great tumult of our financial and economic affairs took place, and at the present time. It is clear that the yield has markedly declined.
For this reason, if I were seeking to criticise, I might deplore what is called "that threepence," and I might wonder whether my right hon. Friend might not have taken a more expansive view of the Revenue—it was pointed out by my hon. Friend the Member for Huddersfield (Mr. Mabane) that the right hon. Gentleman last year under-estimated it by nearly £20,000,000—and could have left the standard rate unchanged until the great re-armament expenses came home, or until the inevitable Defence Loan is floated. I do not wish to set my judgment against his. I admired very much some years ago his standing against the currents of opinion in these matters, and now we see he gets the advantage of having done so; but we may be sure that whenever a Chancellor of the Exchequer does an unpopular thing he is probably right, and you may be absolutely certain that, whenever he does a popular thing, he is invariably wrong. Therefore, I am not going to set my judgment against his,
332
and I do not feel that this is a time when anyone can offer resistance to taxation which is undoubtedly required for national defence.
I have been dealing with the Inland Revenue, but it is when we look at the Customs and Excise that we see the most striking changes. My right hon. Friend got last year nearly £80,000,000 more in Customs Duties than I did in 1928–29. That, of course, is due to the fact that we have become decisively what is called a moderate-tariff country. I am sorry that the Leader of the Liberal party has now gone out of the House; or rather I should say I am glad, because I am sure he would not like what I am now going to say. It seems to me to be probable that protection of the home market has been decisive in enabling an increased fertility of internal trade to compensate us for the curtailment of oversea trade, even if it has at the same time somewhat aggravated that curtailment. Thus, from the point of view of the internal market, and from the point of view of providing us with an immense revenue which anyone can see we could not possibly do without, the reversion to a general system of Protection appears to me to have been fully justified by the times in which we live. Moreover, as one who for the greater part of his active life has been a convinced Free Trader, and still reasons as one, I am one of those who whole-heartedly support the Protectionist experiment, without divorcing myself in theory from Free Trade. No one doubts for a moment that we have definitely taken up our position as a moderate-tariff country, and it is folly to try to re-open the question at this time. I hope and trust that, now that we have embarked on Protection, the Government will try to make a success of it—that, now that we have embarked upon Protection, they will apply a scientific study to it, and that they will do what they think is right in science, and not just think how far they can carry certain Free Trade members of the Government with them. There is no scientific point in that. I do not understand at all those who suggest that in the present circumstances we should have as little of it as we can. There is no sense in that. Let us have whatever is the best interpretation of the new theories which are now established,
333
and which are going to last all our lives—which are not going to be removed in our lifetime. The hon. Member is a very young man. They certainly will not be removed in the lifetime of any of the older Members of the House, and it is essential that they should be given as fair a chance as were the strict theories of bygone years. It seems to me that this system has been justified, and there is this admission that ought to be made. I gladly admit that the fears that we had in bygone years about corruption, lobbying and monopoly creeping in in the wake of a tariff have been unfounded, and that the apparatus of the Tariff Board— They do not come to me, and if at any time the hon. Gentleman is molested, pray let him invoke the support of his fellow Members to free himself from any entanglements into which he may be led. The apparatus of the Tariff Board has worked with the cleanliness, healthiness and decency which characterise so much of our British administration. If all this be true, as I think it is, it certainly conduces to the credit of my right hon. Friend in a manner that is not only personal but hereditary, and must, therefore, be a double source of satisfaction to him.
There are two other changes which I must note. The Budget of 1928–29 had a Sinking Fund of about £60,000,000. That is still suspended. Where has it gone to? I am not, of course, asking about each identical one of these millions which may have been transferred to another part of the Budget, but where, broadly speaking, has this £60,000,000 that we used to give to the Sinking Fund gone? It has gone in unemployment insurance—the right hon. Gentleman may shake his head at me; I am only a private Member; but he cannot shake his head at arithmetic. No dictator, even, can say that two and two shall not make four, and the right hon. Gentleman is not a dictator. In my day, £12,000,000 was provided as our quota towards unemployment insurance, and another £12,000,000 was borrowed on the resources of the fund; but £75,000,000 has now to be found for this purpose by the Exchequer. If you look at the Civil Votes since the time of which I am speaking, it will be seen that they have
334
risen by nearly £130,000,000, from £223,600,000 to £352,000,000. That is where the Sinking Fund, and a good deal more, has gone to. We must look at these facts. The Chancellor of the Exchequer spoke with pride the day before yesterday about the increasing growth of our social services. I share in that feeling. I will only say about our social services, with the creation and development of which I have been connected off and on for many years, that they must not be considered as a weakening of the strength of the nation, On the contrary, I believe they have greatly added to our strength; I believe they have given us that foundation which is essential to national unity, and without which it would be hopeless for us to attempt to make headway against the many perils which are moving towards us.
I come now to a much graver aspect of our affairs as they were reviewed by the Chancellor of the Exchequer in his Budget speech. We heard a great deal of talk, before Parliament met, about a £300,000,000 loan to put our defences in order, and, above all, to give us air parity with neighbouring countries. In the Defence Debate I pointed out that, owing to the restrictions which were imposed upon us by past neglect on the part of His Majesty's Government—neglect to take heed of the warnings which were so plainly given by Members in many parts of the House—the Government, however urgent their need, however sincere their desire, would not be able to spend any very large sum this year, because the contractors would not be able to earn it. I remember very well that when I said I doubted whether they could spend more than £50,000,000 over and above the current Estimates, I saw a look of incredulity on the faces of many Members of the House. But at the present time it is not £50,000,000 that they can spend; it is only 220,000,000 that can be spent on the air and on the other two branches together. Only £20,000,000 can be spent this year in addition to the Estimates. When the Chancellor announced that the Supplementary Estimate would not in his opinion exceed £20,000,000, he proclaimed the failure and the inadequacy of our defence effort this year. One is told that you cannot spend more under peace conditions, however great the need may be, without disturbing the economic and
335
social life of the country; and I noticed that my right hon. and learned Friend the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence a few days after he had taken up his office, made a very important pronouncement. He explained that he was working under peace conditions. I was much concerned at that statement, and thought it premature for my right hon. and learned Friend to commit himself so early to such a limitation upon his powers.
Surely, the question whether we should continue working under peace conditions depends upon whether working under those conditions will give us the necessary deliveries of our munitions—upon whether the gun plants and the shell plants and, above all, the aeroplane factories, can fulfil the need in time. If they can do so, then peace conditions are no doubt very convenient; but if not, then we must substitute other conditions—not necessarily war conditions, but conditions which would impinge upon the ordinary daily life and business of this country. There are many other conditions apart from war conditions—preparatory conditions, precautionary conditions, emergency conditions—and these must be established in this country if any real progresss is to be made, and if Parliament and the nation are not to find themselves deluded in the future by mere paper programmes and promises which in the result will be found to be utterly unfulfilled. I think my right hon. and learned Friend would have done far better to wait until he had ascertained the actual facts about our defence industries before committing himself to such a very serious contraction of his functions and facilities, and I hope he will not be bound by what he has said if, on further study of the matter, he feels that more facts have been brought to his notice.
All these questions we must examine when we come to the debates on Defence, and I trust that we are going to have proper debates on Defence this year. We independent Conservatives who take an interest in these matters are in a very forlorn position as regards being able to bring to the attention of the House the matters in which we are particularly interested, but the Leaders of the two Oppositions have great facilities, and I trust the right hon. Gentleman opposite will not fail to rise to the level of his public responsibilities and make sure that
336
his authority in the allocation of the different Supply Days is exercised in such a way as to cover, not merely the special views of his party, but the general wishes and requirements of the House of Commons.
