Navy Supplementary Estimate, 1936.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

4 May 1936 · House of Commons debate on the Navy Supplementary Estimate (Committee of Supply) · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on May 4, 1936, during the Navy Supplementary Estimate debate, urging postponement of the battleship vote and transfer of the Fleet Air Arm to Admiralty control.
Main themes
Proposed vote for two new battleships, inquiry into air threat to capital ships, Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, Fleet Air Arm dual control, transfer of Fleet Air Arm to the Admiralty, air reconnaissance for trade protection, deficiencies exposed in the Mediterranean scare, obsolete Fleet Air Arm aircraft, comparison with American and Japanese naval aircraft, Royal Naval Air Service in the First World War
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,080
59th percentile
Sentences
97
61st percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 48%47%
  • Geopolitical 25%25%
  • Economic 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

97 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Any information which I can give I will gladly give. I do not pose as an expert in these matters but as one who is accustomed to judge the opinions of experts. But before I can attend any committee of that kind I should have to be sure that it is a real committee. The hon. Member for Londonderry has told us that the intention of the Admiralty is quite plain. The two battleships are set down; they have made up their minds and Parliament is to be asked to vote the money for them. It is very absurd. Surely this is like a curious reversal of the horse and cart, to which I drew the attention of the Prime Minister some time ago, when he did not appoint the Minister for Coordinating Defence until the Cabinet's defence scheme had been worked out in the fullest detail. Now, apparently, the decision to begin the building of battleships has been taken and yet an inquiry is being held to find out whether or not there is not some serious new danger from the air which will render them so vulnerable as to make it not worth while to construct them. That is unsatisfactory. I ask the Prime Minister: Does he not consider that it would be more reasonable not to vote this particular item this evening? We are not fighting a party question here; we all wish to do the right thing, and the Committee will support the Government to any extent for what they require for naval defence. I think there is very little doubt that the Admiralty will vindicate their case, and nothing will be lost. The money will not be required for some months to come.

We must treat the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence with proper respect and not prejudge his position by taking a vote for the construction of ships which may in two or three months be unable to swim the seas under the concentrated fire of aircraft. The reasonable thing is not to put

1413

this naval item in at the moment but to allow the inquiry to take its course, the experts to be examined and state their case, and before the Admiralty attempt to drive a rivet or lay a keel we shall receive from the new Minister a reasoned statement of the grounds which have led the Government to believe that further construction of battleships is an essential part of the Royal Navy. I hope we shall have an answer. We have not got answers to some of these points previously, but I hope that we shall have an answer from the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence or the Prime Minister.

There is one more question on which I should like to put a few arguments before the Committee. It was raised by the hon. Member for Londonderry—the disposition of the Fleet Air Arm. In the Debate on the introduction of the Naval Estimates I referred to this in conjunction with trade defence. I pointed out that the difficulty was in widening the radius of cruisers in the vast expanses of the ocean. If aeroplanes are flown off cruisers or small aircraft-carriers are attached to small squadrons, it becomes a far easier matter to find out where the potential attacker may be. The radius is tripled or quadrupled for which assurance can be given. On the flat surface of the sea every hostile ship can be discerned, I cannot think of anything more economical in regard to cruisers and finance than that the closest association of air reconnaissance and cruiser action should be maintained in our trade protection cruisers.

I am shocked and grieved to find the bitter dissatisfaction which is felt throughout the naval service, as far as I am aware, at the condition of the Fleet Air Arm and with the relations under which that Arm is now governed. The friction and anomalies of dual control are well known. They are very apparent even in times of peace. What would happen in time of war? The integrity of operational command is vital. Aircraft will play their part in all preliminary movements before a battle altering the whole fortunes of the battle, and they will play their part in trade protection. Ought there not to be a complete association of tactical and operational association between these two branches of the naval service, both essential to the life of the

1414

Fleet and also to the food supplies of these islands? We ought to establish the effective responsibility of the Admiralty for the efficiency and adequacy of the Air service. What would be said if Royal Artillery men manned the guns on board warships or if the signals of the Army were run by the Post Office? There is just as intimate a connection between the Air Force which is used from the ships in connection with the Fleet and the Fleet, as between these other two instrumentalities I have mentioned.

Who commands the naval aeroplane? The sea captain commands it on board ship. The Air Force officer commands it when it has landed at the shore aerodrome. But who commands it in the air? That is a moot point, one of those thorny questions which the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence will have to solve. There is a great confusion of seniority. Sometimes in the aeroplane there are three or four officers of different ranks and different seniorities, holding different Air Force or naval positions. As the aeroplane leaves the ship, flies over the water and alights on land all the relations of these officers on what may become matters of life and death are insensibly altered. I cannot believe that the last word has been spoken on this matter. In war everything is simple, said the Germans, but the simple is very difficult, and wherever you can smooth out these endless complications every effort should be made to do so. I am assured that the dual rank, the dual command, the reversion to another service, the relinquishment of these appointments and the general uncertainty which overly officers in the Fleet Air Arm have caused a great deal of discouragement.

Although there is an immense amount of good will, the difficulties and disadvantages are most plainly recognised. There are two departments which are largely antagonistic. There are Admirals who support the Air Arm and those who say that it cannot hurt a battleship at sea. There is a clash of opinion. The Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence is happily blessed with a strong muscular development; otherwise he might even find himself in personal jeopardy on account of this clash of opinion. All correspondence has to be duplicated, all decisions have to await the concurrence

1415

of both sides, all important new decisions involve inter-departmental communications which involve months of delay; all important routine matters involving interdepartmental committees involve weeks of delay. All orders for stores and supplies for the Fleet Air Arm serving with the ships very often get muddled, and the articles themselves are almost invariably late. The movement of the Fleet does not correspond with the movement of the stores from one particular shore air base to another. For instance, the Fleet moves rapidly, a new concentration has to be effected in any part of the world in a few weeks, but a far longer time is required to make the air organisation conform.

For instance, there is now a Mediterranean cruiser which has its aeroplane administered from Singapore, while another in the same squadron has its aeroplane administered from Bermuda. What are the results of this? And we must judge by results. Let me use a homely simile which will appeal to the Prime Minister—the proof of the pudding is in the eating. It is well known throughout the Service that most discreditable and alarming deficiencies were disclosed in the Mediterranean scare in the autumn. I have heard of a great aircraft carrier, sent out in haste on emergency service to Alexandria, which had neither proper numbers nor the proper type of wireless sets for the aircraft. Many of the aircraft were supplied at the last minute without having even bomb racks fixed or the bombing release gear fitted. Necessary spare parts were not available to make certain engines serviceable for many months. The aircraft of one whole squadron which were of a new type were still so inefficient that they had to remain ashore and be replaced by others of an obsolescent type, and only half a squadron of these were ultimately available. After that, it seemed that there were no spare aircraft for the Fleet Arm in the country.

We have heard a great deal of the wonderful qualities of British aircraft, but we know for certain that the Fleet Air Arm has no flying boats or bombers which bear any comparison, so I am assured, with those of leading foreign Powers. The flying boats which were sent to Alexandria recently have been

1416

described to me as laughable compared with those which are known at the present time to be possessed by Italy. I am informed that the design of the bulk of the aircraft of the Fleet Air Arm is out-of-date. It is complained that the Fleet Air Arm aircraft are designed in the Air Ministry by people who are not thoroughly informed about the practical conditions under which the Fleet Air Arm does its work. For instance, many of the single-seater fighters break their propellers very often on making a deck landing, and the new reconnaisance aircraft for the Fleet are so built that the rush of air in the large cockpits numbs the observer and the telegraphist to such an extent that they would die of cold in severe winter service, and even in the earlier stages of that condition would be quite incapable of responding to the wireless signals, of making proper observations and calculations, or indeed of firing the rear machine gun. This, I am told, happens in a class of aircraft which goes about half the speed which some of the fastest ones go and which is described as the eye of our modern battle Fleet.

No one will contend that the Fleet is supplied with aircraft comparable in numbers or efficiency with those of the United States. I do not say that there can be any rivalry with them, but we ought to learn. Is it not a fact, for instance, that the American Navy possesses 550 sea-borne aircraft, apart from 450 co-operating from shore bases? The Japanese Navy controls about 800 aircraft, whereas, even with the extra machines now being built under the programme of 1936, the aircraft of the Royal Navy win not exceed 217.

I am sorry to have to dwell upon these facts, but I think it is my duty to do so. It is far better to have these things while there is time to remedy them. And what is the remedy? I think the only remedy is the immediate transference to the Navy of the whole control of the Fleet Air Arm, which is now vital to its safety and to every form of its action in time of war, and above all to our trade protection and food supplies. I do not believe that what said about the increasing range of aircraft alters these conclusions at all. A fleet or scouting cruiser squadron cannot depend upon the operation of aircraft controlled by another Department operating hundreds of

1417

miles away from shore bases. I am certain that you would be well advised to entrust this matter to the Royal Navy.

I must ask the indulgence of the Committee for a few minutes more in order to close these arguments, which would be incomplete without what I now propose to say. Before the War we had these two services, and with the aid of my hon. and gallant Friend I developed and managed to control the development of the Royal Naval Air Service. Ultimately, it became a very magnificent force. I believe it comprised at the end of the War 2,800 aeroplanes and nearly 55,000 men. I must frankly admit, although it tells against my general arguments, that personally I consider that at the end of the War the Royal Naval Air Force did not contribute sufficiently to the general operations in the conduct of the War. However, that is a mistake which need not be repeated.