- Context
- Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on May 4, 1936, during the Navy Supplementary Estimate debate, urging a revived Special Reserve, more destroyers and a rethink of scrapping cruisers under the Anglo-German Naval Treaty.
- Main themes
- Re-institution of the Special Reserve, training cruiser at Newfoundland, Vote A of the Royal Navy, destroyer building programme, battleship decision and call for an inquiry, Anglo-German Naval Treaty, German submarine construction, scrapping of older destroyers, Hawkins class and C class cruisers, escalator clause, Mediterranean crisis and naval mobilisation, German air power parity
- Duration
- ~11 min
- Words
- 1,337
- Sentences
- 53
- Readability
- 56
- Grade
- 12.2
- Syntax
- 3.21
- Vocabulary
- 2.12
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other53 sentences in 15 paragraphs
Before I come to the two or three larger issues which I am anxious to submit to the Committee this afternoon, I have two minor suggestions of a constructive character which I should like, with great respect and entire
1403
good will, to offer to my Noble Friend, in the hope that he may, perhaps, bring them to the notice of higher authorities. They both properly belong to the Vote A section of our discussion, but the Chairman ruled that we could discuss Vote A topics in the general debate, and, therefore, I venture to refer to them now. The first is the re-institution of the Special Reserve. When I was preparing the Fleet before the War, I devised a plan with the aid of my very competent naval staff, by which about 3,000 men of the Royal Fleet Reserve received a special bounty, I think, of £5 a year—the total expense of the 3,000 men being not more than £15,000 a year, a very small part of Estimates of this size—in consideration of which they allowed themselves to be called up in time of emergency in advance of any general proclamation of naval mobilisation. Of course, this was a very great convenience to us when the crisis came, in the early part of the crisis.
I believe that it would have been a great convenience to the Admiralty during the recent trouble in the Mediterranean if they could have called up a small number of men who had voluntarily taken on a special engagement. You never can tell how a situation will arise. It may well be that foreign affairs may be in a delicate condition and a general mobilisation of the Navy might be prejudicial to the diplomatic course of events, and to have 3,000 or so men under your command who can be quite unostentatiously brought to the ships is a very great advantage. As I say, the cost is a bagatelle compared to the enormous weight of our Estimates at the present time. I hope that that may be considered. I was sorry to find after my inquiries last autumn that this system had been dropped, and I hope that it may be re-instituted.
I have one other point even smaller. Cannot my Noble Friend hold out some hopes that the training cruiser at Newfoundland can be re-established? In endeavouring to raise Vote A, here is a very fine seafaring population accustomed to the work of the small picket boats, sailing boats and fishing boats in the roughest weather. I am told that in the Great War the Northern Patrol of merchant ships which was essential to our blockade could not have been maintained
1404
but for the continued support of the Newfoundlander, who was extremely good in manning the small boats in very rough weather and getting from ship to ship. Newfoundland has fallen upon evil days. There is great unemployment and great privation, and, moreover, it is important to link Newfoundland to this country by every association which is useful and beneficial. If a training cruiser could be stationed there—perhaps one of those cruisers which my Noble Friend is going so improvidently to scrap in a few weeks' time—it would form a valuable recruiting centre and be a new link between Newfoundland, our oldest colony, and the mother country, and give us a stream of invaluable seafaring men for the additions we propose to make to Vote A of the Royal Navy.
Coming to the larger topics, I heard with disappointment the limits of the statement which my Noble Friend was permitted to make. Several very large questions were raised at the time of the Defence Debate a couple of months ago but I do not think that any adequate answers have been given to those questions. The Government have seemed to me ready to be content to leave serious criticism and valid points without reply, except such reply as is offered in the Division Lobby, very often by Members who are not particularly interested in the technical subjects under discussion. Two questions affecting the Navy were raised in March. The first was the number of destroyers which are being built for the Royal Navy at the present time, and the second was the question of battleships, about which we have already heard a good deal of discussion this afternoon. I thought that it was the general feeling of the House that we should build many more destroyers, and that we should postpone the final decision upon battleships until there had been a thorough and impartial inquiry. A good many weeks have elapsed and we see that the Government completely ignore these views. They ignore them, and they express no effective reason or argument why they should be brushed aside.
The destroyer programme is extremely modest and restricted. No attempt is made to utilise the very many smaller shipyards to give us the large numbers which will certainly be needed now that the Naval Treaty with Germany has
1405
authorised a very large building of submarines. I will not say that it is extremely probable, but it is undoubtedly possible, and even probable that very active submarine construction is proceeding in Germany, and the submarines can be rapidly built, as I said may be piece-meal, and assembled very rapidly. A serious responsibility will rest upon those who signed that Treaty, if one day in the next few years it is found that the German submarines are as far ahead of our anti-submarine flotillas as their Air Force is already drawing ahead of ours, in spite of the pledges of absolute parity which were given to us. What is to be done about the destroyers Are any more to be built beyond those nine we see here? What is to be done about the older destroyers which, under the Treaty, will have to be scrapped If adequate flotillas are to be built each year, what is to be done about the older destroyers? Are they to be retained or are they to be scrapped?
I should like answers to those questions from my Noble Friend. Everyone is most anxious to assist him with his task, but I am sure that he would wish to give answers upon these points. If these older destroyers are retained, they will, of course—I must point out this—under this unwise Anglo-German Naval Treaty, open new limits, some new construction to Germany. If, on the other hand, they are to be scrapped, we shall be throwing away vessels of real value for which the taxpayers' money has been used and which still have a most effective part to play in an emergency. Like the Hawkins class of cruisers, if they are kept they open a very large tonnage of brand new construction under the German Naval Treaty to Germany, and, on the other hand, we are now told, that, if they are to be kept, a number of other cruisers of which we could make good use must be scrapped. I should like to know whether the new escalator clause, if invoked, would not give us greater tonnage of destroyers, and also have the effect of preserving these cruisers, which, we are told, have to be scrapped.
I am most anxious to get an answer from my Noble Friend. I do not quite understand why, if he retains the Hawkins class, he has to scrap a number of cruisers of the "C" class. Surely, the 1931 Treaty runs out in a very short space
1406
of time and these vessels would be no longer in the position that they have to be destroyed. I also wish to know about the escalator clause. Will that not save them? Nothing can be more foolish and more unsatisfactory than that we should have sunk serviceable ships which might in emergency be of very great use in all sorts of minor raids, and, at the same time, save a very large sum of money in building five new cruisers year after year.
