Words from the President of the Nation, Alberto Fernández, via videoconference, at the Second Federal Meeting of Law Students from across the country.

Argentina Alberto Fernández · President of Argentina

2 August 2021 · Second Federal Meeting of Law Students from across the country

Context
Fernández addressed the Second Federal Meeting of Law Students via videoconference on August 2, 2021, speaking on public education, legal philosophy, and federalism in Argentine universities.
Main themes
Public university education, federal education access, rule of law, legal philosophy, first-generation university students, diversity and environment in law, human rights education, social mobility, university reform, law curriculum development
Duration
~69 min
97th percentile
Words
8,251
97th percentile
Sentences
184
87th percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
19.0
96th percentile
Syntax
3.55
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 44%43%
  • Social 36%36%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

184 sentences in 31 paragraphs

PRESIDENT. - First of all, thank you to all of you and thank you for allowing me to participate in this space of law students, which I believe is a great initiative. When I was invited to be part of this federal meeting of law students, I quickly said yes. I said yes for two reasons: first, because I am certain, I am convinced that we must strongly promote public education. I believe that one thing that made Argentina different was public education, at all levels; also at the university level.

We were the first with the university reform, when we guaranteed freedom of thought, freedom of teaching, and that was a significant advance at that time, but it was definitely a revolution when public university education became free and allowed the children of workers to access it – back in 1949 – and there the idea for which we have fought so hard became a reality, that there exists, in Argentina, a social upward mobility, that there are no men or women who, simply by being born into a certain social condition, remain stuck in that place, and that the State provides the conditions for progress and development so that they can grow and also serve society. That is why when I was told to participate, I quickly said yes; I find it very comfortable to talk with students. I have been teaching for many years, I was also a student, I was a university leader, like you, and for me it is very comfortable to talk with you and it is very interesting to be able to listen to you. It is very useful for me to see your opinions, your ideas, in an Argentina that is truly trying to end a very unfortunate time, where first as a consequence of imposed policies, and then as a consequence of the pandemic, many Argentinians found themselves delayed in their possibility of development and growth in the society in which they live.

I also celebrate that this is a federal meeting, because we must bring universities to all corners of the country; it is clear that when one brings universities closer to the towns, those who live in those towns have many more facilities to study than if we leave education concentrated in the big cities, as happened for many years with the University of Buenos Aires, the University of La Plata, the University of Córdoba, where many students from the interior came at a huge personal cost, and as it was very costly to think about having a child move, renting an apartment for them, those who were in better conditions could rent an apartment, but many others had to live in boarding houses, and all of that meant a huge effort for families from the interior of the country. Therefore, being able to open and bring the university closer to the students is seen as a great solution.

I saw that someone introduced a message from the University of José C. Paz, which is a university in Greater Buenos Aires; like all universities in Greater Buenos Aires, around 90 percent of students are first-generation university students in their families, and that demonstrates the importance of the university going to its students, because it is not easy for the student to go to the university when this means leaving their home, leaving their family, moving perhaps hundreds of kilometers and imposing a cost on their families that many times is difficult for them to bear.

So, for me, it is very pleasant to be here with you, it is very pleasant to see that this meeting has this federal nature, and it is very pleasant to see so many young people – men and women – who care about law in Argentina, who care about how legal education works, the teaching of law, and who care about how law functions in Argentina, because I am – above all things – a man raised in the culture of the rule of law, and living in a rule of law imposes many things on us. Perhaps, when Julia was speaking earlier, one of the things we must ask ourselves and reconsider is what the philosophy of law is that will govern the legal careers, because many of the issues that Julia raised, which are new, modern issues, related to diversity, related to the environment, are issues that essentially have to do with determining what the legal philosophy that governs us is, what the philosophy that governs us as lawyers is, and when one looks – I say this from experience – when one sees how the teaching of the philosophy of law functions, it is almost a marginal subject in the career, and it is a subject that should be central in the career, because – depending on whether we adopt one legal philosophy or another – we will see things in one way or another. Therefore, I believe these are central issues.

The curricula in all universities have been opening up as society has demanded. I remember back in the 1980s, when the first courses on human rights began to be taught, it was something that was never treated that way, but was treated as a subject of Constitutional Law or Political Law, but was never treated with the autonomy it has today, and today I see how little by little the curriculum advances in minority rights, women's rights, environmental law. These are all things that I believe are related to the social evolution that Argentina is experiencing.

Finally – those of us who have studied law – and have at some point read Mayer's theory of norms, for example, know that law is like a great tree and that behind every legal norm there is a cultural implicit norm. The law rewards or punishes cultural norms, as culture imposes it, and if culture changes, then the law must adapt to the new culture. If culture says that one should not steal, the law will write that we punish the one who steals, and that is how norms in law are constructed. There is always, before a written norm, or a norm established by the State, a norm that arises from our culture. And many times our culture changes and the norms of law change. And at one time abortion was illegal and at another time it was legalized and the typology of abortion changed, because culturally it changed. And at one time criminal law, when classifying behaviors, spoke of an honest woman, and the concept of an honest woman has changed permanently over time, and at one time criminal law punished adultery in a very macho, very patriarchal way. So for a woman to be an adulteress, it was enough for her to be unfaithful to her partner once, and for a man to be an adulterer, he needed to have a mistress outside the home, which was the same as saying a parallel family. Notice the difference in the definition, but then – over time – we realized that fidelity between a man and a woman or fidelity between any couple, whether or not they are of the same sex, has to do with a decision of the couple, it does not have to do with a matter that the State should resolve criminally, and that crime was annulled.

Why do I bring this up? Because I think it is a good topic for us to start thinking about giving legal philosophy the place it objectively deserves, because legal philosophy, the philosophy of law has to do with the logic with which norms are constructed later. I say this as an introduction, because I believe it is much more valuable that we can talk, exchange opinions, and listen to each other, and I already thank you immensely for inviting me to participate in this meeting and I propose that we talk, not that you listen to me. Thank you very much, truly.

PANELIST. - Good afternoon to everyone who is attending this Zoom, and thank you very much, Alberto, for your participation, expressing the honor we all have to be together in this closing panel, through virtuality, as we do today. And to also mention that today, July 31, we commemorate the Day of the Militant Lawyer, due to the assassination of Ortega Peña by the Triple A in 1965. We wanted to know what the figure of Ortega Peña generates for you?

PRESIDENT. - Ortega Peña was one of the many lawyers who were very committed to human rights; I met him when I was very young and I read a magazine that, in those years, he directed with Eduardo Luis Duhalde, who later became Secretary of Human Rights during Néstor Kirchner's administration. Ortega Peña was a very committed man, he was a lawyer very committed to human rights, he was a lawyer who, in the 1970s, we said were lawyers for political prisoners, but in truth what Ortega Peña fought for the most was for the validity of the rule of law, and I believe that is what all lawyers should fight for, all of us who study law.

Sometimes, when I hear someone say to me: “Why did you study law if look at what the courts do, and the law does not exist?” No, we study law because we start from the premise that there is a world that tells us… we study what would be called the ought to be, how society should be just and equal, where rights fully prevail. And we work so that that world of the ought to be exists, and we must work tirelessly. Sometimes that puts us in front of dilemmas, in front of decisions that are difficult to resolve, because many times those decisions put us at risk. No one knows better than Ortega Peña what the risk was of defending political prisoners in a dictatorship, and also standing up against paramilitary groups that existed at that time – like the Triple A – that ended the lives of such valuable people as Rodolfo Ortega Peña or Father Mugica, people who had dedicated their lives to others.

It is right to remember the day of Rodolfo Ortega Peña's death; others died. There was a "Night of the Ties," where many lawyers defending political prisoners died, and all of them deserve to be recognized. Now, the concept of militant lawyer confuses me, because neither Ortega Peña nor those who died were militants of a political cause; they were militants of the rule of law, and militants of the rule of law should be everyone who prides themselves on being a lawyer. All of us who embrace the legal profession must be militants of the rule of law, above all else, regardless of political affiliation. That is why it is very good to remember a man who gave his life for the rule of law to function and who died – I insist – at a time when democracy existed, gunned down by bullets from a terrible paramilitary group called the Triple A, which determined the death of many others and among them the exile of many more. Among them my dear and always remembered Esteban Righi, who, threatened by the Triple A, had to leave the country and went into exile in Mexico during the entire dictatorship.

So, those of us who are lawyers must be eternal militants of the rule of law and we must not give up on that, even when there are other lawyers who put the rule of law in the background to defend interests. Lawyers – like those of us who do politics – defend interests, clearly, and confront other interests clearly, but whatever we do in defense of or confronting other interests that oppose our positions, we must do so within the framework of the rule of law and we must demand the rule of law. If the rule of law had fully existed at those times, paramilitary groups would not have existed, and Ortega Peña would not have been dead, and if there had not been a dictatorship, there would not have been a "Night of the Ties." We must pay tribute to those men, to those lawyers; I don't know if – perhaps – there were women lawyers at that time so committed to the defense of rights; it was other years, they were other times, simply for that reason, because there would have been, I have no doubt, but we must always remember them because they had the courage to uphold the principles and rights that a democratic state and a republic definitely exist.

PANELIST. - And what could you say about the profession of lawyer, from a militant perspective?

PRESIDENT. - The problem I have with the concept of militant is that I definitely associate it with politics, and it seems to me that lawyers do politics, like any citizen, and it is very good that they do, I am concerned about those who deny politics. Politics is a wonderful instrument for changing society. Now, what should our militancy as lawyers be? Now, if the concept of militant sounds as it sounds to me, directly linked to politics, then Peronist lawyers only defend Peronists, radical lawyers only defend radicals. Lawyers militantly uphold the rule of law, and what I believe is that, as militants of the rule of law, we must advocate for just causes, we must do everything necessary for the principle of justice to prevail.

Carrara said that if "the law is not just, it is not law, it is twisted." And we, in recent years, have seen how the law was set aside and was perverted, hurt, confused with pretentious theories, pretentious interpretations that caused enormous damage to the credibility of Justice, but caused enormous damage to the rule of law, because many suffered unnecessary imprisonment, unnecessary preventive detentions, many endured fabricated cases, solely for the purpose of persecuting them, many were pursued to irregularly expropriate their assets, and the truth is that this has nothing to do with a rule of law. And for that to happen, it took lawyers who – as Julia said – in the liberal exercise of their profession acted to the detriment of those victims, it took prosecutors and judges who endorsed those procedures. And that is not good, that – definitely – is very bad.

I have always claimed, even in times when I had not yet reconnected with Cristina and was wandering alone through television channels saying that, in Justice, things were being done wrong, with the invented theories so that preventive detentions could be made effective when they were not necessary. And that led to the unnecessary detention of many people for many years. That theory that said that former officials had a residual power and that is why they should not be released because they could interfere with the action of justice was a ridiculous and shameful theory. And that served to detain a lot of people who, in any other situation, should not necessarily have been detained. So, it seems to me that these are the things that compel us to advocate for the rule of law; that has nothing to do with ideology. One does not say these things because they are Peronists and, in any case, they were affecting Peronists with these decisions; these same things are said, in Brazil, when they detained Lula, in the way they did, when they invented a case against him and convicted him because, there in Brazil, there is the principle of the free convictions of magistrates and there was a judge, who later it was shown what his criterion of justice was, who thought that in his intimate convictions Lula had received an apartment as a bribe and there was not a single piece of evidence to support that. What we lawyers must advocate for is the rule of law and if we see that the rule of law is being violated with a citizen, we must advocate for the rule of law and not ask the citizen what they think, that is what we must do, because, moreover, those of us who were born into Peronism, as I was, I don’t know how many of us are here, but those of us who were born into Peronism, in addition to being proponents of the rule of law, are deeply democratic, we never endorsed a military coup, we suffered them; we never endorsed an illegal detention, we suffered them. Therefore, that suffering that we lived through, we must not allow anyone else to suffer it, in our land, whether they are Peronists or not, that no one should suffer it. And that is why I insist that our militancy is a militancy – as a lawyer I am speaking – extra-party. It is a militancy that ethically commits us to the full enforcement of the rule of law.

PANELIST. - I take this opportunity to greet everyone who is joining us via Zoom or watching on YouTube. In this that you point out a little and just this question we can ask you now because the talk is leading to this question, which is the issue of the responsibility that we have today, as law students, who today are two branches of government and the Legislative Power must also have many lawyers, but we have a branch of government exclusively for lawyers, which is the Judiciary, added to the fact that our president and our vice president are lawyers and added to the fact that there are many legislators who are also lawyers, I think this has to lead us to look at what responsibility we have from the Law when we start to study this. And here comes a question that has come up in many panels and we would like to know what you think about this: what is the form in the Faculty of Law, at UBA, at UNR, in all academic units, where the study plan is going because what we perceive is that many times, a litigator lawyer is prepared and perhaps not so much a legal professional with a social perspective, that is, more is aimed at the litigator lawyer than to train legal professionals who do not only have litigation as their ultimate goal and I want to know your opinion on this and I want to know if this type of training that we receive in our academic units also impacts, with what we talked about before, like – for example – the Irurzun doctrine and others that have emerged, between the years 2015 and 2019 quite a bit, but if that training we receive in the Faculty impacts when it comes to fulfilling these roles, in the Judiciary.

PRESIDENT. - Look, Lucas, the fault of what happens to Argentine Justice is not the universities, it is Justice, let's start there, because the truth is that I have never read a law book, and neither have you, where someone dared to write as a theory of Procedural Law, the theory of that remnant of responsibility that someone who was an official has. No one would have dared to write that one must remain detained, because as it is supposed that he was an official, he has certain power to influence a judicial process, no one would have dared to write such a thing, no one. These things are practiced in Justice, which is another thing, because in Justice we clearly have a problem where power factors influence a lot. We sometimes focus a lot on Criminal Law and Federal Justice, but one could go to other fields, one could see how economic corporations influence Commercial Law, in Commercial Justice, and in Labor Justice, one could see all this very easily. And when there are environmental issues one can encounter the difficulties there are to claim against a company because it is polluting, because the pressure from those economic corporations is enormous on judges to not rule against their interests. That is not a problem of legal education, that is a problem of the concrete application of a law, and of the predominance of economic interests over justice criteria. And that is very serious, because that is what distances citizens the most from Justice. Now: is it a problem of the Law curriculum? I would dare to say no, because we have freedom of teaching in all our universities, that is, we can choose the course that is most aligned with our thinking. We can assume different positions in legal philosophy, as I said before, what I can guarantee you is that I studied Law and I continue studying because I continue teaching it, and I, for example, have never seen, rather, I have read a book, unfortunately I have read it, there it is the other way around, for example, someone has written and developed a theory about what they call the Irrational Res Judicata, which allows one to suppose that the principle of res judicata can fall when a fact is supposedly misjudged, and then legal uncertainty is infinite. It was a theory that emerged in Argentina exclusively to be able to reopen cases where Cristina or former officials of Cristina had already been judged. Now: the theory of Irrational Res Judicata has never been quelled, despite the fact that there were cases where it was raised judicially, it was never applied, and there Justice set a limit and gave a basic certainty, because the principle of Res Judicata has a lot to do with what they call legal certainty, how many times am I going to be judged? I go to this exceptional case that I see, I do not see that in the curriculum of other careers these theories appear as a destroyed object, in any case they seem like painful deviations from the application of justice, and I think that the worst part of our career is the absence of a – I am looking for the exact word – of a practice, of a precise type of practice in the Law Degree. The practical courses tend to be more formal than real, and in truth those who achieve the most practice in the Law career are those who work in Courts. Now, that judicial practice also has these qualities that I spoke about before, one can work in a court where the principle of justice is perverted, and ends up very confused, or one can work in a court where the principle of justice is preserved, and then one can learn a lot. I believe that those who were employees of Bonadío were truly poisoned with the things I saw they wrote; and those who worked with Irurzun, I believe they were poisoned with the legal nonsense that was written there, and they are not to blame, no university, no faculty, those are theories that were applied because at a certain moment power prevailed and they responded to that power. There was someone who says that the same judges who teach the law are the ones who teach Law, that is relatively true, but not necessarily true, because what we also cannot say is that all judges are like Bonadío or like Irurzun, that is not true. What happens is that the things those few judges say are so striking, and the things those few judges say are so unjust, that it truly moves one, but that is not the integrity of the judges, it is not all of Justice.

Then we have another issue to resolve which is how Justice works in Argentina, there is not one Justice in Argentina, there are 24 judicial systems, each justice has its own local justice, has its own local procedures, and this is also a topic to analyze, because it gives the impression..., back in 1985, 86, I was invited to give a talk, in a republican system how Justice should function, I remember that the conference turned into a little book of sixty pages, very small, called Criminal Justice in Republican Democracy, and there I raised my concern, and I believe that those forms have not changed substantially, and that when in 1994 the figure of the Council of the Judiciary was created in the national jurisdiction.

In the organization of Justice, we encounter many, in some provinces of the country, with truly unusual arguments. I believe there is much work to be done and to discuss for those of us who truly want to live in a state of law. But I would not dare to blame the education we received in the faculties; in the faculties, of course, as everywhere, there are different thoughts, and there are more conservative chairs and more progressive chairs, there are more progressive and more conservative views of Law, but we can continue to choose which chair to access according to how we think and how we want to be trained; that is the importance of academic freedom. The issue of Justice is a separate matter; someone pointed out that Justice is not subject to public scrutiny, and they are right, judges are not elected. Now, it is also a huge difficulty to think about electing judges; think about what judges would be like if they were thinking about their election. Also, consider what it can be like for a legislator thinking about their reelection, what it can be like for a judge thinking about their reelection; they could commit all kinds of atrocities. I am not concerned that judges continue to be chosen as they are; what we might consider are some concepts, for example, the concept that is being discussed in the Senate, which is being debated regarding the Chief Prosecutor, regarding the Attorney General's Office. Should the prosecutor have a lifetime position or should it last for a certain time? We should ask ourselves some questions regarding those judges. I do not want to have a controversy; I should not say it because I know it would open a controversy, but I am speaking with law students, and since I am speaking with law students, the best way to teach is to sow doubts. In truth, the Constitution states that a judge must remain in their position as long as they maintain good conduct; the same is said for the President of the Republic, for the Vice President in our case, for the deputies and senators, and for the ministers. Now, all of them, it is true, have a certain time of validity for their mandate. Just as we can say that the prosecutor should remain in their position for a certain number of years and then must renew their appointment, we could say the same for judges; one could say that a judge is appointed for ten years, and after ten years, they must revalidate their status as a judge. Because that is something unregulated, and it is not prohibited, because what is not stated in the Constitution is that judges are judges until the day of their death; that is not there; they have simply said that they will remain in their positions as long as they maintain good conduct, the same as they have said for the prosecutor. If a term can be set for the prosecutor, why can’t a term be set for the duration of judges in their functions? It is a topic for debate; I know it is a difficult, complex debate, but as we have seen judges who endure and remain in their positions, and who are also always aloof not only from public scrutiny, as someone wrote there, but from any type of scrutiny, issuing a bad ruling does not make it a reprehensible conduct, but it could make us think about renewing the appointment of a judge who does so. I cannot say that the conduct of a judge who applies the theory of residual responsibility of the former official for applying that theory has only a reprehensible conduct to be dismissed, but the truth is that I would think twice before reappointing that judge; if they are capable of saying such a thing, I would think twice before saying something. So it seems to me that all of this is a topic for debate, for discussion, which I repeat, I am not proposing to do now; I am reacting to a question I asked about why we do not elect judges. But I believe these are two topics to think about, to rethink, to debate, how to build a better Justice service, which is really what should concern us as lawyers; a better justice service results in a better quality of life for citizens; that is what we must do, nothing else.

PANELIST. - I will complete before the question; I left out what the President said; I am completing something from a president and law professor, so it seems strange to me at the level I have reached, but since I am here, I take advantage of it. But it seems to me that part of the discussion should be that it should not be such a reserved topic, but that we can start discussing it; I believe that the democratization of the Judiciary, perhaps - as Alberto said - is not about voting for judges, but rather that we start talking about certain topics and that the debate begins to be established in society, that it is not so - as you said, Alberto - so distant; it seems to me that it is quite interesting.

PRESIDENT. - But I believe that is a good reflection of yours; it is not nonsense; it is a good reflection because many times people are offended when one questions the rulings of a judge, but in truth, in a republican system, government acts are public. What are government acts? The government acts of the Legislative Power are the laws; the government acts of the Judicial Power are the sentences. Therefore, without a decree, it can be a subject of public debate; they have said nothing; the republic says that when the judge spoke, they spoke. One thing is the judicial ruling, which must be made, and another thing is to discuss the honesty with which that judicial ruling has been issued; these are different things, and that has to do with that public scrutiny that was mentioned.

There must be a higher level of transparency; I am not saying that they should not disclose their sworn asset declarations, but that is what happens, and it seems to me that we, for example, with Néstor, when he was president, Gustavo Beliz and I proposed a decree in 2003, where Néstor Kirchner, as president, self-limited the power he had to appoint members of the Court and submitted the names he proposed to public debate. Since then, when one proposes, except for those who are appointed by decree, which is not our case, but when one follows the agenda of the rule of law, one must put into public debate, I propose Joaquín, I propose Joaquín as a member of the Court, and for a certain number of days, all those who have something to say about Joaquín, in favor or against, have the opportunity to speak to question, and that was a great success; now, the minister of the court is no longer just a friend of the president; they must submit to public scrutiny, in another way, but they must submit; there we opened a great step. Now, what we do with the judges of the Court, with the Prosecutor, and with the Defender of the Court is not what we do with all judges; we do it only with those cases, which are a total of seven or nine people. In everything that is about making transparent what judges decide, what Justice resolves, and subjecting it to public debate, it seems to me that it is something good, as long as it is within the framework of respect that must be given to any questioning in a state of law.

PANELIST. - I am Jaqueline, from the University of Patagonia, Faculty of Legal Sciences; I wanted to greet my classmates from all the universities in the country present at this moment. With my colleagues, we wanted to ask you the following question, in the context of the debate on the decriminalization and legalization of abortion, which resulted, beyond the great activism that drove the popular mobilization in favor of decriminalization. In that sense, another of the great demands of youth and society, we see is the legalization of cannabis for recreational use; we want to know what your view is and if it is possible that it will happen during the current administration.

PRESIDENT. - Until now, the questions have been easy; this one complicates me, but I will try to respond to Jaqueline's concern. I was just explaining, when you allowed me to make a kind of introduction, that the law always runs behind culture; this is the case. What Jaqueline points out as mobilizations of feminism by women, where they demanded the right for voluntary interruption of pregnancy not to be a crime, was determining the State to construct the law that states that. But now another debate arises, which is about the use of marijuana, specifically, for recreational purposes. The debate there is a bit more confusing, and we also have to overcome and put into debate a discussion that has to do with the social hypocrisy in which we live; there is a part of us that tolerates certain hypocrisy. Ultimately, that marijuana is toxic is not in question, but tobacco is also toxic, and alcohol is also toxic, and yet there is a whole industry built around tobacco and alcohol where the toxic aspect takes a back seat. The biggest problem that our youth suffers today in terms of addictions is not precisely due to marijuana; it is due to alcohol. And our young people harm themselves and damage their bodies primarily due to alcohol, but there is a whole industry mounted that is very difficult to question because there is also a social mission in favor of selling and consuming alcohol. This social mission does not exist regarding drugs; there is no doubt that no one wants to enable hard drugs because the damage they cause is enormous. Marijuana is classified as a soft drug, a drug that does not generate damage less than or equivalent to tobacco; I do not know; here I am repeating. What I say is that it is a debate that will eventually arrive. Also, when markets disappear, businesses disappear, and they may stop being businesses; that was what happened with Prohibition in the United States; when Prohibition was in effect, buying a liter of whiskey was extremely expensive; when Prohibition disappeared, it stopped being a business to make whiskey, and perhaps the same will happen when a drug like marijuana is legalized. We have taken a first step by legalizing cannabis for medicinal use because they say that those who know that the plant indeed has that virtue, and hemp, which is a variant of cannabis, could greatly help the textile industry because for many years it is said that the sails that moved the caravels in the 15th century were made with hemp threads, which seems to be a very strong thread. I believe that little by little, the taboo of hemp, the taboo of cannabis is yielding, and we must give it time; we must be careful. I truly, when I say all this, would also say that we should try not to turn to the consumption of any narcotic and to the consumption of anything that harms us physically. And also, someone points out to me there, from the point of view of the State, what we must do as a State is not to persecute the consumer of a joint; it is to pursue the trafficker, who is the one who makes the real business. In any case, the one who consumes marijuana is harming themselves; they are doing harm to their health, just like the one who consumes alcohol or the one who consumes tobacco; they are harming their health; in some cases, that harm is more accepted, and in other cases, it is not, and that is the gesture of hypocrisy I was talking about. But we must be careful because what is clear is that it is a substance that generates some harm; there is no doubt about that; used for recreational purposes, it generates harm to health; there is no doubt about that; what I am not convinced of is that the solution is to prohibit it, and what I am sure of is that the consumer is in any case a victim; they are not guilty of anything.

SPEAKER. - I was saying, Mr. President, that with the kids, we were thinking of an idea that we are going to develop and that has to do with the great vaccination campaign that is being carried out throughout the country, which is the most important in the history of Argentina.

SPEAKER. - I am 25 years old; last week I was able to get vaccinated with the first dose of Sinopharm, so those messages of fear, of where the vaccine comes from, what effects it produces, taking advantage of the fact that we are all young here, give your message to the young people about the vaccination campaign and about the vaccine, so that maybe the fear is lost a bit.

PRESIDENT. - The pandemic has exposed many miserable gestures of societies, that is what I perceive. I remember that Willy Caballero, who was a goalkeeper for the national team that plays in England, I heard him once in an interview where he was asked how he thought the day after the pandemic would be. And I thought that after so many mistakes, we would be much better when the pandemic ended, but now that the pandemic is ending, I have realized that those who were good became very good, but those who were bad became very bad. The truth is that it seems to me a great definition, because the pandemic revealed the human misery of many, it became very evident, and part of that misery was uncovered when the vaccines arrived, vaccines started to arrive. Vaccines are vaccines, as we are in the middle of the pandemic, a vaccine takes many years to develop, because once you have one, you do the first clinical trials, that is called phase three, there is a prior period that takes at least one more year, at least two more years, so making a vaccine takes about four years, and these are vaccines that were made in less than a year, and phase three was reached in less than a year. And that is why all the vaccines have been approved in emergency, because a stage of the vaccine development process was skipped, to beat the virus. Suddenly vaccines started to appear, where vaccines appeared, we went to look for them, I have spoken with the presidents of many laboratories, I, personally looking for vaccines, spoke with the President of Moderna, of Pfizer, looking for vaccines, because what worried me the most was that we could get vaccinated, because the only way to stop the pandemic is to achieve immunization. Some believed that we would achieve societal immunization by letting everyone be free, walk and circulate, that they would get infected first, and that in this way we would generate antibodies, someone proposed this to us when this started, and obviously I dismissed it, because it seemed to me a huge risk. Some did it, the English started to do it and realized what they were generating. So they reversed course and did very well afterwards. And many in Argentina sowed doubts about the vaccines, now, the vaccines that circulate in the world are all vaccines developed by first-class institutes and laboratories in the world. When we accessed Sputnik V, they tried to sow doubt that it was a vaccine bought for ideological reasons, and presented Russia as a dark country that gave us no guarantees, and Russia is one - I am sure - of the three countries, I don't know where to place it, that have developed science and technology with the most efficiency, I have no doubt, if I am not mistaken, it has more than thirty Nobel Prizes, I think 28 Nobel Prizes. The Gamaleya Institute is a recognized institute worldwide, they want to sow doubt that we are communists making an agreement with Russia, as if Stalin were governing Russia, and they sow the fear that they sow, they accused me of poisoning people, and I didn't care, I looked for the vaccines, I got the vaccines. When I went to Russia, they accused me of being a communist and other things, but when I went to Oxford, they didn't accuse me of being pro-monarchist, they didn't call me monarchist, and I brought vaccines from Oxford too, we made an agreement for the Oxford vaccine, and from Sweden, AstraZeneca and Oxford, to be made in Argentina the active ingredient, and we agreed with Mexico on a joint vaccine production system. When the Oxford vaccine came, no one called me. When I brought the Chinese vaccines, they started again, that there was really a Soviet-Chinese-Argentine axis that wanted to establish itself in front of the world as a geopolitical development. And then finally we ended up buying vaccines from the United States, and all good, because what we need are vaccines, because as someone just wrote, here what we need to do is roll up our sleeves to get vaccinated, what we need is to get vaccinated as soon as possible, that is the system. The sooner we get vaccinated, the faster we will be immunized, and the faster we achieve the immunity of all Argentines, then the chances of the pandemic spreading will be less. It is true that vaccines do not guarantee a hundred percent the possibility of contagion, but they greatly minimize the possibility of death, and they greatly minimize the possibility of hospitalization. Look, when you look at last year, the average age of pandemic victims was seventy-four years, when you look now, the average is around fifty-five. And what happened? The first vaccines, the first to be vaccinated, were those over 60 years old and they quickly became immunized, and we continue to advance with those people to fully immunize them, in a world that has also shown how it works, ninety percent of the vaccines remained in the hands of ten percent of the countries, realize what it costs a country like Argentina to get vaccines. The truth is that today Argentina, 75 percent of those over 18 at least have received one dose, one dose is to have an immunity of over 80 percent, and more than 30 percent of the total Argentines have already received at least one dose. We are among the 20 countries that have vaccinated the most in the world, with a lot of difficulty, going to look for vaccines everywhere, jokingly I tell friends, I even went to the subways looking for vaccines, I looked for vaccines everywhere, and that is what I should do, and now when I see today, Juancho... sent me from Paraná, a photo of a hospital that we put into operation in Paraná because it had been abandoned for four years, and I saw the lines of kids under 18 years old that were three blocks long to get vaccinated, I felt such great joy, when this meeting started he was writing a tweet that retweeted what Pancho from Paraná, that photo that is very impactful and very comforting, and the truth is that it made me very happy, of course it makes me very happy, and the truth is that we have to get vaccinated as soon as possible, if we get vaccinated we have much less chance of getting infected, and if we have much less chance of getting infected we have many more chances of not infecting others, we should not get infected not only for ourselves, but to be supportive of others. I hoped that the pandemic would make us more supportive, make us rethink a lot of things, and I believe that we have the opportunity to ensure that many of those things that present themselves to us as acts of selfishness, as acts of individualism, that we banish all this and put back on the table the value of being supportive. Those of us who are Peronists know that no one develops in a community that does not develop, and we subscribe in that context to organize the community so that the community grows, and if the community grows, we can grow. But no one is happy in a impoverished society, in an unequal society, that is why we have that commitment, we have our commitment of origin, we are genetically that, we are genetically supportive, we are genetically concerned about those who have the least, we are genetically concerned that the marginalized have the opportunity to grow and develop. When I questioned meritocracy, I questioned hollow meritocracy, the idea that says the idea comes by merit, that is false, it comes by merit and because they have opportunities, because it is not the same to graduate as a doctor being the son of a banker, than to graduate as a doctor being the son of a worker, it is not the same, one of them has it much harder, the doctor appears when everyone has the same conditions, and some make more merit to get there than others, but let us not blame the doctor, those who live forgotten and mistreated by a society, it is not a problem of merits, it is a problem of opportunities, and giving opportunities and equalizing is an essential matter of the State. That is why we work so hard in that sense. What needs to be done, as a colleague just said, is to get vaccinated, get vaccinated and get vaccinated, and convince everyone that they need to get vaccinated, because it is necessary that we all understand it. There we will defeat the pandemic, when we are vaccinated, and then the virus will be weaker, and we will even try to get vaccinated with two doses and surely with more doses and surely year after year, because it is a virus that mutates and adapts to continue hurting us. So today we have to convince everyone of the need to take care of themselves, because taking care of them also takes care of all the others.

SPEAKER.- Thank you very much to Alberto, thank you very much to everyone who was listening, for us it would be enough, the truth is that it was a great edition of this Law Students Meeting, and we could not close it without a meeting of this nature, so thank you very much for the exchange and we will continue next time.

PRESIDENT.- Thank you very much to everyone, the truth is that it has been very gratifying for me to be able to speak, to listen to you, to be able to convey my views on this time we are living, to be able to ask you please to remain as committed as you have been so far, you will embrace a beautiful career, which is Law, which is a career that is above all deeply humanistic, we choose law because we care about men and women, we care about the human beings who live in this community. We study Law to generate equality, we generally study law because we believe in the solidarity of communities, let no one confuse you, let no ruling that may come out as a consequence of other interests confuse you, we have embraced a wonderful career, we have committed ourselves to the law. I congratulate you for promoting these meetings, I congratulate you for being federal, because Argentina is profoundly unequal, the other day I went to inaugurate a road in Chaco, I don't know if there is any Chaco person among us, and suddenly a lady who lives by the roadside said surprised that for the first time in her life - a lady of my age - she had seen a bus pass by, and it filled me with astonishment. In that Argentina we live, that is not an equal Argentina, it is a profoundly unequal Argentina, and those of us who study law are called to make it equal, so that equality reigns among us, and so that we respect each other in diversity, because in democracy not everyone thinks the same, also among ourselves not all of us think the same, and we must respect each other in diversity, but what we must set aside are discussions that should no longer be discussed, there are issues that we should not discuss, human rights, equality, gender rights, respect for diversity, environmental care, on those things there is no discussion. I thank you and from a distance I embrace you all. Thank you very much for the time you have given me, from the heart.