Words of the President of the Nation, Alberto Fernández, at the 57th IDEA Colloquium (Institute for Business Development of Argentina) from Costa Salguero, CABA.

Argentina Alberto Fernández · President of Argentina

15 October 2021 · 57th IDEA Colloquium · Costa Salguero, Argentina

Context
Fernández addressed business leaders at the 57th IDEA Colloquium in Buenos Aires on October 15, 2021, calling for national unity and economic reconstruction in the post-pandemic era.
Main themes
Post-pandemic economic recovery, national unity and social cohesion, job creation and private investment, social justice, Argentina's structural economic imbalances, state assistance vs. sustainable development, democratic pluralism, poverty reduction, public-private cooperation
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,834
73rd percentile
Sentences
141
78th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 68%67%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

141 sentences in 50 paragraphs

Thank you very much to everyone for being here. It has been a long time since I last came to IDEA; in fact, last year I attended virtually, and this year, thank God, we can do it this way. I woke up this morning with the idea of what I was going to talk to you about, what I was going to share, and frankly, I decided to organize my thoughts into a speech, which I wrote, which I finished writing, and I come here without reviewing the speech, but trying to organize – a little – the essence of what I want to convey to you.

Look, Argentina, our country, is emerging from a unique moment, absolutely unique. The whole world faced a pandemic that devastated economies, businesses, jobs, and what is worse, it took millions of lives.

The vertigo with which we faced that time did not allow us to reflect on what we lived through and on who we are. We were fighters against a virus, of enormous lethality, that spread across the world at an unprecedented speed. Today – after many precautions and after being immunized by vaccines that science developed in record time – we are survivors. We are those whom death could not catch.

Such a privilege, which God has given us, demands that we reflect not only on what has happened; it imposes on us the moral and ethical duty to roll up our sleeves to build a new society, where development is constant, where structural imbalances disappear, and where social justice ceases to be a slogan and begins to become a reality.

Convinced that all of us here are actors in this present, I find it appropriate to call on you to join efforts in the construction of that new society. I am the President of all Argentines and Argentines, and I work every day for the unity of the people. I know very well that – for many years – we have been a society with opposing factions, each pulling on one end of the rope; we have only managed to ensure that the forces do not add up, but only counterbalance each other. Pulling in different directions, we have only managed to immobilize ourselves as a society.

I took office on December 10, 2019, with the frank spirit of calling on everyone to pull the rope, but to the same side. The pandemic – unleashed just 99 days later, here in Argentina – once again turned our society into two opposing sectors, and suddenly, little by little, we found ourselves facing each other in different factions again.

It is this moment, when our lives regain a lost tranquility, that is the right time to abandon insults, loud complaints, antinomies, and confrontations. It is time for us to try to deepen our agreements and minimize our differences.

This is not about unifying ideas. Democracy requires respect for plurality, but – as I have often said – that plurality is symphonic. Each one should play the chord that corresponds to them, in the time given to them, so that harmony makes the democratic system sound good.

The point we have reached today is the corollary of a pandemic and of policies – that were previously applied in our country – that left an economy stagnant and highly indebted. I say this not with the intention of engaging in revisionism, but only with the purpose of being clear about where we are, from what point we start in this task of reconstruction to which I am calling you. I want to leave behind sterile debates, but I want to make them part of the diagnosis of the present so that – from here – we can find the paths out together.

The National Government is the one that must put on the table the different alternatives to find solutions to the conflicts that we face today.

The first major problem that Argentina must face decisively is to end unemployment by creating genuine jobs. We must work with all firmness so that every Argentine finds – in the 21st century – a place to work and earn a decent living for their family.

State assistance cannot be the remedy for the lack of employment; state assistance to the most marginalized sectors is only a palliative to cope with poverty. It is not possible to perpetuate that reality, which should definitely embarrass us.

There is no other remedy than private investment, which associates capital and labor, to achieve sustainable development in our society. That has always been our conviction.

Allow me to share a personal experience that I often repeat, but that helps me explain this perspective we have better. When one travels the country campaigning, I have quite a few electoral campaigns under my belt, thousands of people approach us with a letter, in which they express their anguish and needs. In 2003, when Néstor Kirchner and I were campaigning, those letters repeatedly asked us for “a plan.” In 2003, time and again, thousands of letters asked us for a plan. Back then, more than two million people were beneficiaries of a program called “Heads of Household.”

During the four and a half years of Néstor Kirchner's government, Argentina grew at an annual average of 7%, and more than 2 million jobs were created. This allowed that – when we left government in December 2007 – social plans had been reduced to a number close to 400,000. From more than 2 million, when we left government with Néstor, there were 400,000 social plans left.

That year I was the head of the campaign that led Cristina to her first presidency. We also held events and received thousands of letters and notes that people gave us at those meetings. I then noticed that no one was asking us for social plans anymore. Now they were asking us for better working conditions.

In the eight years that Cristina was President, employment continued to grow. In total, more than a million jobs were created. Unemployment was reduced to just over 5%, a number that reflects more the turnover in employment than the actual unemployment. The number of social plans had been reduced to less than 200,000, but there was one more striking fact: by 2015, when Cristina finished her term, no one was asking for either plans or jobs. What was the demand then? The demand was that wage earners should not pay Income Tax. What a difference, right?

The fewer than 200,000 plans that Cristina left at the end of her term multiplied in the following four years. On December 10, 2019, when I took office, almost 800,000 plans were being distributed in Argentina; from less than 200,000, we were in December 2019, with almost 800,000 social plans.

The indiscriminate opening of imports, the sustained decline in consumption, and the closure of 23,000 SMEs led to a worrying increase in unemployment and poverty.

What I mean by this is that if something characterized the political space that currently governs Argentina, it is the promotion of business investment and job creation. With that same spirit, we are acting today.

That is why we are establishing – through a framework decree – a system that allows those who are currently beneficiaries of plans to become employees in the private sector without losing that right. We need to promote registered employment.

Three economic activities have already advanced in fulfilling that objective: first, it was in agriculture, where we promoted that those with plans become agricultural workers, which is crucial at harvest time; then we advanced along the same path with construction. And yesterday we took another step – in the same direction – with the gastronomic and hotel industry.

Changing plans for jobs. That must be our primary objective. In this way, we will be fighting head-on against the poverty that today has plunged millions of Argentine families.

We have always taken care of formal employment. The Employment and Production Allocation (ATP) is a clear proof of what I say. We supported thousands of employers by paying part of the salaries of those who worked there. We continue to do the same today, providing REPRO in the activities that still need state assistance.

Creating jobs is something we must also address together. We must do it without stigmatization. We should not see work as a cost, but as an investment.

I have heard, in recent times, many demands to put an end to severance pay for dismissals. The idea is repeated, time and again, to generalize indemnity schemes that serve sectors with a high turnover rate and also informality. Construction or textiles are examples of what I mean.

So far, there is no evidence showing the success of those logics. These models are always inspired by systems that exist in Nordic countries or in Austria, and they tell us about them. Now let me not go over those schemes with you.

David Card, who just received the Nobel Prize in Economics, studied precisely the effects of severance pay on the economy of Austria and concluded that severance pay has positive effects. The most important contribution of Card is that he demonstrated that the labor system (with more or less flexibility) does not alter the behavior of the worker at all. Thus, it is concluded that it is not true that workers with greater rights are incentivized to be dismissed.

Let’s see what happens in Nordic countries in this matter, because – many times – they are cited as examples. Let’s see what happens in Finland. In Finland, for example, where dismissal without cause is punishable by between 3 and 24 months' salary and the union must intervene in the conflict in a mandatory way. The fines for arbitrary dismissals can reach 35,000 euros, and these conditions are imposed on all companies with more than 20 employees.

In Denmark, employees – outside of agreements – are protected against dismissal without cause. The severance costs range from 6 to 12 months' salary, and in all cases, the union must intervene in resolving the conflict.

In Norway, there are no severance payments for dismissals without cause. It is true, there are no severance payments, but for someone to be dismissed, the employer must have the consent of the employee, the consent of their lawyer, and the consent of the union. In that context, the dismissed employee invariably continues to receive their salary until the court approves the dismissal decision.

A growing economy that produces and exports needs a well-paid workforce that is protected in its rights. That is what I believe. With this labor system, 4 million jobs were created in Argentina between 2002 and 2015.

The exceptional measures we have taken (prohibition of dismissals and double severance pay) must be understood in that way, as exceptional measures, not as rules. They have been established at a unique moment and will not be sustained over time.

In the same vein, we have taken several of the measures that you – in this very seminar and in the working document – have proposed:

• The TE SUMO plan reduces employer contributions for SMEs and subsidizes part of the salary for companies that hire young people aged 18 to 24. • The Knowledge Economy Law reduces employer contributions by 70% for the entire sector and also eliminates export duties. • For the Northern region, San Juan, and Mendoza, we eliminated employer contributions for 3 years in all productive sectors, promoting federal development. • We have reduced employer contributions by 90% to 95%, depending on the case, for participants in employment and professional training programs.

Likewise, for Argentina to regain its course, it must definitively resolve the debt problem that we inherited. We have partially resolved the issue by reaching an agreement with private creditors. We have ensured that the agreement does not postpone the most needy and allows Argentina to recover. We have gained time and achieved a reduction of the debt of more than 37 billion dollars.

Now, we are discussing the debt taken with the International Monetary Fund. This is a unique case in the history of the organization. The loan – given to Argentina – in 2018, for 57.1 billion dollars represented the largest loan granted by the organization to a member country. That year it represented 55 percent of the total lent by the International Monetary Fund to the entire world. That sum of 57.1 billion dollars was equivalent to 11% of the GDP at that time and was given in a context of capital flight, which contradicted the very statutes of the international credit organization.

As the credit was contracted under the “stand by” modality, we are obliged to pay it within a period of no more than three years, which means that in the next two years, in 2022 and 2023, Argentina is obliged to pay – in each year – more than 19 billion dollars in capital and interest.

The National Government is discussing with the IMF how to pay that debt. We need the rates applied to be reduced, we need to buy time to start paying, and we need to extend the compliance times for that debt as much as possible.

As we are vigorous in the debate with our creditors, we only demonstrate our seriousness. We must resolve the debt problem by making it sustainable, that is, not condemning Argentina to postponement. We must grow, accumulate reserves, and start to comply.

The problem of external debt in Argentina, and the problem of the debt with the IMF, is not a problem of Alberto Fernández's government; it is a problem of Argentina. Alberto Fernández's government would have resolved the problem, because with the waiting time we achieved, to start paying, we – in our administration – would not have to pay anything, but we would leave a problem for the future of Argentina, and our problem is not to get rid of the issue, it is to resolve the debt problem in Argentina; that is the objective. Those who today propose to take more loans to pay off those loans are actually the same ones who generated this debt, and then said to "reprofile" it to deepen the crisis even further.

Our decision to find a quick agreement with the IMF is absolute. But a quick agreement cannot lead us to a bad agreement; these are two different things. We will continue discussing until we are sure that we will have the necessary resources to get the Argentine economy back on its feet and guarantee work for our people. Only from there will we begin to meet the obligations we have inherited.

Growth also confronts us with a sad distributive struggle. Restoring real wages is an obligation we have as a society. Workers' income has seen a decline in real wages since 2016, exceeding 20%. This is a task we must impose on ourselves to fulfill.

Business owners must do their part. We have seen that, in September and so far in October, the price of items in the family basket has increased in an incomprehensible manner. We must find the balance point so that this price increase ceases. We want to do this in agreement with industrialists and commercial chains, but everyone must know that we will be inflexible in this matter. The Argentine people cannot be victims of the speculation and ambition of a few. A society where a few win and millions lose does not resemble a society; it resembles a scam. I trust we can find that balance at a common table where this issue is discussed.

In recent times, through the Economic and Social Council, we have promoted many measures that were the result of the agreement among producers, workers, and the State.

The Knowledge Economy Law; the sustainable electromobility plan; the agro-bio-industrial plan; the strategic plan to promote the construction industry; the plan for the development of gas and hydrocarbons; the bill for State innovation procurement; and the multi-year financing plan for science and technology are examples of what we can do together.

That is the challenge. To recover education, to recover science and technology, to put Argentina and its economy in a good place, to grow our economy, to create jobs. That is our obligation.

Argentina needs business owners who are the first workers. We must listen to each other, we must debate, find agreements; we must understand that we are all in the same boat. The pandemic has already taught us that no one, no one saves themselves alone. We need those business owners, entrepreneurs, and workers, without lobbies and with creativity, without speculation and with production. Without greed and with solidarity.

Enrique Shaw – someone you always remember – said that a company is like a ship: the neglect of one can lead everyone to sink. Let us think of Argentina in that way. Because in this way we can create a better society.

Thank you very much to all.