Statements at the meeting with a group of religious scholars.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

19 January 2004 · Meeting with a group of religious scholars · Qom seminary, Qom, Iran

Context
Khamenei addressed a group of religious scholars at a meeting in January 2004, urging the Qom seminary to reclaim its central role in Islamic philosophical education.
Main themes
Islamic philosophy in seminary education, Qom seminary reform, rational sciences and religious scholarship, legacy of Allameh Tabatabai, centralization of philosophical authority, Shia philosophical tradition, encouragement of young scholars, relationship between jurisprudence and philosophy, seminary management, history of opposition to philosophy in Iran
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,802
73rd percentile
Sentences
118
71st percentile
Readability
45
50th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
70th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 53%53%
  • Institutional 32%32%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

118 sentences in 16 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

This session is very sweet and attractive for me. If there were an opportunity, I would have no objection to this session continuing for another hour or more to hear the remarks of the gentlemen. What you have said was comprehensive; that is, all aspects of what is good in the field of rational sciences and its relationship with the seminary should come to mind and be discussed, were almost present in the statements of the gentlemen. I truly enjoyed it and I thank God. One of the honors of the Islamic system is that the Qom seminary includes and contains a group of young, energetic, and thoughtful scholars, among whom you are the elite and some of the best. Of course, I am personally acquainted with some of the gentlemen and have known their sincerity for years; with others, I am somewhat familiar through their works or articles, and as the saying goes, we have boasted everywhere that we have a gathering of active, thoughtful young scholars in the seminary. You are truly the hope of the future. God willing, these pillars will be able to promise a lofty ceiling and a magnificent structure for the future of the seminary.

In the past, there was opposition to philosophy and the existence of the late Mr. Tabatabai in the Qom seminary. You know that his lessons on Asfar were ordered to be suspended, and he was forced to teach Shifa. In recent times, Qom has been the center of our philosophical seminary; Mr. Tabatabai was also a completely religious, vigilant, constantly remembering, devout person, knowledgeable in exegesis and hadith; he was not one of those wandering mystics - of course, we do not consider private sessions - his scientific and jurisprudential levels were such that no one could deny them; yet, someone like Mr. Tabatabai, who dared to continue philosophy and did not retreat, was attacked in this way. What is the result? The result is that today the level of philosophical thought and knowledge in our society and among religious scholars is limited. With a teacher like Mr. Tabatabai, we should have many first-rate professors among his students in Qom and other cities today. Mr. Tabatabai was an active individual; therefore, the philosophical movement that he established should have expanded widely, which it has not. Of course, at that time we were followers of Mr. Borujerdi, and we still look at him with respect and reverence; however, whatever it was, the result was this. This should not be repeated.

Islamic philosophy - as you said and rightly pointed out - is the greater jurisprudence; it is the foundation of religion; the basis of all religious knowledge in the mind and external actions of humans; therefore, it must expand and strengthen and grow, and this requires work and effort.

The center of philosophy must also be the seminary. One of the greatest losses we have incurred is that the center of Islamic philosophy has been transferred from the seminary to various regions. Some of the philosophy professors were with me last Ramadan; they said that some gentlemen who are not qualified at all teach philosophy in mosques and provide incomplete, superficial, and shallow materials that do not reach depth to individuals. These are losses; we must not allow this to continue. I have repeatedly told Mr. Javadi and Mr. Misbah that we must do something so that Qom does not lose its centrality and authority in philosophy and that the main hub of Islamic philosophy remains intact. Therefore, in this regard, whatever efforts you make will be appropriate and just. Everyone must strive; the management of the seminary and philosophy professors must also make efforts. Philosophy students should be encouraged.

The notion that the privileges of clerics and religious figures belong to jurists, not to philosophers, mystics, and theologians, is not as it used to be today. In the past, Mulla Ismail Khajooei in Isfahan - who was among the students of Mulla Sadra - with his scientific status and greatness, did not dare to teach philosophy. The fate of some of his contemporaries - like the late Bidabadi and others - had created such bitter experiences for them that they did not dare to teach philosophy. Mulla Ismail Khajooei is a scholar, a jurist, a principlist, and one of our great philosophers. Unfortunately, these individuals are not well-known. Let me say in parentheses: one of the things that must be done is to introduce Shia philosophers from different periods. Our philosophy students do not know them; they only know a few famous ones. I was saying that these individuals, out of fear, did not dare to express philosophy. Today, it is not like that; philosophy is a privilege and an honor; not only in the eyes of the seminary but also in the eyes of the people. Some who are not even philosophers claim to be philosophy professors for these apparent privileges. Therefore, do not see the atmosphere as discouraging that now, for example, we must sacrifice ourselves and enter the realm of philosophy; no, today philosophy has a privilege. With the expansion of university spaces and the spread of knowledge and understanding among the youth, today when a talented philosophy student or philosopher emerges in society, they gain a respect advantage. In my opinion, this trend should be strengthened. Do not let the seminary lose its centrality in philosophy. In this regard, whatever can be done should be done. You, who are young and have energy, patience, and enthusiasm, bear this burden today.

I will mention two or three points regarding the teaching of philosophy and philosophical research, which fortunately I have seen in the minds of some friends as well. One is the issue of the political-social extension of philosophy, which I have repeatedly told friends and now also affirming the statements of some gentlemen; however, not with the expression of philosophical renaissance; it should not be presented in this sense. We do not need a philosophical renaissance or to overturn the foundations of our philosophy. The flaw in our philosophy is not that it is mental - philosophy naturally deals with the mind and intellect - the flaw in our philosophy is that this mentality does not have a political and social extension. Western philosophies determine obligations for all aspects of people's lives, more or less: they determine the social system, the political system, the state of governance, the quality of people's interactions with each other; however, our philosophy generally remains in the realm of abstract mentalities and does not extend. You should come and ensure this extension, and this is possible; just as the concept of monotheism is a philosophical basis and an idea; but you see that this monotheism has a social and political extension. "There is no god but Allah" is not confined to philosophical and intellectual assumptions; it enters society and determines the obligations of the ruler, the obligations of the ruled, and the obligations of the people. It is possible to find significant points in our existing philosophical foundations that, if expanded and deepened, will create very fruitful movements outside the realm of mentality and determine the obligations of society, governance, and economy. Seek these points, identify them, and work on them; then create a philosophical system. From the unity of existence, from "the simple reality of all things," from the foundations of Mulla Sadra, if we do not say from all of these, from many of these - a philosophical system of social, political, and economic nature can be created; especially from the added philosophies that the gentlemen mentioned: philosophy of ethics, philosophy of economy, and so on. This is one of the fundamental tasks. No one but you can do this; you must carry out this task.

Islamic philosophy has been a foundation and system that brought humans closer to religion, God, and religious knowledge. Philosophy is for approaching God and finding a correct understanding of the realities of existence; therefore, our best philosophers - like Avicenna and Mulla Sadra - have also been mystics. The very integration of mysticism with philosophy in modern philosophy - that is, the philosophy of Mulla Sadra - is because philosophy is a means and a ladder that leads humans to divine knowledge and God; it purifies and creates ethics in humans. We must not allow philosophy to turn into a series of abstract mentalities devoid of spirituality, God, and mysticism. The way is to strengthen Mulla Sadra's philosophy; that is, the path that Mulla Sadra took is the right path. That philosophy compels a person to undertake seven pilgrimages on foot and to disregard all worldly adornments. Of course, we do not want to say that anyone who is not part of this philosophical system is worldly; no, but this is a good path. The path of philosophy should be the path of religiosity and increasing the connection and attachment of humans to God; this must be observed in the teaching of philosophy, in the compilation of philosophical books, in philosophical lessons, and in the philosophy association - as mentioned. The philosophers we have seen before were all like this; they were individuals who, in terms of spirituality, divinity, and heart and spiritual connections with God, were better, more adept, and clearer than others who worked in the scientific fields of the seminary.

As Mr. Javadi said, "The lover loves the statement and the hater hates the statement," which is also correct. I have another factor in mind, which is the creation of competition for our philosophy in recent times. In my opinion, evidence and signs indicate that the philosophies that became prevalent in Iran - and are still at their peak - were not ordinary. They sought to create competition for Islamic philosophy; therefore, they brought in Western philosophies and translated and promoted them. With the negligence of our seminaries, gradually the situation reached a point where whenever the name of philosophy was mentioned in academic environments - and it is still somewhat the same - the mind would go towards Kant, Hegel, and the like, and it was imagined that philosophy was the product of their thoughts. When Marxist thoughts were very prevalent in Iran, one of the main propaganda tools of the communists was to attack Aristotelian logic and formal logic, which was considered an insult in the face of dialectical logic; they would say these people are supporters of Aristotelian logic! To such an extent, they had devalued Islamic philosophy and the foundations of Islamic philosophy, including logic. This was done deliberately. Of course, we do not say that every student or professor who entered modern philosophy must have connections with the CIA; no, but this became a fundamental thought. Those who were the pioneers of this work - like Foroughi and others - their political and foreign connections and efforts are evident. Today, one can observe signs and evidence that some want to bring strong philosophical volumes that are directly opposite to us - which we have placed philosophy as a completely special matter. Unlike a jurist who, for example, sits and states a matter, the emergence and manifestation of philosophy from within a person is outward; this has been the training of our seminaries; however, they, on the contrary, promoted philosophy at various levels.

One of the fields of authorship and philosophical work is writing philosophy for children. Numerous philosophical books have been written for children, introducing their minds from the beginning to the philosophical foundations that are currently favored by liberal democracy. Certainly, in the former Soviet Union and other Marxist systems, if there was a philosophy for children and youth, it would lead to something like Marx's scientific philosophy. We are neglecting this work. I have advised friends who are working at the Mulla Sadra Foundation to sit down and write books for youth and children. This is a task that Qom can strive for. Therefore, one of the very necessary tasks is to expand philosophy; of course, with solid foundations and good and attractive literature.

In my opinion, there should not be a dispute between philosophy and theology. The most important theological book we have was written by a philosopher - that is, Khwaja Nasir - but it is, in fact, philosophy. We must bring these closer together; there is no obstacle. Philosophy, theology, and mysticism have differences, but they also have commonalities; we must consider and pursue them as rational sciences - this expression that the gentlemen had and is completely a good expression - or in a sense wisdom, which encompasses all of these.

The philosophy association that Mr. Fayyazi mentioned is a very good and correct idea. Of course, a few years ago, I raised a similar point with some friends in Qom and said that a philosophical club or a club of philosophy enthusiasts should be formed; I am now saying that it is good to establish an Islamic philosophy association or an Islamic wisdom association. This is among the very useful plans. A good foundation should be established or existing foundations should be utilized and equipped for this purpose. They should create a lecture hall, set up a place for lessons, and hold roundtables. The movement of free thought that was raised and some gentlemen welcomed is one of the best places for this. Individuals should sit and express their opinions, statements, and arguments; professors should have the opportunity to come and see their philosophical students; they should see who these individuals are in the second tier. Some of you gentlemen have attended the lessons of Mr. Javadi or Mr. Misbah; perhaps you have not attended. Professors should come and see their students, their students' students, or their interested students up close; they should speak or give lectures; this is a very good thing, and I agree with it, and I will help in any way I can.

Another point that was raised and was correct is the issue of attracting national resources for the philosophy of the seminary. This is your responsibility; that is, you should specify where these resources - whether title resources, positional resources (like teaching positions here and there), or financial resources - should be attracted; just as positions are defined in military and administrative forces, and then they look for the right person. You must define positions for attracting assistance.

In my opinion, what the gentlemen said was good. Some gentlemen summarized. The statement of Mr. Khosrowpanah and some other gentlemen was, in fact, a very good summary of the overall work that should be done and pursued. These works will progress when there is planning. What I want to say is that you gentlemen should sit down and form a group and select a chosen group that can dedicate more time to plan; for example, what should we do for the growth, promotion, deepening, and justification of the intellectual movement in the seminary. Some of these tasks are your responsibility, some are the responsibility of the professors, some are the responsibility of the management, and some may be our responsibility; we must specify these. Of course, this work does not conflict with the seminary's program. I do not recommend breaking the seminary's programs to anyone. The seminary has a program, like the program of a large university. If among the group of individuals studying and teaching in this large university with this large program, a group comes and pursues an independent scientific work, this is compatible with the overall program of the university. In my opinion, this work is feasible. Of course, the seminary's planning can also help and support, and if necessary, a recommendation can be made to friends in Qom in this regard; we have no objection. However, the important thing is that your belief and commitment to the importance and fundamental impact of this work should not diminish. You are the engine of this great train; if the engine is turned off or slows down, it will certainly affect the movement of the train. This engine must work, regularly and healthily, and move forward; of course, it must also be supported in terms of credibility and finances.

I once again thank God for the fact that, thank God, I have had the opportunity to meet with you gentlemen. I am happy that you are in the Qom seminary, and I thank God for that. I am also pleased that, thank God, the esteemed professors of Qom have had the opportunity to present such a valuable product to the seminary; however, I again recommend that you continue this movement and move forward so that, God willing, the Almighty God will also assist.

Peace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.