Statements at the University of Tehran Q&A Session

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

12 May 1998 · Q&A session with students at the University of Tehran · University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

Context
Khamenei addressed a Q&A session with students at the University of Tehran on May 12, 1998, responding to questions on university, political, and cultural issues.
Main themes
Basij student organization, press freedom and media criticism, political divisions after presidential elections, Islamic science and culture, rigidity and stagnation in universities, families of martyrs, Guardianship of the Islamic Jurist, student engagement, cultural warfare against stagnation
Duration
~71 min
97th percentile
Words
8,509
97th percentile
Sentences
479
98th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from Persian

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

479 sentences in 107 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

Please write down any points that come to your mind; I will also share what I think is necessary later. However, I would like the dear students to ask questions, and I will respond. Certainly, some of what will be said will be useful; if we do not say all of it is useful. My time will not be taken up. My time today is dedicated to this work. I have set aside all other tasks for today until the afternoon so that I can be here with you. Of course, keep in mind that there will be many questions. Questions will come in regularly, and I may be able to answer some of them; that is, there may not be enough time to answer all the questions. I think it would be better to take the questions and have friends categorize them, so that they can be answered later and returned to you. Of course, I do not make a definite promise; I will try to do this. If it can be done, it will be very good.

Some individuals have raised objections regarding the presence of the Basij or the student Basij in universities, citing military concerns and imposing restrictions. What is your opinion on this matter?

The Basij is not necessarily a military organization; it is not necessarily a military organization. The Basij means the people. I may also be a member of the Basij; however, I am not a soldier. There are Basijis in universities, factories, seminaries, and offices; the Basij is everywhere. The Basij is not a military organization. There is no problem with students being Basijis; rather, it is undoubtedly a value. It is not a problem if everyone is Basiji.

Despite the fact that all members of the Basij are students who have voluntarily and willingly registered, university officials are strict towards this group.

No, I do not think it is appropriate to be strict towards the Basij. Of course, I do not know the details of this matter; I should later ask the respected president of the university to see if such a thing even exists or not. In this country, no one is against the Basij. The Basij has served this country so much that no one can doubt its usefulness—indeed, its necessity. The Basij is a legacy of the Imam.

Please share your thoughts on the toxic atmosphere of the press in the country.

After all, the press is the press! Some are good, some are better; some are bad, and some are worse; each has its own audience. In my opinion, the way to deal with bad press is to develop good press. If the press landscape in the country is filled in a useful and appropriate way, bad press—the kind you call bad, which I do not know what the criteria for badness are—will not find much ground.

After the presidential elections and the epic presence of the people at the ballot boxes, some individuals and officials create divisions with various expressions and use the beloved and respected president for their own interests.

The president is not someone who can be exploited. The president is a prominent, knowledgeable, and wise personality. He has chosen the right path and is moving along that path. Someone may speak for themselves, but I do not think anyone can exploit the president; God willing.

The biggest problem in our universities is the atmosphere of rigidity and stagnation in the realm of pure Islamic science and culture. How do you think this atmosphere of rigidity can be eliminated?

This is a very important and noteworthy issue. Of course, I doubt that this is our biggest problem; however, rigidity and stagnation, wherever they exist, are a problem, and the way to eliminate them is for you—who are students—to enhance the quality of your thinking in the realm of knowledge and understanding as much as you can. Each one of you, when you are knowledgeable, cultured, wise, enlightened, and educated, can spread these concepts in practice; that is, it is the exact opposite of the atmosphere of rigidity and stagnation. If we want to fight against rigidity, the fight against rigidity is cultural warfare. The fight against rigidity is not a military fight; it is a matter of culture. Stagnation and rigidity are also a type of culture; however, a closed culture! It must be confronted with cultural methods. In my opinion, students can be effective in this regard.

If possible, we hope to discuss and examine the problems of the families of martyrs—especially the student martyrs. We hope that our request will be approved.

I do not know if it is suggested that I speak with the student martyrs or if I should appoint someone to speak. It does not matter; we will examine this issue. Although we did not come here with official arrangements, one of you gentlemen should note this down so that I can give it to the office to follow up. Please set this paper aside so that it can be addressed later.

How can one clearly understand the pure line of the Guardianship in everyday and current issues so that individuals cannot misrepresent your opinions as contrary?

What I express in my speeches is the essence of my views. My fundamental opinions are those that you hear from me in my speeches. There is no opinion regarding the current issues of the country, the issues of Islam and Muslims, and social issues that I whisper to someone and cannot say publicly. My opinions are transparent and clear, which you hear in the Friday prayer sermons and in speeches with various groups.

Has it not been stated in our dear Quran that man is created free and that the greatest freedom is the freedom to read and write? Then why has this right been taken from us in the Islamic Republic?

I do not know who has taken this right! Whoever has taken it, introduce them to me so that I can go and take your right from them and give it back to you! The truth is that you young people have not seen the pre-revolutionary period in this country, nor have you seen many countries in the world. Today, fortunately, in Iran, the freedom to think and express thoughts is unparalleled in the world. Of course, I do not want to say that Islam has granted this freedom unconditionally; no, it is not like that. There are limitations in this regard, which are also anticipated in our laws; perhaps what results from all of this aligns with the Quranic teachings you mentioned. However, what is the result of all this today is freedom, and fortunately, it exists; it is very good. The situation in which you see me sitting here and you are speaking, and I am reading your words, is also one of the rare things in the world. I am happy that the situation in our country, in terms of human aspects and respect for human personality and identity, is so good that it creates higher expectations; there is no obstacle to that. However, know that if you go to other places—countries similar to ours, with similar backgrounds—and look at the issues related to freedom, you will see that fortunately, there is no place like Iran in this regard.

What thoughts have you given to the marriage of young students?

Of course, this is an important question. I do not take this question lightly at all; it is truly an important question. In my opinion, it is one of the matters that the relevant authorities should pay attention to. We have made many recommendations to the relevant authorities regarding these issues—both concerning the marriage of young people and the necessities that marriage entails—such as the issue of housing, which I have been recommending to the Ministry of Housing for a long time. They are taking actions, including the construction of temporary rental housing for newly married couples, which is one of those actions. We hope that these preparations will be made, and God willing, the marriage issue will be resolved in some way. In this matter, you are right.

What is the responsibility of newly recruited scientific personnel towards the university faculty members in assisting the Islamicization of universities?

The issue of Islamicizing universities is on the agenda of the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution, which has programs for it, is doing work, and has detailed it in various areas. In this regard, newly recruited personnel and old personnel do not differ; I do not think there is a difference. In any case, I do not interfere in the method of this work and have not done so. The method is related to the university officials and the prominent members of the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution; they must decide. I have proposed the idea and demanded it from them, and I will continue to demand it, and if universities are Islamicized, it will be understood and clarified what I wanted and what I said. I do not think there is even one person in the universities who does not feel the necessity and goodness and usefulness of it. Therefore, everyone has a duty to work in this regard. Of course, I can also feel that the meaning of Islamicizing universities has not always and everywhere been correctly understood by everyone. Some have understood it very narrowly, small, and weakly. The intention is a matter that is much higher than this.

Given the limited resources in the graduate education sector, is there a possibility for progress in the scientific field and reaching the necessary status?

I am not fully aware of the resources available in the universities; however, I am aware that the government's decision is to develop educational and research facilities for students. There may be temporary deficiencies in a university due to the budget constraints and income problems of the government; however, the definitive decision and determination of the government is to address these problems.

Do you believe that the speed of scientific progress is greater in Iran or in the United States?

This is a very strange question. Americans have been striving in scientific fields for many years. In those years when Americans were freely training scientists with their national resources and the resources they plundered from other countries, our nation was under the yoke of a regime that, through oppression, dependency, political corruption, and moral corruption, did not allow Iranian scholars even to think! Do you expect us to progress at the level of the United States and keep pace with them under these conditions? That is an excessive expectation.

I may have mentioned this before, that the fighter jets that were purchased from the United States during the previous regime, if there was a defect in a part of them—which each part sometimes consists of dozens of parts—the Americans would not allow our Air Force technical personnel to open that large part to find the defect and replace that small part! Only the complete part—which sometimes consisted of dozens and sometimes hundreds of parts—would be mounted on the plane, sent to America, replaced, and returned! They behaved like this. There was no number of students, no quality of education, no field of work, no spirit of nurturing, research, and education in the country. Under those conditions, do you expect the Iranian nation to have made progress?

We have been starting for nineteen years. In these nineteen years, we have faced the initial problems of the revolution and the events of this university and the presence of armed groups and the war period. I have many memories from this mosque—the University of Tehran mosque—both from before the revolution and from various periods of the revolution, which it would be good to share one of them with you: In 1979, on one of the days of the week—I think it was Sunday or Monday—I would come to this mosque and perform the noon prayer. Students would gather, and I would answer questions and give speeches. That year, this University of Tehran had become a stronghold for armed groups that, under various titles and names, with G3s and Kalashnikovs, were attacking the people outside the university and the Muslim students! One day, when there was intense real conflict at the university, I came here as usual at noon. When I entered the university, a few students came and said it is dangerous today; do not come here. I said no; I will not cancel my program. So I entered. The university was empty; there were almost no one; very few people could be seen because the situation was dangerous. From the path we came, the students came to the mosque. Perhaps that day, not even ten people gathered in the mosque; everyone had fled. I think we prayed and left; that is, we were also somewhat scared. Subsequently, the university was closed for a while. Perhaps for about a year, the university was closed in our country. See; these nineteen years have had such periods; periods of conflicts, periods of not studying, periods of demonstrations and strikes that were imposed on the university every day. What is the effect of these? When a student is prevented from studying, do you expect scientific flourishing to emerge like lightning in the academic environment of the country? Then there was the imposed war and its problems. Of course, the universities had reopened, classes were held; however, the country was engaged in war. In reality, if we want to filter these nineteen years, ten years of it do not come out. In fact, after the end of the war, we were able to attend to the universities.

Therefore, our ten-year scientific progress is not at the speed of the two-hundred-year progress of the United States; however, I want to tell you that the Iranian student, with their intelligence, faith, sense of independence, and the sense of dignity that exists today in the Iranian nation, especially in our youth and students, if they work for thirty years, there is hope that they will progress as much as a hundred years of others.

What is the best way to deal with immoralities?

It depends on who wants to confront them. If you want to confront them, it is through "language." You have no other obligation besides language. Enjoining good and forbidding wrong for the people is only verbal. Of course, it is not like that for the government. If there is a major immorality, the government's response may sometimes be legal and harsh; however, the enjoining of good and forbidding of wrong that is in the sacred Islamic law is verbal; "it is only the tongue."

Do not be surprised. I tell you that the impact of verbal enjoining and forbidding—if done—is greater than the impact of the iron fist of governments. I have been saying enjoining good and forbidding wrong for several years. Of course, some people do this; however, not everyone does. Not everyone experiences it; they say, "Why does it not have an effect?" Experience it. When you see an immorality, remind it with your tongue. It is not even necessary for the language to be harsh, nor do you need to give a speech to eliminate that immorality. Just say one word: "Sir! Ma'am! Brother! This is immoral." You say it, the second person says it, the third person says it, the tenth person says it, the fiftieth person says it; who can continue the immorality?

Of course, let me tell you, my dear ones! You must recognize the immorality. Some things may seem immoral to some, while they are not immoral. You must know what is immoral. You really must know that this is immoral. Some have said that there must be a possibility of impact. I say the possibility of impact is certain everywhere; except in the presence of tyrannical governments, powerful people, and monarchs. They are the ones who, of course, do not listen to rational arguments and do not have an effect; however, for the people, yes. For the people, words have an effect. Therefore, my answer is that the best method for you who asked me is "language."

Given the cultural invasion in universities and the oppression and monopoly of some faculty members and the expulsion and pressure on Muslim professors, what measures does the system foresee to support Muslim professors and prevent their dismissal?

Of course, I do not endorse the statements that you, my dear brother or sister, have written and I have read. My reading does not imply endorsement—it is your quotation—because I am not aware that such a thing exists. However, if it is indeed the case that in a university environment, the atmosphere is tight for Muslim professors, that is a bad thing; it is not a good thing; but I doubt that it is like that. We hope it is not like that.

Please share your opinion on the solidarity between different groups.

I believe in solidarity. I believe in good relations; good relations that do not mean deviating from known truths and certainties. I believe that there should be good relations among student groups, regardless of their preferences. Look at the countries of the world; various social and political groups in the world, despite their many differences, sit around a table, talk, negotiate; eventually, they reach a conclusion. It does not make sense that in an Islamic university environment, individuals who believe in common principles, accept Islam, accept the Imam, accept the revolution, and accept values—yet have different preferences—do not get along with each other. I cannot understand or accept that.

What is your opinion about civil society, the formation of parties, and the election of councils?

Civil society is a phrase; what does it mean? The slogan of civil society has been given by our President. He explained this word by saying that what I mean by civil society is that society which takes its model from "Medinat al-Nabi." We are all ready to give our lives for such a society; that is clear.

Of course, today in the West, this term has a specific meaning. You should know that the Westerners, with all possible tricks, try to convey the main lines of their thought and culture. Now they have created a form and a set and given it a name; we have nothing to do with them. From our own perspective, this term has meaning for us, and we accept it.

Regarding the issue of parties, council elections, and so on, it must be said that the Constitution has determined the duties of all these. Can anyone not accept the Constitution? The Constitution has determined the duties of councils and the duties of parties. If actions are taken according to what is in the Constitution and some ordinary laws, I agree and believe in it.

I wanted to know your opinion about the groups that support the Guardianship.

In my opinion, all groups support the Guardianship. I do not know of any significant group in the country that does not accept the Guardianship. Everyone accepts the Guardianship. Now, some may have more love and sincerity, and some may have less. For example, we all accept the Guardianship of the Imams, peace be upon them; but there is someone who, as soon as the name of Amir al-Mu'minin, peace be upon him, is mentioned, his eyes fill with tears. He has more love; naturally, he also earns more reward. There is another person who accepts the Imam, knows him, is sincere, and is ready to be killed for Amir al-Mu'minin, peace be upon him; but it is not the case that as soon as they say "Peace be upon you, O Amir al-Mu'minin," his eyes fill with tears. One cannot say, "Why do you not accept the Guardianship, and your eyes did not fill with tears!"

All student groups—both the groups themselves and individual students—are in contact with me and come to me, and all express their devotion to the Guardianship. Everyone accepts it; it is clear that they accept it. I also support all of them in a sense; of course, not materially; I do not support anyone materially. I believe they should be in the university, work, strive, and, of course, make the people Muslim and revolutionary. The duty of student gatherings and organizations is to strive to make the various elements that exist Muslim—of course, they are all Muslims—and revolutionary. They should advance them and make the refinement of morals and the deepening of moral and revolutionary foundations their goal.

What is a successful student?

In my opinion, a successful student is someone who studies well; who refines their morals well and engages in sports well. I have three criteria for a successful student. Of course, a successful young person at home may have other criteria; a successful tradesman, a successful office worker may have other criteria; but a successful student, in terms of being a student, is this: they must study well, engage in ethics and self-refinement, and also do sports.

What is the duty of the youth of Hezbollah and the faithful in the face of deviations and ill intentions that are observed in some places?

If it is a denial, the duty is to enjoin good and forbid wrong.

Please tell us a bit about your youth.

Our youth, in a sense, was very exciting and eventful; in another sense, it is not the kind of youth that one would regret. Know this: when a person does not have your youth, it is appropriate to regret it. My dear ones! You live in a time of freedom and the emergence of talents; however, our youth was not like that.

I came in front of the Faculty of Law of this university, waiting for a brother; we had arranged for me to come and go together. I stood here waiting for about ten minutes. I felt that I was being looked at with suspicion by elements that were everywhere—SAVAK elements and university intelligence and security agents—because I was not a student; they were saying to themselves, "What does this cleric have to do here in front of the Faculty of Law? What is he doing, and what is his goal? God forbid he is doing something political!"

It was the late 40s or early 50s—I do not remember exactly—at that moment, the late "Riyazi Yazdi" happened to come to us. He was a relatively good poet and an employee of the Faculty of Medicine—recently I saw that his collection of poems has also been published. He was very friendly with us. He called my name and greeted me. Then he asked if I had seen the university mosque. Since I had not seen it, he said, "Let’s go, I will show you the university mosque." I think it was around here; now I do not remember exactly. I suspect that after that, the mosque's condition changed; because there were inscriptions there with poetry written on them. He brought us next to those inscriptions and said, "Look at these poems"; he began to read. After he read the poems, when we reached the end, we saw that the poems belonged to him! May God have mercy on him; he had brought us to see these. In any case, we had benefited a lot from his poems; this was another example. Anyway, the atmosphere was one of suspicion and danger. Now, I who was in the field of struggle and had been imprisoned, even when I stood in front of the Faculty of Law for about ten minutes, I was under the pressure of the suspicious looks of the agents. Therefore, life was bitter.

How do you evaluate the role of the representative of the Wali al-Faqih in universities? Is this institution currently fulfilling its fatherly, non-partisan, and trans-organizational role well?

This institution is a very good institution, and the university needed this institution. Of course, this institution existed before my time; I came and actually edited this institution a bit; younger and more active individuals came. From some universities that I hear about, thank God, it is very good; but from some places, students come to me and complain. Brothers have come to me many times and complained; but that complaint is not about the misconduct of that institutional brother; it is about, for example, shortcomings. They do not perform the necessary work; they do not do it on time, and so on. In any case, if there is a problem, it must be corrected.

What will be the outcome and end of the municipality's work?

This should be asked of the judiciary; because I have no involvement in this matter. I am not currently aware of the status of this case. Of course, when a knot was created, and I really saw that there was a problem, I temporarily solved this problem, and this was considering the surrounding circumstances. I saw that the surrounding circumstances—those who are high-ranking officials of the country—were getting into trouble over this issue; therefore, I intervened and temporarily resolved this issue; however, this was not a final solution. After all, it is a case, it goes to court, and the result will be known. In my opinion, the court is not a bad thing; it is good.

I witnessed the injury of a cleric by someone on Kargar Street this past Sunday. In your opinion, what is the reason for the decline in the popularity of clerics after the revolution?

He witnessed the injury of a cleric; however, I have almost witnessed the martyrdom of several clerics. This is not a strange matter. After all, anyone may have an enemy. A cleric was injured in the street; at the same hour, dozens of non-clerics are also injured here and there; this does not indicate a lack of popularity. One cannot generally say that after the revolution, the popularity of clerics has increased or decreased. Some have gained more popularity, while others have lost it. After the revolution, at one point, it rose very high, and at another point, it has slightly declined. It depends on the conditions and some temporal phenomena. Various factors affect this matter. This is a normal occurrence.

Of course, I should not leave this unsaid, that a holy person, if they do not interfere in any matter and stand aside, their sanctity and that heavenly state may be preserved; but as soon as they enter a field, they will inevitably have some opponents and some supporters. If clerics had not interfered in various matters—like at the beginning of the revolution when they were present in committees or other institutions—and had remained in a corner of the mosque and occasionally raised their beards and criticized the situation, certainly some would have become interested in them; but know, my dear ones! When a person enters this field, it is always the case that some will agree with them, and some will disagree.

Of course, tastes are of two kinds: some say it is good for us to remain in a heavenly state; to stand aside and not interfere in any matter. One taste says no, I will abandon my heavenly state and enter the field; I will do what I consider my duty. Some will like it, and some will dislike it; God must be pleased. This is another taste. This taste belongs to those who act well; but not everyone is like that. "Many a robe is deserving of fire." Here, we do not make a general claim that anyone wearing this garment is of high rank and status; no, there are many individuals who, in this garment or in any beautiful and pure and sacred garment, may have an impure essence.

In your opinion, what are the obstacles to the implementation of the luminous decrees of Islam and the progressive principles of the Constitution of the sacred Islamic Republic?

Of course, many of them have been implemented; we cannot say that they have not been implemented at all; but yes, you are right, some of these laws have not been implemented. The obstacles are not just one that I can summarize in one sentence; after all, there are various obstacles. Some of these obstacles are related to performances. Some of these obstacles are related to severe and accumulated weaknesses in management and fundamentally in the management system. Some of these obstacles are related to unfavorable conditions inherited from the past or the propaganda against these decrees or against the Islamic Republic. After all, there are various obstacles.

Please tell us whether you consider revolutionary action to be appropriate in the cultural field? In other words, in the context of immorality and depravity, do you consider physical confrontation appropriate in cases where officials have fallen short and have not fulfilled their duties?

No. You are not at all obliged to physically confront wrong; you are only obliged to speak. What do you have to do? Just say your word. You do not say it, thinking that if you say it, it will not work. Try it, say it; say it many times. Of course, if one person says it, it is clear that it will not have an effect. Encourage others to say it. The act of speaking has a much greater effect than a punch; sometimes even more than a frown; although a frown has a constructive effect and is not like a punch. In any case, in enjoining good and forbidding wrong, if physical confrontation is necessary, it is the job of the government, not the people; unless the government allows it and assigns someone. That is another discussion, and we do not have such a situation today. We really do not assign anyone and do not consider it expedient for such things to exist.

What will happen to the clothing of clerical students in the Islamic sciences?

I did not understand what the intention is. What does clothing mean? For example, if a seminary student is a student, what happens to the clothing? They can come in clerical clothing; there is no problem. Clothing does not make a difference. In any case, if that is the intention, I have answered.

What is your opinion on the plan "Alignment of Medical Affairs with Sharia Laws"?

I have not seen this plan at all and was not aware of its existence. I learned about such a plan from the uproar in the newspapers; some are opposed, some are in favor. I do not know what this plan is and how it is. I do not express opinions about laws and regulations. I intentionally do not express opinions; because there is a channel that must naturally go through that channel. Of course, if it becomes law, I will obey the law; everyone has a duty to obey. In any case, if the meaning of this work is that we want to observe Islamic standards in universities, this is a good thing, rather a necessary one. Of course, if there are problems, those problems must be resolved.

First of all, we have made a covenant to remain true to our promise with Imam Khomeini and our beloved martyrs, and God willing, we will remain true. Secondly, our question is that today the university is devoid of organizations that, as you have stated, should attract at least forty percent of the students. Why do the thinkers of the system not present a model based on attracting forces and also providing cultural productions among them?

In my opinion, student organizations should not take models from outside; they do not need a model. When I say that forty percent should be attracted, I mean that these student populations that currently exist should work well so that they can attract at least forty percent of the students. My belief is that they are underperforming; otherwise, if they were not underperforming, they would really attract forty percent of the students, if not more. Underperformance, sometimes due to poor taste and sometimes due to negligence, causes this work not to be done. But as for what model is intended, this model should be found by the students themselves.

Can someone in our Islamic system be considered absolutely right, and someone or an idea absolutely wrong, or do opinions of right and wrong exist to some extent in every thought or individual? I consider this question to be one of the fundamental questions in the minds of myself and many students.

This issue of relativism is not a good argument. Not that I want to say who is absolutely right and who is absolutely wrong; no, it is naturally known that there is no human being who, in their collection of thoughts, does not have a wrong statement or a false idea—even unknowingly. The one who, for example, pursues a wrong assumption or a false idea must have some things in their words that are true. After all, every liar tells the truth at least once; even if by accident! I accept this; but to make this a basis for thought and philosophy and say that there is no absolute right and absolute wrong, this is wrong. No; absolute right exists, and absolute wrong also exists.

The Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, said to the Lord of the Universe during the Battle of Badr, "O Lord! Today all truth stands against all falsehood." It was truly so. The Prophet was absolute truth; but his opposing front was absolute falsehood. You tell me, what is the right of the disbelievers of Quraysh, who are illiterate, have no morals, bury their daughters alive, prostrate to idols, oppress one another, and commit all that murder? Their right is nowhere; it is absolute falsehood, just as the Prophet is absolute truth. Therefore, the theory of relativism in right and wrong is an argument that I do not accept; but whether absolute right or absolute wrong exists in us in external reality, that is another matter. Yes; I also believe that every person or every group that supports the right may ultimately have some suspicion of error, falsehood, or mistake in it; the opposite also exists.

I hope I have been able to answer this question. If this dear brother or sister who wrote this question still has questions in this area, they should write and submit them; if I have the opportunity later, I will either answer them myself or arrange for a group to answer them, and we will provide more explanation.

Please express your opinion about the various positions regarding the Assembly of Experts elections.

I do not know what the intention is and what different opinions mean. Ultimately, the Assembly of Experts election is, in my opinion, an important election. Of course, the Assembly of Experts, unlike the presidential and parliamentary elections, does not have a process of critique; they wait for a moment, but that moment—the moment of electing the leader—is very important. I have not received any checks, documents, or promissory notes from God Almighty that I will be alive in ten days, or a month, or six months, or a year; I have no guarantee. I might not be here an hour from now; it is entirely possible; not that we want to be polite. Therefore, there must be experts who, as soon as this person falls, can appoint another; just as this was done swiftly after the passing of Imam, regardless of the type of election they conducted—which I consider myself insignificant—the very act and speed of it was very useful and a solution. For this reason, the work of the Assembly of Experts is very important. Trustworthy and competent individuals must be elected and wait. Of course, the gentlemen have a meeting every year where they gather and discuss. This meeting is necessary for them and apparently useful. Many years may pass without needing that fundamental election; however, the moment they do elect, this assembly becomes very significant. That is my opinion; however, if there is another position, I am not aware of it.

As you said, the misguidance of the elites will lead to the misguidance of the masses. Some gentlemen, directly or indirectly, fall into errors within your management. How can this be communicated to you?

Know that currently, communicating a matter to me is easier than communicating it to any official in the country. If at any time someone wants to communicate something to me but does not, the fault is theirs; otherwise, I have numerous meetings and many public appearances. On Mondays—of course, with prior arrangement—many people from various places and different social classes meet with me. Sometimes students come, others come; I have many meetings. Additionally, in our office, there is a public relations department that receives hundreds of letters every day—I do not know the exact statistics now—from the people and summarizes them; the summaries are brought to me every day in the form of a booklet—or as you say, a bulletin—I also look at them as much as I can. Therefore, matters can be communicated.

Who should eliminate the atmosphere of rumor-mongering that has spread in society?

Of course, I do not know if eliminating rumors entirely is even possible or not. After all, there are always rumors in society; however, on one hand, if the people who are the target of the rumors respond wisely, and on the other hand, if accurate news is disseminated by the media, I believe the ground for rumors will naturally disappear.

On the day of the elections on Khordad 2, what did you mean when you said, "No one is like Hashemi for me"?

The reason is that Mr. Hashemi has been collaborating and befriending me since 1957—meaning for forty-one years. A forty-one-year friendship is significant; it is twice your age. Now, coincidentally, there is an interesting point. The day I said this, Mr. Khatami had not yet been elected. It is strange that Mr. Khatami also happens to have the same amount of history with me; since 1958. Of course, at that time he was young. In 1958, when I wanted to come to Qom, his father, the late Ayatollah Khatami—who was a very dear and great man—was in Mashhad, and we became acquainted with him there. He and his brothers were fifteen or sixteen years old; I was not much older than them—five or six years older—but at that age, five or six years is quite significant. In any case, we have a long history with him as well. At present, the situation is good. Our president is very close to us, and thank God, the relations between us are very good and cordial.

What is your opinion regarding prioritizing the admission of combatants, Basij members, and veterans to universities and higher education? Should this priority still be applied to the loyal forces of the revolution?

What is the problem with that? In my opinion, there is no problem at all. Amir al-Mu'minin said: "And let not the good-doer and the wrongdoer be equal in your sight." Those who truly served this revolution and this country went to the front lines; we slept, but they went to fight; what is the problem with giving them priority?

Of course, this priority should in no way overshadow academic criteria. They must achieve a rank academically; an illiterate person does not come to university. Fortunately, it has been like that. Two or three years ago, I received a report that these children who came to university with these quotas, some of them are ranked very high academically. It should be like that. In any case, in my opinion, this priority is a good thing; it is not a bad thing. It is an appreciation of sacrifice.

Please share your views on the future political activities of students and the direction of these movements.

I have expressed my views on this matter. You see, three or four years ago, I said that students should become political; and then I also expressed strong criticism against those who distanced the university from politics. A year after that, or around that time, in a student gathering, I said, "Do not make a mistake; when I say political activity, it does not mean that political activity must necessarily be against the government, against officials, and against the system." Some ill-wishers interpret political activity this way. They think political activity means political maneuvering! This is a type of political maneuvering and a kind of deception to think that political activity in the university is only achieved through speaking ill and insulting this and that; no. Political activity is for developing analytical power in students. If this student does not have political analytical power, they will be deceived, and the deception of a student is a great pain that is very hard to bear. Ultimately, if students want to develop analytical power, they must engage in political activity; they must read, write, speak, negotiate, and debate about politics. Until this is done, students will not gain the ability. My opinion is still the same.

Please elaborate on the characteristics of the Islamic university that you have in mind.

I have given several speeches on this subject, and it is not something that can be summarized in two words. In short, I consider an Islamic university to be one where knowledge is a true value. One does not pursue knowledge merely for the sake of earning a living through it. You see, the Prophet Muhammad said: "Seek knowledge even if it is in China." This means that under the conditions of that time, if it is necessary to go from Hijaz to China to acquire knowledge, go. At that time, how much money and income would it take for someone to ride a camel or a ship to go to China!? Is it possible for such an effort to be compared to material income!? This means that knowledge is a value. This must exist in an Islamic university.

You must love knowledge, value it, pursue it for God and with pure intention. Furthermore, my dear ones! You must engage in self-purification and strengthen your moral foundations. For a country, a scholar, researcher, and genius is a great wealth; but on the condition that they have strong moral foundations; a living moral conscience; otherwise, that knowledge is of no use.

You know that during the previous regime, in our universities, many students completed their education; they had good talents, but then they went abroad and became servants of foreign governments that worked against their own nation! They ate the bread of this nation, studied in the universities of this nation; but they went and became their servants and remained there for the rest of their lives. This is a lack of a waking moral conscience. Of course, if we want to summarize, these points can be made, but if we want to elaborate, it would take an hour.

In Ramadan of 1997, I had the honor of visiting Mecca with Mr. Abutalebi. Visiting the House of God brought about a revolution in me. I believe that if professors of basic sciences and engineering are also utilized in jurisprudential matters, this can create a new perspective in jurisprudential issues, especially in the discussion of theology. Additionally, professors who have a strong desire to visit Mecca for the Hajj can also benefit from this grace.

Now you, who say you have been to Mecca, have found the way—Mr. Abutalebi—what do you have to do with me!? It seems that the key to this matter is in Mr. Abutalebi's hands. I wish he could take me to Mecca as well! In my entire life, I have only been to Mecca once; that was for ten days. From the beginning to the end, we went and returned in ten days. Now you, who have fortunately gone and stayed there for a month, must have benefited more than I did.

As for the use of professors and various sciences in jurisprudential discussions. Of course, the discussion of theology is a theological discussion—not a jurisprudential one—but in any case, utilizing them is a correct and very good idea, and it means using specializations to understand topics.

One of the fundamental shortcomings of our jurisprudence is the lack of understanding of topics; because a jurisprudential ruling is a general ruling that is based on a topic; it pertains to a specific topic. If a jurist does not recognize the topic, they will make mistakes in understanding the ruling and in application; just as, for example, in financial matters, some do not understand money, do not understand banking credit, do not understand banks; as a result, they do not correctly understand the Quranic ruling on usury and may issue a different fatwa. This is one example; there are many other examples. Understanding topics is very good; I welcome it. This is a good thing; of course, the way is to connect with the Qom seminary. It would be good for Mr. Abutalebi to take the trouble to introduce these brothers who are interested in this work to the Qom seminary and its management.

Please state the political and cultural priorities in universities and the correct strategies for the movements of revolutionary Muslim students to achieve them.

I think I have addressed the political discussion. In my opinion, today’s political priorities should not specify topics; they should specify methods; the topics do not differ much. In my opinion, the political discussions of students are good. They should discuss; however, the discussions should be exploratory and investigative, not merely formal. For example, we object to some personalities or individuals or officials who express everything in a formal manner; but then suddenly I see that a certain student at a gathering, whether small or large, makes a formal statement! If a formal statement is bad, it is bad everywhere. Student discussions should be open, flexible, and adaptable, so that ultimately the political analytical power of the student increases. The goal of student political discussions should be this, so that the student can develop political analytical power. The same goes for cultural issues. Now, if we delve into this discussion, it will take a long time; these are lengthy discussions.

Islamic organizations in universities and cultural institutions generally neutralize each other's work. Most of the time, these dear ones spend their time responding to each other's political statements, and in many cases, they focus on each other rather than on the main cultural issues and the main pains of society. Sometimes, in this path, they do not hesitate to commit some of the greatest sins for the sake of God! If you find it necessary, please provide some explanations.

I think the mere raising of this issue carries its own answers. These things that have been mentioned, and that our brother wrote about with pain, in my opinion, are all painful, all bad. They should not clash with each other, should not neutralize each other's work, should not jump on each other, should not seek revenge, and should not deal with each other with bad ethics. Muslim youth should behave this way.

It seems that some cultural, social, and economic activities in our society lack a scientific basis, and it is very simple to prevent problems and possibly waste and extravagance by involving students in some matters. In general, how do you assess the role of students in national and social participation?

Students are one of the lively, active, and vibrant segments of society. In social and political matters, they should also participate in a lively, active, and vibrant manner. It is very good for students to be active in various issues, in the political matters of society, in elections, in rallies, in positioning, especially in positions regarding global and international issues, which are very important. However, regarding the claim that it lacks a scientific basis, it is good if it does have one. Now, I do not have an opinion on that matter.

What is the main duty of the revolutionary and Hezbollah youth?

In my opinion, the revolutionary youth in universities—since we are discussing students—should strive to study well; to think well and elevate their understanding. They should try to have an impact in their environment; to be active, not passive; to have a thoughtful and psychological impact on their surroundings. This is achievable. A young person can sometimes influence their entire environment—the class, the professor, and even the university—through their spiritual character. Of course, this is not achieved through political maneuvering; it is achieved through spirituality, through sincerity, and through a strong relationship with God. My dear ones! Take your relationship with God seriously. You are young; value it, talk to God, ask from God. Supplication, prayer, and prayer with attention and focus are very necessary for you. Do not push these to the margins.

I am a second-year student at one of the universities and have a strong interest in Islamic sciences, and I want to be an Islamic scholar and preacher in the future. Some say, "First get your bachelor's degree, then go to the seminary." What advice do you give? Should I first get my bachelor's degree, then go to the seminary? Or should I get my master's degree, then go to the seminary? Or should I get my doctorate, then go to the seminary? Or should I not go to the seminary at all? Or should I go to the seminary now?

Some of the student brothers have gone to the seminary, pursued seminary studies, and reached high positions; it has been very good. Of course, I think some of them went after completing their bachelor's degree; some went after their master's degree; some are currently students and are engaged in university studies. They are doing very well; although it is somewhat difficult.

However, for the brother who asked me the question and said, "I am interested," I think they should look at their capacities, enthusiasm, and talents; because it cannot be judged from afar. I have neither seen you in person nor know your talents; therefore, I am not very qualified to judge in this matter. You should see if you truly have a lot of enthusiasm, and if your field is not one of your interests, you can leave it now and go. However, now that you have participated in the entrance exam and come to university and have probably completed several semesters, it would be a shame not to finish. In my opinion, it is not bad to complete your studies and at least obtain a bachelor's degree. But if you see that you do not have much enthusiasm, or if you are hesitant, then go ahead and later you will make a decision.

And peace be upon you and the mercy of God and His blessings.