Lecture by the President of the Republic of Poland at the University of Zurich

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

9 October 2018 · University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland

Context
Duda delivered a lecture at the University of Zurich in October 2018, addressing European integration, Poland's Cold War exclusion, and the legacy of Churchill's 1946 Zurich speech.
Main themes
European integration, Iron Curtain and Cold War division, Poland's exclusion from Western integration, Yalta Conference betrayal, Central and Eastern European identity, Churchill's Zurich and Fulton speeches, Soviet influence on Poland, solidarity and Western support, European unity, historical memory
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,208
78th percentile
Sentences
167
84th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
11.6
41st percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
53rd percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 52%50%
  • Institutional 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

167 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Your Excellency,

Esteemed Representatives of the Government of the Swiss Confederation, Dear Director! Esteemed Faculty and Students! Ladies and Gentlemen!

Seventy-two years have passed since Winston Churchill, standing here in the auditorium of the University of Zurich, boldly called for the creation of the United States of Europe. His memorable speech is now commonly regarded as one of the starting points on the path to European integration.

However, in my deep conviction, that speech in Zurich must always be read in connection with another of his well-known speeches from the same year, 1946, in which he made the bitter but accurate observation that "an Iron Curtain has descended across the continent from Stettin in the Baltic to Trieste in the Adriatic." Both there in Fulton, Missouri, and here in Zurich, that British statesman expressed deep concern about the future of Europe. The mutual connection between his two speeches becomes clear from the reading of the next sentence of the speech in Zurich: "If not all European countries were at the beginning willing to join the Union or could do so, we must gather and unite those who want to and can." It reflects the drama at the early stages of European integration. When the concepts of European integration were being born, not all states were able to freely make decisions about their future.

Unfortunately, at that time my country, Poland, was unable to participate in these integration efforts in any way, as our country found itself in the Soviet sphere of influence. The authorities in Moscow did not allow Poland to participate in any of the Western integration processes. The fall of the Iron Curtain meant that Poland, as well as other countries in Central and Eastern Europe, were deprived of the right to make independent decisions about their policies.

Western Allies did not protest when Central and Eastern Europe was cut off from the West. This was poignantly illustrated during the Victory Parade in London, which took place in the same year as both of Churchill's speeches. The Polish Armed Forces were excluded from these celebrations despite the fact that from the very first days of World War II they fought side by side with Allied forces. The British wanted to avoid worsening their relations with the Soviet Union.

I want to make it clear here: the fact that Poland found itself on the eastern side of the Iron Curtain was the result of an agreement made at the Yalta Conference, attended by Stalin, Roosevelt, and Churchill. It was not a decision made by Poland. It was made behind our backs. And let us be honest, they sold us out.

The Cold War division was an attempt to cut Poland off from its natural political environment in Europe. This turned out to be a loss not only for Poland and Eastern Europe – it was also a loss for Western Europe. The Iron Curtain separated Central and Eastern Europe from the West just as it distanced the West from Central and Eastern Europe. Thus, this unnatural division in Europe was created. The shocking nature of this division can best be illustrated by the life story of Józef Czapski – a painter and essayist, an officer of the Polish army. Czapski, coming from a Polish noble family, was born in Prague at the end of the 19th century. He studied first in St. Petersburg and then in Warsaw after Poland regained independence in 1918. In the 1920s and 1930s, Czapski lived in Paris, exhibiting his works in various capitals of Europe. Among his friends was the Swiss painter and writer Richard Aeschlimann, who exhibited Czapski's works in his own gallery in Switzerland even into the 1970s. Some of you may have seen them. According to his biographers, Józef Czapski was a European to the tips of his fingers. After World War II, when he returned to Paris and found himself among very few young people from Central and Eastern Europe, he realized that in the minds of many Western Europeans, there could exist a Europe without countries like Poland. I will quote Czapski's statement from 1950: "Yes – the blood of Europe flows to distant continents, and here in Europe [we see] attempts to sever the religious ties that have bound the broad masses of our continent for centuries."

This meant that the Soviet idea of a divided Europe achieved one of its main goals: the fact of the division of Europe was accepted not only at the political level but also began to permeate the minds of Europeans. It was not only politically imposed but began to bear its fruits in the opinions of individual people.

For decades, in the societies of Western Europe, the belief that what remained behind the Iron Curtain was less European became firmly entrenched. In this context, I am even more grateful to all those who, against this belief, helped Poles and other nations of Central and Eastern Europe during those difficult times after 1945, especially during the emergence of the Solidarity movement in 1980 and later during the martial law in Poland in 1982 and 1983. Unfortunately, despite their efforts, I have no doubt that when, after 1989, Poland and other countries in the region returned to their natural path of integration with European institutions, they had to overcome not only the geopolitical barrier towards the West but also fight against a lack of understanding and false stereotypes regarding our cultural distinctiveness.

I mention this only because it is a very painful experience for us to hear in the political rhetoric of today's leaders the resonances of those stereotypes rooted in the era of a Europe divided by the Iron Curtain. These are the voices of those who would like a more compact Europe, built around a hard core, limited only to Western countries. In their view, the European Union could rid itself of this ballast called the peripheral states of Central and Eastern Europe.

We cannot go down that path. Reproducing bad emotions and false divisions in Europe will always be contrary to the ideas that Churchill proposed in his speech in Zurich. Namely, that the process of integration must be open to those who wish to and can participate; no one can be excluded. The Iron Curtain divided Europe from the Baltic to the Adriatic. At this moment, what we are doing is connecting Europe from the Baltic to the Adriatic and the Black Sea. Through projects such as the Three Seas Initiative. This makes the Europe of the future different from the Europe of the past. Let us be people of the Europe of the future, not people of the Europe of the past.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Today, seven decades after both of Churchill's speeches, we once again think with concern about the future of the European community. Brexit, the eurozone financial crisis, and the migration crisis, to name just three major challenges, have called into question the further direction of European integration and have cost us the loss of people's trust.

Therefore, I would like to present to you the Polish perspective on the future of European integration. This year, Poland is celebrating the centenary of regaining independence. This anniversary prompts us to engage in deep reflection on the history of our country, which has been filled with struggles for freedom. For us, Poles, having a fully sovereign state is not something obvious. It is, however, an obvious value. We view our membership in Euro-Atlantic institutions as a way to articulate our sovereignty, as well as an opportunity to pursue our interests within a broader community. Allow me to now elaborate on how I perceive the three pillars that should be at the foundation of the European Union.

The first pillar is a community of equals. Respect for each country and equal rights for all countries are the foundations of uniting Europe. In his speech in Zurich, Churchill saw it this way; to quote him: "Small nations will count as much as large ones and will gain in glory by contributing their own share to the common cause."

The idea of equality is of utmost importance to me, as I see it as the basis for peaceful cooperation on the international stage; by which I mean not only the European context. I recently emphasized this during my speech at the United Nations General Assembly. I stated then that the international order must be based on the concept of sovereign equality of all states, in accordance with the provisions of the United Nations Charter.

We recognize the fact that there are differences in the potential of states in terms of their size, military capabilities, economy, demographics, etc. However, the existence of such differences is a significant advantage that does not require further emphasis through legal or political decisions. A community in Europe can only be built through the loyal cooperation of states that are equal in their rights. Each state has an equal right to self-determination, and this right must be protected in Europe.

This also means the need to defend the integrity of internationally recognized state borders. Borders in Europe cannot be changed by force. Unfortunately, we have seen this happen in Georgia in 2008 and in Ukraine in 2014. In both cases, it was done by Russia.

Recognizing the objective differences between states, European integration must primarily be supported by our common effort to address existing inequalities so as to give everyone equal opportunities. Our history teaches us, Europeans, that a "concert of powers" always leads to conflicts and bloodshed. World War I is a classic example of this. The idea of European integration was intended to be an antidote.

The principle of equality, which Poland advocates, means that Europe cannot become an exclusive club. For centuries, one of the fundamental doctrines of Polish strategic culture has been nihil novi sine communi consensus, that is, nothing new without common consent.

Therefore, from the Polish perspective, multilateralism and a rules-based order must be built on the assumption that all parties are bound by the same rules and proportionally bear responsibilities. We advocate for international relations among various states and free nations, not for usurpation and hierarchy.

Allow me to provide a practical example: for Poland, it is very important that the Central European region becomes more closely integrated in terms of effective infrastructure. We are trying to implement these ideas through the already mentioned Three Seas Initiative, which connects 12 countries located in the part of the European Union stretching from the Baltic to the Adriatic and the Black Sea. The Three Seas Initiative arose from the need to build better connections along the North-South axis. The Initiative countries simply need to fill the infrastructure gaps that date back to the communist era. However, ironically, for a long time Brussels considered the Initiative counterproductive to integration efforts. This was completely incomprehensible to us.

I am convinced that our efforts to fill gaps and reduce inequalities should not be limited only to countries within today's European Union. From the very beginning of our membership, we have advocated for bringing our eastern neighbors closer to the European Union and to the West. In particular, I mean Ukraine and Georgia, as well as the Western Balkans. We have always emphasized that the doors to the European Union must remain open. We want these countries to become part of the European Union in the future. They have equal rights to become its members, provided they meet the conditions set out in the Treaties of the European Union. And we should provide them with our support. We must ensure that these countries have equal rights to self-determination.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The second pillar of our vision for Europe is a community of ethics. Speaking in favor of European integration in 1946, Winston Churchill emphasized that a community of free European countries must be based on solid foundations. Therefore, we should never think of the European Union solely in terms of a purely technical or bureaucratic construct. There is always a moral dimension to integration processes based on a catalog of universal values.

When I speak of these values, I mean loyalty, solidarity, and forgiveness. They are universal, not just political, because they are not subject to simple voting for or against. If we return once again to Winston Churchill's speech in Zurich, we will find that he frequently referred to moral and spiritual ideas as the basis for European integration. He spoke of moral acts and honesty in the same way as the Founding Fathers of Europe contemporary to him: Schumann, Adenauer, De Gasperi. All of them realized that Europe could only be a successful project if it was deeply rooted in the moral actions of society.

The shared values gave rise to the first institutions of a united Europe. It is not by chance that they were called "communities," because the word community implies an axiological unity among its members. I am convinced that the European Union, in order to survive, must return to those values that are somewhat proto-political. We cannot limit ourselves to individual provisions in the treaties. Today, when many politicians speak about the European Union, they place particular emphasis on the primacy of European institutions – they are convinced that the more Brussels bureaucracy there is, the more unity there will be. And in fact, the reality is quite the opposite. If we reduce European integration to just this administrative level, we will forget its essence.

In our cultural heritage, there are deeply rooted shared values. Europe cannot reject its history – on the contrary, it must draw from it. I would like to put forward the thesis that among the three premises of European identity: Greek philosophy and its concept of democracy, Roman law, and Judeo-Christian ethics, in today's political discourse, we least often invoke our spiritual and ethical roots. This stands in stark contradiction to the line of reasoning of Winston Churchill, evident in his speech in Zurich. It is from ethical foundations that Churchill derived his political and legal concepts, which then became the future of Europe.

Without a debate on shared values, there will be no united Europe. Europe, which is bound only by law and institutions, without being rooted in values and morality, is an entity easily manipulated and open to conflicts of interest. I will give an example: I have no doubt that in a Europe adhering to shared values, there would be no place for projects beneficial only to another country and undermining the energy security of others. I am referring here to Nord Stream II.

A return to values is also the basis for regaining public trust in the process of European integration. Citizens of Europe must once again ensure that European institutions meet their needs; they must have confidence that their choices, including political ones, will be respected, that efforts are being made to understand their motivations. No one can be excluded from Europe simply because we disagree with their political views or decisions. Unless such a person acts secretly and dishonestly to the detriment of others.

The third pillar of the European Union should be freedom. Europe can only be built on the free will of nations. We, Poles, know its true value and for centuries have not hesitated to pay the highest price of human life for freedom. Before Poland returned to the map of Europe in 1918, for 123 years, the country was a victim of partitions carried out between Russia, Austria, and Prussia.

Throughout the nineteenth century, each successive generation of Poles undertook insurrectionary struggles for freedom.

For many people here in Switzerland, and perhaps especially in this historic hall, it may come as a surprise: but the current generation of Poles is the first in 300 years that will be able to inherit wealth from their parents. In the past, the economic achievements of each generation went to waste in the turmoil of freedom struggles in the nineteenth century, then during World War I, World War II, in the times of Soviet communism, and finally – the drastic economic transformations of 1989. Only today is Poland a country that is becoming wealthier and has a developing economy, especially thanks to the innate determination of its citizens and the free access to markets.

But please pause for a moment and think: what would today's Poland be like if we had been able to pass on our wealth from generation to generation over the last three centuries? Poles can take advantage of economic freedom to their benefit if given the opportunity.

But freedom is not limited to the economic dimension. To a large extent, it is a political principle. Poland has always treated its struggles for independence as part of a broader fight for freedom in Europe. In history, many Poles have engaged in the common struggle of European nations against the oppressive empires of their time. Our national cry was "for your freedom and ours."

Therefore, Poland is deeply convinced that the European Union should respect the freedom of debate and political choices. For us, this unity stems from respecting the will of governments elected by the nations. This is the foundation of European democracy. Freedom and democracy cannot be imposed by decrees. They must be rooted in respect for citizens, because only then do we create authentic, not fictitious communities. Therefore, European institutions must be strong, but within the limits of their own competencies. Only those that have been defined in the European treaties by the democratic governments of individual member states. European institutions cannot decide for themselves about their role. They should rather serve than be masters of the European nations. This is how I understand freedom in a united Europe.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Poland is one of the bastions of European integration, as evidenced by the very high support for the European Union. This position is a natural consequence of our history and the conclusion we have drawn from it. Poland has always benefited from peace and cooperation in Europe. It has always suffered when European politics leaned towards divisions, spheres of influence, and when the rights of weaker states were disregarded. We, Poles, are aware of why we need a European community, and what kind of community we need.

I am not the only one advocating for a stronger Europe today. Many voices from different countries and various political groups are echoing the same sentiment: it is high time to save Europe. Józef Czapski, whom I quoted today, was convinced that European integration requires a broad compromise and immense sacrifice from everyone.

Therefore, I call on us to create a united Europe as an ethical community of free states and nations, based on the equality of all its members.

And finally: I have a surprise for you. Do these three pillars of European integration, which I just mentioned, or the three communities: equality, freedom, and ethics, not sound strangely familiar to you? To me – they do. They are nothing more than a translation into the language of international relations of the motto of the French Enlightenment: liberté, égalité, fraternité.

I am not trying to incite a revolution here, but it is worth reconsidering these values.

Thank you very much.