Oxford Debate Championships – Speech

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

21 May 2021 · V Final of the Academic Championships of Poland in Oxford Debates · Presidential Palace, Poland

Context
Duda addressed participants of the 5th Academic Oxford Debate Championships of Poland at the Presidential Palace in Warsaw on 21 May 2021.
Main themes
Debate culture, youth education, argumentation skills, democratic discourse, fake news and media literacy, Polish higher education, elite vs egalitarian universities, language culture, social media trivialization, civic development, fact-based discussion
Duration
~11 min
39th percentile
Words
1,346
39th percentile
Sentences
62
41st percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
3.28
80th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 71%66%
  • Ceremonial 16%15%
  • Technological 10%10%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

62 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Dear Professors, Dear Debate Participants – both teams, Dear Students, All Honored Guests!

I am very pleased that this important meeting – the V Final of the Academic Championships of Poland in Oxford Debates – can take place right here, in the Presidential Palace. I am very happy about this because debate is something very important to me, and the ability to present one's arguments, the ability to discuss is something that should be developed in our society, especially among young people who, while studying at our best universities, aspire to hold important, prominent positions in economic, social, and hopefully – political – life in the future.

I mention this because the development of the Republic is an element that, for me, is – of course – an absolutely primary issue. And when we talk about the development of the Republic, there would be no development without the younger generation, without young people who will build it, who will continue to lead all these important matters – as I said – from economic to social, to public and political issues.

In all of this, the skill of debate, the skill of arguing, the skill of disputing – which is, I always emphasize, an absolutely natural, even necessary element of democracy – is of fundamental importance. The question is: how to discuss?

I think we have no doubt here that, first and foremost, discussion, if it is to be based, should be based on facts, and facts should be an element of the arguments presented. So, first of all: calm, fact-based argumentation. The Polish language: as good as possible – both in grammatical and linguistic terms in general.

And above all, the culture of discussion, which, unfortunately, we must say clearly – not only in our country, I want to emphasize this with all my strength – is generally lacking in recent times. It is often said: "There is a lack of it in Poland." Of course, there is a lack of it, but this is not only and exclusively a Polish problem, but a global one.

Just as the trivialization of language is also a global problem – in the broadest sense of the word. Of course, not only the Polish language. For example, communication through various types of social media.

For example, fake news, which we hear about so often. Various pieces of information that are meant to mislead, provoke anger, or indeed incite aggression – yes, often deliberately broadcast. Deliberately arranged in such a way as to provoke anger, aggression, to incite. Such is the nature – unfortunately – of today's media in general.

If you look coolly at the headlines that can be seen on seemingly serious internet portals, in newspapers, or in the media in general, on the tickers of various television stations, sometimes the headline completely diverges from the actual content of the information that lies beneath that headline.

This is certainly a malaise of today's times. This is certainly something that we – as people who want to argue based on arguments, who want to discuss the truth – should definitely not only avoid, but also oppose. And the simplest way to oppose it is to show a different style, a different class, a different image of functioning in the reality that surrounds us.

I am glad that you will be discussing a very important topic for Polish youth. Because if we wonder what our universities should be like in the future and what our education should be: whether elite or more egalitarian – this is a very fundamental problem that has been debated, one can boldly say, since the very beginning of the 1990s. The brightest minds in Poland have argued about this.

I am glad that you – young people, people who deal with the university on a daily basis – will also be able to talk about this today. I think it is important, and certainly for us, who look at this from a certain distance, your point of view is certainly very interesting.

Also for personal reasons, I am glad that this debate is taking place here. Debate, discussion, speaking are generally something close to me. I am worried when I sometimes hear at our universities that there is a long way to go to a fair debate that does not offend anyone and is indeed a debate based on arguments, not on invectives. But I think we can work on other standards, that we should – it is our duty at least to strive in this regard.

That is why I am pleased to welcome you here. I am immensely happy to welcome you, Professors. That I can also welcome my colleagues – Łukasz Słoniowski, Piotr Szefer, and others who know me from the times when we sat in various Krakow forums, arguing and discussing various topics – about politics, scouting, and other matters, issues that are not necessarily always incendiary.

But what is very interesting to me about the Oxford Debate? From the perspective of a cool approach. As you know, when it comes to debates, I have some experience – perhaps not Oxford, but political, presidential. I have participated in them a few times at various levels: during the elections for the President of Krakow, and later when I participated in the elections to the European Parliament and the Sejm of the Republic, and of course during the debates in the elections for the President of the Republic. Debating is therefore well known to me.

I also know what the pains of debate are. If someone has the freedom to express themselves, if they can speak, they have no problem with that – it is certainly a great difficulty for them to limit the time that applies during regulated debates. It is not at all easy to fit all your thoughts, to express in an efficient and condensed way the content you want to convey briefly, within a specified time. So it is certainly a very good exercise. Because sometimes you have to do it. It is very good preparation, especially for those who want to engage in media or politics.

But for me, in the Oxford Debate, one element is primarily very important: you never really know whether you will be in the proposition or in the opposition. You never really know what the topic will be – whether it is one you agree with or one you do not agree with. Whether it will suddenly be the case that where you would most like to be in the proposition, you are in the opposition – or vice versa.

What is beautiful is that you have to prepare, calmly, to consider coolly what could be an argument from the other side. You have to become like the devil's advocate. And suggest to yourself – that is one thing. Secondly – you have to stand up, speak about it, be able to discuss. That is, you have to express loudly with your own mouth those arguments that would normally be the arguments of your opponents.

It seems to me that very often this is not an easy formula at all, which also greatly tempers manners.

It builds what is extremely important to me: a certain culture of debating in our country and in general – that we know how to discuss with each other, that we know how to exchange arguments, without completely unnecessary emotions, without offending each other, without invectives, in a professional, elegant way, with a culture that we would very much like to see more of in our public life.

I have no doubt that we will observe such a debate here in just a few minutes. I wish good luck to all debate participants, to the debaters, as much strength as possible to gather and present their arguments in the most coherent way. The judges will assess who won. But I imagine that we are today at the absolute pinnacle of debate and I am immensely happy about it.

I wish everyone good luck and thank you once again.