Presentation of the presidential project for amendments to the Act on the Council of Social Dialogue

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

30 October 2017

Context
Duda presented a presidential legislative initiative to the Social Dialogue Council in Warsaw on October 30, 2017, proposing amendments to strengthen the Council's independence and competencies.
Main themes
Social Dialogue Council reform, legislative amendments, organizational independence, employee and employer representation, competency expansion, tax law interpretation, regional social dialogue, consensus-building, socio-economic development, Polish economy competitiveness
Duration
~14 min
50th percentile
Words
1,725
50th percentile
Sentences
59
39th percentile
Readability
27
11th percentile
Grade
16.6
87th percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
2.33
80th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 80%80%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

59 sentences in 23 paragraphs

Dear Prime Minister,

Dear Chairwoman,

Dear Prime Minister, Ministers,

Dear Chairpersons, Presidents,

All Honored Guests,

Distinguished Members of the Social Dialogue Council!

In accordance with the provisions of Article 87 of the Act of July 24, 2015, on the Social Dialogue Council, within 24 months from the date of entry into force of the Act, the Council is to review its provisions and present recommendations for changes to the President of the Republic regarding how it can be improved and how the functioning of the Council can be enhanced. Work on preparing proposals for the amendment of the Act on the Social Dialogue Council has been initiated – as stipulated by the Act – by a team of experts specifically tasked with developing the amendment.

During the plenary session of the Council on June 19 of this year, it was announced that such a project would be created; we mentioned then that there are various proposals, that some of them conflict with each other, and that more work is needed for the final solutions – which will be the result developed within the Social Dialogue Council – to be prepared. In the months that have passed since June, two meetings of the team have taken place in the format of working meetings here at the Chancellery of the President. My colleagues – ministers from the Chancellery, including Minister Andrzej Dera, as well as external experts from all sides represented in the Council – participated in these discussions. They focused on the proposals that were presented, with particular attention to the elements where discrepancies existed.

As a result of these meetings, a draft law has been developed, which I wish to present to you today as a presidential initiative – to submit to the Council for discussion and opinion. What do I want to say about it? Ladies and gentlemen, this is a proposal whose provisions – it can be generally stated – are agreed upon by 80 percent. The remaining 20 percent are issues that still provoke discussions and on which a final consensus has not yet been reached. However, I hope that the Council will address these matters and that ultimately this presidential project, within the constitutional legislative initiative granted to the president, will be able to be submitted to the Marshal's staff.

Regarding the purpose of the proposed amendment, it primarily includes recommendations for changes aimed at increasing the organizational independence of the Council. The Council is a young institution that needs statutory mechanisms guaranteeing its effective actions. The proposed solutions can therefore be divided into three categories. First – proposals increasing the catalog of competencies of the Council and the representatives of employees and employers. Second – proposals strengthening the organization of the Council. Third – proposals clarifying and procedurally addressing the regional social dialogue councils.

Under the current legal state, the employee and employer representatives of the Council have the right to review drafts of legislative assumptions and drafts of legal acts. This catalog does not include other documents prepared by the Council of Ministers. Hence, the proposal aims to expand the catalog of rights reserved for implementation within autonomous dialogue by supplementing the catalog of drafts of legislative assumptions and drafts of legal acts prepared by the Council of Ministers and its members to include the review of drafts of strategies, program projects, and other government documents concerning planned actions of the Council of Ministers in matters referred to in Article 1 of the Act.

Another proposed solution, significant for achieving the goal of ensuring conditions for socio-economic development and increasing the competitiveness of the Polish economy – which, according to the Act, is the purpose of the Council's actions – is the possibility for the employee and employer representatives of the Council to adopt a resolution for the Council's chairperson to approach the minister responsible for public finances with a request for a general interpretation in cases of inconsistent application of tax law provisions in specific decisions, rulings, and individual interpretations issued by tax authorities in the same factual states or future events and in the same legal states, particularly when issuing a general interpretation serves the Council's objectives.

The draft law also proposes to expand the Council's competencies to allow it to approach the Sejm and the Senate with a request to present relevant information to the Sejm and the Senate regarding matters of significant importance in the area referred to in Article 1 of the Act on the Social Dialogue Council.

One of the basic competencies of the employee and employer representatives of the Council is to review drafts of legislative assumptions and drafts of legal acts. This right, under the current legal state, cannot always be effectively exercised, among other reasons due to the lack of the possibility for the employee and employer representatives of the Council to adopt resolutions through postal voting. Postal voting has been reserved for resolutions adopted by the Council in corpore. Meanwhile, resolutions of the employee and employer representatives of the Council can only be adopted at plenary sessions.

Therefore, in light of the desire to strengthen autonomous dialogue, the proposal is to allow the employee and employer representatives of the Council to adopt resolutions using electronic communication means. In the case of adopting a resolution through postal voting, the vote on behalf of the employee and employer organizations will be cast by the Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson of the Council. In this case, the decision will be made unanimously. Postal voting will be valid if all represented employee and employer organizations participate in it.

Furthermore, under the current legal state, the adoption of a resolution by the Council requires the consent of each side. The positions of the employee and employer sides are adopted by a simple majority, provided that at least 2/3 of the members of the Council representing a given side participate in the voting. The position of the government side is adopted unanimously by the representatives of the Council of Ministers present at the meeting. Considering that the government side, in addition to the members of the Council of Ministers, also includes representatives of the minister responsible for labor and the minister responsible for public finances, it is proposed to expand the circle of Council members who may participate in the voting to include these representatives.

In the further part, the provisions of the Act define the composition and method of appointing the Council. The Council consists of representatives of the government side, the employee side, and the employer side. Meanwhile, the works of the Council are attended by advisory representatives of the President of the Republic, the President of the National Bank of Poland, and the President of the Central Statistical Office. It is proposed to expand the circle of persons who may participate in the plenary sessions of the Council with advisory votes to include the Chief Labor Inspector. It is worth noting that currently, the Chief Labor Inspector participates in the works of the Council at the invitation of the Chairperson of the Council. The proposed solution is therefore a consequence of the existing factual state, but the aim is for the Chief Labor Inspector to be able to participate continuously with an advisory vote, in other words – to become a permanent element of the Social Dialogue Council, which seems desirable given the function performed by the Chief Labor Inspector.

Another matter is that the Chairperson of the Council presents an annual report on the Council's activities for the previous year to the Sejm by May 31. However, due to the annual term of the Chairperson of the Council as stipulated in the Act, the report is presented by the Chairperson who did not lead the Council during the period for which the report is presented – in short, it is presented by the next chairperson. Therefore, it is proposed that the Chairperson of the Council present to the Sejm and the Senate annually no later than October 15 information on the Council's activities for the duration of their term and present no later than May 31 the report on the Council's activities for the previous year to the Sejm and the Senate. The proposed solution aims to allow the Chairperson to present information to the Sejm and the Senate for the duration of their term. Additionally, for statistical reasons, the obligation to present a report for the entire calendar year has been maintained.

The regional dialogue conducted by the provincial social dialogue councils also requires strengthening. The previous experiences of the functioning of the provincial social dialogue councils indicate the need to change the provisions concerning them in order to clarify competencies, define voting procedures, including allowing for the possibility of postal voting, ensuring the possibility of financing the costs of expertise and opinions, costs related to business travel, and the travel of delegated members of the provincial councils performing tasks assigned by the Presidium.

Article 88 of the Act specifies the maximum limits of expenditures resulting from the financial effects of the Act for the years 2016-2025. In connection with the increase in the budget act for 2018 of the expenditure amount in part 85 – Voivodes – to the amount of 3 million 200 thousand PLN for the financing of provincial social dialogue councils, it is justified to amend the Act to increase the expenditure limits for subsequent years. These amounts will gradually increase by the projected inflation rate (in 2019 it will be 2.3%, in the years 2020-2025 – 2.5%).

Ladies and gentlemen, the project stipulates that within 24 months from the date of entry into force of the proposed Act, the Social Dialogue Council will assess the functioning of the provisions of the Act on the Social Dialogue Council and present further recommendations for changes to the President of the Republic, meaning we have a consistent two-year period for verifying the effective functioning of the provisions of the Act as a whole – that is, the Act in its currently applicable version and the proposed, drafted provisions.

I submit these proposals to you today – placing them in the hands of the Chairwoman – for discussion, and I hope that solutions will be developed in this regard that the entire Council will be able to agree upon and state that they have a common character.

Thank you very much.