President at the Arraiolos Forum: Open doors are fundamental for the survival of the EU.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

14 September 2017 · Arraiolos Forum

Context
Duda addressed the Arraiolos Group forum of EU non-executive presidents in September 2017, speaking on market economy and social cohesion in Europe.
Main themes
Social market economy, equal opportunities, European Union cohesion, economic inequality, social programs, labor market regulation, post-communist transition, standard of living, worker protections, economic governance, societal stability, EU as economic model
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,860
74th percentile
Sentences
120
71st percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 45%41%
  • Social 36%33%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

120 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Madam President, Excellency,

Dear Presidents,

Esteemed Presidents!

First of all, I would like to sincerely thank you for the invitation and for the excellent organization of this next meeting of the Arraiolos Group. And I thank you for the very interesting topic of today’s discussion. Because although – I must admit – I am not an economist, we are actually discussing the market economy and how it influences and shapes society. This is undoubtedly an important topic not only for today’s European Union, not only for our countries – it is also important for the future of the European Union.

I will put forward a thesis that may electrify some: generally, we have nothing to complain about, things are really quite good, we are one of the wealthier regions of the world, and the standard of living here, in Europe, in the European Union – on average – is much higher than in many other places in the world. Why? Because all our countries either have or are moving towards an economic system that, with wise governance, ensures prosperity. I am talking here about the social market economy, about a system that took shape after World War II, and one of the best examples of its implementation is Germany, which has already been mentioned here. The President of Greece mentioned in his speech that in Germany, practically from the very beginning, after World War II, when the economy and the state began to rebuild, social programs were also included, which I call programs for equal opportunities.

Because they work when they truly equalize opportunities by creating conditions for someone to further develop on their own. Because we do not want to create and implement programs that can be used without giving anything back to society, without giving anything back to the state – that is, not working, not paying taxes, relying solely on what the state gives you. We want the social program to help a person in a difficult situation so that they can get out of that situation – as we say – get back on their feet, that is – I don’t know if this is said elsewhere, but in Poland, we say – to give them a fishing rod, not necessarily a fish. Let them catch the fish themselves later with that rod.

And in this regard, one must say this: without a doubt, a form of societal and economic development that relies solely on a blind focus on economic growth without considering social costs is fatal, because it has nothing to do with a market economy.

I remember, Ladies and Gentlemen, how almost 10 years ago I was in one of the countries of the former Eastern Bloc, which was trying to emerge from its post-communist backwardness, and at that moment it was clearly poorly governed. One could observe the following phenomenon, which was striking when one literally found themselves on the street: about 5-7 percent were super-luxury cars of the most famous European brands – the best models of BMW, Mercedes, Porsche. And next to them, the rest consisted of crumbling cars produced in the Soviet Union. There were no others – there simply were no mid-range cars that the vast majority of citizens in the European Union and elsewhere in the world, where the standard of living is relatively high, drive. What did this mean? For me, the conclusion was simple: there is a dramatic social divide. There is a group of extremely wealthy people and the rest of society, which lives essentially – one could say – from paycheck to paycheck, barely making ends meet, barely able to survive, because if they could, they would live differently.

And here the European Union, with its example of a well-functioning market economy, represents – in my opinion – an extraordinary magnet. It is our task to lead the economy in such a way – we, as leaders of states, we, as those who are in contact with our governments and, to a lesser or greater extent, have an influence on their functioning, perhaps not in a decision-making capacity, but nonetheless in terms of ongoing contact, often within the same convictions, the same political background – this is our great obligation. We need a state that, utilizing its economic potential through various specialized agencies and social programs, pursues a policy of equal opportunities. Thus, it creates conditions for improving the economic situation of those most in need. And those who need help are not left to fend for themselves. This is extremely important.

It is simply about creating in our countries such principles that, for example, by regulating the labor market, will ensure that the interests of workers are protected. That it will not be possible to employ workers in such a way that they are not subject to labor law, but to other regulations, and therefore will not have the protections arising from labor law. That social, pension, or other benefits will not be paid for them – depending on what system is in place in a given country. It is simply about ensuring that a person has a sense of stability and security in their functioning.

Why do I emphasize this so strongly? Because I want to say a few words about my personal experience from my country – the experience of the last 8 years, during which I have participated in the development of Poland not only as an ordinary citizen but also as a politician, who even being in opposition, always has some influence on the ongoing development of affairs, or at least sees political processes very closely and is able to assess them. In Poland, things have taken a turn for the worse over the last 9 years – just as it happened at one point at the beginning of the 90s. A gigantic mistake was made then – I am talking about the early 90s – with one decision, the Deputy Prime Minister abolished all State Agricultural Enterprises literally overnight. This led to an absolute catastrophe in the countryside. Entire large rural areas in Poland fell into poverty. Extracting them from this through certain market mechanisms, through the takeover of land for use by various entities took many years. Currently, the situation is under control and has significantly improved, but there are still areas where one can see the ruins of what was functioning and what was destroyed and abandoned overnight as part of market liberalization.

Such a method – simply experimenting on living social tissue – is something that cannot be agreed upon at all, because such a type of liberal economy leads to the collapse of societies. Fortunately, we emerged from that, but in the last 8 years we have experienced a story that, while not on the same scale, is very similar. The government, in order to emerge from the crisis that came in 2008, focused absolutely on GDP results. GDP growth was the primary element that was emphasized. The consequence of this was such – to put it very simply – that there was a general disinterest in the situation of social strata that were not – let’s call it – the strata of economic success of the last twenty-some years, since 1989, when the market economy began in Poland.

The result was that, in essence, pension and disability benefits were not significantly increased. Wages – on average – especially in less complicated, less specialized jobs, hardly increased at all. This led to a visible divide between large cities and smaller centers, between different social groups. It simply began to be visible. The most visible was where people could not sustain themselves from tourism, where there was no large industry, in smaller towns, for example, in the northeast of Poland.

I must tell you that some cases were truly dramatic and drastic. Because if you see a town where essentially all the shops in the market are closed and have boarded-up windows because no one wants to rent them, and when you ask people: “Where is the youth?” and you hear: “They left” – you realize that the situation is indeed bad and that the method of combating unemployment was simply that the European Union opened borders, and thus people could go abroad to work.

Therefore, one of the most important elements of my program, when I was running for the office of President of the Republic, was to firmly establish the issue of creating a system of equal opportunities, raising the standard of living – in short: creating a chance. Of course, it was clear to us that this required intervention from the state and that it was a task for the state authorities. Because of course the economy will develop, of course it must be market-based, of course you cannot force entrepreneurs to raise wages, that cannot be done – it must be dictated by market conditions, which is probably obvious to all of you. However, we simply came to the conclusion that Poland needed, for the first time, a truly serious program – we initially called it “social,” but then we moved away from that social element, heading towards simply a pro-family program. We concluded that we must provide very strong and clear support to families raising children.

Here, there were two reasons. First, families raising children were in the most difficult situation, and we had many children who, according to European Union standards, lived in poverty. Moreover, we needed a demographic impulse because Poland’s demographic situation began to become difficult, and for several good years, the growth was already negative. Therefore, we stated that if we need a demographic impulse, and the program is to have such a character, we must move away from the social element, that is, we cannot call it a social program and we cannot create it in the manner of a social program – it must be a program for everyone. It may be better for some, but it must be a program for everyone. And that is why we decided that we would pay 500 zł per month, which is about 120 euros, for each child in the family, on average starting from the second child, and in families that are poorer – to put it simply – that have lower incomes, we would pay this money from the first child. But we would pay it to every family – even to one that earns, for example, 100,000 euros a month. To every family!

There was a lot of controversy around this. First of all, there is an ongoing debate, voices are raised about whether these funds should be paid to wealthy families, those living at a very high level even by average European Union standards. There is still a discussion about whether it should be paid to every family from the first child. But the biggest critics of the program said that the money would be poorly spent, that people would not know how to handle it, that it would not be spent on children. Ladies and gentlemen, I do not know how it is in countries wealthier than Poland, how the use of such aid funds looks there, but I can say that we conducted very thorough research in Poland – precisely on how these funds are used. I can provide you with the results of this research. Almost 43 percent is used for food and clothing; 34.2 percent is spent on expenses related to fulfilling the school obligations of children, that is, in short – on school education; 32 percent is spent on extracurricular education and additional activities for children, including language classes and other developmental activities; 11 percent of respondents declared that they allocate these funds for their pleasures or hobbies and entertainment.

I had long discussions about this, especially when we were introducing this program – it was in April 2016, just as the Olympic Games were approaching, critics were shouting that people were going to stores and buying large LCD televisions with the money from the 500+ program. And I believe that if there is a large family that has never had such a television and the children have complexes because of it, or if a child has never had a smartphone – then let the parents buy that smartphone for them, so they are not the only child in the class without a smartphone. So they do not have to explain to their peers that they do not have a smartphone because they do not want one. Because no one will believe them anyway.

This is a system of equal opportunities, which also involves psychological support – it is extremely important. And that is why – in my opinion – we must always remember this. Of course, we monitor the way these funds are spent. In cases where they are spent poorly, there is administrative intervention, the funds are suspended, for example, if someone is abusing a child – if we have that established, at that moment the funds are blocked, so there is state control. But it is extremely important that we implement such systems. They are implemented in various ways in many countries of the European Union. But I think that generally, it is a way out of developmental backwardness. Just as we – I do not hesitate to say – for 50 years stuck behind the Iron Curtain, today we need to emerge from this developmental backwardness. And some means must be sought.

I must tell you that I have great satisfaction with this program because in many discussions, I said that this money would not be wasted and that it would return to the economy. And today, the results of the Polish economy show that they are returning. We have GDP growth – we planned for 3.2 percent, and it turns out that it is currently estimated by rating agencies at even 4 percent. So this money is returning to the economy. Consumption has significantly increased – people are simply spending this money. First, there was a drastic increase in consumption, now we are slowly seeing an increase in savings, which is also very much needed.

So it is clear that this program, which theoretically is a support program, is in effect also a support program for the economy. Because people simply spend that money. There is no situation where they stash it under the pillow and it does not work. It works for the economy, and in some part it returns to the state in the form of taxes, indirect taxes – and that is extremely important.

We must keep an eye on such things, primarily on the backbone of the social market economy, so that it does not deviate too much. It must be an economy that is a mixed element – on one hand, it has liberal elements, but on the other hand, it also has strong social elements. This is enormously important because the economic center of gravity in the world is clearly shifting beyond Europe. Right now, the Asia-Pacific region is producing about 40 percent of the world's Gross Domestic Product, and Europe must find a way to ensure that its position is not systematically weakened. Why am I saying this? Because I have recently emphasized this issue very strongly several times. Ladies and gentlemen, we are currently at the stage of Brexit, right? This is undoubtedly a significant weakening for the European Union. Because the great European economy, which is the British economy, is leaving, and the consequences of all this are difficult for us to predict today, and above all, we have a clear demonstration that the great European project has lost its attractiveness, since one of the great European societies has said "no" to this project.

But I believe that there is a fundamental issue for the survival of the European Union ‒ if this does not happen today, the Union will disintegrate: open doors of the European Union. We, ladies and gentlemen – in my conviction – in the perspective of years or decades need new countries in the European Union so that we remain competitive. If we are optimists – and I am an optimist – we assume that world economies will develop, and our great European economy must also develop. We need countries that today – perhaps to a great extent – aspire to join the European Union. However, we must keep repeating to them: "The doors of the European Union are open. If you meet the criteria, you will be accepted into the European Union." Because only in this way can we build its potential. If we close ourselves off, the Union will probably disintegrate, and we will all lose out on that. Because if we are to produce, and we want to produce, we must have markets for our goods. And our markets will not be enough. That is why this balance is so necessary for us: to support, but at the same time, to expect. And it is a matter of whether we will govern well. This is our – in my conviction – great task.

Thank you very much.