The President's speech at the conference "Together on the Constitution, Together on Social Policy"

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

13 March 2018 · Conference 'Together on the Constitution, Together on Social Policy'

Context
Duda addressed a national conference on the Constitution and social policy in Poland on March 13, 2018, discussing social rights and state obligations.
Main themes
Social policy, constitutional guarantees, social market economy, Catholic social teaching, pension system reform, labor rights, history of social policy, industrial revolution, social solidarity, socialism and communism, retirement age
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,417
41st percentile
Sentences
56
37th percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 33%32%
  • Institutional 28%27%
  • Economic 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 19%18%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

56 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Dear Minister,

Esteemed Ministers,

Honorable Members of Parliament, Senators, led by Professor,

Esteemed Presidents, Chairpersons, Directors,

All Distinguished Guests!

Together about the Constitution, together today about social policy – an extremely important topic, which we have already touched upon to some extent when we held the first consultative debate in Gdańsk. At that time, we spoke about labor rights, of course also about issues related to social security, thus about elements of what we call social policy. Because in the large set called social policy, we have many subsets, that is, further policies that make up this great task of the state ‒ but also of society ‒ which is social policy.

Ladies and gentlemen, once upon a time, something like social policy certainly did not exist in today’s understanding of the term. Social policy actually arose from the needs of the times, primarily triggered by the industrial revolution that took place in the 18th century, but its true, tumultuous development, its flourishing, really occurred in the 19th century. The problem was the situation in which, as a result of this revolution, hundreds of thousands or even millions of people in developing countries around the world found themselves – people who, having abandoned their former lives in rural areas, moved to cities in search of their chance.

Of course, they encountered something that was completely natural at that time, namely: something that we could today call predatory capitalism, that is, the thirst for profit, where no one and nothing was taken into account when it came to those who performed wage labor. Of course, the consequence of this was workplace accidents, the death of tens of thousands of people at work due to the lack of any – because they did not exist in a written sense at that time ‒ safety and hygiene standards, very low wages, and the poverty in which that part of society found itself that performed this wage labor, which – let’s say openly – was simply the misery of workers.

The result of this was the emergence of ideological currents – socialism, communism – and, ladies and gentlemen, eventually something happened that had to happen. In 1891, Pope Leo XIII said a decisive “no!” and issued a momentous, historical encyclical published on May 15, 1891, “Rerum novarum,” in which he showed what obligations arise from faith, what are the obligations of a Catholic, a Christian towards one’s neighbor, also in labor relations, in relations between employer and employee. He also showed the differences between Christianity and its effects and the socialist or communist ideology and their effects.

This truly changed the world. The social teaching of the Catholic Church began to develop tumultuously at that time, which, in effect, together with the achievements of social democracy and the labor movement ‒ with what trade unions managed to achieve thanks to the workers' right to associate ‒ created a system that today we could say is the ideal economic system: a social market economy. A system that led to great wealth in the Western world, to great economic prosperity, and to an extremely high standard of living, the peak of which probably occurred in the 1980s, when we were still – unfortunately – behind the Iron Curtain.

When we look at all this from the perspective of our country, which began to change in 1989, observing this debate, we will ask primarily one question: do constitutions at all provide any guarantees in this regard? Well, ladies and gentlemen, the answer is: in most Western and European countries ‒ indeed they do. Constitutions contain elements that clearly state the obligations of the state related to social security. And our currently applicable Constitution from 1997 also contains in this regard – when it comes to social security – the provision of Article 67 and other provisions that can be combined regarding the principles of social policy or constitutional protection of certain elements of social policy.

The problem, ladies and gentlemen, lies in just one thing – the best example here is the issue of pensions. Although this Constitution has been in force since 1997 and although these provisions exist, they have not changed in this regard, a serious change in the pension system was first made in 1999, introducing the second pillar insurance, which breaks away from the solidarity system. This is no longer social solidarity; it is personal prudence – whether you save for retirement because that is your decision, or you do not. Thus, the system of social solidarity that was developed in Europe and that functioned here for decades has already, in a sense, been broken at this point. That was the first moment.

The second moment – how memorable – was the raising of the retirement age for all Poles to 67 years, which was particularly painful for women, especially those living in rural areas.

And the third moment, in which there was another legislative intervention in the pension system, was the transfer back to ZUS of over 51% from OFE. All this happened under the current Constitution. The issue of raising the retirement age was brought before the Constitutional Tribunal, which said: “There was no violation of the Constitution.” Of course, the ruling was specific, as six out of 15 judges submitted dissenting opinions, but the fact is that the Tribunal recognized: the Constitution does not protect citizens from violations – because I believe that there was a violation of their rights, that they were not warned at all and that, in fact, their interests were ongoing interests when this change was made.

And now, ladies and gentlemen, we ask ourselves the question: should, in light of these experiences, the Polish Constitution be different in this regard? Should it speak in a much more precise way about the retirement age? I pose a question mark here. Or should it foresee a protective mechanism that would generally refer to the issue of the retirement age – not stating what it should be, but, for example, a provision that stipulates that a change in the retirement age can only occur with a qualified majority of votes in the Sejm of the Republic of Poland and in the Senate? This is my question that I would like us to discuss. Do we need better regulation in this regard than today’s?

And the second element, ladies and gentlemen: extremely important ‒ also emphasized by the Constitutional Tribunal ‒ is a certain balancing cooperation, cooperation of partners. Today we have the Social Dialogue Council, which includes representatives of the largest trade unions, representatives of employers, and also the government side – which is extremely pleasant and honorable for me, taking place under the patronage of the President of the Republic.

The question is: should issues related to broadly understood social dialogue be better regulated in our Constitution? Are stronger safeguards needed in this regard? So that a situation like the de facto collapse of the Tripartite Commission a few years ago does not occur ‒ and a few years de facto without institutional dialogue in a state that has 38 million citizens, thus being a truly large state.

And finally, the last question, extremely important – perhaps less constitutional, but rather systemic – namely the issue of the pension system as such, its construction for the coming decades and the problem of demographics. Well, ladies and gentlemen, while in 2010 in Poland there were four working people for one pensioner, by 2020 there will be only three. And as experts estimate – by 2035 there will be only two. The question is as follows: are we able to defend the current pension system? To defend it in the sense – to ensure that it retains its viability and that it is able to pay decent pensions at all. That is one matter.

And the second matter: ladies and gentlemen, what actions should be taken – perhaps precisely in social policy – alongside the already introduced 500+ program, so that Poles want to have more children, to create better living conditions for families.

I leave you with these questions. In a moment, experts will speak, whom I will be pleased to listen to. Once again, I sincerely thank you for taking the time to come to the Presidential Palace for this debate. I would like to sincerely thank the esteemed Professors and Experts for being willing to share the results of their work and their thoughts with us.

I invite you to discussion and debate.