The President's statement to the media in Bastogne

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

16 December 2019 · Statement to the media commemorating the 75th anniversary of the Battle of the Bulge · Bastogne, Belgium

Context
Duda addressed media in Bastogne, Belgium on December 16, 2019, during ceremonies marking the 75th anniversary of the Battle of the Ardennes.
Main themes
Battle of the Ardennes 75th anniversary, World War II commemoration, Polish participation in WWII, Allied sacrifice and veterans, judicial impartiality in Poland, PiS judicial discipline legislation, Jan Śpiewak pardon consideration, Polish-Allied solidarity
Duration
~9 min
30th percentile
Words
1,042
30th percentile
Sentences
45
29th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
12.4
49th percentile
Syntax
3.26
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 57%56%
  • Geopolitical 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

45 sentences in 14 paragraphs

I warmly welcome you and the viewers from Belgium, from the Ardennes, a place that commemorates the battle from 75 years ago, as we celebrate the 75th anniversary of this battle, which we in Poland call the Battle of the Ardennes, sometimes referring to it as the Ardennes Offensive – the last offensive of the German Nazi army during World War II, where Hitler hoped to break the Allied front here in Western Europe and change the course of World War II. Some historians argue that it was a completely mad action and a crazy idea. The fact is that thousands of German soldiers were involved in it and a huge amount of combat equipment, primarily the most modern German tanks of that time. There was a winter battle, as the weather was completely different from this year, with snow lying everywhere. And above all, it was a clash of elite German units with American troops who were not expecting this attack.

Today we have gathered among Western European leaders, but also with the American Secretary of Defense and veterans, to honor the memory of those soldiers who fought here for a free world, for a free Europe. Many of them, thousands of soldiers, fell. It was, as the Americans say, their biggest battle on the Western front during World War II. Indeed, over 7,000 American soldiers are buried in the cemetery in Luxembourg, who died in this battle during those December days of 1944. The battle lasted more than two weeks, and the entire offensive ended in a German defeat. The losses on both sides were enormous. Today we gather here to honor the memory of those soldiers.

I am very pleased that we, as Poland, have also been invited, that we sit here together with our allies, although Polish soldiers – specifically Polish pilots – participated only in the very final phase of this battle – fighting in the air battle over Ghent.

But nonetheless, we are here as participants in World War II. And in a symbolic sense, I believe that this is a gesture that honors our soldiers who fought during World War II, primarily here on the Western front, side by side with Americans and British. Our heroes who liberated Belgium and the Netherlands. I am very glad that in this way they are also being honored – through this Polish presence today, during these ceremonies that are very important primarily for the veterans from the United States, but also – as we see – for the Belgian Royal Family, for the Grand Duke of Luxembourg. We accepted their invitation to these ceremonies. And I express great satisfaction that we are also invited and present here.

Mr. President, you invited Jan Śpiewak to you. Are you considering pardoning this activist?

First of all, for any reaction from the head of state to occur, a relevant application is needed. If an application is submitted in this matter, the case will certainly be thoroughly examined. It is, in a sense, shocking. One could say, in a great simplification, that a man who fought for justice, or at least acted under the conviction that he was fighting for justice in this very shocking case of Warsaw tenements, is convicted in a criminal trial, so the case is specific. Like every case, it requires thorough examination. And if an appropriate application is submitted to me, it will certainly be thoroughly examined.

Mr. President, how do you assess the PiS project that aims to discipline judges? Would you sign such a law?

First of all, let’s start with the fact that these are solutions that – at least part of these solutions, because I understand if you are talking about disciplining – that the rule in democratic countries is that judges do not speak out on political matters and do not interfere in politics. This is a norm that is primarily observed in countries in Western Europe. Judges do not participate in current politics precisely so that later, when they resolve matters touching on politics, there is no doubt that they stand on either political side.

This is necessary so that judges, also in the eyes of society, can maintain what is so very important, namely impartiality and the social sense that they are impartial in the matters they resolve, which in turn allows for building a sense in society that the judgments issued by courts, that is, by judges, are just judgments.

Such a system must finally be introduced in Poland. As we see especially in recent months, or the last few years, the situation is very bad here. And if we talk about the political impartiality of judges, unfortunately, in Poland, this is a situation that requires very deep analysis and very deep repair.

I greatly lament this, but we see that these are indeed the facts of recent years. So the regulations that will clearly and distinctly define what judges should not do and how they should not act, how they should not express themselves, and what they should not do are, as we can see over the last few years in Poland, very much needed. And they exist in the legislation of other countries. I see nothing wrong with similar regulations – as in other countries – being introduced here. Of course, they cannot absolutely concern the adjudication by judges and the assessment of certain factual situations and the interpretation of legal provisions that judges make. However, issues when judges obviously, evidently, and deliberately act contra legem are certainly a very debatable matter.

A question about the case of the President of the Supreme Audit Office

Ladies and gentlemen, as I have said many times, if even some of the serious allegations against Mr. President Marian Banaś raised in the media turn out to be true, I have no doubt that someone who has committed such actions cannot hold the position of president of such an important institution as the Supreme Audit Office.

Of course, the matter is very difficult, it concerns constitutional issues, but it also concerns very important state matters, and therefore I appeal in this situation, also to a certain healthy sense and a sense of responsibility for state affairs, also to Mr. President Banaś.