President: The EU must pursue an open-door policy.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

7 May 2019 · Debate on "Ten Years of the Eastern Partnership. Lessons for Georgia and Poland."

Context
Duda addressed a Warsaw debate with Georgia's President marking ten years of the Eastern Partnership, reflecting on its successes and limitations.
Main themes
Eastern Partnership assessment, Georgia-EU relations, Russian aggression and regional security, EU membership aspirations, President Lech Kaczyński's legacy, Poland-Georgia relations, Euro-Atlantic integration, association agreements and financial instruments, democratic institution-building
Duration
~18 min
60th percentile
Words
2,139
60th percentile
Sentences
87
56th percentile
Readability
53
70th percentile
Grade
11.6
41st percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 61%61%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

87 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Debate with the participation of the President of the Republic of Poland and the President of Georgia titled "Ten Years of the Eastern Partnership. Lessons for Georgia and Poland." Excerpts.

Mr. President, Madam President, you just mentioned the issue of the occupied Georgian territories: Abkhazia, the Tskhinvali region. When the agreement was signed – the Eastern Partnership program – it was just a few months after the Russian aggression against Georgia, which highlighted Russia's determination to rebuild its influence in the region. But as we have learned over the next 10 years, that was not the end. Today, a war is also ongoing, this time between Russia and Ukraine.

How do you assess the Eastern Partnership, Mr. President? To what extent was it a program that sufficiently responded to the challenges of the time? To what extent and for what reasons was it an initiative that was not fully able to prove effective?

President Andrzej Duda: Thank you very much, first of all, for this discussion. Thank you, Madam President, for being able to sit here together – thank you for your presence in Warsaw. Thank you, Director, for leading this debate.

I will answer this question perhaps even a bit more broadly than it was asked, revealing a fact that I do not know if you are aware of.

I do not remember if in his statements – primarily in the river interview given in 2009 and 2010 – President Lech Kaczyński mentioned this. As you know, I was then a minister in the Office of President Lech Kaczyński, who was extremely engaged – as everyone surely remembers – in the matter of Georgia, its freedom, territorial integrity, and independence, but also its belonging to Euro-Atlantic structures, that is, to NATO and the European Union. This was something that was extremely important to the President, and I will not hesitate to use the word – it was something he truly fought for.

And when you now ask me about the Eastern Partnership, I will answer this way: at the moment it was established, the President was disheartened. I would not want to use the word that he was dissatisfied with the Eastern Partnership program – but he wanted Georgia to be in the European Union, to be a full member of this great international European organization, and he believed that the Eastern Partnership was a kind of substitute platform. That is, the effect of the Eastern Partnership would be that Georgia would never become a member of the European Union – due to, of course, the lack of an association agreement at that time, etc. He simply wanted Georgia to follow the path that Poland took to join the European Union.

He was aware that the Russian aggression was carried out precisely to prevent that. He believed that – due to the attitude of our partners from the European Union, their relationship with Russia, their fear of Russia – the Eastern Partnership was simply a postponement of Georgia's entry into the European Union forever.

If he could share with us his observations, thoughts about what happened today, it must be said: indeed, there was no chance at that time for Western countries to decide to accept Georgia into the European Union. So, is it good that the Eastern Partnership was created? From today’s perspective, I would say: yes, certainly. If there were to be nothing, then it is certainly good that the Eastern Partnership was implemented.

Why? Because today there is an association agreement, because there are funds from the Neighbourhood Instrument and other financial instruments that flow from the European Investment Bank – Georgia can benefit from this, and it does so very well when it comes to the possibility of receiving favorable loans. But above all, money is flowing there from European instruments specifically intended to support the countries of the Eastern Partnership. Georgia benefits greatly and well from this, as it is today the country most closely aligned with the European Union among all the countries of the Eastern Partnership. And there are programs that the President mentioned: Erasmus, Erasmus+. Others: there is already visa-free travel today, there is an agreement on a deepened free trade area. These are certainly elements that have greatly helped Georgia.

And if we look at Georgia as our friend, as a country we hold in great sympathy, as our ally, then every step that has been taken to strengthen democratic institutions in Georgia, to strengthen the stability of Georgia's financial and political system, to enable Georgia to cooperate militarily with Western countries, which strengthens its security, because it also strengthens its potential, to enable Georgia to improve its infrastructural conditions, which, of course, serve ultimately the economic development of the country, because if we build roads, railways, airports, if we implement infrastructure, we thereby improve investment conditions and conditions for economic functioning – it is good that the Eastern Partnership was implemented.

Did President Lech Kaczyński expect that such instruments and elements as I mentioned – visa-free travel, the association agreement, the deepened free trade agreement – would be introduced? I think he doubted it; he feared that the Eastern Partnership would boil down to round words, to certain promises given only and exclusively, that it would not be materialized through all these subsequent elements.

If today we look at it from the perspective of 10 years – of course, in the meantime, Ukraine was also attacked, and I think the West has shed its illusions about the fact that in the first case, that is, the attack on Georgia, the victim fell on the knife; no, the victim was pushed with a knife; and in the second case, this also happened; I think that then the West shed its illusions about what Russia's real intentions are – also these integrative actions deepened, and the conviction grew that we need to attract countries like Georgia, supporting them more and more. Hence – in my opinion – there was an acceleration of certain processes leading to deeper integration that took place then.

I hope that President Lech Kaczyński's dream of Georgia's membership in the European Union and NATO will come true. Because that is precisely the path we would very much like Georgia to take – for the good of its citizens above all, for the flourishing of the country, for the improvement of the quality of life, for the strengthening of the country's security.

Are we able to remodel the mechanisms of European neighborhood policy in the eastern dimension to avoid the trap in which we only support the modernization of these Eastern European and South Caucasian countries, which is of course right and proper, but at the same time, when it comes to the process of European integration, we are dealing with a dead end?

President Andrzej Duda: The answer to this question is very complex. I will smile and say: What to do? Of course, accept Georgia into the EU. And the problem is solved. But in fact, this answer is complicated. Georgia has indeed made tremendous progress and continues to do so. Above all, we must continue to enable Georgia to make these advances, meaning that Georgia and other Eastern Partnership countries should increasingly align their legal solutions with those that function in EU countries, so that this process deepens, so that we deepen the association process, for example, by tightening and creating new fields of sectoral cooperation between Eastern Partnership countries, particularly Georgia and the EU. And that we might perhaps begin to institutionalize the Eastern Partnership more strongly, by introducing at least the institution of a presidency within the Eastern Partnership. Why? To enable the realization of all those elements that are the most characteristic reality for EU countries, the reality of the EU.

Despite the lack – at least for now – of actual membership in the EU, to bring Eastern Partnership countries to the EU level in terms of legal standards, quality of life, institutional solutions, functioning of democratic institutions, all those elements that will later allow – I hope, because I believe deeply – to introduce Eastern Partnership countries into the EU completely practically without cost. Of course, those that want to, because that is another problem. Do the countries of the Eastern Partnership really want to be EU members? This problem works both ways. On the one hand, we still have a crisis situation in Europe; let’s not deceive ourselves – the EU is in crisis, and one could even say in several crises. There is certainly a crisis in the EU related to Brexit. I keep repeating that the EU must continue to pursue an open-door policy, because otherwise it will cease to be attractive at all. I fear that if it does not pursue an open-door policy, it will threaten its existence. Meanwhile, if Great Britain were to actually decide to leave the EU – we do not have that yet; it is a process that shakes the EU from time to time – it would be a very bad signal for the entire EU if at the same time it does not start accepting new members, saying: please, this European project is attractive, and others want to belong to it.

The response to Great Britain's exit must be an open-door policy and the enlargement of the EU. That is my conviction, and I do not hide that in some sense this perspective is also a hope for Georgia and other countries. And that is the direction in which – it seems to me – we should move. Certainly, tightening and supporting Georgia and other Eastern Partnership countries is the only way, because after all, the majority of them, with the exception of one country, have their largest economic partner precisely in the EU as a whole. The largest economic exchange is with the EU. Only one country has a larger economic exchange with someone else, and the EU is in second place; of course, that is not Georgia.

How long might the process take before Georgia and Ukraine receive an offer of EU membership? Wouldn't it be more practical for the EU to diversify its approach and provide greater support to those countries that want to get closer to the EU? Would such a diversification of approach not help, for example, Georgia and Ukraine?

President Andrzej Duda: Each of these questions is a difficult question. I cannot answer when Georgia will become a member of the EU. I do not know if those who represent our – EU – countries in the European Council would be able to answer that question. I fear that it would not be easy either. That is the first element.

The second – this is the proposal of the Ukrainian Ambassador. Mr. Ambassador, I will say this: there is one problem that is important, and that is a voice against a decisive institutional diversification of countries within the Eastern Partnership. Namely, if we call it directly: you are Eastern Partnership A, and you are Eastern Partnership B, then the question arises whether this will not undermine the European ambitions of the citizens of the countries that will become B countries. This is also an element of discussion – I say this analogously – within the EU, within the EU itself. Should the Union be a Union of two speeds? We say: no. No, because it would certainly negatively affect the perception of the EU by Poles, who still remember the years of communism and that they were in Europe B. There, behind the Iron Curtain, everything developed beautifully, while here it got worse and worse.

In my opinion, if there is something that can discourage citizens – not the authorities – from the EU, it is that they feel neglected by it, that they have been somehow belittled, pushed down in relation to the EU. This European project must always be attractive to them, and to be attractive, it must be real.

What can certainly be done? We can assess the approach to the EU, assess the introduction of institutions that function in EU countries, political institutions, the functioning of the economic market, various elements of life – infrastructural development, the course of visa-free travel, etc. And depending on the state of affairs – to those countries that are more advanced and closer to the EU in these respects, provide greater support, thereby motivating them even more to carry out these actions.

And this is something that is not only real but something that the EU should do. Because it may indeed be the case that there are countries in the Eastern Partnership whose authorities are not really fully interested in participating in the EU. And they will never want to belong to it when it comes time to make a decision.