President: The number of extraordinary complaints is increasing.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

18 June 2021 · Conference on extraordinary complaints

Context
Duda addressed a conference at the Supreme Court on June 18, 2021, discussing the functioning and future reform of Poland's extraordinary complaints institution.
Main themes
Extraordinary complaints institution, Supreme Court proceedings, judicial justice reform, citizen grievances and sense of injustice, legal aid and parliamentary office experience, de lege ferenda recommendations, social justice principles, Polish constitutional law, court system dysfunction
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,895
54th percentile
Sentences
76
50th percentile
Readability
53
70th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
5th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 59%59%
  • Social 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

76 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Esteemed First President of the Supreme Court, Esteemed President of the Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs – specifically regarding extraordinary complaints, Esteemed Presidents – Ladies and Gentlemen, Esteemed Judges, Esteemed Professors, All Esteemed Ministers, that is, spokespersons, All Distinguished Guests!

Thank you very much for being present at this conference – I do not hide it – very important to me, important also for the office of the President of the Republic of Poland as such, because the purpose of this conference is to discuss [this topic] with you – with practitioners, with those who operate daily in the matter of extraordinary complaints, in its current construction, in its current realities, and thus you already have several years of experience in working with extraordinary complaints, both you, Presidents, you, Judges, as well as you, Ministers, representatives of entities and bodies that are authorized to submit extraordinary complaints to the Supreme Court, thus fulfilling the civic requests that come to them.

The conference serves to – first of all – discuss the time when the institution of extraordinary complaints functions. So the question is: how does it function – well or poorly? And in connection with this, the second issue: what should be the conclusions de lege ferenda, that is, what should be the conclusions also for the future.

Because for me it is obvious that the introduction of the institution of extraordinary complaints was a certain experiment, which, as you remember, took place with great noise, to say the least, from some circles outraged that anyone could claim that any final court judgment was issued incorrectly and could be issued in violation of the law or in a manner violating justice.

I have never been a judge, nor a lawyer, nor an ombudsman, but for several years I was a member of the Polish parliament, I was also a member of the European Parliament. As a lawyer, a doctor of legal sciences, I also ran – of course – a parliamentary office, to which any interested citizen could come to present their grievances, requests, or simply to talk with the deputy and his collaborators.

I do not hide that when the residents of Krakow and my constituency in general realized – and this happened quite quickly – that the office of Deputy Andrzej Duda was providing de facto free legal advice, it became very crowded, many people came. As a result, fortunately, we managed to gather a group of very open young people who wanted to help. And we provided this legal assistance, I hope, at a fairly high level.

But above all, many people came who had a huge sense of being wronged. If someone asks me: “How do you know that in Poland people believe that the justice system is not functioning well, and there is generally a sense of rather injustice than justice of the Polish state in this sense of the word?”, I say: “Unfortunately, from personal experience, I am very sorry, but I have dealt with these people myself. They came, cried, begged.”

It is the case that a parliamentary office is a place where people come, usually having exhausted all possibilities – it is coming to ask for help in hopeless situations. Unfortunately, it is possible to help in very few cases. Sometimes it works – and it is a great satisfaction, but indeed most often these are hopeless cases.

A very similar situation occurred later here when we established Dudapomoc – first during the presidential campaign, and then when I was elected to the office of the President of the Republic of Poland, fully within the structures of the Chancellery of the President. To this day, this office functions successfully. We have a service team that receives petitioners from all over Poland every day, precisely to provide them with free legal advice, to help in various situations.

So the enormity of injustice and, above all, the sense of injustice, of being wronged by the justice system was gigantic and is enormous. Something had to be done about it. Especially since there were indeed cases that seemed to be evident violations of the law and common sense by the courts, in completely incomprehensible situations. There was no shortage of that.

So when I hear some statements from legal elites about a democratic state of law, etc., I think they should read Article 2 of the constitution and see that there is a comma there and it is written “realizing the principles of social justice.” And whether the principles of social justice are really being realized or not, one simply needs to ask the people, and not ponder what the state thinks – so to speak.

If people say that the state is unjust, it means that it is unjust – and that’s it, and there is no point in discussing it with them. Especially if they say it collectively. Because – of course – dissatisfied individuals will always exist, everyone is aware of that. Most court cases have two sides – one wins, the other loses. And the one who loses is very often dissatisfied with everything and has grievances.

But very often there are indeed people who are determined, with very complicated cases. We wanted to help in this. I do not hide that a person who also motivated me a lot to introduce such regulation was Janusz Wojciechowski – you all know this name and this person. Some probably directly, some from the media.

For many years, Janusz was not only a judge, and later a politician, but above all – as a politician, and also a lawyer – he then ran an office where he provided free legal advice. He had much greater than I, much longer experience in this area.

He was a great advocate for the introduction of the institution that would allow for raising back to a very serious consideration, by truly top legal authorities in our country, precisely such cases for which people walk around desperate and seek help.

And that was the genesis of the creation of the extraordinary complaint: precisely so that people who have legal authority, legal knowledge, excellent legal experience, and at the same time are honest people of impeccable reputation, would simply take another look at the case. Also having the opportunity to verify the facts functioning in this case during the resolution. In what way was this factual state established by the court? What evidence did the court believe and why? And did it really do well, ruling most often in several instances? That was the point of the extraordinary complaint.

It was about allowing people to verify these judgments once again, so that someone would familiarize themselves with the case. To prevent a situation where suddenly the Supreme Court would be flooded with an incredible number of extraordinary complaints without any control, we introduced an intermediate level. A bit like it used to be with extraordinary revision – a very old institution, long since non-functional.

Namely: to have intermediate responsible entities that would be the first sieve verifying precisely from the legal, professional side, and at the same time also taking into account – due to the nature of their function – precisely, for example, the cases of citizens or patients, or others that are particularly within the purview of these entities; so that they would be the entity directly submitting complaints to the Supreme Court – those that from their point of view are indeed justified and meet the requirements set for extraordinary complaints by the prepared regulations for this purpose.

In 2017, this law – as you know – was adopted. We then accepted that there would be the possibility of verifying judgments even those long final, since 1997, I believe from October 17, if I remember correctly. Later, there was a period of three years from the moment the law came into force. However, time showed that this period needed to be extended, so I proposed its extension by another three years – because it was ending this year, in 2021 – to 2024. That is what happened.

It must be said that the number of extraordinary complaints being submitted is increasing. Someone might say: “It is doubtful whether this is good.” I will say this: unfortunately, it only confirms the diagnosis that was at the basis of establishing the extraordinary complaint, that there is indeed a huge sense of injustice and people need this re-examination.

Very often – as you know perfectly well as experienced practitioners – the very fact that the case is being re-examined constitutes a certain balm for the souls of these people and shows that the Polish state is indeed taking an interest in their case and is trying to do something about it – that it is not the case that they are left completely to their own devices. No – there is an entity to which one can submit a request for an extraordinary complaint, it examines it, considers it, justifies it, discusses it. This is also important.

Therefore, contrary to all those who were and are against it, I approach this institution with great attention. I am immensely grateful – I want to emphasize this with all my strength – to the Supreme Court for a whole series of judgments, and especially their justifications regarding the extraordinary complaint, because very often I had the feeling as if I were writing that justification myself; that I would also describe the institution of the extraordinary complaint in that way and what it actually serves.

I am immensely grateful for that. I will be grateful for all your voices here, at today’s conference, in this today’s debate, because I care very much that this institution exists and is an important element in healing the Polish justice system. Because it will be a tremendous healing power for it that people will increasingly feel that the justice system is fair and works well.

And they will have that feeling when they believe that the state is just – I have no doubt about that. When they believe that the state is indeed taking an interest in their matters – that has been lacking for decades. And no matter how much I am told how happy a state the Third Republic of Poland was, I will say that in this respect it is rather doubtful. And that it is certainly a deficiency that still needs to be repaired in our country.

I thank everyone who contributes to this. I thank all of you for wanting to discuss this topic. I hope that various proposals will be made regarding what changes and modifications can be introduced, because I believe that this is very important.

I will say more: I think we are being very carefully observed – we, who bear the responsibility for these matters: how sensitively we approach this and how much we are truly attuned to human matters, human feelings of justice, and we strive to make the surrounding reality of the justice system truly just and more friendly to people.

I hope that we will manage to build such a feeling in our country. I wish that for you and for myself. Once again, thank you for today’s meeting, we will listen to you with the utmost attention, I am very grateful for that.

Thank you.