President: We can seek claims against the Russian state for the Katyń crime.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

9 May 2022 · Katyń Museum

Context
Duda addressed a meeting at the Katyń Museum on May 9, 2022, urging pursuit of legal claims against Russia for the 1940 Katyń massacre.
Main themes
Katyń massacre, Russian state responsibility, legal claims against Russia, Soviet crimes, historical truth and justice, Russian imperial ambitions, Bucha massacre parallels, international justice, Polish-Russian relations, historical memory, war crimes prosecution
Duration
~9 min
31st percentile
Words
1,050
31st percentile
Sentences
44
28th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.90
3rd percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 56%32%
  • Ceremonial 24%14%
  • Institutional 20%11%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 43%

44 sentences in 17 paragraphs

Dear Presidents, Ladies and Gentlemen, Directors!

Thank you very much for meeting here, in this special place, at the Katyn Museum, regarding a very special matter, despite various attempts over decades, one could say – because since 1989 we have decades, so one could say that for decades; as it was de facto impossible before – still unresolved.

Of course, many years ago, the authorities of Russia admitted that they indeed committed the Katyn crime. They showed, even made documents available, from which it clearly follows where decisions were made and where orders were issued. But we also know very well that today’s Russia, which is trying to once again make itself an empire – and certainly has imperial ambitions, and has had them for a long time; perhaps not through the mouths of its highest authorities, but through the mouths of various historians with significant influence in the Kremlin – has repeatedly denied the Katyn crime and the Soviet responsibility for that terrible murder.

From our Polish point of view, one thing is clear and obvious. First: the truth, for which there has been a struggle for long decades, de facto for 82 years, since the time when that terrible crime occurred, in which your loved ones perished. So – first – the truth. And second: the issue of responsibility clearly defined and enforced.

Of course, there is the question: from whom, after all these years, can this responsibility be enforced in a situation where the direct and indirect perpetrators are no longer alive? They are not among the living. As we said, 82 years have passed – in human terms, their presence among the living is simply impossible.

However, they were not private individuals. They were officials of the Soviet state, politicians, members of the Soviet administration, soldiers, so – to put it briefly – it was an organized apparatus of Soviet power, which the current authorities of Russia absolutely recognize as their continuation. In this regard, there is no doubt that the present Russia can also be fully called the successor of the Soviet Union.

Especially since – as we see – today the Russian army parades on Red Square in Moscow under the banners of the Soviet Union, under the red stars so characteristic of the Red Army, under which those red stars 82 years ago their fathers murdered our officers and Poles in general.

In this regard, I have no doubt that the Russian state today is indeed the one that bears the inherited responsibility for the Katyn crime. And if we can pursue any claims today, we can indeed pursue them against the Russian state. I believe that this is the path we must take.

Is there a chance for this? Paradoxically, there is because of what is happening at this moment. But mainly because Russia and the Russians – I say this with regret – have shown their true face, which was seen by those who were murdered in Katyn. Today, the same face is seen by innocent civilians, Ukrainians murdered by Russian soldiers, as the whole world has seen.

How terrible and reminiscent – what struck the Poles – are the images of kneeling murdered people in some basement in Bucha. This is the reality that the world has seen today. This is in some sense a repetition of those images that were not recorded, but certainly occurred, at the moment when our officers were murdered and many other people as well.

When we talk about this today, there is no longer what was just a few years ago: that we are returning to some old matters, that we are anti-Russian, that we have Russophobia, that we are returning to a very painful period of World War II, when many were murdered. No! Recently, in the last decades, many did not murder. And if they did, international tribunals were immediately activated and crimes were prosecuted – even the crimes committed in the former Yugoslavia during that war. We know very well that many perpetrators, many responsible for those crimes had their trials and many of them also ended up in prison.

In this regard, I believe that this is a time when the world has somewhat opened its eyes. I had the feeling that it is my moral, in some sense historical duty, also towards you, but also towards the Republic of Poland simply as a whole, to renew the attempt – although it failed a few years ago – to obtain the approval of international justice entities, so that this crime would simply be acknowledged and that responsibility for this crime would also be acknowledged.

Of course, the possibilities are today significantly limited from a formal side, and this is the basic problem at the moment. However, I believe that this matter has two dimensions – and you are well aware of this. It has a purely legal and historical dimension, but it also has an international dimension in a political sense and in the sense of historical memory; that we, Poles, should show history as it was.

And there are various possibilities – this is what I have gathered from my conversations with experts: with my experts from the President's Chancellery led by the Minister, with experts from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, with experts dealing with international law, with scholars – even those that would allow us at least to attempt both a legal and political elevation of this topic.

And this is exactly what I wanted to discuss with you today. I wanted you to hear personally what – in our opinion – the possibilities are, what paths can potentially be taken. We simply also wanted to ask what you think about this, precisely as those who are personally connected to the whole matter, as well as to the issue of pursuing claims – also in an emotional sense; not political, not state, but rather in a very personal, familial sense.

So I thank you immensely for this meeting today to everyone who attended. I hope we will have a good conversation on this topic, which will lead us to move forward. Some preparatory work has already been done, and we would like to continue this work in a direction that you will accept.

Thank you very much.