Speech at the congress "Together for the Constitution at the National Stadium"

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

26 April 2018 · Congress "Together for the Constitution" · National Stadium, Warsaw, Poland

Context
Duda addressed a congress at Warsaw's National Stadium on April 26, 2018, concluding the first stage of his 'Together for the Constitution' nationwide debate on constitutional reform.
Main themes
Polish constitution reform, constitutional referendum, national sovereignty, centenary of Polish independence, civic participation, constitutional tradition, Rule of May 3rd Constitution legacy, nationwide consultative debate, state modernization, social engagement in lawmaking
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,018
76th percentile
Sentences
112
68th percentile
Readability
34
23rd percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.40
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 79%79%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

112 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Marshal,

Esteemed Ministers, Honorable Madam President, Honorable Mr. Chairman, Esteemed Presidents, Esteemed Professors, Members of Parliament, Senators, Dear Youth who are smiling at me here – I am very pleased, I am glad that you are with us, All Distinguished Guests!

First of all, I would like to sincerely thank you for your presence today in this – as some might say – unusual place, but on the other hand significant for contemporary Poland, and especially in this spacious and beautiful interior – at the National Stadium in Warsaw. In a discussion about an issue – I am convinced – very important for all of us, and above all for the future of the Republic. About the Polish Constitution, about the legal foundation of our system. And at the outset, I would like to say a few words about the campaign, of which today’s congress is a part.

This campaign "Together for the Constitution" began on August 25, 2017, in the historic BHP Hall of the Gdańsk Shipyard. Today marks the end of the first stage of this debate, encompassing various communities, conducted – as has already been said and shown – in different places across our country. And the summary is taking place in a unique location, in one of the most recognizable symbols of the changes that have taken place in our homeland since 1989 – right here, at the National Stadium.

Here, I would like to thank everyone who has engaged in this ongoing dialogue for nearly a year ‒ the thousands of my compatriots, Polish women and men, participants in our meetings, as well as those who sent their comments to the Chancellery of the President by mail.

The aim of the "Together for the Constitution" campaign is to show Poles that their fate is in their hands. In the year of the centenary of regaining independence, we should have a special sense, I am convinced, that we can fully sovereignly – as a nation, as a society – shape our future and that of our homeland.

I am pleased that the project, the commencement of which I announced last year during the May 3rd Celebration, is still developing. We remember that the creators of that famous Government Act of 1791, which aimed to strengthen the Republic and give it new forces for development, foresaw that every 25 years there should be a reflection on the need to revise constitutional provisions. Today, we also face a similar challenge. Poland needs a constitution that meets the realities of the 21st century.

This year, we celebrate a great, unifying jubilee for all Poles: the 100th anniversary of Poland regaining independence. It is a special opportunity and obligation to recall the proud heritage of the past, but also to look with energy and boldness towards the future. A good Constitution ‒ one that streamlines the state and ensures prosperity for Polish citizens ‒ must serve that very future.

The project I initiated aims to involve society in the process of creating the Constitution from the very beginning of the work on it. This is the essence of the nationwide consultative referendum, which is to answer the question of whether citizens want changes or the adoption of a new Constitution, and to determine the direction of the amendment. This is a reversal of the previous practice, in which Poles were asked for their opinion only at the end, and their choice was limited to approving or rejecting an already de facto adopted constitutional act.

As part of the nationwide debate before the consultative referendum on the amendment of the Constitution, I encourage you to reflect on the Polish constitutional tradition. It is prudent – in my opinion – to begin the search for the best solutions for the future with a careful look at the past. Therefore, it is worth and necessary to examine, in this context, the history of our ancestors. This is the purpose of the exhibition "Together for the Constitution," presented here for the first time, which you will have the opportunity to view today. It reaches back to the times of the Polish nobility and illustrates how many areas of constitutional thought Poland was a precursor and a model for others.

As part of the ongoing campaign, ministers and experts from the Chancellery of the President visited 18 largest Polish cities, including all provincial capitals. We have repeatedly met at expert conferences in Warsaw and in other places across our country. The debates concerned issues of local government, rural areas and agriculture, the system, family, social policy, the economy, and other important matters. We met with thousands of Polish women and men. We collected hundreds of constitutional surveys, in which Poles once again confirmed that they expect a change in the Constitution – as nearly 81 percent of respondents said, and they want to participate in a referendum on this matter – which was confirmed by 74 percent.

Ladies and Gentlemen, in the process of making changes to the Constitution – a process that I initiated – the institution of the referendum is of key importance. It gives a voice to the sovereign, engaging citizens in the most direct and universal way. The role of the referendum in the Polish constitutional system should be strengthened compared to that which was designated by the creators of the Constitution of 1997.

Constitutional referendums in the last 30 years have gained extraordinary significance and popularity. From 1975 to 2000, among democratic countries with more than 3 million citizens, at least one constitutional referendum was held in 39 countries. Since 2000, there have been even more, and they are permanently changing the world order – it is worth recalling, for example, the French referendum rejecting the Constitutional Treaty for Europe or the British vote on leaving the European Union.

These referendums concerned constitutional matters ‒ not only the literal change of the constitution but also issues of state affiliation, the creation of autonomous communities, or issues of integration with the European Union ‒ or disintegration, as shown by the results of the two aforementioned votes: the French and the British.

We also have important experience in this area. In the ratification referendum held on May 25, 1997, regarding the adoption of the Constitution of the Republic, adopted by the National Assembly on April 2, 1997, more than 12 million citizens participated, which means a turnout of about 43 percent of the total number of eligible voters. Almost 53 percent voted "for," while 46 percent voted "against." The adoption of the Constitution was decided by 6,396,641 votes "for," which is about 22.5 percent of the total number of eligible voters.

And at this point, it can be said that we are dealing in Poland with a true historical, political, and legal paradox. It consists in the fact that although the Constitution of the Republic of 1997 was approved in a nationwide referendum, its provisions essentially deprecate this form of exercising power by the sovereign nation, considering, for example, the provisions of Article 4, Article 90, Article 125, or Article 235.

The referendum in its conception – which is intended to be a method of direct and decisive expression of will by all citizens of the Republic, i.e., the most democratic form of exercising power – is always only permissible, never obligatory in any matter, as is the case in other countries that provide for constitutional referendums.

The Constitution also limits the permissibility of using a constitutional referendum only in relation to certain changes to the fundamental law – concerning the regulation of the system of the Republic, freedoms, rights, and obligations of the individual, and the procedure for amending the fundamental law.

A regular nationwide referendum, possible in matters of "particular importance to the state," essentially depends on the parliament. It can only be ordered by the Sejm or by the President, but with the consent of the Senate expressed by a qualified majority of votes ‒ only in the case of ordering a constitutional referendum does the Head of State have an independent position. The Constitution does not provide for the initiative to conduct a nationwide referendum by the interested parties, i.e., citizens, as is the case in many European countries. It requires, however, for a binding result of the referendum, the participation in such voting of more than half of all eligible citizens.

The Constitution does not distinguish between legislative and consultative referendums nor does it establish who and how its result is to bind. The fundamental law leaves these issues to be resolved in an ordinary law, i.e., in the 2003 law on nationwide referendums.

Ladies and Gentlemen, in the first nationwide referendum conducted under the Constitution of 1997, which concerned Poland's accession to the European Union, on June 7-8, 2003, nearly 59 percent of nearly 30 million eligible voters participated. About 77 percent of valid votes were cast in favor of ratifying the Treaty, which amounted to over 13.5 million, representing 45.25 percent of all eligible voters. This was – so far – the referendum with the highest level of engagement of the sovereign.

The second and so far only nationwide referendum took place in 2015. As we remember, it was initiated by the then-serving President – Mr. Bronisław Komorowski ‒ just after the first round of the presidential elections and the official announcement of their results. The voting took place on September 6, 2015, exactly one month after the inauguration of the newly elected President of the Republic. At the same time, it was two days after the decision of the outgoing Senate, which denied me, as I was then beginning my term as President, permission to conduct a referendum on socially significant issues ‒ such as the abolition of the compulsory schooling of six-year-olds, lowering the retirement age, and the protection of State Forests. The referendum initiated by President Bronisław Komorowski took place with a record low turnout of only 7.8 percent of the total number of eligible voters.

This radical absence of citizens indicated not so much the insignificance of the referendum issues but rather the rational political thinking of Poles, who massively refused to participate in a procedure treated instrumentally.

Ladies and Gentlemen, the preliminary initiative I announced a year ago to prepare a consultative referendum, which would ask about the need to change the Constitution, is undoubtedly unprecedented. Not only because it concerns constitutional issues, which are of the highest importance for the state, as in the case of the referendum of 1997. What is even more important – the universal vote I propose does not reduce the participation of citizens in the exercise of power to a symbolic dimension. It does not limit Poles to making only a "yes" or "no" decision. This referendum, to a much greater extent, defines each citizen's active and subjective role.

The nation – in my opinion – should have a conscious and real influence on the entire constitutional process. First, on determining the directions, and even the content of specific provisions of the new or amended Constitution. Then ‒ after conducting legislative proceedings in parliament, taking into account the results of the consultative referendum ‒ the approval of the introduced changes should take place through a final constitutional referendum. It is then – in my opinion – that Poles will feel that this is fully their own Constitution – designed, discussed, and adopted with the participation of all citizens who want to express their opinion on this matter.

The model of social law-making of the highest rank, which from the very beginning engages the nation in the work of constitutional reflection, is perhaps innovative in today's times. However, it constitutes – in my view – a confirmation of the essence of the statehood of the Republic as a common good for all of us, its citizens. And it is the realization of the principle of the sovereignty of the nation, entitled to exercise power directly also in the sphere of law-making and shaping the system. It would be a fulfillment of the political mission entrusted to me by the nation and a great satisfaction for me if the referendum process could be conducted in this very form. It fully corresponds to the constitutional role of the President of the Republic as the first representative of the Polish state, a servant of the nation, and an expression of the Polish raison d'état.

It is true that in practice, the nationwide referendum has so far played a rather illusory role in the Polish constitutional system. It has been an instrument available only potentially – but only with the consent of representatives of the legislative power, and not obligatorily at the request of the nation. A good change in this area is, however, possible. Moreover – it is needed, and in my opinion, also expected. After all, even the currently binding Constitution speaks of the regained by the nation in 1989 possibility of sovereign and democratic determination of the fate of the homeland. All the more should this be relevant in 2018, in the centenary of the rebirth of the Polish state after 123 years of captivity and partitions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, the directions of changes to the existing Constitution can actually concern all issues raised in its text ‒ starting from the preamble, through all chapters of the fundamental law. However, the question arises about the limits of the sovereign's decisions.

We recognize that representatives of the nation – deputies and senators, politically diverse as well as varied in professional preparation or life experience – although they do not possess the attribute of infallibility, as long as they adhere to the provisions of the Constitution, are entitled to unlimited substantive legislative competencies. Why then should we limit the legislative powers of the sovereign itself, which the deputies represent? Is it because there is a fear of politicians manipulating the will of the people? Or is it because we succumb to the argument that people do not understand important and complex constitutional issues and therefore they should be left to professionals? However, let us consider whether, by thinking this way, we are getting closer to or distancing ourselves from the essence of democracy. We must boldly and logically address the fundamental question: why can the collective sovereign, which is the foundation of the current system, not play a fundamental role in constitutional changes?

Of course, we cannot view a referendum naively – as an ultra-democratic tool that is a remedy for everything. A referendum – like any human creation – is not an institution perfect in axiological, normative, or political terms. This is evidenced by the experiences of contemporary states both in terms of regulations and practice.

However, this should neither discourage us nor bind our hands. If the Constitution is to express the aspirations of the nation that constitutes it for an independent existence in a sovereign state, then this entity cannot limit its sovereign power, including in the area of constitutional law-making. There are grounds to defend the radical view that the subject of a referendum can be almost anything – certainly the Constitution, its amendment, or revision.

Ladies and gentlemen, the cycle of debates indicating directions for changes in the Constitution has produced a very rich and valuable material, which prompts me to pose several questions today, for example:

- about the possibility of initiating a nationwide referendum approving laws that would concern constitutional matters, such as changing the currency, the pension and retirement system, education, public higher education, or the healthcare system;

- about the need to supplement – expressed in Article 9 of the current Constitution – the principle of respecting the international legal obligations of the Republic with a European reference and confirming the supremacy of the Constitution in the complex legal system – for instance, by giving Article 9 the wording: “The Republic of Poland observes the binding international and European law, in accordance with the Constitution of the Republic of Poland”;

- about the need to emphasize in the Constitution the special position and privileges of the family as the foundation of national existence, also considering the expansion of the catalog of values currently protected under Article 18 of the Constitution – such as marriage, family, motherhood, and parenthood – by adding “fatherhood” to this catalog;

- about the need to include in the fundamental law the division of local government units into voivodeships and counties, and not only – as is the case in the current Constitution – solely municipalities;

- about the need to introduce a provision that obliges the state to provide special protection for Polish agriculture and rural areas; for example, about the need to introduce provisions that more strongly protect individuals affected by disability or incapacity.

It is worth emphasizing that constitutional reflection has also turned to general issues, such as the optimal constitutional model of executive power.

However, one thing is clear to me: the fundamental goal of constitutional reform remains undoubtedly the strengthening of Polish independence, sovereignty, and the prosperous existence of Poles.

Ladies and gentlemen, I am convinced that today’s meeting – which is a summary of the achievements of the nationwide discussion so far – will also become an important step in the process of improving the constitutional system of the Republic. This is indeed a path laid out over many stages, in which the culmination of certain reflections simultaneously constitutes an invitation and a commitment to undertake further tasks.

I trust that this path will lead us to the desired goal, which is a Poland strengthened in its independence and sovereignty: free and secure, just and solidary, modern and prosperous. A Poland where honesty prevails, not cynicism and villainy. A Poland that will be able to meet all the challenges of the 21st century. A Poland that will be a source of pride for Poles and a bastion of our identity, national spirit, and our great, over 1,050-year tradition. I deeply believe in such a Poland and I want to serve that Poland with all my strength.

Thank you and I invite you to the debate.