Speech at the Council for Security and Defense

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

8 March 2022 · Council for Security and Defense meeting

Context
Duda addressed Poland's Council for Security and Defense on March 8, 2022, discussing lessons from the Russian invasion of Ukraine for Polish military modernization.
Main themes
Ukrainian resistance to Russian aggression, territorial defense forces, Polish army modernization, defense of sovereignty and independence, volunteer fighters and civilian soldiers, military morale and determination, homeland defense law, infantry equipment and modern weaponry, lessons from the Ukraine-Russia war, Polish national security
Duration
~8 min
29th percentile
Words
1,004
29th percentile
Sentences
35
21st percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
14.3
69th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 74%74%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

35 sentences in 17 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Chairman, esteemed Generals, distinguished Professors, all highly esteemed members, dear Council members!

Thank you very much for this meeting and I would like to express my gratitude to General Wiesław Kukula, Chief Commander of the Territorial Defense Forces, for accepting the invitation to this meeting, as I believe his presence here today at the Council forum is absolutely desired, and I am very pleased that we will be having this discussion here today.

There is no need to hide it: with great engagement, but also with great, I do not hide, fascination and admiration, I observe the struggle of the Ukrainian people – for that is how it must be clearly stated – for freedom, for their own state, for the independence and sovereignty of Ukraine.

The Russian aggression, with forces of overwhelming superiority compared to the officially reported statistical data about the Ukrainian army, sends a shiver down the spine when one compares these data – what forces Russia initially had at its disposal and what forces Ukraine initially had at its disposal.

It turns out, after more than 10 days of essentially continuous fighting, that primarily Ukraine possessed what no statistics could account for, namely: people who are absolutely determined to defend their homeland. It turns out that spirit provides enormous strength in the fight against material.

On one side, we have Russian forces that are indeed largely devoid of the will to fight and real morale, and are now, to a large extent, simply scared; and on the other side, we have absolutely determined, almost frantic Ukrainians defending their homeland, who are ready to give their lives anywhere just to defend their country.

This is incredibly impressive, but above all – looking at it coldly from a military perspective – it turns out that the gigantic Russian army has been largely halted by the Ukrainians. Originally, it was planned that the entire special operation – as it was called – would be concluded in two or three days.

Meanwhile, it turns out that probably over 10,000 Russian soldiers have fallen – which means de facto a thousand soldiers a day – when throughout the entire Vietnam War, American forces lost about 50,000 soldiers over nearly 10 years. And here, 10,000 in 10 days! So the losses are simply unprecedented. And all of this is due to the extraordinary determination with which the Ukrainians are fighting.

The question is: who is fighting? Of course, there are Ukrainian soldiers, fighters who have fought in Donbas and Luhansk for eight years, who have been constantly engaged, always on the front line, and have gained combat experience that is invaluable. But they are not all. A huge part of these people probably never even held a weapon before. And now they are picking it up and going to fight to defend their homeland.

How is it possible that with such a small amount of technical equipment compared to the Russians, tanks, armored vehicles, aircraft, combat and transport helicopters, the Ukrainians – because this is an army, but in a large part a volunteer army, one could say a territorial defense, simply ordinary citizens who have taken up arms, often men well beyond the normal conscription age, serious, almost elderly gentlemen – are still fighting and are able to stop the enemy? Of course, they are supported.

Of course, that support is coming, that support is visible – for example, in the video materials where we see how Russian tanks, Russian helicopters, Russian planes are being destroyed: that often it is enough to have the equipment of an individual soldier; equipment that an individual soldier is capable of using. There is no need for a group or special extensive preparation. Simple, modern, extraordinarily effective weaponry compared to what the Russian army has today – largely outdated equipment. It turns out that this is effective defense.

It is good that this meeting is taking place today, it is good that General, Chief of the Territorial Defense Forces is with us, because this is exactly what we need to talk about – also in the context of the law on homeland defense currently being adopted by the Sejm: how to shape the process of modernizing the Polish army, so that we can effectively stand ready to defend our homeland at any moment.

Not only through super-modern systems, super-modern tanks, super-modern missile defense, super-modern digitally controlled air defense, but simply through good basic equipment for the ordinary infantry soldier, who volunteers and after a short training will be able to defend effectively and will pose a real threat to the enemy – so real that it will not be worth attacking, because the threat of enormous material losses, and above all human losses, will be immense. This is an extremely important – in my opinion – stage of modernizing the Polish army in such a way as to maintain the country's security to the greatest extent possible.

I want you to discuss this today. I also want to witness such a discussion. I want General to express his opinion on this matter, and for the Generals to speak on this issue as experts in these fields – such fighting; fighting that has a semi-partisan character, when there is indeed a clash between a technically equipped opponent and a theoretically unequipped, but well-combat-equipped soldier determined to defend his homeland.

I am convinced that we have such soldiers and such people in Poland – who, if necessary, will be ready to stand and defend Poland, its borders, and freedom just as men and women are defending it today in Ukraine. I absolutely believe that as a society we are capable of this.

And what is happening in Ukraine – with all the tragedy of these events, the death of people, the great misfortune that we also encounter here, taking them in Poland, into our homes, refugees, women, children – with all this misfortune, their attitude is admirable. And absolutely worthy of imitation in every respect.

Thank you very much.