Speech at the First Plenary Session of the Arraiolos Group

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

15 September 2021 · First Plenary Session of the Arraiolos Group

Context
Duda addressed the Arraiolos Group plenary session in September 2021, presenting Poland's position on EU strategic autonomy, NATO, and European integration.
Main themes
EU strategic autonomy, transatlantic relations and NATO, European integration, EU global role, nation-state sovereignty, open-door EU policy, cybersecurity and hybrid threats, Belarus destabilization, EU single market reform, defense and security cooperation, Nord Stream 2 pipeline
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,300
38th percentile
Sentences
67
44th percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
48th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 69%69%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

67 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Excellencies, Ladies and Gentlemen,

thank you for the invitation to participate in this year's Arraiolos Group meeting. I am pleased that we can finally meet, as in normal times, face to face. We represent the diversity of our countries, regions, cultures, and economic profiles. Despite differing views on the future of the Union and the further course of its integration, what undoubtedly unites us is a deep conviction and attachment to the European project. I declare this clearly on behalf of my country.

The discussion about the future of the European Union is also a reflection on the concept of "strategic autonomy" and an attempt to answer the question: what is necessary for the European Union to become an influential and important player on the global stage.

In my speech today, I want to present three theses: First: building a strong position for the European Union in the global game cannot come at the expense of undermining the role of NATO and transatlantic relations. Second: the Union, if it truly wants to be European, must pursue an open-door policy. It cannot be a club.

Third: the use of terms like "autonomy" or "strategic sovereignty" in the context of the EU must include respect for the nation-state.

Regarding the first point, we must be aware that in the face of increasing geopolitical rivalry, the European Union, wanting to be a subject co-shaping the international order, should strengthen its own resources, capacity to act, and defense. But this should never come at the expense of a proven alliance.

It is hard to imagine the history of World War II in Europe and its post-war fate without close cooperation with our partner across the Atlantic. After all, it was American troops who sacrificed their lives to liberate the western part of our continent from the occupation of German Nazis. At the peak of the Cold War, in the 1960s, there were about 400,000 American soldiers in Europe. This enormous, often heroic effort was aimed not at the occupation of Europe, but at its defense against the invasion of the Red Army and ensuring the security of the Old Continent. We truly know well what the Red Army is.

Similarly now, although there are definitely fewer American troops, about 60,000, their presence is the most important element of our security. This does not mean in any way that American policy should be approached uncritically. I believe, for example, that allowing the construction of the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, a project that is extremely harmful geopolitically, is a cardinal mistake that will lead to a security deficit across large areas of our continent. Nevertheless, the United States is and will remain for a long time the closest ally and the best guarantor of security that Europe has ever had. The USA is also part of our heritage. Poles, Irish, Italians, Germans know this very well.

Therefore, any strengthening of the EU at the expense of transatlantic relations and the North Atlantic Alliance must be categorically excluded. Let us set aside ambitions and treat security as a priority.

The Union, given the differing strategies of member states or differences in the perception of threats, is unable today and in the near future to take care of its "hard" security on its own. We need close cooperation with allies, a strong NATO, and close transatlantic relations for that. Our actions should not duplicate NATO's tasks. Instead, we should develop the EU-NATO dialogue and strengthen European technological and defense potential. Poland also sees the potential of the Union in areas such as cybersecurity, combating disinformation, or hybrid threats – including those occurring at our eastern borders with Belarus, where the Lukashenko regime is trying to destabilize the Union by attempting to smuggle cynically exploited people into Western Europe. After all, everyone knows that Poland, Lithuania, and Latvia, which are currently struggling with this problem, are actually defending the security of Germany and Scandinavia.

Speaking about strengthening the international role of the European Union, we must primarily strengthen the economic potential of the Community. In my letter last year addressed, among others, to you – the leaders, co-leaders of Europe – I wrote that as Europe we must again become a great, innovative, and relevant "production workshop," because this is of strategic importance for our economic subjectivity. This economic potential directly translates into strength and global position. To strengthen its role in the world, the Union should primarily continue the reform of the single market, shedding protectionist tendencies that limit the freedom of competition. In this way, we will secure our economy against crises.

However, in building the global position of the EU, we must remember about ourselves. The strength of our community and its perception in the world should stem from its credibility. We will not be credible if our partners, who are making modernization efforts and want to join our community, are not given that opportunity. That is why I speak of enlargement. We are Europe, a Continent, not a club for the chosen.

Therefore, we must be open to other European countries, to those that are already genuinely implementing reforms aimed at accession to the Union. Unfortunately, more than 30 years after the fall of the Iron Curtain, the territory of Europe is still divided.

Today, the curtains are not made of iron, but of customs barriers, visa restrictions, and a lack of membership prospects. And I say this openly: in our immediate neighborhood lie European countries that should be part of our community. Recently, I visited Moldova on the occasion of the 30th anniversary of its independence. I saw young people there who enthusiastically want to change their country. We all saw Ukraine in 2014, where young patriots and democrats died on the barricades for their country to have a chance to one day join the European community.

Therefore, if we want the Union to be a truly European union, we must continue the policy of enlargement. There is a consensus on this matter in Poland. In 10-15 years, there will be a different president of Poland, and he or she will say the same thing, as long as this matter does not move forward. Because I assure you that Poland will not rest until this division between "the Union and the non-Union" is ended. Because, ladies and gentlemen, a divided continent cannot have any strategic autonomy.

Now the third issue. In Poland, which actively participates in the dialogue on the role of our community on the global forum, the terms "autonomy" or "strategic sovereignty" do not evoke enthusiasm and are contrary to the will of the founders of the Union. "Sovereignty" is, after all, an attribute of nation-states – they are the ones who remain the "owners" of the European project. Thus, the competences of our community should be limited only to those that have been voluntarily transferred to it by the member states. A lack of understanding of this state of affairs, as well as a lack of a common European identity or language, results in something we know well: a democratic deficit in the institutions of the Union. It is the nation-states that are democratic, and the Union operates on the basis of an agreement between them.

Excellencies, Ladies and Gentlemen,

In conclusion, building a strong position for the EU in global politics is a task that we can only achieve through cooperation. The place of our countries and our community is undoubtedly among the players in global politics. However, this cannot come at the expense of our existing alliances. It cannot be contrary to the vision of the European community of the founding fathers. We will achieve this only within the transatlantic community, with open doors to new countries and with respect for the sovereignty of our states.

Thank you.