Speech at the inauguration of the XII National Congress of the Bar Association

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

25 November 2016 · XII National Congress of the Bar Association

Context
Duda addressed the XII National Congress of the Bar Association in Kraków on November 25, 2016, honoring the Bar's historic role in Polish statehood.
Main themes
Role of the Bar in Polish history, legal profession and public trust, Polish national identity, historical continuity of the legal defender, Bar Association's sacrifice during wartime, state-building and legal institutions, memory of Lech Kaczyński, Polish statehood anniversary, self-governance of the legal profession, lawyers under partition, Warsaw Uprising sacrifices
Duration
~32 min
85th percentile
Words
3,880
85th percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
14.4
71st percentile
Syntax
3.36
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
55th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 46%46%
  • Ceremonial 37%37%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

123 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Dear Madam Marshal,

Dear Mr. President of the Supreme Bar Council,

Esteemed Members of Parliament and Senators,

Esteemed Ministers,

Dear Mr. President of the City of Kraków,

Esteemed Presidents,

Esteemed Counselors,

All Delegates to the National Congress of the Bar,

All Distinguished Guests,

I would like to thank the President for these words and I will say this: I am here for several reasons, which I will enumerate, although I want to emphasize from the outset that each of them is equally important to me. There is no gradation among them.

First, I am here as the President of the Republic out of respect for the Bar as an institution, today I can say: an institution of the Republic of Poland, of the Polish state – an important institution in the Polish state, which I will specify shortly.

Second, I am here in memory ‒ the memory of President Professor Lech Kaczyński, my president, and his relationship with the Polish Bar as a lawyer, as a scholar of the Faculty of Law and Administration, a university professor, and as the President of the Republic, as a man, as a Pole, a statesman. Also through the memory of the president, Ms. Counselor Joanna Agacka-Indecka. These are the first two reasons.

Third, I am also here to show respect to you, the community, and the Presidium of the Supreme Bar Council led by Mr. President, because we met in June of this year for the first time when you wished to come to the Presidential Palace to present the annual report of the Polish Bar to me. Thank you for coming to the Palace, thank you that we could sit down, talk in a good atmosphere, a calm atmosphere, a substantive, factual discussion about important matters for Poland, also about the future. For these reasons, I am here with you today.

I will begin by deepening this first point. The profession of lawyer is probably one of the oldest in the world; in antiquity, the first documented mentions of the work of legal representatives appear, and it is then that the name ‒ advocati ‒ appears in ancient Rome. But it is also the very early emergence of the institution of the legal defender in our country, in Poland. This year we celebrate the 1050th anniversary of the baptism, and thus ‒ as we all accept ‒ the 1050th anniversary of the establishment of the Polish state. The defender in the process appears essentially at the very beginning, and this is historically documented. Jan Długosz in his chronicles writes about legal defenders during the time of Bolesław Chrobry, the first king of Poland. But even Karol Bunsch in his novels writes about legal defenders during the time of Mieszko I, the father of Bolesław Chrobry. Then there is an absolutely documented history of the actions of defenders in processes on Polish lands in the Polish state in the 13th century and then the emergence of the profession of legal defender at the turn of the 15th and 16th centuries before the Crown Tribunal. Then the entire history up to the present day – but the most important thing is not that it is long, because it is long. The most important thing is who lawyers were for the Polish state and Polish society, for Poles, for all of us as a nation.

And secondly, what their attitude was in this state-building sense. And here I will point out perhaps the cases that are closest to me. It was in times when the Polish state did not exist, as it was partitioned, in 1901 when the lawyers from Greater Poland, Poles who were lawyers under Prussian partition, thus in the Prussian state, defended the children and parents from Września who did not want to be Germanized, who wanted to pray in Polish. It was these Polish lawyers who died fighting for an independent Polish state – they died in uprisings, they died in Piłsudski's Legions. The significance of the Bar as a profession, as a community, as a particular profession of public trust in the state perspective is evidenced by the fact that the temporary statute of the Bar of the Polish State was one of the first acts issued by the Chief of State Józef Piłsudski, it was December 24, 1918, and in March 1919 the Supreme Bar Council was constituted, thus de facto the true Polish bar self-government returned. A professional self-government as a profession of public trust. But it is not only that ‒ it was lawyers and legal trainees who died in defense of the homeland in 1920, fighting against the Bolshevik onslaught, it was lawyers who died on the fronts of World War II, it was 95 percent of Warsaw's legal trainees who did not return after the Warsaw Uprising and after the war. It was almost half of the Polish Bar that did not survive World War II because they perished. Just like the memorial 14 Righteous, who despite demands from the German authorities did not hand over, did not identify among Polish lawyers their Jewish colleagues and found themselves in concentration camps. It was all Polish lawyers of Jewish descent who lost their lives in concentration camps and in other places where they were murdered by the German Nazis.

Finally, ladies and gentlemen, it is the great chapter of the Polish Bar, which was already mentioned today by Mr. President Andrzej Zwara, during the communist period, when there was an attempt to muzzle the Polish Bar, when it was not safe, because one could even lose their life, yet there were lawyers in your community who were not afraid to stand up and defend in political processes, who were not afraid to act as auxiliary prosecutors against the actions of the people's power and its functionaries – let me mention Mr. Counselor Maciej Bednarkiewicz, who passed away on November 11 of this year, just a few days ago. It was Mr. Counselor – who also passed away this year – Maciej Dubois, a defender in many political processes. It was Mr. Counselor Władysław Siła-Nowicki, who has long been gone from among us. It was Mr. Counselor Jan Olszewski, a later prime minister, it was many, many Warsaw lawyers and from other cities, like the Kraków lawyer present here, Mr. Zbigniew Cichoń, also a defender in political processes during martial law and the 1980s. It is the current elder of the Polish Bar, Mr. Counselor, Mr. President Czesław Jaworski.

This is, ladies and gentlemen, the core of the Polish Bar that built its beautiful chapter, and this is the core of the Polish Bar – of course among them are many, many other lawyers whose names I have not mentioned – but they built the opinion in society about the Polish Bar in spite of those, because there were also such people in the Polish Bar at that time, who collaborated with the communist regime and did not defend in political processes in the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, 1980s. But there were those Righteous who were not afraid, despite the risks that were associated with it, and it was they who built the Bar as we would all like to see it ‒ those who call themselves statesmen, those who call themselves patriots. And this is the great chapter of the Polish Bar, before which certainly everyone, with the President of the Republic at the forefront, should bow their heads. And I bow my head today before this great achievement of the Polish Bar throughout Polish history.

These, ladies and gentlemen, are the two extraordinarily important figures I mentioned – the figure of Mr. President, Professor Lech Kaczyński, as I say, my president, and the figure of Ms. President Joanna Agacka-Indecka. It was with President Lech Kaczyński, as Mr. President mentioned a moment ago, that I was for the first time in my life at the National Congress of the Bar, it was March 6, 2010. And then I heard that speech of Mr. President, which perhaps some of you remember and which I think is worth recalling here today, because despite the passage of more than six years, almost seven without four months, its essential points remain relevant.

Mr. President said then that the Bar plays, above all, a very important role as a group of people performing a significant legal profession, plays a very important role in a rule of law state, which in Poland is still under construction, plays an important role when that state is already built, but also plays an important role at the stage of its construction. And essentially he said this: this role can be dual, because it is first of all very high qualifications of professional preparation, but it is also principles – and he emphasized this strongly. These are ethical principles, these are moral principles. A lawyer who acts in the state ‒ because many of you have in your life also whether behind you or ahead of you political activity. But most of you do not engage in it. So those who do not engage in it can certainly have a positive or negative impact on a person's life. Depending on whether they are guided by these principles or not. If they are guided by them, if they adhere to them, if they care for them, that influence – one must assume – will be positive, it will also be building a good name for the Bar, but above all it will indeed be serving a person with their work, their knowledge, their unique skills. To which the Bar and lawyers are called, as a kind of service to humanity. An exceptional profession – a profession of public trust. But it is also the possibility of harming a person – when these moral, ethical principles are not adhered to, when they are broken. Harm sometimes in a very serious way ‒ and the same is true for the Polish state. If a lawyer, if a legal professional acts or should act, undertakes actions for the Polish state, then if they act ethically and morally, guided by their best knowledge, they have a chance to help that state build its strength, build its stability, build its good name. But if they break ethical, moral principles, if they do not apply them, they will harm that state. And President Lech Kaczyński wished at that time to all present, to the Polish Bar that its actions would always be positive and that it would always have – for Polish society, looking collectively and individually, and for the Polish state – the most positive effect.

But I, ladies and gentlemen, would like to add one more thing to this – if I may – something that I personally also consider important, somewhat extracting it from this morality and ethics, because essentially it could be found there, but I want to exemplify it in a special way. So, ladies and gentlemen, I wanted to ask you, as a community, for one thing, because of course, as you know, as you say, when I meet with those representatives of yours whom I know, as you have also written recently in the media, even yesterday, as Mr. Counselor Czesław Jaworski wrote in his latest publication in "Palestra" ‒ in the Bar, as a certain collective of people, there are very different opinions. Some are more radical, others are less radical. Some are more convinced of a certain ideology, others of another, opinions vary – consequently, there are also political disputes on various topics. As in any large collective of people. Of course, we always have the right to that dispute, because dispute is a certain nature of democracy. But I have one request for you as the Bar, as a whole, as the entire community: if as a community you express yourselves or will express yourselves in the future on matters either purely political or at the intersection of law and politics, I ask for one thing – I would ask for the greatest possible objectivity in the sphere of facts, that is, to present them as they were, and in the order in which they occurred, in the sphere of their assessment and significance for the matter. I would ask for objectivity from your community as a whole, I would also ask the authorities of the Bar ‒ those future ones that will be elected by you ‒ to ensure that the position of the community as a whole, not individual lawyers, here everyone has the right to their opinion, but the community as a whole, is a balanced opinion, as objective as possible, because only then can it be said that the Bar assesses the situation and takes its position, but does everything to not take a decisive side in the political scene, because with an objective assessment of the facts such a statement is objectively impossible, and in any case unjustified. I ask for this very much.

And I wanted, ladies and gentlemen, to ask for one more thing in the context of what President Lech Kaczyński said, because the second element that he strongly emphasized was precisely that which Mr. President also mentioned today – the issue that was then very alive and the subject of strong, sometimes heated discussion about the merger of the professions of lawyer and legal advisor. Mr. President said then briefly: it does not seem that this is going to happen today in an institutional, statutory sense, but I want to say one more thing – he said then ‒ if the self-governments want, they will merge, and we must respect in this regard the independence of the self-governments and their right to decide as marked constitutionally. I absolutely uphold the position of President Lech Kaczyński now, as the President of the Republic.

And I will say, ladies and gentlemen, more, referring to the second extraordinary person I spoke about today. I met President Joanna Agacka-Indecka, perhaps seemingly under not the most pleasant circumstances. Namely, when I was the Deputy Minister of Justice, Madam President, as a representative of the Presidium of the National Bar Council, came with a delegation to the Ministry of Justice to discuss the issue of access to professions. It so happened that I was assigned to that task. I do not deny, I was 34 years old at the time, please forgive me ‒ I was young, I did not have political experience, nor did I have as much life experience as I do today, sometimes difficult ‒ that at the beginning I was quite impetuous. But it was the very calm demeanor of Madam President that made a huge impression on me at that time. We, ladies and gentlemen, worked for a year, meeting very often, and we developed, in agreement and calmly discussing, the specific provisions, the content of the amendments to the Law on the Bar, which actually defined the scope of opening legal professions, in the area of the legal profession, of course. Similar solutions were later adopted regarding the second profession – the profession of legal advisor.

Ladies and gentlemen, I want to say one thing, which was also extremely important to me besides the fact that we worked out with Madam President and the environment representing the Polish Bar in those discussions, negotiations, that work ‒ one thing that is also extremely important to me, besides the fact that we could sit at the same table and that we adopted certain arrangements. As you know very well, in 2007 I ceased to be the Deputy Minister of Justice, a different political option came, which had previously been in opposition to us, so there was a new Ministry of Justice headed by a new minister, who actually came directly from your environment – Professor Ćwiąkalski was then the Minister of Justice. I found myself in the office of President Lech Kaczyński as his minister responsible for legal affairs. And I must tell you that I received with great satisfaction the day when the Sejm, at the request of the Ministry of Justice, passed the Law on the Bar, this amendment regarding access to professions, practically in the form that I had established then with Madam President Joanna Agacka-Indecka and the delegation of the National Bar Council. Do you know what I thought at that time? I thought to myself: “Wow! Pacta sunt servanda.” And it made a great impression on me because Madam President could have changed that project later, and I think that if she wanted to and if the environment of the National Bar Council wanted and strongly pressed the minister on this matter, such a change would probably have occurred ‒ and the changes that were made were only cosmetic changes. This, ladies and gentlemen, caused my immense and never-diminishing respect for Madam President and for those who hold this presidential function within the National Bar Council, which has lasted through the remaining years and continues to this day. I respect the legal community for keeping the agreements, because it was a gesture ‒ and for that, I thank you.

Madam President was certainly a wonderful lawyer and a wonderful person, and I keep her in my memory with great respect and gratitude. And that, ladies and gentlemen, this element, but I want to say one thing in this context, because the whole thread was aimed at concluding it in the following way: I now look at this as President and I want you to know that I know, because I have such personal experience thanks to Madam President Joanna Agacka-Indecka, that certain things concerning the legal profession can be established and worked out, I know that it can be done ‒ if one wants to. And considering the constitutional position of the legal profession, as President, I want to tell you one thing, namely: I want to work with you and I do not agree that certain things concerning the profession, which are significant, should be changed without the profession ‒ so that we understand each other well. You have, in these matters, first of all, the right to a voice, and secondly, nevertheless, these issues related to significant matters of the functioning of the profession as a profession of public trust, which at the same time bears responsibility for the performance of this profession, should be agreed upon with you. And I, as the President of the Republic, will be negotiating these matters with you. And if it turns out that there are any changes that have not been discussed with you, that have not been agreed upon, and they appear, I invite you to come to me. We will sit at the table, we will discuss this topic – I am open to it, always! If you have any objections, or any proposals, or any initiatives that you believe can be shared with the President of the Republic or discussed with the President of the Republic as someone who, for example, has the right to legislative initiative – I am open to it out of respect for the Polish Bar and its achievements.

But in connection with this, I have one request for you: namely, there was also talk here today about how to build a further good image of the bar in the eyes of Polish society, and thus also its prestige. Well, ladies and gentlemen, in my personal conviction ‒ this is my personal conviction, but also stemming from certain experiences, meetings, and many, many conversations with ordinary people – the issue of ethics and morality in professional life is of extremely important significance. Therefore, I ask you to act in such a way that the issue of responsibility, which is enforced within the legal profession, is treated with utmost seriousness. That these proceedings are conducted quickly ‒ above all, that they are conducted, and thus, that the environment and those who are responsible for disciplinary matters do not act according to principles of camaraderie, but act in the interest of the legal profession as a profession of public trust, in the perspective of what the Constitution speaks of, thus in the public interest, but also in the interest of the profession as such and the opinion about that profession. Therefore, to recognize these problems related to disciplinary matters, enforce them in proceedings, and in the case of violations, punish them, and that in a clear and unequivocal manner. So that ‒ in short ‒ it is an efficient, reliable, and fair judiciary, which will also present an opinion about the profession to Polish society.

I wanted to ask you very much ‒ as the legal community ‒ to implement such disciplinary responsibility within what the Constitution of the Republic of Poland guarantees you, because I believe it is extremely important for the opinion that exists about your community. And therefore, to the extent that this community will count in the Republic as a prestigious community, as a community that is listened to, as a community whose voice matters, for the average citizen as well. Thus, as a community that enjoys social authority.

Ladies and gentlemen, and finally the last matter – the matter of access to the profession, because this matter was raised last in his speech by President Professor Lech Kaczyński. I personally believe that access to the profession of lawyer is currently open. In this sense, there are certain objective criteria that must be met in order to become a legal trainee, there are certain objective criteria that must be met in order to later pass the exam and be able to fully become a lawyer – of course, trainees are also members of the profession – in the sense of being a lawyer. These are clear, transparent criteria, they may not be very simple, but that does not matter. Because as President Professor Lech Kaczyński said at that time, one must indeed demonstrate certain knowledge in order to become a legal trainee, because this is a profession of public trust. This knowledge should indeed be reliably enforced. But I believe that there is no need to make changes in this regard – both tightening and simplifying or facilitating – at this time, that is my personal position and my personal observation.

Ladies and gentlemen, in conclusion of my speech, once again thanking you for the invitation, I wanted to wish you fruitful deliberations, I wanted to wish you to choose the best authorities of the Polish Bar, I wanted to wish those authorities every success in their work for the bar and in their work for the Republic in their upcoming term, and I wanted to say that I am ready to cooperate with the Polish Bar through its authorities, that I am – as I said – open to all initiatives, proposals, comments, and objections. I will be ready to meet with you as many times as you deem necessary, and I will be pleased if, when I ask the bar for a meeting as the President of the Republic, that meeting will also be possible from the side of the National Bar Council or other lawyers.

I sincerely thank you for the invitation and once again wish you fruitful deliberations. Thank you.