The speech of the President of the Republic of Poland at the conference "Constitution for Citizens, Not for Elites"

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

25 August 2017 · Conference "Constitution for Citizens, Not for Elites" · BHP Hall, Gdańsk, Poland

Context
Duda addressed a conference in Gdańsk's historic BHP Hall on August 25, 2017, advocating for constitutional reform to serve citizens rather than elites.
Main themes
Constitutional reform, citizens vs. elites, democratic state, division of competencies, Constitutional Tribunal legitimacy, Solidarity trade union legacy, retirement age dispute, acquired rights, judicial reform, referendum rights, executive power balance, Polish democratic history
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,862
74th percentile
Sentences
124
73rd percentile
Readability
45
47th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 68%68%
  • Ceremonial 20%19%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

124 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Most Honorable Mr. Marshal of the Senate,

Most Honorable Host – Chairman of the National Commission of NSZZ "Solidarity",

Esteemed Ministers,

Esteemed Members of Parliament, Senators,

Your Excellency, Archbishop,

Esteemed Madam President,

Esteemed Presidents,

Esteemed Professors, Chairpersons,

All Distinguished Guests Present!

First of all, I would like to sincerely thank the Chairman and the entire National Commission for the fact that this first debate concerning the constitutional future of the Republic – it may sound very grand, but that is what it is really about: how Poland will look in the future – is taking place right here, in Gdańsk, in the historic BHP Hall, which – I think we can say – is the cradle of Solidarity. And it has its beautiful history from those memorable days of August 1980 to the later years when Solidarity saved the BHP Hall with its own resources, so that this historic place would be a testament to the great change that took place for Poland – primarily for Poles – at the turn of the 80s and 90s thanks to Solidarity.

Because it is precisely thanks to Solidarity that Poland ceased to be the People's Republic, in whose constitution there was a perpetual alliance with the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics and the leading role of the Polish United Workers' Party, and became the Republic of Poland. Because that is the great premise of this constitutional change – that Poland is to be a Republic, and thus truly a democratic state of citizens. And today’s debate serves precisely this purpose, so that we – almost 30 years after those great constitutional changes – can also realize the process of actually building a democratic state in Poland by addressing the deficiencies that exist in the current constitution. The Chairman spoke about this today, and then the Marshal, mentioning a whole range of these shortcomings.

I must tell you that two issues struck me the most over the past few years. First, the competency dispute that arose between the Prime Minister and the President of the Republic, which was conducted before the Constitutional Tribunal at the request of then Prime Minister Donald Tusk – one could say – against President Lech Kaczyński. I had the honor of participating in this proceeding before the Tribunal at that time as a minister in the President's Chancellery alongside the current Professor Dariusz Dudek, for which I am once again immensely grateful to Professor – for those presentations back then and the extraordinary legal knowledge that Professor demonstrated. But that situation made me realize how imprecise the Polish constitution of 1997 is in this regard – how imprecise the division is, not so much of powers, but of the competencies that these powers possess. Starting from the two parts of the executive power, namely the president and the government led by the prime minister, through the subsequent powers, namely the legislative and executive. But I primarily saw that dispute then between the two parts of the executive power.

And the next situation was the moment when, despite such determined protests from Solidarity and other trade unions, the retirement age was raised – against Polish society, against workers, against what I believe is the fundamental principle of acquired rights, because people agreed to something different when they started their professional careers, their work, building their pension entitlements.

And then I experienced – I must say – two disappointments. The first was that this voice was not heard at all by the then parliamentary majority, that a referendum on this matter, which Solidarity requested, was not allowed, presenting then 2 million signatures – we all remember that protest outside the Sejm.

And the second element was that the president signed this law, and then the Constitutional Tribunal stated that everything was in order and in accordance with the constitution. And I must tell you that at that time, that Tribunal lost its legitimacy in my eyes – that very Tribunal. Because the last link that is supposed to guard the fundamental rights of citizens is indeed the Constitutional Tribunal. And in this regard, the Constitutional Tribunal not only failed the exam – I would say: it lost a great civic case at that time.

I must say that for me, absolute proof that serious changes in Poland and a new constitution are needed – just as serious changes in the judiciary are needed – was the speech already mentioned today by the former chairman of the Constitutional Tribunal, who shouted under the Supreme Court that everything must remain as it was. Because it suits him and his colleagues, because they have their very high pensions and are generally on a pedestal.

And hence, ladies and gentlemen – as I believe – among other things, this slogan under which we meet today: that the constitution should be for citizens, not for elites. I would make a slight modification: the constitution should be for citizens, not just for elites. Because that is what it is really about. After all, members of various elites that exist in our country are also citizens of the Republic. But it cannot be that the majority of the provisions in the constitution favor the state becoming elitist, because that causes the elites to detach from society, and the position presented by the former chairman of the Constitutional Tribunal is the best example of this. Because, dear ladies and gentlemen, 80 percent of people in Poland today demand a reform of the judiciary.

Just as – according to the latest research presented by CBOS – almost 80 percent of our citizens who were surveyed believe that a consultative referendum on the constitution should take place. I did not know this when I presented this proposal on May 3. I did not know that support in Poland for this idea is so enormous. I believe this shows that Poles, after 30 years of building democracy in Poland, have matured and see where the deficiencies are and where the strengths are. That they have also experienced those moments that I experienced – the disappointment related to some elements of the current constitution.

I agree with those who say: "Not everything in this constitution is bad." Of course, not everything is bad. There are many good elements, there are many elements that have proven themselves. But there are important elements that have not proven themselves, that have failed the exam, or that are written in such a way that they are essentially empty elements.

Just as we have the social market economy written down – as the Chairman reminded us today – in the Polish constitution, but in fact we do not yet have this social market economy in Poland; we are still building it. And this has been going on, ladies and gentlemen, for the last 20 years – and it has not been realized. Why? Because – in my opinion – the provisions in this regard in the constitution are insufficient. Perhaps insufficiently clear, and above all insufficiently secured.

There are many such areas, especially those that are of interest to the Independent Self-Governing Trade Union "Solidarity" as a workers' organization, that truly require at least clarification – and this is a great task. That is why I wanted and announced this constitution more than a year before the date on which I would like the referendum to take place. I would like it to take place on November 11 or – we will see – November 10-11, so over two days. Why? Because this is an extremely important moment for all of us, Poles. Because we are all very attached to the independence of the Republic, to a sovereign state – because we know that only in such a state can we determine our own fate. And only in such a state can we build our future.

And this new constitutional idea is to be a way forward. Because I believe that the period of 20-25 years, when a certain summary is made of how the constitution functions, is a long period – we must be aware that we will actually be creating it for the next generation. It is to be a constitution that will draw from the experiences of the last 30 years, which will also emerge from the experience of the struggle for independence, from the experience of those nearly 50 years of communist enslavement and all that was bad then and of which we all still remember.

The constitution of 1997 is, for me, a constitution of a transitional period – precisely the period in which we are constantly rebuilding democracy, in which in some sense we are learning democracy anew. And I think that these 30 years are indeed such a moment in history when this sum of experiences is already very large. And it allows us to easily assess this constitution from 20 years ago – how it functioned, in which aspects it passed the exam, and in which it did not.

But I would like this assessment to be made not only by experts. I wanted Polish society to make this assessment. There is a legal term – the concept that the internalization of a legal norm occurs, meaning that the legal norm is accepted by society, it is adopted and is realized, executed. Well, in my opinion, for there to be a real internalization of the constitution, it must primarily be understandable to people – it must be what people want, what they expect. It must realize certain directions indicated by society. And this is precisely what the consultative referendum is to serve. I have already said this: I am not just concerned that lawyers, experts will write the constitution, the National Assembly will adopt it, and then society will be able to express whether it wants it or not. But it is about the constitution being built as society, as citizens want it – and this is precisely what this more than year-long period of constitutional debate is to serve. Because it began on May 3.

I am pleased because various experts' statements, articles are emerging, people are discussing, we are discussing here today, I have already discussed with representatives of Local Government at the Presidential Palace about what the expectations of local government representatives are regarding the new constitution, how they believe that these issues of local and regional authorities are realized by the constitution. Should we have three levels of local government written in the Constitution of the Republic of Poland? These are questions that automatically come to mind.

And there are many such questions. The retirement age mentioned here today – how should these important issues be secured in the constitution? Should it be through direct writing, or by introducing solutions that certain matters must be voted on by a qualified majority? I would like us to discuss all of this. What level of social security guarantees should be provided for in the constitution? Even for the disabled or families raising disabled children. Should we secure benefits for families related to the 500+ program in the constitution? Or similar. Finally: how should the division of power look? Do we want to elect the president in general elections? How many deputies should there be? How many senators? Should education be free, guaranteed by the state? Should higher education be free? How should the financing of primary health care, healthcare look? These are the elements that need to be discussed, and I am glad that this discussion is beginning. I am immensely pleased that it is starting precisely from Solidarity. Because Solidarity is not just a word, but as a movement, it is a symbol of regained freedom for all of us. There would be no constitution of 1997, there would be no path to building a democratic state without the great Solidarity movement.

I would, ladies and gentlemen, very much like – and I say this not only to you gathered here in the BHP Hall at the Gdańsk Shipyard, but I also say this to all those who are watching or listening to me through the media or who will be able to familiarize themselves with the message from this meeting – that we should indeed engage in this discussion. I would like constitutional debates to be organized by various environments, because every voice is important and every idea is important. This is truly a show of the Republic – a civic state, where citizens discuss, where this social awareness is built, how important the constitution is for our future, for the future shaping of the Republic, for whether it will be a state that is successful – in the sense that it is a state that is truly sovereign, competitive, that manages to cope and creates safe living conditions for its citizens.

For me, as the President of the Republic, these are absolutely fundamental issues and it is my greatest aspiration – for the Polish state to be a state that is becoming increasingly prosperous through the wealth of its citizens and its strength, in how it secures them both in the country and beyond its borders. Therefore, I appeal for such constitutional debates and discussions to be organized throughout the country. I can say – as President and as one who also has the assistance of the President's Chancellery, ministers, advisors, and other collaborators – that I will strive and we will strive to participate in these debates whenever we are invited to them. Of course, we will also organize meetings and debates at the Presidential Palace. But I would like such discussions to take place all over Poland. Because it is extremely important to me that this topic becomes truly a social topic, that many people form their opinions on this issue, that many people also reflect on how the current constitution functions and what they would expect for the future of the Republic, for their children, grandchildren. For me, this is an extremely important matter.

I am very pleased that the Marshal of the Senate is present at this meeting. It is the senators who effectively decide whether the referendum initiated by the President will take place or not. And I am glad, because the presence of the Marshal here today is proof that the Senate and the senators take this issue seriously and that it will indeed be a serious debate, a discussion. I would also be pleased, Mr. Marshal, if the Senate, either on its own initiative or at your initiative, conducts some constitutional debates – even before the presidential initiative is finally formulated – because they are very much needed.

Ladies and gentlemen, once again, thank you for today’s meeting, thank you to all of you and the experts for coming, thank you for the discussions that will take place here shortly, for the presentations of the experts, because every voice in this debate is extremely important. I believe that we will carry on this constitutional debate until the referendum ‒ and we will continue it beyond that, because a constitution is not prepared in a week, a month, or a few months. A constitution is prepared over a long time, because it must be well-developed. And I believe that we will succeed, ladies and gentlemen. And that – as the Marshal mentioned ‒ the May Constitution of 1791 or the March Constitution of 1921 provided for such a summary, regarding how the constitution functions, every 25 years. Perhaps it will turn out from all our constitutional work that exactly 25 years after the adoption of the 1997 constitution, we will have a new one, or perhaps it will happen sooner – but we certainly will not rush it, and I would definitely like the direction of this thinking about Poland’s future – and thus this thinking about a new constitution – to be shaped by the will of the Polish society.

And in conclusion, I will say: the constitution, ladies and gentlemen, that exists is indeed – one can clearly say – a constitution of the minority. Among those entitled to vote, only 22 percent actually voted for it. The turnout was 42 percent, and “for” – as the Chairman mentioned today – was 6 million 300 thousand citizens. And I will remind you of one more fact ‒ that previous discussion about the civic constitution, the project proposed by Solidarity: many citizens, a decisive majority ‒ because studies were conducted at that time showing 67 percent ‒ wanted the subject of the referendum to be a choice between the constitution adopted by the National Assembly and the civic constitution. And that was, ladies and gentlemen, another mistake ‒ in my opinion, it was a violation of democratic principles.

I believe that over these 20 years we have matured greatly, that today we truly know how to build this democracy and how to safeguard it. And I believe that such situations will not occur again – situations where the government goes against the majority of citizens. Because that should not be the case.

Let us remember: the Republic of Poland – the sovereign is the nation.

Thank you very much.