The speech of the President of the Republic of Poland during the High-Level Debate of the UN Security Council.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

17 May 2018 · High-Level Debate of the UN Security Council · UN Security Council

Context
Duda addressed the UN Security Council High-Level Debate on May 17, 2018, speaking on strengthening international law in the context of maintaining international peace and security.
Main themes
International law, peace and security, peaceful settlement of disputes, sovereignty and independence of nations, UN Charter, multilateralism, rule of law in global order, mediation and diplomacy, aggression and naming threats accurately, Korean Peninsula, historical foundations of international law, Poland's role in international affairs
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,922
55th percentile
Sentences
103
64th percentile
Readability
28
13th percentile
Grade
13.9
66th percentile
Syntax
2.68
11th percentile
Vocabulary
2.41
91st percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 45%45%
  • Institutional 34%34%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

103 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Statement by the President of the Republic of Poland

Mr. Andrzej Duda during

The High-Level Debate of the UN Security Council

Strengthening and Promoting International Law in the Context of Maintaining International Peace and Security

EXCELLENCIES!

Distinguished Ladies and Gentlemen!

Dear Ms. Maria Luiza Viotti, Judge Hisashi Owada, Judge Theodor Meron, I would like to express my gratitude for your substantive and insightful remarks.

I would like to begin my speech with a quote from Paweł Włodkowic, the rector of the Jagiellonian University in Kraków, who in the 15th century proclaimed that there are certain rights of nations that must be guaranteed: existence, freedom, independence, one's own culture, and decent development. Włodkowic wrote: "Where force acts more strongly than love, there one seeks what constitutes one's own interest. All law, including natural law, condemns those who attack those wishing to live in peace" in accordance with the principle of treating others as you wish to be treated.

Włodkowic's arguments were deepened in the 17th century by Hugo Grotius in works recognized as fundamental in the field of international law, namely in the works entitled "On the Law of War and Peace" and "The Freedom of the Seas." The conceptual work initiated by Włodkowic, and subsequently strengthened by Grotius, gave rise to the idea of the law of nations – the foundation of international law. Today, after 600 years, Poland wants to return to these roots. We want to emphasize that there is no peace without law. International law remains the strongest tool in the hands of civilized nations, allowing for the provision of lasting peace – a peace based on trust and mutually respected norms and values.

The need to rediscover the lost meaning of the works of Włodkowic and Grotius is particularly evident today, when a certain paradox of the modern world becomes clear. On one hand, there is an extensive system of international law and the institutions that uphold it. This is the UN system along with international courts and tribunals. On the other hand, there is a visible temptation worldwide to place power above law, and fear above trust. Therefore, I invite all countries and institutions sitting at this table today to discuss the significance of international law. For us – as States – it will be difficult to cope with these challenges if we do not invest in the very foundation of the global order: respect for international law.

I believe that this is impossible without first coherently defining the fundamental categories of international law in the context of contemporary challenges to peace. These also pertain to the broader political discourse. Because if we call an act of aggression a "conflict," without properly defining the victim and the aggressor; if we define a threat as a "challenge," without defining its source; and if we refer to the development of aggressive military capabilities as "disturbing the balance," without stating who is building up their offensive military capabilities – then we will not be able to choose the appropriate legal steps to respond.

In international law, there are no unnamed phenomena, and improperly defined concepts create a distorted reality.

Dear Ladies and Gentlemen!

After these general remarks, which I would like us all to take to heart, I would like to focus on the issues concerning the functioning of international law in three aspects:

First, I would like to refer directly to Chapter VI of the United Nations Charter – the Peaceful Settlement of Disputes. In Poland's view, this is the most effective tool in the hands of the international community applicable in cases of disputes and inevitable conflicts.

The United Nations has a rich history of utilizing envoys and mediators. For decades, they have been sent to flashpoints around the world to assist both sides, providing their expertise and experience. Their mission is to prevent violations of international law or to stop its infringement. In this context, we remember the late UN Secretary-General Dag Hammarskjöld, who gave his life standing guard over the international order.

It is also worth highlighting recent mediation successes, particularly those concerning West African countries. For example, in The Gambia, where ECOWAS undertook effective intervention during the political crisis in 2017.

Furthermore, we must not forget that initiatives for peaceful dispute resolution also take place outside the United Nations and regional organizations. This occurs with the participation of recognized moral authorities. I would like to mention here the special role of the Pope and Vatican diplomacy in the process of normalizing international relations and peacefully resolving many global crises.

The importance of resolving conflicts through diplomatic means is currently evident in efforts to reduce tensions on the Korean Peninsula. Poland has been engaged in the region for over 60 years, including through participation in the Neutral Nations Supervisory Commission in Korea. We have always emphasized the need to maintain open channels of communication, which I personally reiterated during my visit to Panmunjom earlier this year. We fully support new high-level diplomatic initiatives aimed at restoring peace on the Peninsula.

We must also not forget one of the longest conflicts in the world – the conflict between Israel and Palestine. Poland, as a country with close and good relations with both Israel and Palestine, has always supported all initiatives aimed at stabilizing and strengthening peace and security in the Middle East. Only a return to bilateral negotiations, based on relevant UN resolutions and international law, can lead to a peaceful resolution of this conflict. This is the only path to a two-state solution. Today, more than ever, we need peace in the Holy Land – a sacred place for all major monotheistic religions. If we want to achieve peace, terrorism and violence are never the solution.

Dear Ladies and Gentlemen!

The second issue I would like to highlight concerns situations where peaceful dispute resolution is not applied or does not yield satisfactory results. This leads to conflicts and wars, death, suffering, and a lack of hope for millions of people. At this point, we must ask ourselves: how to protect international law, and in particular – international humanitarian law in the darkest times?

The Security Council can introduce targeted sanction regimes. We welcome international solidarity in implementing sanctions and exerting maximum pressure on states that disregard the international legal order. Coercive measures, even if they sometimes cause divisions and are not perfect, are often crucial in defending the principles of international law. In this context, sustained international pressure must go hand in hand with dialogue, as sanctions should never be an end in themselves.

The imposition of UN sanctions requires a decision from the Council. Unfortunately, there are situations where a lack of consensus prevents effective action against obvious violations of international law.

The Syrian conflict has been ongoing for eight years. Continuous and widespread violence, violations of international law, including human rights, are a daily reality for Syrians. The situation in Syria requires the United Nations and each member state to stand up for humanitarian principles. The international community, and in particular the Security Council, must emphasize the importance of ensuring that all humanitarian organizations have free access to the entire territory of Syria. All parties involved in Syria must be called upon to take action to prevent the use of weapons of mass destruction, including chemical weapons. All members of the Security Council should be convinced of the necessity to end this disgraceful practice.

Dear Ladies and Gentlemen!

As the President of the Republic of Poland, I cannot fail to mention my region – Central and Eastern Europe. The violation of territorial integrity, along with the illegal annexation and occupation of Crimea and the separatists in Donbas, who benefit from strong support from a third state, poses serious challenges not only for Ukraine but also for the stability of the entire European continent.

Poland supports the idea of deploying a UN peacekeeping operation in eastern Ukraine. The mandate of such an operation should not be limited to protecting the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission but should cover the entire conflict area, including the entire internationally recognized Ukrainian-Russian border. The international community should not ignore the current desperate situation of the Crimean Tatars and human rights activists in occupied Crimea, who are constantly threatened and harassed.

Speaking about Central and Eastern Europe at this forum, I must also address the widespread concerns regarding so-called frozen conflicts in Georgia, Moldova, and Nagorno-Karabakh. We must strive to support open, constructive, and respectful dialogue that will contribute to their successful resolution. These conflicts represent a clear violation of international law, which the Security Council can and should address.

EXCELLENCIES! DISTINGUISHED LADIES AND GENTLEMEN!

Finally, thirdly, I would like to address the issue of accountability. The international community, and in particular the Security Council, is morally responsible for ensuring individual criminal accountability for international crimes.

In this context, I would like to emphasize Poland's support for mechanisms of international law aimed at bringing to justice those responsible for violations of international law. We remember the work done by the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia. We have also noted the referral of cases from Sudan and Libya to the International Criminal Court.

In 2016, Poland welcomed the establishment of the International, Impartial and Independent Mechanism (IIIM), which recently published its first report. This mechanism remains a unique initiative that contributes to preventing unimaginable crimes and human rights violations in Syria and to pursuing accountability for them.

At the same time, as we have repeatedly emphasized: the impunity of those responsible for chemical attacks in Syria is not only contrary to international law. It also undermines the peace process and our collective security. Therefore, we fully support the establishment of an independent, impartial, and professional mechanism for attributing responsibility for the use of chemical weapons. Every such crime must be properly investigated, and those responsible must be held accountable. Such crimes must never be repeated.

I would like to emphasize that the non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction has always been an important element of Poland's security policy. In our actions within non-proliferation agreements, including as the chair of the Second Preparatory Committee of the Review Conference of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons in 2020 and the Hague Code of Conduct against Ballistic Missile Proliferation, we consistently advocate for the primacy of international law, strong international institutions, binding norms on non-proliferation, comprehensive and credible verification mechanisms, the implementation of best practices, and closer international cooperation.

EXCELLENCIES! DISTINGUISHED LADIES AND GENTLEMEN!

In conclusion, I would like to address the principle of acting in good faith. Adherence to this principle is an inseparable element of respect for international law. If we observe the actions of certain states contrary to the spirit of international law, we cannot pretend that they are legal and tolerate them. We cannot accept dubious legal justifications for actions taken in bad faith – in fraudem legis.

The law cannot be a tool against justice. It must serve only and exclusively justice. For those who seek justice, the law must be a supporting force. This particularly applies to issues such as compensation for historical losses or contemporary inquiries, for example, regarding air disasters, such as the full clarification of the causes of the crash of the Polish plane near Smolensk, in which the late President of the Republic of Poland Lech Kaczyński, the First Lady, and all members of the Polish delegation perished.

EXCELLENCIES! DISTINGUISHED LADIES AND GENTLEMEN!

We are morally and legally responsible for responding and restoring trust in international law.

Thank you.